Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Stallion Win Legend/excellent Art Performances In India

By Godzilla | 27-Jun-2018

Guys

Progeny out of Win Legend/Excellent Art performances in India are not viewed that great by International Racing Centres. As per them, its nothing short of a mediocre performance.

Guys in this forum are overwhelmed at the look of Sir Cecil [Win Legend], its performance. They praise Sir Cecil is a great horse that they ever seen. They also doubt whether Excellent Art progeny can stay a mile and half trip.

For the information of experts here that both Win Legend and Excellent Art progeny can stay, in Indian conditions.

In India, if you take a mile and half derby distance, the pace is very slow till a mile marker. The real Race starts at 1600 mtr marker and the pace picks up gradually. The acceleration starts after crossing the bend always. In international Racing Centres, the pace picks up right from the word "Go". Thats the difference

In the past, experts here were of the opinion that Phoenix Tiger progeny can travel only upto a mile. They all proved wrong. Rochester failed in a mile Race against Castlebridge and subsequently defeated the same Castlebridge in a 2000 mtr Race with handsome margin. Punters left out this horse including me in the Derby distance with the same doubt, and Rochester won Indian Derby hacking the field. The same Rochester would have failed, if lived and participated at other international centres.

What happened to the grey Hall of Famer, which won both Calcutta and Indian Derby. This is out of Win Legend. No news about this horse afrterwards.

In view of the above facts, kindly do not keep arguing that Sir Cecil is great and Star Superior is unfit to travel more than a mile.

Post Your reply

19 Replies

Azim said ...

30-Jun-2018
Godzilla

Don't hide behind Punjabi girl. Punjabi girl is by win legend and ur corfe castle is by excellent art.only Rochester have won black type race in Phoenix tower pedigree bro and in excellentart the record is zero.
When it's comes to sir Cecil u don't like sircecil and win legend and when u want to prove ur point regarding corfe castle u r hiding behind Punjabi girl which is also from winlegend.correct urself and don't be this much egoistic.its harm in racing uncle.

Hunted said ...

30-Jun-2018
Corfe Castle is running the 7 Furlong Arshad Ali Khan Cup and not the Bangalore Derby. as for it's Pedigree it's very apparent that he probably won't see out a very stiff mile like in the Colts Trial, his full sister Ruffina was best at 6f and 7f.

Godzilla said ...

30-Jun-2018
Azim/Ashwin

Horses can win without run benefit. Correct yourselves, Already one 1400 mtr and one 1200 nmr O/S work given for Corfe Castle.

A mock Race also will be given. What else you need for a Champion Horse and Jockey.

I am going to watch work outs of this horse from now on. You guys also do,

How Punjabi Girl won without any good performance and track ? If the horse is good, it can make it.

You guys will not look beyond Sir Cecil and Star Superior, like a frog in the well attitude.

Azim said ...

30-Jun-2018
@godzilla

U jump star superior to corfe castle..
Corfe castle for bangalore derby just keep dreaming brother...hahaha

Ashwin said ...

29-Jun-2018
Is Corfe castle going to run the Bangalore Derby? Without a run so far? I think you shouldn’t presume that he will run . Secondly, let’s consider the contenders who have run so far , Instead of using our imagination on frivolous issues and arguments.

Godzilla said ...

29-Jun-2018
manish

Let the Bangalore Derby results be out. Then it will become clear whether I can smile at your ignorance or you can laugh at my madness in picking Corfe Castle.

The guys who are still washing are responsible for their predicament and I am not involved. Dont try to pull me down.Ha ha ha ha.

Manish said ...

28-Jun-2018
@Godzy,

I sometimes laugh at your statement. If you declare that Corfe Castle would be the winner, then it would be better that CC was analysed and not the others. You are you. The persons to whom you gave lift last sunday, are still washing themselves. Dont know why??

Godzilla said ...

28-Jun-2018

Guys

Having analysed thoroughly Sir Cecil and Star Superior, I would like to firmly state that CORFE CASTLE with Trevor atop will lift Bangalore Derby.

Indian_turf_record said ...

28-Jun-2018

Statistics of stallions PHOENIX TOWER and EXCELLENT ART.

