Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Strange And Unbelievable Handicapping In Rwitc

By Srinivas | 07-Oct-2019

Yesterday, I was surprised with the strange and unbelievable weights allotted to the runners in Race No.124, ie The Threptin Fillies & Mares stakes, at Pune.

Auburn, a 6 times multi-race winner with a rating of 103 was allotted a low weight of 51kgs, while Roberta, only a 3-times winner, and with a far lower rating of 89, was allotted 57kgs, ie 6kgs more than Auburn, despite being atleast 7kgs inferior to tge latter on the rating scale.

On the above mismatch in weights allotted to the 2 runners, i feel sorry for those who backed Roberta.   What is more surprising is that despite this serious anamoly, Roberta was installed the favourite, and the bookies being well aware of this, kept on eating the favorite whose odds kept on increasing all the time.

No wonder, Roberta finished in the ruck and failed to come on board, taking tons of good money down the drain, while Auburn who was well placed on the scales, donkey-licked the entire field.   IMHO, I feel even if Auburn carries 7kgs more than Roberta, in future, it will still beat the latter with ridiculous ease.

I guess RWITC has a lot of explaining to do, as to how such mismatched weights were allotted to the 2 runners.   As a matter of fact, this has been happening quite frequently in RWITC, particularly in Class 1 terms races, which needs to be corrected sooner rather than later, so that gullible punters do not suffer backing the false favorites.

Post Your reply

31 Replies

Vishal Karanjia said ...

09-Oct-2019

Following were terms for this particular race.Hope this helps:

A Salver to the Breeder of the Winner. ( In the event of a Foreign Horse winning this

race, the Breeder’s Salver will be presented to the Owner of the Winner.)

For Fillies and Mares, 3 years old and over.

Weights :- Foreign Horses:3 years old, 53.5 kg;

4 years old and over, 58 kg.

Indian Horses: 3 years old, 45.5 kg;

4 years old and over, 50 kg.

Penalties :-After April 30th 2017,

Winner of a Grade 3 race, 1.5 kg

Or of 2 or more such races, 2 kg

Or of a Grade 2 race, 3 kg

Or of 2 or more such races, 4 kg

Or of a Grade 1 race, 6 kg

Or of 2 or more such races, 8 kg

Penalties for Foreign Horses:-

After April 30th 2017, Winner of a race 2 kg.,

or of 2 races 3 kg.,

or of 3 or more races 6 kg.

In addition: After 30th April 2019,winner of a race of value Rs. 5 lakhs or over 2 kg.

Cheers!!!

Sun said ...

09-Oct-2019

@Srinivas,

Noted that from your side it is closed topic.Similarly from my side I want to add one.The race Fillies&Mares trail stakes is framed perhaps on the lines of Classics to give a chance to capable horses which missed a chance when Classics were run due to late maturing.

Each club may be having a policy in framing Terms Races.As I observed at Bangalore Terms Races do not provide a good spread of Weights resulting in the higher rated horses winning the Terms Races also.We should congratulate RWITC for framing Terms Races with a good spread of weights giving some chance to Low Rated horses to take advantage of pull in Weights and also a chance to Punters to  test their Handicapping Skills.

Thanks.

Godzilla said ...

09-Oct-2019

Srinivas

Its high time we both attend classes on Racing. I have included myself to keep you calm.

Raghavan said ...

09-Oct-2019

Srinivas,

You are right.  Roberta was compelled to carry higher weight.  But, handicapper has to first obey the rules.  He has allotted weights as per rules and one can not fault the handicapper.  

It was good on your part to acknowledge and thank all who either supported or opposed your narrative.  

But, I thought at least seniors like Transparency and Chanakya will remain disinterested in this discussion.  Well.  One can not straighten a dog's tail.  A man with 46 years racing experience was reckless to claim place dividend on Malavika, that finished 3rd in a six horse field.  Even a fresher with one day's exposure will not make such an outrageously bad & wrong claim.  And he is teaching rules here!  People who live in glass houses should not throw stones at others.

Autonomy said ...

09-Oct-2019

Dear Srinivas

Sorry. i missed what you wanted to convey. I advise you to write about it to Racing Pattern Commitee instead of posting here. I believe they decide about any change in the system

Best Regards

Srinivas said ...

08-Oct-2019

Thanks to all those who responded, in support or agsinst my argument.

I have observed such "mismatched anamolies" even in the past, but none as glaring as the one under discussion.

It indeed pained me a lot when I saw hundreds of people wagering from a thousand to tens of thousands on Roberta, as a favourite, for win and place, even as I was sure that it had no chance of even placing, let alone win.   It was like throwing good money after a badly placed horse, which was doomed right from the beginning by the ridiculous terms of the race - a fact ignored by most.

Systems are made by people, systems certainly don't make people.   The sooner the powers that be realise this, and try to correct the system, the better it will be for the racing people at large.  If this cannot be done, there is nothing an individual can do, other than to grin and bear it in desperation.   After all,  like they say MIGHT IS RIGHT, however wrong they be !

This discussion is now closed as far as I am concerned.

