Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Re: Perfect Star

By Indian_turf_record | 15-Aug-2018

Most people believe that for a horse to have a winning chance (1) He must not be running after long layoff (2) He must not be grossly overweight (3) He must not be running over drastically different distance.

Perfect Star defied all these three beliefs today at Pune. His last run was on 4 Feb at Mumbai in Indian Derby where he was unplaced.

Today he ran at Pune after gap of over six months, was 25 kgs. over-weight and won over distance which was exactly half of his previous run.

Which why I maintain that anything is possible in racing and sometimes all calculations go for toss.
Post Your reply

35 Replies

Indian_turf_record said ...

20-Aug-2018
@ JP

Could I request you to refer my posting addressed to Mad Max (8/16/2018 9:32:15 PM) and another one addressed to Autonomy and Others (8/18/2018 4:42:30 PM) ? I am sure it will clarify.

Jp said ...

20-Aug-2018
@ ITR,your query 3) he must not be running over drastically different distance. 2000 to 1400 is it not drastically different distance ?

Indian_turf_record said ...

19-Aug-2018
@ JP

Like others, you have still have not got the parameters right.

We are looking for a horse who has won at HALF or DOUBLE the distance on his NEXT start. Mysore Derby is 2000 m. so CONFIDENT VICTORY's win over 1400 m. does not qualify.

Jp said ...

19-Aug-2018
Confident Victory finished 3rd in the Mysore Derby (long neck,neck) behind Splendid Surprise and came to Bangalore won the Darya Daulat Cup 1400 mts beating Rhapsidion Snow.

Indian_turf_record said ...

18-Aug-2018
@ Autonomy and Others

You seem to have misunderstood the topic. As 2YO or 3YO every horse starts by winning shorter distance races. There are several instances of Indian Derby winners (Princess Beautiful, Deepak, Odds On, Chakori, Balam, Commoner, Rough Deal, Alijah, Loyal Manzar, Prince Pradeep, Rose Royal, Red Rufus and many others) who had won 1000 m. race early in their careers.

The topic here is about horses winning over drastic change of distance (HALF or DOUBLE) in CONSECUTIVE starts. Velvet Rope's previous start before Derby was RR Ruia Cup over 2000 m.

All the same, thanks for your reply. Your participation is much appreciated.

Autonomy said ...

18-Aug-2018
@ITR Sir

Velvet Rope, the indian derby winner of 2006, who beat two giants i.e.Mystical and Holding Court, won a 1200 mtr race and two 1400 mtr races before winning Indian Derby.

Thanks

Simhan said ...

18-Aug-2018
Castle bridge also won 2000 mtrs,1600 mtrs &1200mtrs.

Jp said ...

18-Aug-2018
@ ITR, Thanks.

Joshi said ...

18-Aug-2018
Appeaser from D Byramji yard was one such which always preferred long distance but after a lay off won a sprint race

Indian_turf_record said ...

18-Aug-2018
@ kumar_blore

I am sure you mean Bangalore season because there is no Oaks run in Mysore season.

After winning Bangalore Oaks, Nairn won two races from six starts in the remainder of that racing year. Her wins came in Civil Service Cup (1800) and Governor's Cup (2400).

Kumar_blore said ...

17-Aug-2018
@againstodds,
When you mentioned about darashah,I remember a horse called Nairn which won the oaks in the Mysore season before winning a sprint distance....I might be wrong,ITR can correct it if am wrong.
Thanks

Indian_turf_record said ...

17-Aug-2018
@ JP

STAR CONTENDER did win Karnataka Police Trophy over 1200 m. ridden by Robin Corner on 4 Nov 1990. His previous race was Derby Bangalore (2000 m.) -- not Stayers' Cup -- during Bangalore Summer season where he finished fourth.

Memory plays tricks when events have taken place nearly 30 years ago.

@ stop fooling punter

STRENGTHTOSTRENGTH does not quite fit the bill. He won over 1200 m. on Saturday and 1600 m. on Sunday. BERGAMO had done the same thing much earlier.

Pk said ...

17-Aug-2018
Stopfoolingpunter
The horse u are referring is strength to strength

Jp said ...

17-Aug-2018
I am sure Star Contender won a sprint race in Bangalore. Some time back I quoted this in this forum and said Jagadish rode the horse. Somebody corrected it as Robin Corner.

Stop Fooling Punter said ...

17-Aug-2018
The best example is of the horse owned by Maj bp singh Ridden by L''maire

Invitation weekend won on Sat and sunday [forgot the name]

Indian_turf_record said ...

17-Aug-2018
@ JP

STAR CONTENDER won Stayers' Cup at Bangalore (not Hyderabad). His next run was in K.R.O.A. Cup during Bangalore Summer season over 1600 m. in which he finished fourth. He never ran in a 1200 m. race after Stayers' Cup.

