Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Indian Derby : Questions To Be Answered?!

By Smart-still-poor-punter | 06-Feb-2018

The dust has settled with 'Rochester' lifting the Indian Derby. But it opens the proverbial Pandora's Box, leaving many questions to be answered.

First and foremost, the equation between Indian and foreign jockeys : The first, second, fourth and fifth placed horses in the Derby were ridden by Indian riders, and none of the foreigners could make it to the board other than David Probert, who even came a cropper on the much-taltened 'Manifold.' That he misjudged the pace of the race by remaining in the tail for too long which cost him the race is something everyone could see for themselves. The hype that was created around 'Aggregated' after S A DeSousa was declared to ride the animal was so much so that the horse came for strong contention, at least on paper. There were punters who even liked 'Perfect Star' to do something, only because David Allan was on the back! The other couple of horses carrying the got-abroad riders on their back also did not convince on the field.

In sharp contrast, look at the determined show put up by C S Jodha, Suraj Narredu and even Y S Srinath. Blaming Srinath or 'Prevalent Force' for not winning the Derby is like blaming Stalin for not winning the recent Assembly bypoll in Chennai. Yes, the animal was fancied, but by whom?... certainly not by the connections. Otherwise, the owners would not have rushed for the half a million rupee Derby race available in Chennai in a platter. Right?
Coming to the most popular horse of the year, 'Lady in Lace'. When most of us knew that the animal had undergone some setback and was also suffering from poor health, the run given by the Lady was something that needs to be applauded loudly. It's true that the animal, as expected by many, started tiring out in the last 150 mts or so, but still managing to hold on galantly to the runner-up berth. If you are still going to accuse Suraj of not giving that extra, you are unfit to be a race-goer.

Now, coming to the Conqueror Rochester! What a day the connections had! Sunderji must have hoped for the Derby win, and that too very much in the hands of a less-popular but highly-skilled rider like C S Jodha. The reason is simple. He had seen the run in the Ruia Cup, decimating 'Castlebridge' without straining a muscle. That was enough for the owners to allow Jodha to partner the horse. That Jodha held on to his nerves till passing the winning post goes to his credit. He himself had admitted later that he was a bit nervous when he was about to overtake the Lady.
Now, my question is where did foreign jockeys gain any prominence here? Why our talented riders are not chosen for the big races by our owners and trainers? I think the trend will slowly start changing now and we can see more and more Indian riders getting the billing ahead of their foreign counterparts in Classic races.

Another question that needs to be answered is the instructions given by trainers to the riders, and to what extent the latter follow them. I wonder if the trainers of Prevalent Force and Manifold did really ask their respective jockeys to remain at the back for so long, which at least cost Manifold a certain race.

My final question in this post is why big stables like that of MAM (or A C Muthiah) prefer to run their 'donkeys' in Derby races, knowing well that they are not going to be there anywhere at the finish, no matter who comes from which part of the world to ride them. Similarly, it's time for owners from Kolkata to know that mere participation is different from winning a big race.

Post Your reply

23 Replies

Mad Max said ...

08-Feb-2018
@ SSPP
I addressed comments (Mad Max said ... On : 2/6/2018 12:29:52 PM) to SFP, MISTAKENLY. Realized it much later. Sorry.

Hunter said ...

07-Feb-2018
No doubt foreign jockies have better riding skills. Even their posture atop the horse is better than their Indian counterparts. As an expert once said, a foreign jockey like David Allan gives a horse 2-length advantage straight away.
Generally speaking, foreign jockies are less corruptible, though there have been instances of foreign jockies also pulling their mounts in India and abroad.
CS Jodha needs to be complimented for his win in ID, but he is no great jockey. If it was so, he would not be a regular in Delhi races, which are rigged 90% of the time. Doing bidding of corrupt owners and trainers of Delhi would be done by a workmanlike jockey and not a champion rider. So, let's please not go overboard.
Rochester had excellent credentials but most experts, tipsters and punters avoided the horse because of the jockey and the suspect stamina of Phoenix Tower progeny.

Transparency said ...

07-Feb-2018
After the Race All r smart and played only Rochester.lol

Zeddzzz. said ...

07-Feb-2018
Good And Reputed Foreign Jockeys Are Any Time Much Much Much Better Than Our Local Champions.
WHY ?

1. They Are Really Honest. No Hanky Panky.
2. No Connections With Local Bookies Or Local Mafia's For PULLING n FIXING.
3. They Understand The Horses Much M M Better Than Our L C's.
4. They Listen And Follow The Instructions Of The Trainer Religiously.
5. As Per Champion Trainer Padmanabhan, Once He Said On Record Why Most Of The Time He Is Bringing Foreign Jockeys. He Said,
Quote
"After The Track Work And A Race, They Give Very Honest And Extremely Good And Accurate Feed Back About The Horse, Then In Consultation With Them, We Decide About The Future Runs Of The Horse"
Un-Quote
6. Untill Now No Foreign Jockey Found In Fixing Of Big Races (Except R.Hughes Jacquiline In The Invitation Cup Against Becket) Where Az There Are Many M M Examples Of Our Champ's Pulling Great Horses In The Main Events And Bigggg Races With Immunity, Can Name Soooo Many.
so My Vote Is Alwayz For Foreign Jockeys.