Chanakya said ...

08-Oct-2019

raghvan,

 you  prove that  fools jump in  where  angels  fear  to  tread...

carry on

Prinit said ...

08-Oct-2019

You just have to go with the rules. Go with the flow. Eg if in gully cricket if one bounce is out then so be it. Same here. All can see that the horses rating is low but weight is high. Then why play such horses. And this is the fun of racing which is what gets the intellectuals there. To bet their knowledge against the various variables.

Raghavan said ...

08-Oct-2019

Chanakya,

You are right.  Ignorance of rules is no excuse.  For eg, in a eight or more horse field, place dividend is paid on a horse that either wins or finishes 2nd or 3rd.  However, the place payment is restricted to only the winner & runner up in a race that has 4 or 5 or 6 or 7 runners.

I would like you to enlighten the horsetalk members under which rules you claimed place dividend on Malavika.  You see, Malavika finished 3rd in a race that had 7 runners but due to scratching only 6 ran.  You have written several essays on racing matters; well versed in rules; have 46 long years racing experience.  So, all horse talk members will find it most useful if you give the rules on that aspect.

Hunter said ...

08-Oct-2019

Fillies & Mares Stakes is an old race and I am sure it has been run on same or similar terms for many years. To bad-mouth the club unnecessarily should not be encouraged. Srinivas has probably wasted his 50 years in horse racing. Such a pity.

Sun said ...

08-Oct-2019

@Srinivas 

By following a simple calculation you can get a first cut approximation of advantage or disadvantage to a horse in a Terms Race For a while assume that current rating of a horse measures its caliber on some scale. Say here Auburn rated 101 at 51kg For every Kg add 2 rating points compare official rating with the rating worked out. Negative is disadvantage to horse. This way no punter can get fooled Sorry to say you try to reinvent the wheel. It is very clear that Terms Races are framed to give top rated horses a chance to win if weights are in order

Rajesh said ...

08-Oct-2019

Surprising to read an article like this terms race rules should be taught to you. Please read the prospectus and you will learn. No use shouting about something that most people know about. Pay as per your calculations and knowledge not tips and you'll be better off.

Sun said ...

08-Oct-2019

@Srinivas

I hope you got your doubts clarified except one that why such races are framed  It is to see that a horse is not required to carry back breaking handicap  You must have observed that the highest rating given to a horse is 124.If it were to run in the highest handicap race of 80+ it has to carry 71 Kg  A terms race limits this handicap to a reasonable It also helps in determining the best horse limiting the handicap advantage enjoyed by a lowly rated horseHope you have no more complaints about race clubs or Handicapper

 

Ruchi said ...

08-Oct-2019

Such a simple issue

ROBERTA has run 2 ND in two graded races.

Handicapper is cent percent right.

It is a different issue that ROBERTA is a over hyped horse with no acceleration whatsoever.It is a one paced horse who can run at same speed even over 4000 mts.Do others will come back to it and that's how it placed

Srinivas said ...

08-Oct-2019

Friends,

I say this for the last time : the system of assigning irrational weights in terms races is awful and totally flawed.   Due to this, while gullible punters are taken for a ride, bookies make merry at their expense.   Particularly in RWITC, the frequency of Terms races in class 1 being held almost every 2nd day is too high, thereby increasing the chances of punters suffering that much more often.   This needs to be changed immediately.  Is RWITC listening ???

Pharlap said ...

08-Oct-2019

Ok, say; let this case be not an anomaly.

Do they occur frequently or once in a while (human error) may be, in handicapping races; and when this happens- a request.

Could all of you help us? whenever possible in this forum preferably prioir the race?

Chanakya said ...

08-Oct-2019

Ignorance  is  no  excuse.  Terms  race  DOES  NOT  FOLLOW   handicap  rules...

Kautilya said ...

08-Oct-2019

Mr Srinivas

Please get your basics right first and then question the handicapper or the club. Its a term race and weights are assigned according to the terms of the said races. There is much much difference between a handicap race and a term race. And please embed it in ur mind that handicapper always knows better than you me or any other punter here. 

Transparency said ...

08-Oct-2019

The Guy doesn't know the difference between Term and handicap races .Teach him first .

Iim Blue said ...

08-Oct-2019

That's why the Court said this is a game of skill. The Club has no role as the weights were allotted as per the terms of the race. The Trainer knew before hand that the horse had no chance,  yet he chose to enter the horse for this particular race. The bookies of course saw the writing on the wall and installed the horse as favourite.If a racegoer falls to this oldest trick in the game,  he should quit immediately and save his family. How hard it is to earn  the money and how easy to lose! 

 

Srinivas said ...

08-Oct-2019

Dear Jimmy, Sir,

So you agree that the system is flawed, be it at RWITC and/or other clubs.   Such being the scenario, it is in fitness of things that the anamoly is sorted out sooner rather than later.    Otherwise it will only mean grave injustice to owners of graded group race winners, who are asked to carry more weight than they are rated to, which then leads to doosras or teesras of same owners winning by default, and punters suffering immensely.