PHOENIX TIGER. 5 Crops, 266 foals. One black-type winner (ROCHESTER) beyond 2000 m.

EXCELLENT ART. 1 crop, 83 foals. One black-type winner (MAURITANIA) beyond 1400 m.

[ Current crop of 3YOs not included in above statistics.]

Kolramsri said ...

28-Jun-2018
T.V.Sunday should thank URVASHI for being mentioned in racing columns. If my memory serves right, first foal of T V Sunday to find entry in the race card was Monte video, which was accepted to race in Bangalore, and was withdrawn before coming under starters order. Similarly their other stallion Sir Bord.......( could not spell it correctly) also failed miserably.This is an aide-memoire for Hunter.

Indian_turf_record said ...

28-Jun-2018
@ Hunter

Pleasantly Perfect standing at Dashmesh ?

Hunter said ...

27-Jun-2018
@Hunted,

Before Win Legend landed at Dashmesh, these were the stallions standing there:

Hurricane State
Pleasantly Perfect
Carnival Dancer
Princely Heir

Barring a few winners of Hurricane State, can you remember names of progeny if other stallions?

Happy hunting....

Hunter said ...

27-Jun-2018
@Hunted, You are speaking of long ago glorious past of Dashmesh Stud. How many years ago Elusive Pimpernel ran? They have been in a rut past few years. Now, fortune has smiled upon them and they should do well. We should be happy for them.

Hunt happily....


Old And Wise said ...

27-Jun-2018

anyone, anyone, who calls dashmesh stud a small farm, must not be allowed to voice his opinion here or anywhere on any racing forum. but then thats just my opinion. to have no knowledge and post comments is really silly on part of the person. but then, like horses make fools of people all the time, lot of people like making fools of themselves too.

ps. no, im not one of the brar boys nor am i a breeder.

Hunted said ...

27-Jun-2018
Mr Hunter- Win Legend at a small stud? I think they have bred over 100 Classic winners including the great Elusive Pimpernel. A little knowledge is a dangerous thing

Glasgow Prince said ...

27-Jun-2018

I feel stayer and non-stayer are relative terms. Rochester won the Derby but the same Rochester failed when faced with a different set of horses in the Invitation except Lady in Lace who had a setback prior to the Derby.It all depends on the competition. It is therefore better not to use such labels so that we analyse each race dispassionately.

Was Star Superior plain unlucky or was he the victim of foul play? Barnabas who had come in onto the rails from an outside draw clearly slowed down the pace around the 1200 forcing Suraj to check his mount to avoid clipping the front runner. SS lost about two lengths in the bargain which was too much to make up.

Sam said ...

27-Jun-2018
I also wonder why the timing is 2.28/30 /34 abroad when the horses just bolt out of the gates and continue the momentum.
At the curragh and ascot the mile is run straight. No bends. Still the time comes up to 1.38 or nearby.
Then why horses like Desert God fail when tested abroad??
Hall of famer developed severe complications in travel. She died and was brought to pune.

Hunter said ...

27-Jun-2018
The empirical evidence points to progeny of Phoenix Tower and Excellent Art not being able to stay. It's the exceptions which prove the rule. Hence, Rochester and Star Superior. The latter will stay, going by his record breaking win over a mile in Mumbai and his run in the Colts on Sunday.
Win Legend stands at a small stud, so hasn't been getting quality or quantity in mares. All that is set to change now after success of Punjabi Girl and Sir Cecil.
On last Sunday, Sir Cecil was badly bumped and Neeraj Rawal was all nerves. Let's ignore this run of his. Star Superior should have won the race given these circumstances but Suraj Narredu gave a disappointing ride - allowing two lengths leeway to Sir Cecil at the top of Bengaluru's short straight. It is to the credit of Star Superior that he almost closed the gap. The gap would have been fully closed had Suraj controlled the outward drift of Star Superior.
It will be a different race in the Derby, and why should we believe it will be a match race between these two colts? There are hidden horses which could come to the fore....

Happy hunting....

Punter said ...

27-Jun-2018

Dear Godzilla,

Thank you for the Info.

After looking at the Match Race I feel Star Superior is on better staying, stamina capability than Sir Secil.