Munesh said ...

07-Feb-2018
These foreign jockeys dont use the whip as viciously as our Indian counterparts to win a race

Mano said ...

07-Feb-2018
PF or LIL , not to blame the jockeys or the horse, it was only the owners and trainers who have not taken derby quite seriously,if the horse was trained well before the derby it could have been either PF or LIL.. I feel the jockeys will give their best effort to win the derby, but it was the trainer who makes mistakes at the end of the day..

Munesh said ...

07-Feb-2018
These foreign jockeys dont use the whip as viciously as our Indian counterparts to win a race

Dr Harun said ...

06-Feb-2018
SSPP,the best i have read on HT.The way Aggregated was sweating ,must have got dehydrated before going in forget running the distance.Thats why it sunk without a trace.Most missed out on Rochester on the belief that PT"s progeny dont stay over a Mile.Yes C S Jodha gave it a beutiful ride.Om Winter Renaissance i thought he never got a free run as he got stuck near the rails,if not he would have gone close.Today he kept Rochester free from any traffic problems and made his move in the last 300m.This win must have done CS a world of good.

Kumar_blore said ...

06-Feb-2018
@sspp,
Beautiful write-up, thoroughly enjoyed reading it.... frankly kudos to the jockey to follow lady in lace,which was a true contender & great job from trainer for having Rochester race fit,the horse has a big heart and it gave it all in clinching the derby.....
And regarding foreign jockeys,my guess is it a jockey like David Allan had rode Rochester it would have won more comfortably,Jodha might be better than other foreign jockey's,but David Allan,SA desousa, Chris lemairie, Hughes were best foreign jockey's who I found good in indian circuit...

Savio said ...

06-Feb-2018


I had overheard in the Padock Area Members Enclosure PF had some problems 3 days before the Derby while he was given gate pratice

Malesh horse was kept on trot and canter waste of Money to Fly Jockey S A Dsouza

In the invitation Manifold will run a good race

I had mentioned outsider will win the Derby


Savio

Jp said ...

06-Feb-2018
Part II could not be completed due to internet failure. Whether Isnt She Special and Desert God failed because of lack of effort on the part of jockey/trainer after spending so much of money. Similarly here in India the owners spend huge sums and race their wards. You cant expect them to win every race and all cant be winners. I am not saying that racing is fair in India. It has several defects like supervision, drugs & medications, benami owners, connections(jockeys/owners/club officials) connected to illegal book makers and so on. But, as they say the show must go on. Why Derby, so many races in India are one sided and we can ask all the questions in all the races.
Though I have written several times about certain issues without any derogatory or unparlimentary words against any one the writings are not published for reasons best known to the editors.

K.rajkumar said ...

06-Feb-2018
dear all my punters indian derby race is pre-fix,the day shapoor mistry bought a share on lady in lace that time im decided Phoenix tower breed will win this year derby,why&how?lady in lace is the only threat to rochester.rochester won ruia gold with easily. castlebridge good for mile,in 2000m derby in bangalore manifold beat easily castle bridge.now mani fold beaten by lady in lace in same distance in pune derby there ROCHESTER.is clear second
manifold.is fourth,now in 1000 guineas he want to take with windsor forest.he had threat with lady in lace before that raceday.prevalent force not ridden well i had a doubt on y.s riding in this particular derby,in invitation cup usha stud will engage the jockey forsure,and every one is involved,including club officials,oweners , trainers,jockeys has to listen their instructions ,example ruia gold cup winner amount is 1.5 million wonder no owners ,trainers are ready to participating,for the third place,one donkey got athird and that horse is 300 meter away from rochester,&castle bridge,that give clear picture of future plane of indian derby winner last year also they did,hall of fammer also pre fix,that day also played ,in indian derby also i played i made good money,,

Anilxk said ...

06-Feb-2018
Dear SSPP,
I never think that race is decided before a fortnight.The final tactics will be done in the dying minutes,when punters are betting.No boby can fore see result in an open race where the ratings are with in 25 points(except pace setters).For me ,I fancied Rochester and played only SHP,THP,Not even place.It is the best prepared horse and less travelled one.We have to congratulate SK.Sunderji and Team.and more over P.Trevor who given him track with out notice.

Stop Fooling Punter said ...

06-Feb-2018
I.T.R I stand by my comments.

Sat eve all three gave an interview during MUM races saying that we [each one ]

Have to beat P FORCE.is this the level of their assessment. Riding a horse 6 months back and current form are 2 different thing.

Pray tell me on what basis they came to this conclusion .

The horse finished a poor 4th.I s this their reading of horses and racing [ A big no ]

It was deliberate. Take it or leave it

Manish said ...

06-Feb-2018
The main intention of preferring foreign jockeys by the connections is that they follow the instructions of connections, unlike indian jockeys who sometimes, repeat sometimes, cheat their own connections.

