India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsStar Boy Disqualified
By Sachin | 02-Mar-2019today in last race horse no 4 star boy was disqualified and can any one tell why stewards took this decision and it was a nightmare for the punters
21 Replies
S S said ...
05-Mar-2019I purely agree with raj
Shyamkopalle said ...
05-Mar-2019The answer the power yeilding members did it as they backed the horse for place as placed it.
Raghavan said ...
05-Mar-2019The rules say that there should be weigh-in and horses that does not weigh-in or their weight shows huge variation should be disqualified. To that extent stewards action is correct. When there are specific rules / or precedents / or conventions the stewards have no option but to follow them.
Some people suggested that horse should not be disqualified; but at best should be declared a non starter. In this particular case, that sounds reasonable. However if there are specific rules/ conventions/ precedents, the stewards can not ignore them and indulge in appeasing the punters.
I know, there are many who tried to grab the 'pick-up' money by playing that horse for place. (60 ps). I do sympathise with them.
I do not agree with those who argue that horse should be declared non starter & money should be refunded. If an odds on favorite loses, all that the jockey has to do is to avoid 'weigh-in' and ensure money back to the punters.
Bobby said ...
04-Mar-2019The bigger question reamins why did he not weigh in, has he gone to bathroom what action has been taken on him Trainer and Club
Chanakya said ...
04-Mar-2019It is surprising and sometime amusing to read various posts which have no logical back-up or correct perception of a problem/situation...
If rider does not 'weigh in' after the race the runner will be disqualified - is a wellknown fact, even if he/she wins the race!
Many times , in the past 30/40 years, some daring and 'well- protected' - l'ower' category riders have done this. Somtimes, 'they' ( who - jockey or trainer?!!!) have made a hole in the 'weight sack' sothat during race a part of the 'dead' - weight' is lost during running!!!
Jockeys used to be banned for few months, very few times for a year or more - NEVER FOR LIFE, which is done in Australia and some other countries...
We don't do that - because we are Indians ...
Bharadwaj said ...
04-Mar-2019some thing wrong.and plz let me know the by laws of the racing clubs and punter rights please any one can help
Ask said ...
04-Mar-20191) who is responsible to ensure wheather jockey has weighed in.
To best of my knowledge there is only one exit for jockeys in paddock area.
If club ensures no punter enters race course without entry ticket it is certainly criminal negligence of club to let jockey out without weigh in.
Star Contendar said ...
03-Mar-2019aravind sharma, good you have settled down in canada, i also left all my debters in bangalore empty handed with a bowl, came and seettled in kansas city, living happily, like you even i would have also played your horse and would have lost a fortune, god is very great.
S C Sharma said ...
03-Mar-2019Disqualification is ok but what about the loss punters incurred by playing shp or place? What is their fault? Tomorrow a favourite win and if jockey failed to weigh in than the favourite will be disqualified and punters will suffer. Actually jockey should be penalized by levying heavy fine or suspension because this is total negligence on his part and it is difficult to understand whether he did so intentional or accidential. In such cases culprit is jockey not the horse or owner who looses the rank and prize for their no fault.
Baski said ...
03-Mar-2019Jockey Md. Ismail failed to weigh in after the race. Hence Starboy was disqualified. But I surely feel, that it is gross injustice to all those punters, who may have played Star boy for place. Truly they were not at fault. There is every chance that weighing in was not done, deliberately. So what I feel is that, in such cases as these, the punters who had bet on starboy must get their money refunded. And this refunded amount should be collected as fine from the respective jockey and their connections. Just disqualification alone does not suffice full justification.
S S said ...
03-Mar-2019Punters didn't what is going on there, we all know the reason, y the star boy disqualified. But still, it is a cheating all the punters ,how v know that.it is the job 2 check the jockey whether the jockey weighted or not. They are all making fool of us .announce nonstarter, we invest lot of money ,they will do like this ?cheating
Raj said ...
03-Mar-2019There has been so many talks about the race. But if the Jockey fails to weigh in, then it is not the mistake of punters. Those who have backed for Place were the most sufferers for unknown reasons. The horse came and finished close 2nd, and if the jockey fails to weigh-in, let a fine of hefty amount be given to him or otherwise let the horse be declared Non Starter. Why should punter suffer, bad decision by HRC, that too immediately after th race an Stwards enquity was announced and horse was disqualified.
Bellamkonda Suresh said ...
03-Mar-2019Md.Islam lost weights.
M.menon said ...
03-Mar-2019because he did not weigh in
Bobby said ...
03-Mar-2019I also fail to understand why it was disqualified. The club should have made se proper announcement.
Ashokpunjabi said ...
03-Mar-2019STAR BOY was disqualified because jockey failed to weigh in after the race which is mandatory .
Arvind Sharma said ...
03-Mar-2019Big race, only one real bet for the day as me quit racing long time ago and happily settled in Canada but still when I saw some big race, my feelings ready to flow and really like to share.
Bradfield college
play as much you can without any regret & wish you good luck to all my friends.
Shiva said ...
03-Mar-2019He did not wayin after the race.
Vinay said ...
03-Mar-2019the jokey failed to weigh in after the race, so the horse is technically disqualified
Libero said ...
02-Mar-2019The reason was announced then and there itself bro, the apprentice jockey Md. Ismail failed to weigh in
Wajid said ...
02-Mar-2019Very bad part of the stewards hyd star boy was disqualified with out any reason. Well my 45 years exp. I never seen
Wajid
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter