Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Re: Toppers Of The Four Derbies Contest

By Major Srinivas Nargolkar (retd.) | 07-Feb-2019

Mr. S.K. Sagar's ingenuous contest has come to a close. With parameters being specified and the placings on the board as well as the dividends being unalterable facts, the final results have been known since the time Sir Cecil hobbled into the third place at Mahalakshmi. However, it is my pleasant task of confirming them.

The TOP FIVE finishers,, as already mentioned in Mr. Sagar's post of 06-02-2019 7.08 P.M., are:

RAKESH MENON - 8,01,400 points

CEE KAY - 3,54,900 points

GAYATHRI - 3,15200 points

ABHAY...PUNE - 2,95,140 points

THE DOC - 2,49,700 points

It was Abhay...Pune who led at the end of the first round having picked the first three in the Calcutta Derby in the right order. Rakesh menon, however, was on his heels. Four of the top five correctly identified the winner of the Bangalore Derby and though Abhay...Pune still led, Cee Kay, Rakesh menon and Gayathri were bunched up just behind. The Hyderabad leg virtually decided the contest as Rakesh Menon correctly predicted the first three finishers, though not in the correct order. A return of 5,47,600 points for that saw Rakesh menon break away from the field. The final leg was the least lucrative of the four and did not affect the standings.

Congratulations to the Toppers and especially to all other contestants. If there is no field, there is no race.

Rakesh menon had only one winner but his picks of Barbaresco, New Moon and Bradfield College showed his eye of the outsiders. Of the top five, he was also the only one to have Star Superior in this three for the Indian Derby.

CEE KAY correctly identified the first three winners while Gayathri had two. Some years ago, Mr. Sagar had asked me to announce the results and if I remember rightly Gayathri had done well that year also. I am especially amused by Gayathri's reference (03-02-2019 8.15 P.M.) to the Indian Derby favourite as 'Sir Devil'. I do not know if that was intentional or accidental but he certainly proved to be one as the majority chose to ignore the warning bells regarding his fitness.

Abhay...Pune had two winners while The Doc had three. I think -- I am open to correction -- there were three instances of a contestant getting all his three slections right. I have already mentioned Abhay...Pune and Rakesh menon. The third instance that I recall was of Ganesh in the first leg. 

There were about 60 contestants and among them were 'rathis' and 'maharathis' of the daily selections threads. That being so, it was a bit disheartening to find that only Rakesh menon and CEE KAY showed a positive return on the investment of 3,24,000 points. Just goes to show hard it is to be a punter.

Finally my sincere thanks to Mr. S.K. Sagar for inviting me to do the honours. Mr. Sagar is the author of three serious, philosophical books. It amazes me how he can keep abreast with racing while being involved with more demanding projects. As long as there are people like him in racing, there is a "Bright Light In The Sky".

Post Your reply

14 Replies

Any said ...

12-Feb-2019

Congrats all winner

Congrats Abhay.........Keep posting regular....great.

Gc Raj said ...

10-Feb-2019

congrajulations to the winners.

we should thank immensly the adminstrator of indiarace.com for providing us a free ,and easily accesible web site to all horseracing lovers.

MAJOR Saab iam your regulor reader of all your articles,wriiten with good scientific, sound knowledge.

 

S.k.sagar said ...

09-Feb-2019

Heartiest congratulations to the winner `Rakesh Menon`, the first runner up `CeeKay`, the second runner up `Gayathri` and to `Abhay-Pune` and `The Doc` for finishing in the top five. Four of the top five are well known names for their expertise and their track records in these PTR contests, and now Cee Kay has also joined this elite group.

@ Rakesh Menon .. you took over the running before the bend and were a distance clear soon after entering the straight and did`nt have to do much to retain that lead and made it a one horse race. Great show.

@ Cee Kay … You are the only one to have picked three winners (the first three legs) and thus managed to get three double win rolls, and a treble win roll. If you had also picked Star Superior in the final leg you would have probably overtaken Rakesh Menon, as in that case you would have got three additional Double Win Rolls , three additional Treble Win  Rolls, plus a mini jackpot win roll of nearly two lakhs.

@ GS .. My sincere thanks and heartfelt appreciation for your enormous help in calculating the scores of all the participants in good time. Your commitment was exemplary and I hope you will be available during the `2019 INVITATION WEEKEND PTR`.

@ SKumar.. Very nice write up. Thanks for calling me yesterday, I think we spoke with each other after a long gap (more than a year). It was a long and interesting chat. I appreciate your involvement despite your very busy schedule work wise and family wise.

Thank you so much Major Nargolkar for your wonderful presentation covering every aspect of the contest. You have many fans here who are deeply inspired by your excellent previews on the classics.  All the participants must have been delighted when they came to know that you agreed to be the Chief Guest. Thank you also for your kind words about my involvement in books. Indeed they take a lot my time + I am still working full time with stringent deadlines.

 You were right when you mentioned in your preview for the ID that the `Information in the Field` was inadequate particularly with respect to the extent to which Sir Cecil was fit or unfit. When a punter has to contend with these uncertainties regarding fitness, it becomes difficult for him to make proper assessment despite his expertise on the subject. Ordinarily such horses should not be permitted to run, but the Indian Derby comes only once in the lifetime of the horse and we cannot deprive the owners the opportunity for landing the prize even with a slightly unfit condition, as even the prize money for finishing third is quite substantial. I think Roberta should also have been permitted to run.

