Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Wrong Decision Taken By Stewards Of Mrc

By Lucky Laxman | 27-Feb-2019

In the 3rd race Amazing kitten won in the objection. And white cone was hoisted and bookies started payments and some punters had taken their winning amount. I too played the horse 10 k at 4/1 and suddenly there was an announcement saying that the 3 race was declared as null and void. In my 42 years racing experience I never seen such decision. 

Post Your reply

17 Replies

Aravind said ...

01-Mar-2019

Mr Sukumar I knew well abt rules and regulation.in this particular case not a single rule was followed. It's ok it's happening at very rare instances.but doesn't mean that punters angry with stewards action and gehored jockeys?

Also book makers of second tote came and shouting at stewards. In racing no punters makes money in every race.when BeSafe lost Did Mumbai punters reacted angrily like in Chennai?  it was crores of rupees riding on BeSafe. Punters behaviour is to be corrected. Officials shd be warned to be careful in future.

Rame said ...

01-Mar-2019

I have witnessed the whole drama live, the centiments of the punters at that point is just because Yash ridden horse is owned by the Steward and Committee member the race has been upheld in his favor.  Before taking such decision the stewards should have evaluated the replay well with complete transparancy.  What is the need to decide an upheld decision in such a swift way without playing replays.  Moreover, in all the other centers it is the decision of the Committee/Stewards after the inquiry the strips will move out of the room and decision is announced by vote by the present stewards.  Is this followed in chennai on Race No : 182 on 27.2.2019.  The mode of operendi leads to these suspicision and room for speculation.  Interestingly it is observed the Cheif Stipendary Steward who is instrumental in the upheld decision is the same person who is part of the criminal conspiracy on the doping of Queen Lathifa.

Raghavendran said ...

01-Mar-2019

Madras Racing was slowly coming to good center, suddenly droping by distance by some of  the officials, (these kind of incedent)

Hope it will be normal agian

And also commentary is very very poor, atleast for Classics days they can call other center commentator 

Skumar said ...

01-Mar-2019

@ Arvinth.. I am not sure about what you want to convey. First and foremost is the decision to uphold the objection was wrong as there has been no instance where a objection has been upheld when there has been an interference at about 100 Mts from the starting gate. They could have fined the jockey for dangerous riding. Even after the objection was upheld and the white cone was hoisted, the decision to declare the race null and void was not right. Given to understand that the original winner who was drawn 10 was put into stall no.9 and the race was run. Is it not the job of the Stipendary Steward to see that before the race and take necessary action against the starter. Public money is involved and the officials concerned need to do their job for which they are paid handsomely. Punters should not be penalised for the wrong doings. 

Aswin Patel said ...

01-Mar-2019

GOPAL,

Pardon my lack of racing knowledge and of rules but I would like to ask anyone on this foroum if they have ever seen or heard  of successful objections for a crossing in the first 200 mts,

If you care to use simple judgement horses that are drawn wide will be comming in , are you expecting them to run in a straight line?

I had asked a friend who was in the race course to back for me since I was watching from home, as he has not asked me for money , I presume he did get the money back

S C Sharma said ...

28-Feb-2019

Destiny@1: As the 3rd race declared null and void and jackpot leg started from 2nd race the decision of the club is correct to leave 3rd race set aside and continue the packpot from 4th race on wards. Thus jackpot races become race no 2,4,5 and 6 and consolation given for winners of races 2,4 and 5 and jackpot given for  winners of 2,4,5 and 6 races. As far as dividends are concerned I think it is typography error and 30 percent amount mentioned against 70 percent and 70 percent amount mentioned against 30 percent and when you take the actual payment  by presenting the ticket it will be cleared to you. Thanks and God bless you.

Wajid said ...

28-Feb-2019

Very bad part of the chairman decision on 3rd race I never seen such person in my 45 yes. 

Aravind said ...

28-Feb-2019

Yesterday I was witnessing entire scene in Chennai course.long back I wrote in this forum that experienced and fully knowledgeable admin staff is not there in MRC.thats why it's all happening.they shd bring them on contract basis to oversee rules book r strictly followed.

Coming to the point Stewards has every right to decide a race results after due enquiry.upheld s correct in the sense before 100mtr mark from starting point it all happened.again yashhad very long time to set right.but horse is not capable for that.once stewards decided it shd be obeyed by all.punters action is condemnable.all these r common in racing.it s not end for them.today they list tomorrow they gain.another point disturbing s bookie shouting at a steward s condenncond.a mistake s done.ok atleast any one of them either punters or bookis shd accept credit.both opposing and questioning officials s wrong.had MAM alive wud dismiss that bookie who shouted against official.on the part of bookie it's business they shd understand. My suggestion to every race club is get a signature from every punters before entering into race course that he will not disturb running of races and  also abide rules and regulations of club.