I beg to differ with your concluding para, that Roberta will never win another race.   Yes, it will never win a terms race where it is allotted unreasonably higher weights, but it can certainly win whenever the right weight is allotted to her according to her rating, in handicap cases, where all other horses have equal chance of winning.

 

Amar said ...

08-Oct-2019

Goodbad13 sir,

please give some more details on handicap races for different centers

Aravind said ...

08-Oct-2019

Ok sir this forum has detailed discussion about rating system. It's goid. Idont think if asked even club wud not provide suchbindeoth detsils on rating system. Good atleast now punters are aware of the syetm and carefully play.  But one thing I m confused that having known the weight difference and though Roberta s superior but at this mark has risen doughts among race goers how it became bookies/tote favourite? 

Srinivas said ...

08-Oct-2019

@goodbad13,

I do know the difference between a graded race and a handicap race.

If I still preferred to write the lead post, it was just to try and educate a specific section of punters, who are not able to identify the glaring anamoly, and end up playing a wrong horse who has little or no chance of winning.   The result is all there for you to see, and I pity those punters who backed Roberta, which only brought them misery.

As rightly pointed out by Jimmy Sir, Roberta is a first class donkey, which will continue to suffer from irrational weights it will have to carry just because it won a group 1 race.   I repeat, unless the RWITC does away with this ridiculous anamoly, such horses are well and truly doomed, and the sooner one realizes this, the better it will be for their finances.   Take it or leave it, it is your choice !

Jimmy Karanjia said ...

08-Oct-2019

This has nothing to do with RWITC please. Roberta is the winner of a class I grade I race, the Indian Oaks and any horse who wins a class I grade I race has to suffer the burden of the weights for the rest of his/her racing career. It has happened with so many horses, Accolade won only a Pune Derby but kept running at top weight for the next 2 years and winning nothing. Dessert God, Adjuducate and a bunch of other names. Auburn has never won a classic or semi classic race and hence will always enjoy the weight handicap in terms races.

Roberta is a first class donkey of a horse who will never win a race in her career from now on, and it is not only because of the weight she carries but also the lack of class.

Srinivas said ...

07-Oct-2019

Dear Autonomy,

I am sure you will agree with me that most race-goers are laymen, who do not even understand the basic tenets of handicapping.   They have no inclination, nor any interest, to do any study, leave alone go through any prospectus.   They are followers of the so-called herd mentality, and bookies thrive on their ignorance.

Roberta is of course an Indian Oaks winner, which is a graded group race.    But this should not entail a far higher weight for it to carry, even as it was rated a lowly 89, in comparison to the higher rating of 103 assigned to Auburn, who was to carry 6kgs less.  THIS IS THE POINT I WAS TRYING TO MAKE.    So, it is only fair that proper handicapping is done to ensure that each horse has an equal chance of winning.   In this very race, it is a fact that Roberta was doomed to fail from the very beginning, and it came as no surprise to me that it failed to hit the board.

My 2 cents, Mr Autonomy, derived from 50 years in horse racing !  

Goodbad13 said ...

07-Oct-2019

Dear Srinivas,

No hard feelings. I am surprised that without knowing the difference between a terms and handicap race you are blaming the club blatantly 

This is prospectus

The Threptin Fillies’ & Mares’ Stakes (Grade 3)

Weights :-

3 years old, 45.5 kg;

4 years old and over, 50 kg.

Penalties :-After April 30th 2017,

Winner of a Grade 3 race, 1.5 kg

Or of 2 or more such races, 2 kg

Or of a Grade 2 race, 3 kg

Or of 2 or more such races, 4 kg

Or of a Grade 1 race, 6 kg

Or of 2 or more such races, 8 kg

In addition: After 30th April 2019,winner of a race of value Rs. 5 lakhs or over 2 kg.

ROBERTA

4 years old and over: 50

Penalties :-After April 30th 2017,

The Hindustan Times Palate Fest Indian Oaks (Gr.1): +6

Weights raised At Acceptance stage: +1

Final weight 57

AUBURN

4 years old and over: 50

Penalties :-After April 30th 2017: Zero

Weights raised At Acceptance stage: +1

Final weight 51

Hope this clears your doubt

Autonomy said ...

07-Oct-2019

Dear srinivas

Could you please explain what os class I term race

Best regards

Autonomy said ...

07-Oct-2019

Dear.srinivas 

Download detailed prospectus from rwitc webwite. Reach out to page of this race.and.check how the weights are alloted.

The weights alloted are correct.

La roundine and roberta both have.a grade.1 indian.classic victories

You will get your answer in prospects

Vijayakumarvn said ...

07-Oct-2019

Sir kindly enlighten such kind of grave mistakes in future so that you can save at least  readers at this forum  thanking you 

Srinivas said ...

07-Oct-2019

This is a rejoinder to my earlier post.

Some will accuse me of writing the stated facts, post facto, or hindsight is always 20/20.   My apologies, I was not able to write about the anamoly earlier, as I was hard pressed for time, although I did remark about the same to some punters prior to start of the particular race