Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Star Superior Proved Superiority

By S C Sharma | 02-Oct-2018

 Star Superior put at rest the doubts raised about his staying capacity by winning the Hyderabad Deccan Derby in style by making his own pace and winning from end to end in a smart time of 2.05.295 and Corfe Castle proved that like Ruffina distance races are not his cup of tea and he finished tame third. Star Superior slightly drifted after entering straight and when applied pressure to accelerate but Suraj Narredu immediately corrected him by using his whip from left and he responded magnificently to score by three and half length. My opinion following all the way to SS also drifted and in last furlong travelled wide outside almost nearing outer sand track railing but still managed to remain second. SS also proved that he is second best to Sir Cecil . His body weight is more than 500 kg(517) and throughput his career he is very consistent and maintaining good condition. Kudos to his young trainer and Suraj Narredu.  More will be heard about him in future and his runs will be watched with lot of interest.

Post Your reply

9 Replies

Indian_turf_record said ...

04-Oct-2018

@ CRK

You do have a valid point. When we are talking about what is going to happen in future, different people have different views.

Last year Castlebridge won Mysore Derby by nearly five legths in time of 1:59:62 against opponents who were doubtful stayers, physically unfit or not yet ready. He is the only horse in India to have run 2000 m. under 2 mins. He never won again beyond a mile and is more of sprinter today.

There were some pedigrees angles which suggested that Castlebridge may not be a true stayer. There are similar doubts in case Star Superior also.

Let's wait and watch.

Crk said ...

03-Oct-2018

 @ ITR .

Star Superior clocked the best time over 2000 m, winning comfortably against miler horses. Not withstanding the competition, would it be right to doubt his staying ability, considering the timing and ease of victory ?

A conclusion on a weak foundation !

Jp said ...

03-Oct-2018

I agree with Indian Turf Record. If 10 sprinters run 2400 mtrs , one will win .It does not mean the horse is a stayer. The race appeared as though it was decided to gift the race to SS,when there were only 4 acceptors. Prevalent Force started in Chennai and everybody thought it is next Mystical. I wrote in this forum that PF ran with a poor lot and let it run with real challengers. Let SS run few more to say it is a stayer. Both the winner and rubber up are drifiting in the closing stages repeatedly and what the trainers are doing.

Race Tiger said ...

03-Oct-2018

sir now time has came to watch the staying Capebelity and power of Roberta the Indian derby winning filly from pesi"s yard

Indian_turf_record said ...

03-Oct-2018

@ S.C. Sharma

     Thank you your reply. There is difference between  track record and  race record.  Star Superior's is race record and not  track record.

     The concept of staying ability being relative one has different interpretations and each to his own. I can only quote some examples.  CASTLEBRIDGE  did win Mysore Derby over 2000 m. but subsequently reverted to sprinting. PREVALENT FORCE won Deccan Derby and South India Derby but he also is now running over shorter distances.

      Winter racing will show Star Superior's true aptitude and untill then we can hold on to our individual  interpretations.  

 

S C Sharma said ...

03-Oct-2018

Indian - Turf - Record:  Sir,  I am really thankful to you for correcting my mistake in noting down the timing of the winner SS. I remember only Tintabulation cut better than this time over this trip. If I am wrong you can correct me. While admitting my mistake and regretting  for mentioning wrong timing I too disagree with you that when a horse making his own pace cut the second best timing of that racing center how can be he denied or not accepted that he stays the trip very well and how still we are raising doubts about his staying potential/capacity?. I think if any other horse would have pacemaker than Star Superior would have equalled  or surpassed the earlier record of Tintabulation.

M.m.beamrao said ...

03-Oct-2018

@turf record.      Well said.

S C Sharma said ...

03-Oct-2018

Sir,   The fastest time over 2000 mts trip at Malakpet, hyderabad race course is 2.03.818 and the winner who cut the timing is Tintinnabulation in the year 2014 on 18th of August and the trainer was L V R Deshmukh.

Indian_turf_record said ...

03-Oct-2018

@ S.C. Sharma

 

      Firstly, you have inadvertently given the time clocked by My Opinion as the wining time. Star Superior won in time of 2:4:591 and it is fastest time ever for this race.

      I hope you will permit me to disagree with your statement about Star Superior proving that he can stay..Staying or not staying is relative . Not one of the four runners was bred to stay or had showed potential to stay. If four milers run in 2000 m. race and one of them wins, it does not make him stayer.