Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Rochester It Is-the Phoenix Tower Progeny

By Pradeep | 04-Feb-2018
Dear All,
First let me congratulate the whole group of people behind ROCHESTER- the Owners, Trainer & jockey- CS Jodha & the syces who nurtured it.
Thrashing out the great belief of one & sundry that Phoenix Tower progeny can't stay the Derby distance of 2400Ms. Seems LIL lost some condition due to the setback & the lady showed it in last 100Meters unlike Pune over 2000Ms.
On to Invitation at Calcutta & tables can be reversed.
Aggregated & Sana - The First one at least proved onceagain that it's the horse & not the rider. Aggregated & Sana will not finish in first four of Invitation for sure.
Once again Congrats to the Winner very open heartedly.
Post Your reply

21 Replies

Anilxk said ...

06-Feb-2018
Rochester is not at all an un sure horse, he defeated Castlebridge the highest rated of his age category with ease and more over the financial matter also to be considered.At present The Mistrys are the only better placed buisiness group in the Industry.Main owner of Shroff is Mistry
Main owner for M.Narredu is Mistry(after J.Mody shifted horses to Cama)
Main Owner for Sunderji is Mistry
Main Owner for Toddy walla is Mistry,
Even MAM horses are purchased by Mistry so he is no owner for them also.
With out assessing all these factors why we all are crying and fighting out.

Anilxk said ...

06-Feb-2018
Friends,
Respect each other and reply with sportsman spirit,not with spirit inside.We all are in punting for a long time ...may be jimmy,anusree,or vyas may be followers of Prakash Goshawi studied handicapping in systematic manner,But most of us are not.When we are discussing a matter or giving a suggestion ,we respectfully has to say that this is my opinion,and never say this is right.The final result is the discussion done at paddock and the strategy which worked that moment.I am sure that none of the writers in this column except one person in bangalore are owners of horses.We are analysing some bodys horse, running with some bodys instruction ,driving by some riders,with some body prepared.The possibility is always near to nill,but we are all surviving because of patience self derived tactics and assessment of last minute.Respect and accept each other.
Anilxk

Zeddzzz. said ...

06-Feb-2018
Hi Guyz,
Someone Waz Talking About Invitation Cup.
Read My Lips, For Sure Sure n Sure.
The Invitation Cup Will Go To A Five Year Old. Most Probably Temerity Or Mathaiyus. No Manifold, No Rochester, No L I L, No P F Or Anyother HIDDEN 4 Year Old. Just Save Money To Back Temerity Or Mathaiyus And Ruffina Twice In 2 Day, Sprinters n Super Mikes. All Bets Are "Bank Of England"
Just Bang On Them n Go Home Very Healthy n X X X Tremely Wealthy.
All The Best.

Bkd said ...

06-Feb-2018

Just look at the day light robbery by trainer Magan Singh ..1st race Delhi.

ATOMIC POWER..on money favourite ridden by Dhanu S Deora!
Deliberately went slow to let stablemate SURAAGNA(20/1) ridden by Guepreet Singh to pip him at the post?? Superb riding by GS....indeed!

No inquiry..nothing....white cone hoisted....and the show goes on.

RWITC, the parent body for DTC, should hang their head in shame!

Jimmy Karanjia said ...

06-Feb-2018
Mr. Mad Max,

So now as you are running out of topics for healthy debate you are going on a community and blaming a community for mal practices in racing. How old are you? 20? You can say whatever you like, does not bother me in the least because I see you as a hapless human being with a lot of anger and frustration within.

All the knowledgeable Parsee gentlemen in racing, Mr. Mad Max is blaming you all for this sport being degraded for so called Doosras and Teesras. I actually agree with him on this one, but this blame should not be restricted to a particular community or individual. There are individuals from various cultures and communities who are involved for whatever is happening to this Royal Sport. Blame one and all ! Either quit the sport if you cant afford to lose money or then be part of the game! Your choice. The game will continue as it is with little improvement, use your brain, select the doosras and teesras, pursue with horses who have lost as hot favorites they will win in their next outing, so many many examples come to mind. Artus, Summer Rays, Drogo, Beshiktash, Alyaties to name a few. There are few owners with who this is a set pattern and trend so follow your instinct and mind and you will lose less.

Till then stay blessed!

Cheers,

Jimmy

Mad Max said ...

06-Feb-2018
@ Indiarace Admin

I doubt my post at On : 2/5/2018 6:41:51 PM is little obstructive and hurting a community, even though I have not specifically mention any community's name. Whatever I said in the above mail was sudden, incidental and unintentional.

If I hurt anyone due to above mail, I tender my unconditional apology herewith. This community is famous for their honesty, sincerity and sacrifices and they are they served heart out in the development of modern India. Kudos to them and their breed. My frustration was against some miniscule people act against the punter community and common people.

Bkd said ...

05-Feb-2018
I agree with you MM regarding DOOSRAS and THEESARAS striking with alarming regularity. This is not restricted to any community per se, but EVERYBODY does it with impunity. If I was a big horse owner, I too would do it...hehehe!!

