Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Why Classic Races Look So One-sided These Days?

By Smart-still-poor-punter | 24-Oct-2018

Hi Friends,

For quite some time now (at least since 2014, the year I quit punting) I find racing, as a whole, fast losing its charm with many races remaining beyond the reach of the punters, whose "problem-solving" skills seem to have reach a hollow deep.

Senior race-goers, who have been around for 3-4 decades, can see the glaring difference in style of running of Classic races before and now. The participation itself for Classics have come down alarmingly, and even if there is a fair representation, the winner walks to win? 

Very rightly, some colleague had pointed out in this column recently that these so-called Classic winners will not even manage to fill the frame if run abroad.

I don't blame the Padmanabhans, Narredus and Shroffs who enjoy the liberty of taking around their top-ranking horses across the country to sweep the Classics. But why all of a sudden there is a dearth in talent and it now looks as if only these big names can win major events in India. Why so?

Even the biggest race in the Indian Calendar - the Invitation Cup - has lost its charm, particularly after the mega event was thrown open for horses of all age groups. Although that decision has helped to bring in better participation, the winning pattern has not changed and no old-timer has managed to spring a surprise as frequently as expected.

A 'Sir Cecil" winning in Mysore and 'Desert God' cantering for home in Hyderabad are being celebrated as if they have won the 'Epsom Derby'? I know Sir Cecil will made to sweat in the Indian Derby by many smart horses in Mumbai. Even if Sir Cecil, who Padmanabhan has described as the best horse to be trained by him so far, lifts the Indian Derby, not many seasoned punters would like to place it alongside all-time greats like Elusive Pimpernel or Mystic Memory. According to my knowledge, these all-time greats always won in a tough set where there used to be two or more strong fancies in a race. Is that the condition now?

Those who can read between the lines will not find it difficult to zero in on the essence of the problem. The real problem lies with the 'strong' adjustments going on among owners and trainers, who give the lion's share to big names and succumb to pressure and part away with the little bones thrown at them. This has to stop if Indian racing has to improve, and if at all Classic races have to be run as real Classics.

Post Your reply

8 Replies

Cee Kay said ...

26-Oct-2018

All those considering Sir Cecil to be ordinary will have their answer when this horse runs in Mumbai. Its only a matter of time! Cant wait to watch this grey to go from class to the best India has ever produced. Go Cecil Go!

Hunter said ...

25-Oct-2018

Smart-still-poor-punter and JP both make valid points. Big buyers like MAM, Khaitan, Wadhawan have faded away  Sales of yearlings have slipped. So, studs like Poonawalas, Sarainaga and Manjri are running horses in their own colours. The big owners were interested in winning classics. Considering the investment and the fickle nature of breeding, the return on investment does not interest the new owners. The new brash lot want to win races and make money - prize money and more important betting wins. So, the clubs are compelled to frame races under a mile. These under-miler horses cost less and ultimately deliver a return on investment for the owner. No wonder, longer races and classics have lost their charm. What's the solution? It's up to Poonawalas and Mistrys to not import 'short-distance' sires like Excellent Art and Phoenix Tower, but bring in stayer-producing sires. These very guys have the clout in the clubs to get more races framed over longer distances. Else, you will continue to have these farcical Derbies and St Legers.

Jp said ...

25-Oct-2018

Do the breeders display the MRP before selling a horse? Even in auction conducted by the clubs do the auction stops at MRP? Owners are purchasing in auction after paying GST. Maybe off the record sales the price may be kept low to avoid GST. This is part and parcel of any investments. It is the people who invest shoud take care. The investments are not there because of the bad atmosphere in the racing industry now. Lot of unscrupulous elements have become owners/members and racing is not clean manytimes. So no new owners are coming into racing not for want of funds,lack of interest or GST. GST is there for everything.Do you mean to say investments are not taking place in other industry? 

Breeders should all sit and talk about the present scenario and bring about chnages in their sales method to attract new owners to make racing an attractive investments. The club also should think in the same line to attract new owners and try to conduct clean racing to attract more punters.

P G said ...

25-Oct-2018

What with giving a free hand to connections to manipulate few races every racing day keeping them happy, and also big connections puchasing small time connections to win races, dur to the small amount of prize money.

To some, photo-op at prize distribution stage is more important than free and fair racing

These are the games being played by the top connections, irrespective if the sport is going to dogs.

Throw these people out, and the sport will again get it's lost glory back.

Boosa said ...

24-Oct-2018

Your post is very much true, see a 6 year old winning Golconda St Leger, can we consider this has great horse or no 4 year old is there too challenge DG, pity we are going backwards, 5 years back I was confident of winning some races now a days even if god  comes down with a  lorry of money can't win racing by punting.

Saggittarian said ...

24-Oct-2018

It's just simple mathematics.

None are interested in investing, for,

GST, maintaining cost going up.

This is clear as can be seen that many horses run these days in stud colours

Kailash Trivedi said ...

24-Oct-2018

Very simple,bcz there's very limited intrest in horse racing shown by Indian entrepreneurs and lac of interest from government side.racingis looked upon as a bad gamble and even regular punters hide their interest from fellows and near and dear ones.secondly it's was never a game of skill and continues to be so,honest is at premium and we see that a few families control the game.dont blame taxes as these are avoided by big names.

Jp said ...

24-Oct-2018

Very simple.We had big owners,lots of dedicated trainers and very few hrses were running in breeders colours.

a) Racing has lost; Big owners like MAM,Khaitan,White,black V and red cap.

   b) very few dedicated trainers..Give and take policy of the trainers with making money as the prime motive. Owners are also with same motive.

    c) drug abuse and medication infringements since developments are taking place in drug industry also

    d) lot of breeding establishments and the big ones are out of reach for many 

    e) Since there is no sales for big studs ,the breeders race many horses now in their colours. Few years back there were only single digit horses i the breeders colours and count the numbers now. Breeders have invaded even Mysore.

     f) the present owners invest small amounts just to get the trainers connections for getting tips to make money.They are not bothered about horse,classics etc.

    g) there is a lot of risk involved in buying a good horse,training and to get the results. Fleeting Arrow is a good example. C.D. Hayes who rode the horse when it as 2 year old was very much impressed about FA. But, see the end result which was due to the trainer.

   h) too much of black money in racing and investments in buying horses becomes difficult.