Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Sircecil Vs Desert God

By Aravind | 22-Oct-2018

Probably next year Invitation cup both great horses in India cud participate in this race.Assuming both are accepted dear honourable IR members pl ponder your views who will win? Sir Cecil or Desert God? Some may think it's silly to discuss about it but when great punters indulge in genuine talking in this forum it wud be interesting to c all views.I am sure it's going to be a deadheat!!

Post Your reply

28 Replies

Subzero said ...

25-Oct-2018

 ROBERTA

 ROBERTA

 ROBERTA

 

Hunter said ...

25-Oct-2018

Well done @drk!

At which window can I collect my winnings?

Toroloco said ...

25-Oct-2018

Guys dont underestimate Star Superior. It is indeed a special horse. He is currently being trained and prepared for long races.  You will  definately see Star Superior peforming well over long distances in the Winter seaons in Mumbai and Bangalore.

Drk said ...

25-Oct-2018

winter derby's 

kolkotta : shivansh

hyderabad :  star superior

banglore: sir cecil

mumbai  : sir cecil 

hyd (invitation)  sir cecil

sprinters  : rufinna

Zubin said ...

25-Oct-2018

Yes Any..

Certainly if all goes well than Roberta will be a super threat to Sir Cesil. 2400 m is a severe test for front running horse. 

But before any conclusions let's see how the progress goes..

Zubin...

Hunter said ...

25-Oct-2018

The Indian Derby will not be a walk-over for Sir Cecil. Watch Rajendrasinghji Million on coming Saturday. This race is likely to throw up new challengers. I'll be watching Hammersmith and Merlot closely.

Any said ...

24-Oct-2018

Just Assume Both will be running for 8FL with Ruffina, LIL, SERJEANT AT ARMS........hahahahahahaahaha

It just crezy feeling..

Any said ...

24-Oct-2018

Agree Mr.Zubin

This time Pessi ready to fire in indian derby-2019. he has good horses 1000m to 2400m He can upset any race. doesn't matter wheter Sir or God for invitation.

Varun said ...

24-Oct-2018

Sir cecil will be anothet hall of famer, but she was lightly raced and Indian Derby is her 6th start while SC as said by Padmanabhan, is aiming for Indian Derby as his 10th or 11th start, he may lose his gas and can be beaten in Mahalakshmi track by other horse like Roberta or Arabia. His only negative is front running tactics, he cant last long in long mumbai straight (600 mts). hall of famer win was not impressive and the timing says it all. He will be beaten in RR Ruia Gold Cup (road to indian derby) let the winter classics start then we can see his downfall in upcoming winter classics, although i like him, im sure he wont win Indian Derby. He can be entered in invitatation day races (Super Mile) and the Super Mile is in the mercy of another wonder horse Serjeant At Arms.

Aravind said ...

24-Oct-2018

Thanks for all your comments and views. Sharma ji has had realistic approach and I m also in similar line that SC may go up in each and every race and DG may retaire to stud after 2 or 3 races.but even it compete with SC I dought it's caoabikity to hear SC.also one members view abt foreign victories I think SC could do proud of Indian racing in foreign countries if owners decided to take thete.

Mohan said ...

24-Oct-2018

@godzilla,

Star superior? Really? Are u in your senses compairing Class 1 animal Star Superior with classic Sir Cecil and Desert God?

Jaykar said ...

24-Oct-2018

@godzilla, i saw your selections against Sir Cecil on Mr.Handsome and also your yestdays selection of Reunion against Desert God.. all your selection failed misreably...now you taking name of Star Superior with SC and DG..have you really forgotton equine and handicapping study? Or building up of racing losses causing this pain in u?

Ramdas said ...

24-Oct-2018

it is going to be one horse race for star superior on invitation day ,the paddy's stable will not be sighted.

Vinodrocks said ...

24-Oct-2018

Keep an eye on "MY OPINION", and this up-setter can topple and has time to improve upon and can strike rich either in Indian Derby/Invitation.

Sir Cecil has current form needs to maintain this through the next six-seven months which is a big task

Arunkumar said ...

