Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

18 Bookmakers Arrested.

By Raghavan | 23-Dec-2018

The Mumbai police on Friday (21st)  arrested 21 bookmakers and seized around 1.41 cr bet money.  3 bookies were permitted to go home on Saturday morning.  The other 18 have been charged with tax evasion and are sent to police custody.

Punters based at Mumbai to please inform whether any bookie functioned yesterday (saturday), and is there any chance of betting today with bookies.

Post Your reply

27 Replies

S C Sharma said ...

26-Dec-2018

Rahul= I have not hidden anything and not placed any facts partially as stated by you.  I stated very clearly that raid or arrest permission is  required from higher-ups that means the person who  sign the proceedings to be completed ensures after satisfying himself that proper ground is there or not for raid and arrest like complaint etc , as per your version or they have convincing proof  with them that something illegal or wrong commited. These officials place all the facts before the court and court gives every chance to arrested persons also to deny and defend themselves with the help of lawyers. It is obligatory for the person who conducts the raid to follow legal procedures as in the present case the raid and arrest  was done under the supervision of a DCP rank official as per the requirement of the matter. I think this is clear what I wanted to say.

Pramod said ...

26-Dec-2018

In Mumbai bookie take only 2% tax on above 2000/- bet

Rahul said ...

25-Dec-2018

Dear Mr. Sharma,

 

You are partially incorrect. Police cannot arrest with approval from higher ups. They first need to file an FIR with a name of a complainant and only then arrest. Without the FIR they have no right to arrest. So it is obvious that someone had made a complaint which was registered and action taken. Yes the arrested people then have to be produced before a magistrate within 24hours as you mentioned.

Ravi_hyd said ...

25-Dec-2018

sir, i think people should check the facts before reacting negaively on someone. it takes only few minutes to check on google whether the news is fake are true.

Chanakya said ...

25-Dec-2018

@Ravi, Mohan,Romit,Josh, RFreak, kautilya etc.,

My  point  was: ED caught oe  seized -Rs  !.41 crore ;  which media ,paper, journalist gave  this  figure. Quote it. Every bookie's  stall employs  8 to  10  people in  Mumbai but  number  of   stalls  were  never  more  than  17  or  18  in Mumbai   and  even  less   in  of  course...

More  than the  stall operators  there  are  double  the  number of  cutters/operators  in  the ring...

why  these 'law enforcers' forgot  them -  they  are  the ones  who  do  not  pay  a  single  paisa tax and  their  turnover may  be  much  more  than  those  of  the  stall  owners...

Why  you  peole  are SILENT  about  them?  Do you  have  any  connection with them?...

Pradeep said ...

25-Dec-2018

Dear All,

Pune scenario- On Saturday only 4/5 bookmakers operated & on Sunday 2 more joined them & did business in usual style.But yesterday on Monday not a single bookmaker was in action. The crowd was also very little & few stray illegal fellows accepted bets on Win/place at odds of their own will. This will go on till club/Pune police stop them.

On Friday when races are at Bangalore some clear picture will emerge.

Arvinder Singh Paul said ...

25-Dec-2018

Why is the RWITC is so quite on this issue. Why are they so silent. Not  a single word on their website......WHY ? We would definitely  like to hear from them. 

S C Sharma said ...

25-Dec-2018

Godzilla: Why everytime and in your every wright up you are misguiding everyone? Do you mean police arrested the bookies without legal sanctions? The Police have every right to raid and arrest if proper permission is taken up from higher ups. After arrest they have to produce the arrested persons before court or at the residence of magistrate within 24 hours and file a case explaining the circumstances under which arrest was done and after hearing both the parties magistrate and court will decide further course of action like custody, bail or stay till disposal of the case. Always put forth right version.

Raghavan said ...

24-Dec-2018

Lucky Lakshman,

I only wrote what I saw in newspapers.  Whether there are only 4 bookies or 40 bookies, I do not know.  What I know is 100s of people were arrested and according to the police version among the arrested were 21 bookies.  Of which 18 are sent to police custody & 3 were discharged on Saturday morning.

Raghavan said ...

24-Dec-2018

Rajeshwar,

There are many who indulge in drama and show their contempt for tote.  And they will be in red hot rage if anyone suggests that there should be no bookies!

Well.  In the past, I have posted too many letters about the way bookies hijacked the turf rules and take bets at 10% tax.  It is almost a decade that they acted with impunity.  And treat the small bettors with contempt and ridicule.  The problem for small bettors is they get least support from other bettors. 

A punter betting 500/- may still prefer to bet by paying full tax to the bookie.  But, the bookie view him the way you view a fly in your coffee cup.

Demonetisation to some extent softened them.  They did all the circus to convert black to white and succeeded only in part.  They were forced to burn the unconverted cash. 

The Government should compel all bookies to computerise their betting operation.   Totes are computerised.  The Government can order the same for bookies also. That will curb the malpractice to a large extent.

Raghavan said ...

