Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Excellent Art

By Godzilla | 01-Oct-2018

There is nothing to boast about Sire EXCELLENT ART.  Progeny out of Excellent Art cannot travel more than 1400 mtrs. 

This has been proved at Hyderabad today. Sublime in a 2000 mtr Race with lowest handicap Neeraj Rawal up finished in the ruck. So too, the much hyped Excellent Hope which lost to KING MAKER in a mile Race.

The guys who had acquired Excellent Art progeny under the impression it will travel long distance, must be keeping their hands on their head and dejected.

Star Superior is an exception.

Win Legend, Phoenix Tower, Steinbeck, Multidimensional, Burden of Proof Whatsthescript,Net Whizz, Varenar, West Virginia, Princely Heir, Sedigefield, Lord Admiral, Deans Kitten, Dream Ahead etc. are better Sires than EXCELLENT ART.

 

 

Post Your reply

19 Replies

Godzilla said ...

04-Oct-2018

Hunter

Yesterday in Mysore another Excellent Art Sire progeny TURF MAGIC flopped even in a 6 furlong Race.

Daybefore, in Hyderabad both PROCLAMATION and HAILSTORM flopped in a mile Race.

From now on you give Winners details and I will give flop details. Treat this an arrangement.

Godzilla said ...

03-Oct-2018

Hunter

Gimme the break up clearly indicating the distance, class, and the set Excellent Art progeny had 17 wins as per you out of 128. I can account for 2 wins of Excellent in Pune, one win of Star Superior and one win of Issable in Hyd yesterday. Gimme the balance 13 winners.

Please dont write about Phoenix Tower. I dont know why you are accounting for PT which we are not discussing here.

Godzilla said ...

03-Oct-2018

Boosa/ITR/SC Sharmaji

I would like to clarify that I have not taken anyones write up personally.

One Star Superior is not enough to indulge in beating the drums that Excellent Art is a Champion Sire nor its earnings points out the real facts about the Sire. Star Superior is a rare golden gift which Poonawals realized quite late and grabbed a partnership with Narredus to run in their colours. It will not stand the Indian Derby distance of 2400 mtrs at Bombay.

Even Elusive Pimpernal was a sole Champion. What happened to other horses out of Sire of EP ?

Suraj was so nervous on Star Superior yesterday, the horse got drifted in the straight and won. Then he thanked Almighty by gesturing and continuously flashed victory sign as if he won a hard fought battle. That shows the level of confidence of Suraj on EXCELLENT ART progeny. Take a look at the video so that you will desist calling my statement as an exaggerated one.

It was similar to Indian Cricket team beating minnows Banngladesh in the last ball and then hugging each other and flashing victory sign.

One guy in Calcutta named his Excellent progeny as Cadillac and the dam side of the horse was Classic Sky. He must be dreaming this horse will run the long distance like Cadillac, whereas it has not travelled the speed of even the flop Tata Nano.

I will not hesitate to rate DESPERADO [Wing Legend [JPN] - Integra) as the Champion in the making.

 

Hunter said ...

03-Oct-2018

Here's what the record says...

 

In 20 racedays in this Pune season, there have been 123 races with following leading sires:

1. Excellent Art: 17 wins

2. Phoenix Tower: 15 wins

Other sires like Varenar and Sedgefield are distance behind.

 

Rahul said ...

02-Oct-2018

what was great on the win os SS. He drifted under pressure beat a horse who was so tired that drifted to the outer rail and 3 rd ran a 6 fulong sprinter. Excellent Fart against the Champion SC will be treat to see how he makes mince meat of SS in any race mile and over.

Boosa said ...

02-Oct-2018

Mr Godzilla again u took it personally great #no hard feelings  dont u think star superior stayed or not  and more over results won't speak anything about horses if it was like that then all the big owners would have brought horses with results and y mistry is trying to win a Indian derby in his own colours then it was easy peasy for big owners to win big races  recent example is lady in lace brought by mistry and star superior by poonawallas . I might be wrong in judgement but it doesn't mean you are right #please throw some light on Godzilla s understanding and please educate him a more #if u give more winners it doesn't mean u r knowledgeable in racing #even the amateurs crack more races #i hope u got my point boss#

Indian_turf_record said ...

02-Oct-2018

@ Godzilla,

1. Yes I can but prefer that you look for it yourself.

2. The Champion Sire is not determined by me  or anyone else. The stallion whose progeny wins maximum stakes in a year  automatically becomes the Champion Sire. I have merely said that Excellent Art has a very good chance.

Godzilla said ...

02-Oct-2018

ITR

In the first Race at Hyderabad today, EXCLUSIVENORTHWIND thrashed both Hailstorm and Proclamation belonging to EXCELLENT ART. The winner of this Race carried 60 kgs, back breaking handicap.