I appreciate that you are speaking from memory while I am writing after checking printed records.

Jp said ...

17-Aug-2018
Star Contender won the Stayer's Cup @ Hyderabad and then in its first outing in Bangalore summer won a sprint race(1200).

Indian_turf_record said ...

17-Aug-2018
@ againstodds

Thank you very much for your reply.

We are looking for horses who won HALF the distance in the very NEXT start. Diabolical ran in Invitation Cup (2400 m) and won B.T.C. Anniversary Cup (1400 m.) on his next start. Not quite HALF the distance. There are others like Almanac who have also done it.

Diabolical won Indian Derby in 2007. His good run at Calcutta came in 2008-09 after a gap of one year.

Againstodds said ...

17-Aug-2018
@ITR sir.

Long ago , at the beginning of Mysore season, trainer Z Darashah used to surprise us , used to win a sprint with a long distance runner, that too in class I. Reason attributed by knowledgable race goer was, a long distance runner can do it during its first run of the season. There may be substance in it. I may be permitted to bring to your notice, the performance of Indian Derby winner Diabolical, later in Kolkata , it started winning the distance - from 1400M to all the way to 2800M in a single season. If I am wrong , ma be corrected.

Indian_turf_record said ...

16-Aug-2018
@ Mad Max

Your point that Perfect Star had won his only previous race with a body weight of 500+ is very valid.

I can cite some horses who won at double the distance in their next start. BUCEPHALUS won Indian Derby (2400) after having won over 1200 m. in previous start just six days earlier. HOVERCRAFT and BRIGHT HANOVAR won Turf Invitation having raced in 1200 m. race previously.

I can recall only one horse who won at half the distance in his next start. OUR SELECT won Indian St. Leger (2800) and on next start won Lumley Cup (1400).

There must be several other such examples. If somebody mentions them, I can check them out.

Jp said ...

16-Aug-2018
"Race gifted to Karthik"???!!!!. What about other races when your choice wins?

PS had a good long rest, good track work and a very impressive mock race. It had run with better horses in terms races.

Hunter said ...

16-Aug-2018
Perfect Star featured in our Derby PTR entries, but we all ignored it now, so we pay....

HH....

Smart-still-poor-punter said ...

16-Aug-2018
Both 'Star' and 'Angel' turned out to be armchair rides for Imran Khan. It's true that not many would have had the guts to go beyond this rider, in a centre like Pune. But then, his trainer knows about the rider's ability. That has been proved beyond doubt here. If Trevor, Sandesh and Suraj alone keep winning, there is going to be no charm in racing. Isn't it?

Golden Girl said ...

16-Aug-2018
It was third favourite horse in the race,so we can not say ,that it was fluke horse.Many of us overlooked Perfect star cause of overweight and wrong distance,long lay off.The race was run on merit.The timing Perfect Star clocked is 1.09.69.None of his 9 rivals has clocked this time at this weight,ever in their life.Thus it was a very well planned successful gamble.
Overweight horses rarely win,but we must take in account at what wt.the horse has won before? WELL EVERYDAY WE LEARN SOMETHING NEW IN RACING.

Rrajesh said ...

16-Aug-2018
Godzilla sir
gift therace to kartik?????? a comment like this coming from you.surprised

just see records of perfect star...with which horses he has run,fought and distance

i thought it was a good bet in win place which i had posted....but i saw 25 kilos put on ..i played very small place bet and cursed myself

Savio said ...

16-Aug-2018


Attn Mad Max

Thanks for your write up

Walking down memory lane if i am right Look Out trained by Trainer Imtiaz Sait ridden by Light weight Jockey Yusuf Khan won the race at the age of. 8 or 9 distance was 1400 mts in early 70


Savio

Stop Fooling Punter said ...

16-Aug-2018
ITR I followed this strictly way ofnot rouching wt.increasde horse and lost on this case and Shivalik heroine[up about 23 kgs]

I have won in 5 cases where wt. increase was seen so not bad but one must always stick to one rule.

Mad max your point is valid but how can one keep track of it with so many horses.

Godzilla please stop this whining of gifted races.you are way out of your depth.


Ask Lagad,he is finding it difficult to get a winner even with 18 runners

Suresh said ...

16-Aug-2018
The one & only reason for PERFECT STAR win was earlier it's all runs were TERMS races with classic horses in classics. Now in handicap won easily. In my choice of selections I have given only PERFECT STAR & I played only that horse win.
Thank you

Manish said ...

16-Aug-2018
@ITR

Dont confuse exception with rule. The factors you stated above normally hold true in racing. But definitely not everytime.