24-Dec-2018

Godzilla,

Only police can arrest a person.  Of course Judge can overrule the arrest.  I do not know on what logic you are stating that police can not arrest a person.  Anyway the DCP in charge of this operation knows his powers, jurisdiction etc better than you & me.

You are telling that Chanakya is the best person to give a correct picture.  O K.  If he is that good, no one stops him.  But, let him not question how a Bangalorean will  know what is happening in Mumbai.

 

Pinaki Ghosh said ...

24-Dec-2018

Bail plea of the bookies have been rejected while they're put up in Girgaum court today. Next date is 26/12/18. 

Also, pl note Pune bookies are operating in full gusto and they're acting on their own without disrupting their normal activity.

 

Rajeshwar said ...

24-Dec-2018

Chanakya,

Who cares for the numbers of bookies arrested. It was long time coming. In fact these bookies should have been put behind bars long back for the amount of tax evasion they were upto. Kudos to the economic offence directorate for taking this step. An unified tote is the only way forward to root out the corruption and daylight robbery in horse racing.

Rajeshwar

Godzilla said ...

24-Dec-2018

raghavan

Police have no power to arrest anyone. It should be the duty of incometax department to scrutinize the accounts and take them into custody.

I dont know what is happening in Mumbai.

chankya is the best person to present the correct picture.

Kautilya said ...

24-Dec-2018

Chanakya

there is something called media which provides news to public, You need not be at place of the incidence to know about it.

Just dont write anything just for the heck of it. It belies  the name you write under.

Raghavan said ...

24-Dec-2018

Seems Chanakya does not read local papers. 

But does he visits race course?  

How many bookies were given license I do not know.  But among them 18 persons are denied bail and Magistrate ordered them police custody for 2 days is news published.  Raghavan may be sitting at BNG.  But, in this era of mobile/internet whether that matters?

Rizme said ...

23-Dec-2018

It's all across the news paper website 

https://www.google.com/search?hl=en-IN&ie=UTF-8&source=android-browser&q=raid+in+Mumbai+race+course&gws_rd=ssl

Lucky Laxman said ...

23-Dec-2018

Mr. Chanakyaji you are absolute correct. I had been to Mumbai on that day there were hardly 12 to 15 stalls were in operation. But how he is telling that 21 were arrested and 3 were allowed to go. Is it possible?  And the amount they found also wrong. Why these rumours are spreading by our htians. Surprisingly they didn't mention the denominations of the currency they seized. 

Ravi_hyd said ...

23-Dec-2018

sir, news of arresting bookies has come in times of India. Link is given below. Now a days a person can get information on what’s happening around the world, sitting at home. You don’t need to be present physically at particular place where incident happened. 

https://www.google.co.in/amp/s/m.timesofindia.com/city/pune/18-bookies-arrested-in-racecourse-raid/amp_articleshow/67212470.cms

Race Freak said ...

23-Dec-2018

Chanakya,

That was hillarious.

S C Sharma said ...

23-Dec-2018

This news appeared in media and there is no reason to disbelieve Raghavan who correctly quoted the figure of cash seizure. DCP Abhinash Kumar of zone 3 with the help of tardeo police conducted the raid for stealing tax money under section 420 and 34 of IPC 3,4 and 12 of gambling act  and 7 of Bombay race course licencing act.          Regarding arrest also Raghavan stated correctly and the same appeared in press. Consequently bookies are not operating at Mumbai as a protest and hardly five bookies are operating at Pune.  If  anyone  have further updates in this regard may pl be posted.

S Joshi said ...

23-Dec-2018

Mr.chanakya

This information is in todays Times Of India.I hope you read news papers.

Rb said ...

23-Dec-2018

chanakyaji,

khabbar pey yeh poori industry kayam hai.

rb.

 

Romit Pune said ...

23-Dec-2018

Chanakya everyone is aware of this happening..u living in which world...if u dont belev on it plz visit race course betting ring you will get your answer

Mohan said ...

23-Dec-2018

@Chanakya,

There is something called social media and newspapers. Dont know which world you living in.. the figures writer might have mentioned may be differ but the fact he is sayng is known by almost all punters as we follow news spread around..

Ravi_hyd said ...

23-Dec-2018

news came in times of india paper. link is given below. sir, these days one can get information on whats happening aroundt the world sitting at home. 

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/mumbai/18-bookies-arrested-in-racecourse-raid/articleshow/67212470.cms?

Chanakya Kaushik said ...

23-Dec-2018

This  man  says  the  'raiders'  seized  about  Rs.1.41  crore ...

 who  gave  him  this  information...

wherfrom  he got  this  information  sitting  at  Bangalore  and  never  visiting  bookies  ring  at  that  city...

He  has  never  seen  Mumbai's  bookies  ring - whether  it  has  19  or  21  or  91  stalls..............................................

Every  visitor  knows  THERE  WERE  NEVER  21  STALLS  IN  THIS  SEASON - DURING  MAIN  OR  OFCOURSE   CENTER'SW  BETTING.............................