Though only two of the contestents managed with a positive return on a total investment of 324000, it has to be realized the exorbitant tote deductions on the dividends are a huge dampener for the Punters. If we take this aspect into consideration and determine the weighted average tote deduction as about 35 %, then the Par Score is worked out as about  210000, in which case as many as about twenty participants should be considered as in the positive territory. But I fully agree, with such enormous tote deductions, it is very hard for the Punters.

@ Rakesh Menon and CeeKay… may I have your postal address so that I can send you a copy of my new book `BRIGHT LIGHT IN THE SKY` as soon as I receive my copies which may take a couple of weeks.

@ Admn. Indiarace .. Thank you for your full support

Thanks to all the participants for making this Contest a big succe

Rakesh Menon said ...

09-Feb-2019

Dear friends,

Thank you so much for recognizing my efforts. I must say that your congratulation messages really touched my heart.Your kind and encouraging message has motivated me to do even better than I have done. Thank you..

@Major Saab,

Am a great fan of ur Articles..Thank you..

Congrats to all the participants And all the very best for the prestigeous Invitation weekend PTR..

Ramiyer said ...

09-Feb-2019

congratulations to Rakesh and all top five.

Thanks to Major sir for the nice narration.

Thanks to Sagar sir and G.S.rising star of ht for the update and coordination.

Vampsvenom said ...

08-Feb-2019

CONGRATULATIONS TO ALL THE RESPECTED WINNER AND RESPECTED RUNNER UPS

AND ALSO CONGRATS TO ALL THE PARTICIPANTS

Gsl said ...

07-Feb-2019

Yes n bow congratulations to all the top 5's ..specially to Rakesh menon ji coming from the bend being midway just like star superior n swamping them with ease..that's the way to teach a lesson... IF someone is unfit or not 100% fit..THE DERBY is half gone..I as everyone miscalculated as sir c was coming into this race more reputed than besafe..yes on the other hand I had my doubts as well on him at more than evens being quoted.. STAR SUPERIOR has revenged it..Poona Walla buying him earlier in the monsoons has proved to a very gud judgment The confidence of excellent art to provide.them with derby ..They felt if phoenix tower can do with rochestor why can't excellent art..STAR SUPERIOR was always a great champion had it not been padnamabhadan sir I was always going to back the star.....ahead of adjuticate.who herself was the class..but her prep in Mumbai was nt the derby prep..probably in invitation where she has to face even more challenge from the previous crop in Hyderabad get's her on right feet..she has a very gud chance to repay the due's..let's. Watch her further progress leading to invitation..though I know fillies or mare record isn't that great since it's renewal or even if not..She posseses something that cud give the kolkotta filly or mare the cup..The luck of the race will play it's part..All the best to her backers..she might pay gud dividends.. THANX AlL GOD BLESS GSL

Isr said ...

07-Feb-2019

Congratulations to Rakesh for topping the contest . Congratulations to other toppers and those who participated and performed well.

Gs said ...

07-Feb-2019

Major Srinivas Sir..Im a very big fan of your writting...And you gave the Perfect presentation here..Thankyou Sir

Congratulations to The Winners who finished at Top 4..RakeshMenon You are absolutely Awesome..As well as Ceekay Gayathri and Abhay..Pune..The Doc

@Skumar..Thankyou for your appretiation..Its my previlage to work for PTR team..Im very much enjoyed this tournament..I'm a Junior in Racing..Hope I can do Next time better...
Thankyou SK Sagar For This initialization of tournament...
I wish to have a PTR contest for upcoming summer seasons..Im eager to participate in it..

Once Again Thankyou Skumar..SK Sagar sir..And All participants who accompained towards the tournament..

Thankyou

Againstodds said ...

07-Feb-2019

Congrats to Rakesh Menon sir, CEE KAY sir, Gayathri Madam, Abhay Pune sir, The Doc sir for the excellent performance. Congrats to all the participants.

 

With best wishes

Kumar said ...

07-Feb-2019

Is fantasy horse racing leauge like dream 11 is illegal in india?

The Doc said ...

07-Feb-2019

@ SK Sagar sir

Thank you for conducting the Four Derby PTR like every year. Its an amazing contest and hope to do better in next edition

@ Major Nargolkar sir

Its always a delight to read ur writtings. It is an honor to have you onboard for result declaration. 

@ Rakesh Menon

Excellent job as always. Congratulations and keep up the  good work. 

@ CeeKay, Gayathri and Abhay Pune

Well done and well played. Better lucj next time. 

Bkd said ...

07-Feb-2019

Hearty Congratulations to the fabulous five!! 

All the very best for future Games of Skill.

 

Regards,

BKD

Skumar said ...

07-Feb-2019

Congratulations to all Winners and Runners..... Rakesh you cantered away after the Hyd leg... Many Congrtas.... Late spurt by all could not catch up with the leader.... Home bend Matters.....In ligheter vein pls...

Congratulations to the Father of Four Winters Derbies PTR Contest, Shri Sagar Ji....whilst we very badly miss Srikanth who left us all couple of months ago.

 

GS :- Well done ... u came on your own to coordinate the contests and you are just Fantastic My friend.

Respected Major Srinivas Nargolkar Ji :- thanks a million times for taking your precious time and allocating the same to us all... Every write up of yours inspires one and all and in such short Presentation you have covered all aspects of this Years Contest.... All I can say from my heart is ....Hats Off to you Sir.....

 

Dear Friends :- Due to high committments both Personal as well as Professional i could not devote any time at all and I sincerely Thank GS for doing single handed Brilliance in coordination.... Every Ex PTR Team Member is very proud of GS's Spectacular show and i convey my sincere thanks on behalf of all our team members.

 

Regards

 

SK