Gopal said ...

28-Feb-2019

Ashwin Patel. In absence of Proper info not wise to post comments. Pls check race again. Umesh was supposed to be in draw 10. For some strange reason horse came out from draw 9 . Even if that's an excuse , watch first 200 metres where Seven Crores cut across the field and badly interfered with Yash Narredu horse.  If you still feel there was no interference , drop in here and post your views. Btw did u get refund of 200+ tax ? .

Aswin Patel said ...

28-Feb-2019

I had backed 7 crore and have seen the race, I could not comprehend the objection , what I heard was "my filly is a small made one and it shied away , it took me 2 furlongs to get her back into her stride " or something to that effect, please correct me if I am wrong.

I heard Umesh say that  he could not control his horse and went close but had not disturbed the filly, again something to that effect.

I was suprised to hear UPHELD without much discussions, it was the fastest decion that I have seen  in more than 45 years as a punter.

The replay was also truncated giving rise to suspicion of collusion  amonst the stewards and unhealthy practices, they have by their actions displayed.

My bet was for rs 200 at 12/10 so I am not speaking from my pocket, in my opinion it looked like a staged objection and I am disappointed with Yash a youngster to have playied a role in this. .I for one had liked the kid amongst all the Narredus,

Rg said ...

28-Feb-2019

Malpractices are happening at all centres including Mumbai. Why blame Chennai alone.Stewarrds and interested parties manupulating results to feed their own interests is happening all over India. The way races were conducted on Derby day at Delhi, where a horse which ran second to Sergent at Arms in a mock race was beaten by a B class animal speaks volumes of 'Honesty' of stewards.

God save Indian Racing.

Destiny@1 said ...

28-Feb-2019

Hi Sharma sir.... A small question.... My Chennai JP has been passed yesterday... Due to work I came bit early from the ciurse... Last night when you check the dividends... The consolation is showing 5400 in hyHyderab... How is this possible one race has been null n void... 2 horses has been withdrawn on the next 2 races...is that a mistake amount in the site...

Thank u

S C Sharma said ...

28-Feb-2019

After the announcement of objection result and revised placings and the white con hoisted and all clear signal given the process of disbursement of payment started in bookmakers ring as well as on tote and number of persons torn and distroyed their unsuccessful cards and tickets and their action was not wrong. After this with inordinate delay if the stewards decide and announce the race null and void it shows their immaturity level and exposes them that they have not applied their mind and the decision created confusion and chaos . Tote counters and bookmakers seen refusing refund as they already made payment as per revised placings. The stewards not taken into account the repercussions and they are totally responsible for this irresponsible and immature act and the inconvenience caused to punters.

Vinodrocks said ...

27-Feb-2019

Pathethic decision seems the stewards we're in a coma mindset. 

Also BTC refund the dividends for those punters who have fancied other horses in that particular race. Please update???

Also the entire Mrc who has taken such stand should be banned from entering the MRC premises. 

Govindarajan S(chennai) said ...

27-Feb-2019

Well said sir, I also seen the worst historical decision. In the same race treble dividends also paid after the white cone hoist.(Rs150).
If the race nul and void ,the treble amount paid for all the entered horse on that particular race. But they paid winning horse( no.(4)).
After some seconds they stopped paying.
    They have not made any announcement
Regarding jackpot ticket till last race, suddenly after 1 hour they told "JACKPOT WILL BE PAID ON FIRST LEG WINNING NUMER", and 2nd leg,3rd leg,till last last leg numbers multiplyed as winners for jackpot.
           Another mistake also made in the same 3rd race. Actual draw number of horse no.(1) SEVEN CRORE is 10. But SEVEN CRORE stands in the draw no.(9). How it possible ? and why starter allowed jockey C.UMESH from draw no.(9) to ride his mount .
Will jockey suspended for one year?.
I want ,Turf authority should take immediate action against Madras race course to stop further racing and betting. If it is not possible then Turf authority send nutral  qualified strewards from other racing centers.

Very important news is,
In 2nd tote - no refund amount was given to punters by bookies on that particular 3rd race. Because bookies already paid winning amount to winning punters.How they pay
refund to all the horses ?.

Govindarajan s(chennai)
 

Mahi said ...

27-Feb-2019

One of my friend also play 10k at 3 1/2 odds and the bookie pay his winning amt....after 30 minutes one of bookie worker cum to my friend and say to re back the winning amt.....even i heard that the objection is upheld due to pressure of the horse owner sultan singh... how much it’s true... i don’t know.... but the cheenai people temper is out of control and totally regret  the decision of steward after that the race is call null and void...fool steward of MRC...

Jannat said ...

27-Feb-2019
In the 3rd raceWrong decision taken by stewards of MRC .I never seen such decision. this is  the worst situation