India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsSandesh Right
By Godzilla | 09-Jul-2018Jockey A Sandesh is right. Lady in Lace came on to Sana at 350 marker as well as at 50 mtrs and squeezed Sandehs mount which can be viewed clearly without
any iota of doubt, whereby Jockey Sandesh had to check his mount twice.
There were no deliberations on Sandeshs objection.
One Steward just sitting relaxed in his chair said over-ruled and all others followed suit. In all fairness second place should have been given to Sana and third to Lady in Lace. Who knows Sana could have won the Race also, had LIL and Suraj not interfered.
The Stewards in Bangalore or as bad as in Mysore. If this objection is not upheld, I dont know what is their yardstick to upheld the obections.
The Stewards should realize Jockeys risk their life to triumph. These guys sitting in Air Conditioned Rooms simply pass judgement without even to have a meticulous look at the objection.
Atleast one retired Jockey should be nominated as Stewards in every centre, its high time. I mean quota system.
34 Replies
Aswin Patel said ...
13-Jul-2018I am sorry , I lack the capability give you any winners, I can at best tell what I believe are pobable / possible winners.
Into the spotlight and Iris are probable winners in my opinion.
Arrogance is another horse I will consider wagering ONLY IF IT LOOKS BETTER THAN Desert Angel in the paddock.
If Isinit she lovely is an odds on Fav , I will LAY it. IMHO there are quite a few horses that can beat it.
BOL.
BTW , Do you remember a story about a Fox and sour grapes.
Stop Fooling Punter said ...
13-Jul-2018it is the IT services led by Infosys and TCS which have earned millions and they are not NRIS.
Pray tell me in which way have they contributed besides having the best of 2 worlds.
All are not bad but one odd here tried to pull us down and sadly you are defending him.
GODZILLA BE INDIAN and be proud of it inspite of all the draw backs in some areas
Godzilla said ...
13-Jul-20181. I dont agree with you.
2. NRIs are good guys.
3. Because of them, their parents are able to lead a fabulous life.
4. If the NRIs request the Indians to raise their standard of living, whats wrong with it ?
5. Undoubtedly Indians have to pull their socks up and lead a quality life.
6. Indians should develop the habit of tolerance in all departments.
7. What India was 30 years back and what India is now ? The development took place because of NRIs. NRIs contribute heavily to the development of India. None can deny the fact.
Still the majority of Indians refuse to learn and criticize those [NRIs] who are instrumental in lifting India up.
High time guys realize the reality.
Stop Fooling Punter said ...
13-Jul-2018Service tax has ensured that there is no way one can dodge taxes. The tax base now is very wide the GST collections show how so many are paying taxes
Forget few hundred at the top majority are now tax compliance.
N o doubt we have a long way to go before many nations but let us be proud of what we have achieved
This habit of NRIS trying to pull us down has to stop
Godzilla said ...
12-Jul-2018Ashwin
Concentrate on Saturday and Sunday Races and gimme winners. Lets discuss other matters later.
Aswin Patel said ...
12-Jul-2018You seem to be well traveled and an astute observer, maybe you were a victim of the cops in the USA or is it from google that you got all this info ?
SFP said it rightly " The problem is these Indians exported abroad forget their origins very fast So why talk of USA ".
I do not know if you heard of the saying " When in Rome be a Roman ".
Do you pay all the taxes you legitimately owe to the Govt ? if not,how are you expecting the benefits which others enjoy in other countries ?
Still poor punter is SMART, please read his comment
" Majority of Indians are indisciplined." If you believe this, come up with solutions, bring a change, don't just make a statement and shrug it off.
If you cannot do anything about it then accept it as a fact and don't complain
Is it true that Indians when they go abroad, adhere to the prevailing laws and NRI's when they visit India revert to their old habits.
I just remembered a quote " Ask not what your country has done for you, Ask what you have done for your country " .
I can go on but I will end with " Walk a mile in the other persons shoes before you pass Judgement"
Accept others opinions but Act on your own.