Secondly, if you observe minutely, there have been certain races where foreign riders have shown their skill, specially david allan.

I dont remember the race, but the way DAvid brought his horse into contention near the bend by his superb presence of mind, was brilliant to see. many other examples can also be quoted.

No wonder, there have been some reverse instances also. Not denying that.

Indian_turf_record said ...

06-Feb-2018
@ stop fooling punter

Your posting:-

"It is clear that pessi Malesh and suraj were part of a massive false flag game plan. All 3 harped on P. force without seen this horse run."

I know nothing of false flag plan but your facts are incorrect. All three have seen this horse run. Pesi Shroff was at Guindy when he won SI Derby; Suraj has ridden in four races won by Prevalent Force and Malesh Narredu saddled second placed Mygrator when the horse won his first race.

Aravind said ...

06-Feb-2018
Prior to Derby I hve told many that this year there s no cut above horse like in previous years.only LIL has got majority liking but that too also diminished when it list to class IV horse Smasher in Mick race.same thing happens to Be safe case also immediately written in HT abt it.but any at that time fired me.but once Besafe lost all kept silent.so riding and placing of the horses in better position only wud help to win this Derby.ultimately both Rochester and LIL got this point and followed.PF MF not read this theory and hence lost.In Invitation LIL will strike coz it was the only horse even after setback ran powerful race.

Jp said ...

06-Feb-2018
Part II. Dubai racing carnival invites the best from around all over the world. Among them one wins and the rest finish behind with the world's best jockeys and there is a last finisher also. Is it the lack of effort or the instructions from the trainer for the result. Where did Isnt She Special and Desert God finish ? Is it the ji

Jp said ...

06-Feb-2018
Manifold was drawn 1 and it is not a fast horse and while start there was some jostling which rendered the jockey the to remain at the back. If not for that interference the horse/jockey could have won or run closer to the winner. They say the luck of the race irrespective of who rides plays a major role in the result. Saying why so and so has entered the horse is surprising. All the entrants can't be winners. Racing requires few horses to run and only 1 can be the winner. Yes sometimes the horses are run not with intentions in the race it is run but with future race in view.

Sandy said ...

06-Feb-2018
@MadMax I Agree with you..

If you see my previous Post on Derby Selection i have Mentioned that

"Among the Above Bunch of Horses, Manifold Looks Formidable. Tracking well at Mumbai. Danger to it could be Lady in Lace (which was tried first time at 2400 mts and Rochester too)"

But my Strong Fancy was Manifold, but looking closing on the Race results on 3rd feb and 4th Feb. Shroff's Multiple Wins on Both Days and Sunderji's Deliberate Runs for Their Mounts to loose, Made us to Think..

Im Happy that all the Above Mentioned Horses are there on Board..


I Wanted to Acknowledge one person on this Occasion Major Srinivas Nargolkar (Retd.)

"In racing, you lose some, you win some. In the instances mentioned above, Kashmir, Dr. Ramaswamy and Dr. Poonawalla may have been thwarted in their ultimate aim but all of them have won the Indian Derby with some of their other purchases. Perhaps, Mr. Shapoor Mistry will follow in their footsteps."

This Paragraph made me to Read Between the Lines to Think Big !!

Stop Fooling Punter said ...

06-Feb-2018
WELL Written sir.

There is an over hype about jockeys and even horses [ask shirkes how many of these got abroads horses flopped]\

it is clear that pessi Malesh and suraj were part of a massive false flag game plan.
All 3 harped on P. force without seen this horse run.

They all ignored the time of 2.10 clocked by Rochester[my reason for choosing it].

It is good to expose them even after the race.

Well done sir keep it up

Mad Max said ...

06-Feb-2018
@ SFP

Good article. I think this is the first time you have written a lengthy one.

You said ...."I wonder if the trainers of Prevalent Force and Manifold did really ask their respective jockeys to remain at the back for so long, which at least cost Manifold a certain race"

There are some tipsters who vouched Prevalent Force and Lady In Lace will get a heart-burn after reading above statement. No one in India made such a bold statement after this year's Derby, even I used words with caution. Now I want to see how many stones or petals coming from various zones.

I follow a rare set of trainers and their antics, and Pesi is one among the list. If he scores a quadruple either on Saturday or Sunday on Derby weekend his Point of Interest on Derby race will be negligible.

This is my personal opinion, Pesi had some forward ideas hence he might have convinced David, PF is the contender hence sit pretty close to pace behind Prevalent Force till final bend and extract MF only after PF make his final move. David smelt he is wasting time behind PF and Srinath, by the time he alerted Manifold LIL and R'str were far ahead. As a last nail, Srinath hit it on Manifold's head by hampering his way. DON'T BE SURPRISED, YS Srinath choose MANIFOLD in the INVITATION, because he is the darling of the Mass and Ameetha Mehra due to their Alaindair combination.

Godzilla said ...

06-Feb-2018
s-s-p-p

Brilliant Obervation and Write Up. We need more write-ups like this. Going to Races and betting alone is not enough.

Such articles will make the new comers to learn more about Racing. Keep it up !