Godzilla said ...

16-Aug-2018

ITF

The Races were allotted to Karthink Ganapathy. Otherwise, his horses rarely win.

Rakesh said ...

16-Aug-2018
thats why they are called as "general"..

Mad Max said ...

16-Aug-2018
@ Indian_Turf_Record

Perfect Star won R.No.153 with a body weight of 514 Kgs and beaten Lord of The Sea by 3-3/4 lengths over a mile trip. Thereafter in subsequent runs, it shed its weight to 486. I was waiting for it to regain its fitness level. Today it regained it the body weight to 511 kgs and it won. So Perfect Star was not overweight. It was a perfect gamble.

I still remember, in the past our veteran trainers like SS Shah, Imtiaz Sait, Pesi Shroff gambled their long distance horses over (2400m) over sprint and won a few times (I cant recall names of horses). Sir, you can cite us names of few horses won from 2400m to 1200m. I played Perfect Star at 5.50. Because of the pathetic dividends declared at totes, I found it easy and lucrative to play with the bookies at 10% tax. Alvida Tote !

Srinivasan said ...

16-Aug-2018
If you observe the track PS has tracked 800M in 48 and last 600M in 36 seconds ( iTHINK ON 11-8-18)which no other horse has done it.

secondly if you observe all other 4yo has won two races in Mumbai and PS was not.

In fact the best animal IN THE STARS I played and this animal did not figure in board.

IT IS BETTER NOT TO SELECT THE HORSE WHICH HAVE WON IN MUMBAI (THAT TOO 2 TIMES) TO BE LEFT ALONE TILL THE MUMBAI SEASON AND THIS APPLIES TO BTC ALSO.

Goodbad13 said ...

15-Aug-2018
Though I am posting it after the race PERFECT STAR had all the opportunity to defy the common beliefs which it made perfect use off. Before I get into postmortem I would like to thank DRCHEENU whom many here might be knowing for transferring his immense knowledge and helping me to dissect the race into digestible portions

THE ENLIGHTENMENT PLATE to be run about 1200 Mts
Terms: A Handicap for Horses Rated 60-86 (Class-II) (40 to 59 eligible) open class (age no restriction)

10 runners

Narrowing down into digestible portions

Ignoring the older lots (HIGHLAND BREEZE, PRICELESSGIRL, QUEEN CREDIBLE): 7 runners left
Ignoring the same class winners who are yet to come to winning mark: (EXCELLENT GOLD, GAZINO)5 runners left
Ignoring the runners who opened the account in class 4(STAR OF THEA): 4 runners left

Generally, after this step, I would start looking into horses with run benefit in the class however the tricky part is all 4 remaining runners are getting into this class for the first time.

PERFECT STAR had a BIG advantage on other 3 because of his consistent good runs (not I also ran) in the following races
The Poonawalla Breeders Multi-Million 4th
The Colts Championship Stakes 2nd
The Deccan Colts Championship Stakes 4th
The Kingfisher Ultra Pune Derby 4th
The Jacqueline Indian 2000 Guineas 3rd

So despite being just a maiden winner, he ended up in this class and with a solid preparation grabbed the race with all 4 hooves.

Of the remaining three GLYNDEBOURNE had an advantage of running 3rd in Gr3 (The F D Wadia Trophy) so she rightfully claimed the bridesmaid spot.

In fact, PERFECT STAR did not defy any beliefs

1) He must not be running after a long layoff: Well a mock race might not be equivalent to race but good enough to ignore the layoff
2) He must not be grossly overweight: He weighed 514 when he won the maiden race so I am assuming he was underweight till today
3) He must not be running over drastically different distance: Purely my assumption horse has proved he is only good enough to earn stakes money by running into places in Graded/Terms race and Pune season has roughly 4 races for class 2 to be run over 1600. So I am sure Mr. Ganapthy would like to see his horse win and smart enough to take advantage of the poor opposition

After reading the above many might have below questions

Older horses have beaten 4-year-olds in the past
Same class winners have repeated before coming to winning mark
so on and so forth

There is absolutely every chance of the above scenarios happening but only in case of the 4-year-old does not fit into the scheme or its an on money fav

Would like to finish with the golden words of DR CHEENU "First understand the past results before you start to analyze the future card"

Good luck all.

S C Sharma said ...

15-Aug-2018
Indian - Turf - Record: I fully agree with you. Sometimes many calculations go wrong in racing. That's why the saying reminds me that only certainty in racing is uncertainty. I saw the mock race of PS and other impressive workouts also but still preferred to ignore because of only one reason that the six furlong distance may prove too sharp for this gelding. I proved wrong. Pl continue to bring such things to light for the benefit of one and all. Thanks.