This is not any personal affront so don't treat it as one.
Manish said ...
12-Jul-2018one has to stop the car and fold their hands behind their neck.
You watch too many hollywood movies.
Srinivas said ...
12-Jul-2018In Singapore and Dubai, even spitting on the road will be subject to heavy fines. These days, in Dubai even jay-walking is a punishable offence. Question of bribing the police doesn't arise, you could be subjected to additional fines if you dare to do so.
Stop Fooling Punter said ...
12-Jul-2018Today we are able to feed most of us. Mobile user is touching new highs.
I fail t o see where Suraj cut across from him at any stage.
Al these so called NRIS leave us alone and live in the country you have now adopted
Godzilla said ...
12-Jul-2018Even if you cross marked speed limits, the cops from nowhere will follow like shadow and one has to stop the car and fold their hands behind their neck. Its not India to throw a fifty note and getaway. One has to pay the fine.
Majority of Indians are indisciplined. They throw litters, urinate on roads. Even the elite take their pet dogs for a morning walk, so that it shits on the road, so that they need not worry about disposal. Dogs bums are required to be covered with baskets in foreign countries, so that the shit remains in the basket for proper disposal later.
One cannot throw cigaratte in Ocean in a cruise in US [from NY to Liberty Statue}. You will be booked under Ocean Abuse and a fine of 100 $ will be imposed. Whereas most of the guys in India near Ocean shit and wash their buttocks with the ocean water [saltish and antiseptic].
Dont make me to write more.
Aswin Patel said ...
11-Jul-2018" In US if you cut like LIL while driving a Car, not only one will be fined and one may have to forgo the Driving Licence also. "
REALLY ?
Smart-still-poor-punter said ...
11-Jul-2018Your rejoinder appears to be hitting the nail on the head. Why to ask for justice from stewards or a blanket ban on wrong-doers when we ourselves encourage illegal betting. To ask justice from a place like race course is a bit too much. You bet and you sweat. That's what every punter has been destined to.. Am I right?
Vishnu G said ...
11-Jul-2018Raghavan said ...
11-Jul-2018What if stewards had upheld the objection? A small section who played Sana SHP would have benefited. As the objection was only against Lady in Lace [and not the winner], Sana would be 2nd and Lady in lace would be 3rd. Place payment would have been same. Trinella & Exacta some effect. But for majority of punters the swapping of places 2nd & 3rd would not matter much.
Now, stewards over ruled the objection. Perhaps they might have felt that even if Sandesh is right, the interference is not so serious to upgrade Sana, who had finished 1.75 lengths behind Lady in lace.
Let us say that Godzilla is absolutely right. Strictly applying natural justice Sana should be upgraded. Rules are rules. 1OO% adherence should be there!
Godzilla jee. In any other matter, you can demand 1OO% adherence to rules. Not in racing. In racing you can demand 1OO% adherence only after you bet by paying full tax. 95% bettors are betting by paying 1O% tax. And, these people have no moral, ethical right to demand anything from Club, stewards.
Karunesh said ...
10-Jul-2018Sandesh first objection is absolutely correct. He was totally squeezed for room because Suraj came on him and cramped him for room as a result he had to check his mount who was traveling well. The second one near 150m is not so strong as LIL was traveling well and was a little far from Sana. In my view, the objection should have been upheld.
Manjunath said ...
10-Jul-2018Stop Fooling Punter said ...
10-Jul-2018I have said many times if you do not like the way races are run or conducted by any turf athy. better to skip that center.
Morever other than stake money, It did not matter much.some ups and down in forecast and tanala.
Trying to pull down others who express their view is in poor taste.AVOID
Atchut said ...
10-Jul-2018everybody has his own views to express but not to thrust on others.
viewed the video n the objection is not worthy.
Smart-still-poor-punter said ...
10-Jul-2018Everyone has a right to express their viewpoint. Isn't it? You have given yours in the first place, and it doesn't mean everyone should subscribe to it. That objection, according to me also, has no substance in it. Worth getting overruled.