In fact, it is the race club's who are to be blamed squarely for encouraging these deceptive practices, obviously with a view to feather their own nests.

Unless TAI, takes a decision on behalf of all the race clubs, to disallow MULTIPLE entries from trainers and owners or alternatively bracket ownermates/stablemates, we will never ever see fair racing in India!

Had it been so, ROCHESTER would been bracketed with LADY IN LACE, and punters of both these horses would have benefited.

Larry said ...

05-Feb-2018
Gosh, Mad Max, don't you ever give up?
It seems like you're perennially logged on to Horsetalk forum. Don't you do anything else for a living?
Honestly speaking, I had great respect for you, that's when BTC had shut shop, and you were the only one optimistic about things getting back in order, and you spoke like a really seasoned person, one who knew what he was talking about, and things did pan out the way you put them across, but as of recently, your antics are a bit of a let down.
Get on with life, pal. Just picking up grudges with one and all isn't going to get you anywhere.
I know I'll get a mouthful from you now, but who cares.

Mad Max said ...

05-Feb-2018
@ Jimmy Karanjia

I dont know from which community you belong?
If my guess is correct, your community has least respect for NATIVE INDIANS.
So we are not expecting anything from you guys.
As a premium tipster you might have tipped Lady in Lace and Prevalent Force to your Premium customers. Your ego will not allow you to surrender before any one. Hence it is better to rationalise your views and suppress others.

There are so many horse owners from your community.
They are also the BADSHAS of DOOSARAS and THEESARAS.
Punters have no expectation from these owners.
Long live your breed.

Mad Max said ...

05-Feb-2018

Lol !  One Month back he backed this filly to win Indian Derby, comments available in the archives, many. After the LIL's reported set back he grabbed the next best Prevalent Force also. Our challenge was not about Manifold, yes, I said I like it, it does not demean my PROMISE TO HIM - you are making symply hype around LADY & PREVALENT, both will lose and you will never return to Horse Talk for shame. Because of your arrogance how many horse talkers lost their hard earned money. How much you have got from bookies. We know you got a large Packets from the bookies when Be Safe and Murioi lost. Shame on Guys ! Now he is playing gulati and taken up the issue I liked Manifold, so what..? Yes, now I am not saying I LIKE Manifold in INDIAN INVITATION, SHE WILL THRASH ENTIRE BRIGADE, let the trainers parade their horses. Now I am saying you there is only Manifold in Indian Invitation. Now our interaction will be after the Invitation Cup !

Azim said ...

05-Feb-2018
@ deep impact
I apologies it's s k sunderji not imtiaz sait..
@madmax
sometimes u win sometime u loss of u loss so accept it bravely..read my post I have appreciated the run of manifold..I have mention that if David probert settled his mount in 5th 6th position it wud be may be different story all together ...may be manifold wup have won and interference made by prevalent force may be cost her..
but what I told before whenever lady and manifold will run together lady will finish ahead of manifold and lady did it besides her setback and empty gas on last furlong..so this time I won may be next time u will win brother..and for me for the invitation cup lady will not be contender it's gonna be all the way prevalent force if odds more than 4..

Jimmy Karanjia said ...

05-Feb-2018
Madmax,

I have nothing to say to self consumed people like yourself. My filly ran a good race she was beaten fair and square by Rochester, I am accepting it. Be Man enough to accept that your filly was tamed by mine and the winner

Your filly Manifold will finish in the same placing in the Invitation. No improvement from where she ran yesterday. Wait n watch!

And regarding your statement of Sab Doobega, whats that? No body, atleast not me got destroyed I played Rs. 2000 on Lady in Lace and was happy to give that money to the Bookie, no hard luck stories here. And you want me to say sorry to you? Who are you? Some non-existent whining crying insecure punter? Please, not worth my time or efforts. Atlease I dont have that habit. I accept my fillies loss and hope for her to run better in the Invitation.

Cheers,

Jimmy

Deep Impact said ...

05-Feb-2018
@azim : Your lengthy post race analysis why are you naming ISait as Rochester’s trainer..come on bro get your basics right first

Mad Max said ...

05-Feb-2018
@ Azim

Dont stoop to this level.
Check Godzilla's ID WINNERS thread I clearly informed the racing fraternity PREVALENT FORCE & LADI IN LACE is a JODI LAY BET with reasons. In India I doubt anyone said LAY BOTH. I clearly mentioned why PREVALENT FORCE should lose because of the Shoe and equipment changes.

Under this thread I have already commented future prospects of LADY IN LACE, PREVALENT FORCE. Don't Look beyond MANIFOLD in the Invitation, if you have any doubt, watch the Derby race again. In future dont target me, I will also would not address letters to you.

@ Jimmy Karanjia

Why not making a comment about your Jodi, Prevalent Force and Lady In Lace, both your hyped beyond any imagination. I was telling you all SAB DOOBEGA, why not come back and say sorry for so many abuses you made against me in each an every letters you posted. If you dont remember go browse and read those letters. Now dont raise the subject my Manifold also did not win and try to escape.

Aravind said ...

