Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Can A Punter Be A Successful Bookie?

By Smart-still-poor-punter | 28-Aug-2018
Hi Everyone,

A majority of punters, at some point of time in their racing career, used to dream about becoming a bookie, thinking that being a bookmaker is the easiest thing to be in this world to make money.

I had seen some of my close friends opening book in Mysuru, hoping to cash in on the 'poor' temperament of race-goers and the unstable racing environment to make a fast buck. But within months, I remember finding them on the floor? When asked, they said "It's no joke to be a bookie either". They hastened to add "it appears being a punter is the safest thing to be". I did nothing but laughing to myself!

There are popular bookies in Chennai today, who were mere card writers ('pencillors' in racing parlance) of yesteryear. But the secret behind their roaring success is that their transition was straight from being a card writer to a bookmaker, and no punting in between.

There are bookies, again in Chennai, who play madly in the ring without being much bothered about the business in their stall. While most of those standing in the ring might think that they are doing the 'cut' for big people, the truth remains that they play for themselves. This is a punter-cum-bookie business. For them it's profitable too!

A normal punter, who invests in the range of Rs.5,000 to Rs.10,000 on a given day, dreaming to become a bookie can prove disastrous only because he will continue to operate the book under the guise of a punter. He will be either afraid to eat the favourite when all others do, or he may unknowingly eat the second and third favourites, and some times even long shots, and land himself in deep trouble.

One of my friends, who managed to gather about Rs.5 lakh in the early 1990's (a huge amount then!) wanted me to accompany him when he decided to open a book in Mysuru (Remember, during those days opening a stall in a centre like Mysuru happened in a matter of hours!). I joined him to Mysuru but stayed in different rooms in the same lodge. I, as a punter, earned a few thousand rupees during the weekend while he ended up losing 50% of his investment within that period. He dropped the idea of continuing with the business, came back as a punter, only to lose the remaining money also very soon.

The survival of a bookie also relies on a host of factors. There are many leading bookmakers who had given up half way through, fearing that they may come to the roads if they continued with the business. But they always have the option to invest in some other profitable business. Unfortunately, for a punter there is no second option. Be a punter and die a punter!


Post Your reply

8 Replies

Raghavan said ...

01-Sep-2018
@ Champ

"Most of the punter die as punter" : True.

"few who make it disappear quietly". partially true. There are people to whom god may bless with big gain. Those who run away after such bounty are doubly wise. But, there are punters who squander all their gains and thereafter lose heavily from their pockets also.

"those who make noise are not believed". Seems true. I was having company of such extrovert people. Of course they used to stay with me till I oblige them with coffee and cigarette. They used t talk perfectly about the races that are already run. For the current and subsequent races they used to add riders like "if, but, upset, fluke" etc.

Champ said ...

31-Aug-2018
most of punters die as a punter...

few, who make it disappear quietly...

those who make noise are not believed...

Oh my God.... Raghavanji, do u hear this.....

Small Time Punter said ...

30-Aug-2018
When I thought of becoming a bookmaker, I went to one of the person, who had burnt his fingers couple of times by becoming a bookie. It was in late 90s. It was relatively much easier to get a bookies licence. He said, one can become a successful bookie if one can master the art of balancing the book.

PUNTING IS COMPLETE NO-NO.

AND finally he said, once you become a bookie
"EVEN IF GOD COMES AND SAYS THAT THIS HORSE WON'T WIN". Please IGNORE his information and concentrate on book balance. Then only you can become a successful bookie.

Chanakya said ...

29-Aug-2018
punter and bookie are 2 sides of a coin - most of people believe.

but the truth is otherwise...

bookies exist because of puntrrs - not vice versa...

any punter can become a successful bookie. provided he has self control, and KNOWS the game...

LONG AGO in 70's/80's a big punter became a bookie at Mumbai with a stall in the ring but after 2 or 3 seasons closed down...

now-a days i see at least 4 or 5 bookies of yester-years moving around in the 'ring'...

but there are 3 or 4 bookmakers of 70's and 60's who are still doing business...

most of punters die as a punter...

few, who make it disappear quietly...

those who make noise are not believed...

Krishnamurthy said ...

29-Aug-2018
dear SSPF, A leading bookmaker in bangalore, who also happens to be punting minded, has tried his bookmaking skills at Delhi pune hyderabad and now operating in Mysore.

Smart-still-poor-punter said ...

29-Aug-2018
@ Raghavan
@ Raghavan


@ Raghavan : I slightly differ with you when you say that one can look ahead to compound his money to come back with compound interest in the next 2-3 days. Maybe you are true as long as that man is not a former punter. What I want to state here is that a punter has more or less a fixed mindset like "I will play only this horse at only this odds", "this trainer is popular for pulling" and "this jockey is useless". Bookies generally don't entertain such wild thoughts."Eat, eat" is all that they know but they also know up to what extent to eat. Punters, in sharp contrast, hardly know what is their limit. And there starts their downfall. You are right, a bookie can land himself in trouble if he tries to don the role of a punter also. Having said that, there are bookies who sustain both. That is only because they are blessed with lots of wealth. And the earnings that they make as bookmaker offsets their loses at the other end. Am I right?

@ Godzilla

It's nice to see you comparing punters and bookies with carpenters and plumbers, and so on!

The fact remains that punting is only seen as a passion for many, although bookmakers consider it as an absolute profession. Not even 5% of the race-goers live through racing.

Again, a carpenter can be a good plumber also. Please what stops them to be both? For egs, the carpenter who visits my house in Kerala regularly did all the plumbing work when my house was smashed by recent floods. Similarly, what's wrong in a mason being an electrician. It can only bring additional income. A civil engineer will be delighted to pursue the job of a mechanical engineer too.

I did not say that a punter cannot be a bookmaker. It's after all his money. But my contention is that he can't be successful. That's all. Let us also not compare the lifestyle of Indians with Americans, or even the earnings people make in these countries. Hardly there can be a parallel.

Godzilla said ...

29-Aug-2018
sspp

Can a Carpenter do a Plumbers job ? Or a mason can do an Electrician job ? Or a Civil Engineer can do a Mechanical Engineers job ?

Everyone has got different role to play.

Bookies get the odds from one source and they stick on come what may ! Overall the Bookies make a profitable book. An intelligent punter knows how to make money despite momentary losses.

In US, a whore makes more money than anyone else. But again look at the hardship she has to undergo !!!!!

Therefore, thats that.

Raghavan said ...

29-Aug-2018
If a man opts to become a bookie, he has every reason to expect a decent earnings. Sometimes, he has to pay from his pocket but he can expect that money with compound interest come back to him in the next 2-3 days. That is what my understanding is. However for every theory there will be 1 or 2 exemptions.

A bookie may land in trouble if he decides on double role. A bookie & a punter.