Godzilla said ...
10-Jul-2018Guys
Read Ikram Khans Race Review of Sundays Races at indiarace.coms Home Page, which is cent percent in line with my observation. It states since after the bump and closing in the gap, Sandesh not stopped riding, the objection was turned down. Stewards expect Sandesh to completely stop riding Sana to justify upholding the objection. Jokers.
Godzilla said ...
10-Jul-2018vishal
Are you one of the Stewards from BTC or their spokesperson ?
Vishal said ...
10-Jul-2018Rightly over-ruled 10 times out of 10 for me.
But i respect your views and lets just leave it at that.
Cheers
Vishal
Punter said ...
10-Jul-2018Super observation and suggestion!
I always look forward for your posts. Its not only the selection but anything to do with racing. You have a very wise wisdom.
Smart-still-poor-punter said ...
10-Jul-2018Please do not blame the Stewards, and now Vishal, for overruling that frivolous objection. I too viewed it from the up and there is nothing to complain. You can see both at 150 ma nd 50 m that Sana was struggling to move forward even when Lady in Lace was devouring the ground. Why to blame LIL?
Sana was clearly going back at every stage and that is why even in the last 50 m he was easily overtaken by LIL. Let us accept the fact.
Godzilla said ...
10-Jul-2018
vishal
Do you know how to view the video in case of objection ?
The video is in two parts after the bend - the upper one shows front portion of running of horses and the lower one - side portion of running of horses -
View upper portion .. you will find LIL and Suraj bumping at 150 mtr marker where Sandesh had to check his mount - again at 50 mtrs when Sandesh was coming thru rails, Suraj again squeezes him and takes his ground. Sana came behind 1 3/4 length to LIL despite checking at two different places. Now tell me, if Suraj is not bumped Sana and squeezed, who knows Sana may be first and second in the Race.
In US if you cut like LIL while driving a Car, not only one will be fined and one may have to forgo the Driving Licence also.
Smart-still-poor-punter said ...
10-Jul-2018Fido Dido said ...
10-Jul-2018Smart-still-poor-punter said ...
10-Jul-2018Jockeys are treated in a shabby manner everywhere in India. I remember being very close with a jockey from Nepal, riding for the biggest stable in Chennai when I was living there some 20 years before. He used to confide with me that the 'Guinness record-holding' trainer used to shower abusive language on him during morning trials. There were also instances when these hapless riders used to manhandled. What a pity!
It's absolutely right the jockeys must be treated with respect. Why stand with folded hands when replying to Stewards? Who are these people? Are they Gods on earth? Even in courts we don't find an accused standing like this when answering queries from the judge.
I will only blame the Jockeys Association of India (JAI) which has done hardly anything for the betterment of its members. JAI should first attend to this critical issue raised by Godzilla.
Srinivas said ...
10-Jul-2018Agreed with your post, Godzy ! Some sense of rationlism and compassion for fellow-beings (jockeys) is definitely warranted.
But, the question is : Do the Stewards have the will and understanding ??? I very much doubt it.
Pandit said ...
10-Jul-2018Monise said ...
10-Jul-2018Ramiyer said ...
10-Jul-2018Jockies with folded hands answering the questions.Yes it is similar to the scenerio at police station. They also should be allowed to sit.
Racebro said ...
09-Jul-2018You have made a very valid point.
No one bothered to bring it to the attention of people or officials.
Officials should take notice of your comments. Thanks.
Godzilla said ...
09-Jul-2018One more point
The Jockeys involved in the Stewards Room are treated with scant respect by the Stewards. They are asked to stand like peons. In all fairness, there should be separate sitting arrangement for the Jockeys in the Stewards Room at the time of enquiry and they should be questioned with respect. They Stewards behave as if the jockeys are accused and question them like criminals in a Police Station.
After questioning the jockeys, they should be told that the enquiry is over and they may get along and the judgement will be passed soon. The Stewards should learn manners first.
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now