24-Oct-2018

i can see only ROBERTA as a potential threat to Sir Cecil

 

Zeddzzz. said ...

24-Oct-2018

First Of All It Will Never Happen. 

Even With A Remotest Of Remotest Chance It Happen, Then Even After Giving 5 Kgs,  S C Will Beat D G Hollow. 

No Deadheat Or Any Other Any Other Drama. 

Wolvarine said ...

24-Oct-2018

Where is the invitation races this year??

Zubin said ...

23-Oct-2018

Firstly let Sir Ceceil win 2400 m graded race. He has not raced on mahalaxmi. If there is a fast pace race and pace setters than he will find it hard to go 2400m. Mark my words.. Derby is open and not a one horse race.

Zubin

Godzilla said ...

23-Oct-2018

The problem with Indian Racing Industry is, they have only three extremely good horses namely:

Desert God Sir Cecil and Star Superior

These three horses go to different destinations individually and participate in all big stake events, which make the owners of other horses not to participate in such events, thereby making the important events one sided and boring.

We are restricted to praising these three horses only. 

Mark my words,if these three horses, go abroad [the first one already returned after poor performance] and participate in Races over there, they may not even touch the board. 

Shyamkopalle said ...

23-Oct-2018

Much hype about sir cecel, stamina credentials unproven unlike desrert God,doubt dou sire, will be beaten horse this year only.

Rrajesh said ...

23-Oct-2018

sir why waste time on discussion which might and might not happen next year ..... 

Isr said ...

23-Oct-2018

Both the horses were tested together on training track on July 7th ( ref. The Hindu) and reported as follows:

1800m: Sir Cecil (Qureshi), Desert God (Neeraj) 2-9, 1,600/1-50.5, 1,400/1-37, 1,200/1-23, 1,000/1-9.5, 600/42. Former started three lengths behind and finished a length in front with plenty in hand.

In invitation perhaps the old horses have conceed weight to the younger horses.

Eagle Eye said ...

23-Oct-2018

Desert God always simple thing sir Cecil needs to go abroad and have more experience same contusion for Indian public go that said learn the world it's all racing

Abhi said ...

23-Oct-2018

Only sir cecil

Uday said ...

23-Oct-2018

It's going to be desert god... 

Don't look after any horses.... It is gonna one horse race. It has class and stamina. So my vote goes to DESERT GOD

Hunter said ...

23-Oct-2018

When the Invitation is run, SC will be 4-year old while DG will be 7-year old. No way can DG beat SC!

Race Time said ...

23-Oct-2018

Running with 3 year olds and running with the experienced pros is a different game all together. At the moment if you ask though sir Cecil showed lot of promise if these two horses run i would put my money on desert god keeping its smashing stamina and class into consideration. We shall have to wait for winter classics to commence and only then making a decision is wiser. 

S C Sharma said ...

23-Oct-2018

Aravind: The marriage is yet to be performed but we want a discussion on first issue whether male or female? OK. Nice. Nothing wrong. In my opinion SC and DG running in invitational race possibility is bleak. There are number of reasons to arrive at such a conclusion. But regarding comparison between these two I wish to place some points: 1) The age difference SC 3yr old DG 6yr old. 2) DG already reached its peak and by next year planning to retire and for him still many races are in store with his age group horses. 3) Sir Cecil considering his age factor still scope for further improvement and he is winning races without much hard work.4) SC's real potential will be known when he get a fast pace setter to stretch out and some one really dare to comes near him from behind in last furlong and challenge and match strides and go all out with him. SC reserve stamina remains yet to be exposed. 5) Lastly  if in real it happens next year clash of these two than there will be no deadbeat but SC will easily prevail upon DG on equal weights. 6)  If these two giants enter in a handicap race where they give 6-10 kg weight to each other than only a possibility of DG beating SC may come in picture but that also seems to be not likely. 

As per trainer Padmanabhan's own version SC is very special so far he trained and he is giving everything expected without coming under pressure and he will go further up and up, where DG will remains there and preparing for farewell. Next 2-3 years SC will dominate in all races whether in his own age group or with older age group horses. Thanks for starting a debate on this.