05-Feb-2018
Congratulations S K Sundering CS Kids and owners part owner Manjiri fantastic effort by your classic horse Rochester.afyer viewing Derby Race I feel Rochester at any point was not stressed and it easily win the race. Invitations is quite open now and bookies wud happy to quote 4to1 for all horses coz no one is clear cut winner there.

Raj said ...

05-Feb-2018
Calcutta champions remain in Calcutta. They get hammered when they come to western India. This lot is so poor that the older lot Alandair, Terminity will hack them up n the invitation. I’ll be surprised if any of them place.

Meiyappan said ...

05-Feb-2018
The jockey of MANIFOLD was keeping the horse last but until final 200 metre.Then he started pushing the horse which responded well but winning post was near. He should have kept the as privious running he shold won the race. It is jokey"s ill judgement.

Sri V said ...

05-Feb-2018
I am surprised to see no talk regarding this horse which won Indian Derby today.

Anyways I played place, but unlucky on playing WIN on this horse.

Azim said ...

05-Feb-2018
@pradeep
yes buddy it's a very important win for shapoor(doosra)..it's a very important victory for hardworking jockey cs jodha..no limelight not show off no marketing no rumours imtiaz sait and Cs jodha concentrated on work and they won handsomely..again imtiaz sait proves that pessi and narredus are kids infront of himmm...
a day yes pradeep it's a well deserve victory from ROCESTER but phoenix tower progeny having staying problem it's true u can see how Windsor forest run in bangalore oaks u can see how tutankhaman ran in hyderabad derby u can be witness of runs of mighty phoenix tiger horse even his class of animal having a staying problem although it's a good victory I am not trying to taking credit away from Rochester.Rochester indicates his class temperament and improvement in Ruia cup only when he beats Castlebridge by lengths and remember castlebridge was hot favourite only 15 paisa..So Rochester have improved a lots it's fact..
Regarding run of lady in lace for sure she is having set back and it shows in last 100 metres entering into straight Cs jodha(Rochester)was pushing his mount and Suraj( lady in lace ) was very handy but lady don't match the stride of Rochester into the straight she has beaten by unexpected horse by lengths and it's a big margin.lady in lace left no gas in her after 2200mtr may be the setback cost her the race still she proves she is a best filter in India..
run of manifold is also very nice David probert unable to settle a good position may be if he settled manifold in 5_6th position may be different story all together.still manifold flies and Tokyo the 3rd position from prevalent force...
for prevalent force it was a over confidence ride by Ys srinath he never settled himself and may be prevalent was not race fit bcoz of travelling and all..he was not in good condition..I think it was a just body day in office for prevalent force he will beat any horse on his day for sure..
aggregated over rated and sana not able to do a justice with hefty entry fees of Indian derby..
@madmax(if available)
see our threads of past I told you whenever manifold and lady in lace will meet in future lady will finish ahead of manifold and she did finish ahead of manifold besides her setback and all excuses..and u were only shouting the name manifold manifold manifold...

note.prevalent force will beat manifold/lady/Rochester in future classics..
it was his first run in Mumbai and owner and jockey took it very lightly...

congrats to the shapoor(doosra) and Cs jodha and imtiaz sait for well deserve victory..
thanx azimmmm

Mad Max said ...

05-Feb-2018
MANIFOLD was following PREVALENT FORCE most of the time, same way BE SAFE followed Amazing Graze in the earlier Indian Derby. By the time the David realized PREVALENT FORCE is a spent force, (the way Suraj realized Amazing Grace is a Sprentforce) David and Suraj both tried their best to ride out. Hard luck continued Manifold was thrown out of the competition because of Srinath's negligent riding at the last furlong taking MF deliberately out.

Smart-still-poor-punter said ...

05-Feb-2018
The manner in which C S Jodha positioned 'Rochester' (should be as per the instructions of the veteran trainer) right from the start, keeping his mount alongside 'Lady in Lace', and then making the challenge once the 'Lady' was being hailed by the excited-voicing commentator, the race came to the boil and Rochester was now being hailed the winner!

Those who are going to blame the Lady or its rider suraj Narredu should understand races are for all the animals and not the favourites alone.

A jockey like C S Jodha, who has been in the field for quite some time now and has been mainly focused in Mumbai and Pune, and to some extent in Delhi, should now be freely hired in centres like Bengaluru, Kolkata and Hyderabad also. Or, should I say, we are going to see that very soon?

IT is quite right that the horse matters more than the rider, and that's what the run of 'Aggregated' (S deSouza) exactly had to prove, and to a greater extent run that of 'Perfect Star'. (David Allan).

Finally, the man - Shapoor Mistry - tasted success with the biggest race in the Indian racing calendar. What we have to take note of is the no-risk element he ensured while going for a big race by taking a major share in the Lady. Punters alone do not take risks, mind it!

Finally, the run of 'Manifold'..Vow! Where from did the animal run up to finish third, and in the process pushing a hapless 'Prevalent Force' to the fourth spot. 'Themis' and 'Ben Sur' will also be heard repeatedly in their respective centres soon.

In all, if you keep away the money that was lost by punters who fancied on the first three favourites, the Derby race was a real treat to watch!