Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Pune Rno 2 Rating Of Regal Shot

By Sun | 26-Jul-2018
Dear All,
Can any one throw some light on Rating as appearing in RNO 2 of Pune today.It is shown as 46 but in RNO 96 of Mumbai it was 34 and Rno 166 it ran unplaced but now I see 46.Did it run in Delhi OR Ooty after Feb 10th engagement.Normally IR updates all runs of a horse.
Post Your reply

13 Replies

Crypticblue said ...

28-Jul-2018
@sun, that was a typo. It should be 46 n not 40

Sun said ...

28-Jul-2018
@Sanjay Shinde,
Thanks for your input.
@Cryptic Blue,
This may also be trues but HC could have given 41 to 45 rating for the horses to move to Chennai but why 46?Secondly the Chennai Ratings are in themselves a mystery to me when I look at Rating of Knight of Ke in Chennai and in Mysore.They are 20 points in some cases and in some cases they are not so high.

Sanjiv Shinde said ...

27-Jul-2018
@ sun

You are absolutely right one of my friend spoke to Mumbai hadicapper Niranjan singh he said its request promotion from Aravind ganapathy.

in my opnion it should win in next outing .

Crypticblue said ...

27-Jul-2018
Lets end the impasse here. There is no rocket science handicapping applied to either Regal Shot or Smart Vision. The actual reason, as I understand, is rather different.

Some of the horses from this trainer's yard were supposed to be transferred to Chennai. However, Chennai would not accept horses rated below 40. The Mumbai handicapper, thus based on a request, raised the rating of these horses. However, the horses ended up not going to Chennai. Period!

PS: The above post is merely to educate readers/writers on this forum struggling to find a sensible answer. And is not aimed to malign any individual/professional.

Sun said ...

27-Jul-2018
@Dharmesh,
Regarding Smart Vision rating in 5-1 my explanation holds good.just look at RNO 68 it placed 3rd and its rating is 26 and after race also it is normally 26 so this coreesponds to 62Kg in 1-26 class so in 20-46 class also it is assigned 62Kg ie 46 rating.
Logic is very simple Handicapper assumes that the horse may be having hidden potential and by requesting a promotion and getting assigned 49Kg he may run away with 2 wins.After all rating is a number on a scale and finally it boils down to the Timing a horse can turn out at a particular Weight.
Handicapper is very alert.

Daniell said ...

27-Jul-2018
THANK YOU SHARMA JI FOR VALUEABLE INFORMATION.

THANKS A LOT.

KEEP IT UP
DANIELL.

Sun said ...

27-Jul-2018
Dear All
Sorry to bore you on this topic but it is not a matter to be taken light.I could come up with a plausible explanation.This must have been a case of request promotion and RS was at 32 Rating that is 55KG mark in 20-46 scale.The overlap between scales is 3KG so on request promotion it is set to carry 55Kg minus 3Kg that is 52Kg and in 40-66 scale 52Kg translates to 46 which is rating assigned on request promotion at the end of the season.
Your views please.

Sun said ...

27-Jul-2018
Further to my post I looked at the Rating of Regal Shot at end of season on the RWITC web site and to my surprise it is indeed 46.Then I looked at Revised Ratings for 10th Feb races when Regal Shot ran in RNO 166 and its name is missing in the Revised Ratings page of RWITC web site.Only RWITC Handicapper can throw some light on why at the end of season it is rated 46 while it ran RNO 166 at a rating of 32 big question mark

Dharmesh said ...

26-Jul-2018
@ SC SHARMA

Then what about today 5-1 SMART VISION rated 46 and last start it was rated 23 ie straight one class raise.

I think your explanation is not correct because even if Regal Shot is eligible to run in class 3 it’s rating wont be raised to match the rating as per terms. It should have run with the rating of 32 or below at the lowest weight as per the terms of race. For example REMEMBER ME rated 69 & EXCELLENT GOLD rated 79 both ran in class 1 ( 80 & above) on opening day but both weighed same as SUMMER GOLD rated 81.
So even though Regal Shot is eligible to run in class 3 because of terms of the race it’s rating should have not been changed.

Regards

Sun said ...

26-Jul-2018
@S C Sharma,
Thanks for your detailed explanation but what I observed today is a deviation from standard practice.
I know that if a lower class horse is entered in a 2 class eligible race the min weight to be carried is at 49 but the rating is correctly mentioned.Here Jager Bomb rated 50 is at 53.5Kg so even if RS was assigned 49Kg the parity is maintained ie 50-9 equal to 41 still much higher than 32 its actual rating why 51.5Kg and because it is 51.5 the rating is shown as 46 ie 50-4.Any explanation ???
Now coming to earlier practice just look at RNo 245 of 25th March.Here it is 80+ race with 60-79 eligible and the rating of 2 horses viz Eternal Sunshine and Frivolous were shown as 78 and 74


@Anto what has my query to do with my racing caliber.If you through the above I had a point.Regal Shot at 51.5 why not 49 still maintaining the parity and 46 rating shown matches with 51.5 which is puzzling.

Raj said ...

26-Jul-2018
Sharma what you explained is what Mansoor Shah was doing in Bombay season 18. That’s how he was so moral on them.

Anto said ...

26-Jul-2018


@ SUN sir your questions is the best evidence of your racing caliber

@ S C Sharma sir your explanation as well.

I always spend time in reading your valuable article and explanation

Thanks,

Anthony

S C Sharma said ...

26-Jul-2018
SUN: you have rightly pointed out about RS whose rating is 32 and race publications showing it as 46. Last time this horse ran in 20 to 46 rating horses but this time he preferred to run in 40 to 66 rated horses because in this race horses 20 to 39 ratings are also eligible. As per RS rating he should carry weight of 44.5kg. But in this race( in today's run) the bottom scale of weight is 51.5 kg and top weight is 59. Trainer knows very well that here he is running on 7 kg worst terms still he is allowing so that the horse should finish no where and next time he will enter in right class with rating favorable/suited to him. Some times trainers continuously enter horses where terms are not suitable to their wards and suddenly one day they change their placement. Recently in Bangaluru trainer Padmanabhan did the same thing with Big Sur. He entered him with horses rated 100 and above where as his BS rated 72 and next outing he changed to 60 and above rating and won the race. That day I picked BS as my day's best bet and he obliged in 3.5 odds.