Poonawallas horses out of Excellent Art can win in Pune only, being his home ground. 

Can you give details of the performance of EXCELLENT Art progney with distances this year before calling it a Champion Sire.

Bellamkonda Suresh said ...

02-Oct-2018

True

Godzilla said ...

02-Oct-2018

Boosa

I have gone thru your posting. You will have to agree, all said and done about Sire Excellent Art, the performance of progeny  of Excellent Art with different dam side is very poor so far .  Records speak. Even with a stayer like Classic Sky being dam side, it flopped - the horse in question is Cadillac.

One Star Superior is not enough, which will not stand Winter Derby distance. Win Legend is a real Legend.

Godzilla said ...

02-Oct-2018

Hunter

Dont compare Phoenix Tower with Excellent Art.  This year Indian Derby winner is Rochester, whose sire is PT. In Kolkata  Monsoon Derby Peluche out of sire PT gifted the Race to Shivansh . We talk with records supporting our statement.

You, yourself is admitting that EXCELLENT ART progeny cannot travel more than 6 furlongs. The buyers can, therefore, bargain and buy horses out of sire of their choice.

Abbas here stated that Ace and Arazan also duds. He is correct.

Whispering Shadow said ...

02-Oct-2018

Hmm ..interesting read ..

Star superior is an exception ..coz ...others Haven't entered good horses against it .

I suspect if it can stay the Long hyd stretch for this mile and a quarter trip ..

My eyes will bring on Sandesh's mount Evon Von Brando .. 

Indian_turf_record said ...

02-Oct-2018

    Racing year ends at end of month and SBAI will announce breeding awards for 2017-18.  It is very possible that Excellent Art will be Champion Sire. Horses are judged by results and not what people call them.

Abbas said ...

02-Oct-2018

I AGREE WITH GODZILLA.......POONAWALA STUD FARM IS PRODUCING DUD AFTER DUD....STARTING FROM ACE , ARZAN AND NOW EXCELLENT ART..........I AM AFRAID KUNIGAL GOING THE SAME WAY WITH AIR SUPPORT......IT DOESNT MATTER FROM WHERE THE STAMINA COMES INTO THE HORSE...WHAT MATTERS IS THE CONFIDENCE OF A PUNTER WHICH DEFINATELY COMES FROM THE SIRE....

Hunter said ...

02-Oct-2018

Please do not blame Poonawalas for importing Excellent Art and by same token do not blame Mistrys for importing Phoenix Tower. First try to answer some questions pertaining to horse racing in India:

1. What percentage of races are framed for 'staying' distances, i.e., mile-and-half and more?

2. How many owners are interested in winning classics?

The answer to both questions is 'very few'.

So, that puts pressure on breeders to breed horses who will do well over 1200-1400-1600 metres. That's where Excellent Art and Phoenix Tower come in. These stallions keep throwing up progeny who perform well over shorter distances, thus meeting demand of the prospective owners. It's Economics 101 - supply meeting demand. There would be some exceptions of course - but remember that exceptions prove the rule.

Boosa said ...

02-Oct-2018

Knowledgeable punters analyst and pedigree experts please throw some light on this can a race can be won by a horse tactically when it is inferior to the running field by just two or three lengths 

S C Sharma said ...

02-Oct-2018

Boosa:    what you stated is correct at the time of buying horses owner,trainer give more weight to dam side. How many races won by sire and over what distance count less than how many races won by dam counts more. Number of owners prefer to by fillies instead of colt because of breeding value. Before retiring to stud how many races won by the filly or mare counts and breeding value of the foal totally depends upon performance of the dam. Thanks for your write up. 

Boosa said ...

01-Oct-2018

Mr Godzilla I am again frustrated by your comments on excellent art do u know how much a stallion s blood line goes in to a horse I pity you seriously make a note 90percent of the time mares make a horse a stayer not stallion where in the world have u seen a dud stallion no where to be precise all the stallions are good to stay but it's mother's side contribute more the stamina part of a horse do u think then poonawallas  didn't had knowledge while buying excellent art don't be be judgemental on stallions always brood mare contribute more to the performance of the horse then if your vision was true every student farm would have brought horses as stallion which are bred to stay (till cow come home ) it's all about mating with brood mares and mares in scientific way by experience it may work it many not work .mark my words star superior has improved leaps and bounds and its genuine stayer it's a live threat any body who wants to win Indian derby has to beat #STAR SUPERIOR (if u have doubtplease cross check the split timings with the stayers )if a horse isn't cut above the other runners in any field more the 7 furlings if it is equally matched then luck and pace and judgement by jockey produces the result .I hope u won't take it  personally it's just my opinion .

Naren said ...

01-Oct-2018

Burden of Proof is no more