Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

'star Carnation' & Change Of Jockey?

By Smart-still-poor-punter | 05-Mar-2018

There is a general feeling among a majority of punters in India that a foreign rider will make a lot of difference to an animal's riding fortunes. So, when 'Star Carnation' finished runner-cup recently in a Classic race, instead of congratulating one of India's veteran riders, A Imran Khan, they started bemoaning his ride, saying a 'strong' jockey would have reversed the result and the horse would have won the race. But despite David Allan being entrusted the job, Star Carnation finished off the frame. If you compare the two different rides, we will feel like appreciating the riding sense of Imran Khan, who kept the animal at the rear position and gave it a free ride only in the closing stages. In sharp contrast, Allan kept it in the front bunch almost all through the race, but when the boiling point came the horse hardly had anything left in the tank.

So, now the question is had the animal been run by Imran itself, could there have been a better result?

Post Your reply

5 Replies

Giant Fly said ...

09-Mar-2018
Many things have to be taken into consideration ... course / pace of race...instructions and of course travel from one center to another...it’s always not about the jockeys and finally let’s not forget it’s an animal we at talking about...I am sure they have good and bad days too

Hunter said ...

06-Mar-2018
Imran Khan a better jockey than David Allan?? What a joke!!
Imran Khan's posture is not so good and he whips excessively. Fit for Hyderabad only where he became a champion by winning 'made-up' races....

Happy hunting....

Dseetharamarao said ...

06-Mar-2018


EVERYONE KNOWS THE ABILITY OF A HORSE, BUT PUNTERS FAILED IN FINDING THE

FORM OF A HORSE. FIRST TO DISCUSS THE FORM OF A HORSE BUT NOT JOCKEYS.

A D said ...

05-Mar-2018
@SSAP

You seem to be an intelligent and experienced punter, still you are comparing the rides of two jockeys.

Do jockeys have a say in these big races and not follow instructions ???

Or aren't they to ride as per the instructions of the trainer ???

You realize what happens when a jockey does not follow the instructions of the trainer ??? Trainers can complain and jockeys could be fined or suspended.

Jp said ...

05-Mar-2018
Both the riders have to ride according to the instructions from the trainer/owner. So we do not know what instructions were given to each. Anyway we cannot compare the both. One is an International rider and another should have hung is boots by now. But due to lack of quality jockeys he is getting a second innings with the connections believing that experience is better. Still this jockey is not made for big races. Except winning the Derby in Hyderabad ,I thing he has nothing to show in his CV.