Some clarity is needed regarding the term favourite in tipsters selection.
Is it the overnight favourite ? The morning favourite ? Or, the favourite at noon ? A horse may open as favourite when the bookies first chalk their prices but money comes on another horse and he ends as the favourite. Then there times when the book favourite is different from Tote favourite and the Tote favourite at different centres are different.
Watcing the TV relay from Madras, it appears that STAR APPEARANCE had lowest odds on books. As per MRC site (and indiarace site), Tote favourite was British Empress. BTC on its site shows Star Appearance as favourite on Tote.
Why is clarity needed ? Because people who follow tipsters do not know which horse tipster is referring to. Take example of Mumbai races yesterday. One tipster posted:-
5) 365 open favourite will lose.
In that particular race according to indiarce No 3 was shortest odds on books and also Tote favourite (same according to RWITC site). Surely tipster could not have tipped No. 3 to win and also mentioned "favourite will lose".
There will be no confusion if the name of horse is mentioned.
17 Replies
Chanakya said ...
06-Jan-2020
@ Glasgow Prince,
Very well explained.
Indian_turf_record said ...
06-Jan-2020
@ Glasgow Prince
Your response is much appreciated.
Glasgow Prince said ...
05-Jan-2020
ITR, sorry for the delayed reply. I feel it has to be the tote favourite at the race track where racing is taking place because only the tote strictly works on the parimutuel betting principle and the on course tote will presumably have the highest volume of betting among totes at different betting centers.
A statement like ‘the favourite will lose in the fifth race’ will essentially have to refer to the above favourite irrespective of whether it is a prediction based on astrology or it is an intelligent guess based on the degree of difficult y envisaged in finding the winner.
I don’t see any anomaly in the example which you have cited viz. ‘635 open favourite will lose’. This is because the tipster doesn’t know who will be the tote favourite at race time. In my opinion a statement that says ‘favourite may lose’ does not carry any weight as that is the case in most of the races.
If the tipster says ‘favourites of race no 4 and 5 are false favourites’ he is evidently referring to the favourites at the time of writing.
That is that as far as this topic is concerned. Coming to your speciality i.e. authentic records, I would like to bring to your notice that I have observed certain errors in the official records at various times although I have not kept a record of these errors. Such errors are specifically in respect of happening at the race track such as change of jockeys at race time and objections raised. In this respect, the official records cannot be taken as the last word. This is purely for your information.
Indian_turf_record said ...
04-Jan-2020
@ Cruise_B'lore
Old habits die hard ! You are again calling me ITF.
Cruise_b'lore said ...
04-Jan-2020
Hello ITF,
You are right. That was in reference to The SI 1000gn, the previous run of Sta Apperance.
With regarfs to the Oaks results, yes, indeed, tote at B'lore paid in excess of Rs 800/-.
I was did go for the races on that day which, co-incidentally, had Kolkata races too. I had fancied Glendower in the 2nd race and walked out after collecting the payout. I did not on further.
The question of agrreing or disagreeing about tote favourites does not arise because I was replying to your query of Star Appearance. Nothing more.
regds,
Cruise
Indian_turf_record said ...
04-Jan-2020
@ Kolramsri
Only in Classics. So that I can confirm about Winged Wonder, Grand Parade, etc !!
Indian_turf_record said ...
04-Jan-2020
@ Cruise_B'lore
I think you are mistaken about the race in question. I am talking about SI Oaks on 1 Jan 2020. For that race, the winner paid Rs.800 at Bangalore and Horse No 05 (Star Appearance) was the favourite. I have the BTC IVB result opened in another window and I am looking at it.
Your winner paid Rs. 48 or thereabouts is a clear indication that we are talking about different races.
In any case it is not the specific case which is important. My point is that for the same race it is possible for two different Totes to have different favourites. If you don't agree, that's ok. It is your prerogative.
Another example:-
SI 1000 - Chennai (Latin Dance) Bangalore (Royal Currency)
I have serious doubts about the Tote favourite shown at Chennai.
Kolramsri said ...
04-Jan-2020
Indian_Turf_Record.
I am surprised at seeing your interest shown in Chennai races.
This year Pongal Derby will be run in two divisions. ( Two divisions of Governor's cup) Madras Race Club will create History.
Chanakya Kaushik said ...
04-Jan-2020
I_T_R,
There is no ambiguity in the meaning of a favorite - a favorite is the runner who is favorite at tote at the track where race is run. All the result books, BOL, Cole, VEL follow this rule.
You have taken an isolated case to prove your point that I was right in one case and wrong in another prediction. I've also given my reason that when I posted my prediction the favorite was different than that who became favorite at race time.
As you say that statistical d ata is your aim, why don't you find out what is the percentage of my failure in these type of pre-race predictions. I've never claimed anytime absolute 'certainty' on these predictions but believe that I'll not be wrong more than 1 or 2 times out of 10 predictions giving about 80 to 90% success rate...
favorite of race no 4 will/may lose clearly indicates that the reader may either do not bet on the favorite or if has the facility then he can 'lay' the favorite...
Cruise_b'lore said ...
04-Jan-2020
Hello ITR,
Indeed a typo error and thank you for pointing it out.
Star Appearance paying Rs 48/- or thereabouts at the Bangalore makes it clear that it wasn't the favourite. I am certain and say with absolute confidence that Star Appearance was not the tote favourite.
Bookies were not operating at Bangalore on that day following the raid by CCB on them at Btc the previous day.
regds,
Cruise
Indian_turf_record said ...
04-Jan-2020
@ Cruise_B'lore
Could I request you to kindly check the IVB results section on BTC site ? For Chennai races on 1 January, the favourite shown for race no 5 (Oaks) is Horse No. 5 which happens to be STAR APPEARANCE.
Hence my point that Tote favourites for the same race (SI Oaks) on two different Totes different Totes (Chennai and Bangalore) were different (British Empress and Star Appearance).. I have noticed cases (rare, it must be said) when the favourite in the books and Tote at the same centre are different. The next time I come across it, I will post it here.
Who is the favourite for a big race was is an important part of the statistics I maintain. I am still trying to ascertain who the favourite for SI 2000 Guineas was. Sites mention Lightning Bolt but I was watching race relay and I think Impavid was best backed. I don't know if bookmakers were operating in Bangalore that day but I cannot imagine Lightning Bolt being better backed than Impavid in Bangalore.
By the way, you keep addressing me as "ITF". I hope it is only a typo and nothing derogatory.
@ Glasgow Prince
Nice to see your post after ages. Wish you found time and inclination to do so more often.
Thank you for confirming that favourite is the best backed horse at the starting time.
The doubt arose because sometime back Chanakya had predicted "favourites of race no. 4 & 5 are false favourites" for Pune races of 16 August 2019 and claimed successful prediction. Race no. 5 was won by the favourite and when this was pointed out to him, his reply was:-
"16/8 - Yes Cupido won the race as favourite but in the MORNING Patriot's Day was 3/2 and Cupido 9/4 ...... " (capitals mine).
[ His post 16-08-2019 01:54 ]
There is one clarification you can give. Supposing for Calcutta Derby next Sunday, Trafalgar is favourite in Calcutta ring and Tenno Sho in Mumbai ring, who is the favourite ?
On the principle by which SP is decided in England, I feel that the favourite at the track counts and not at an off course centre.
Raghavan said ...
04-Jan-2020
Glasgow prince,
In 90% races, favorites can be identified. Shortest priced horses.
However, if there are two horses commanding equal odds (Say 2/1) or almost equal odds (say 22/10 & 23/10) a punter will be confused as to hich one is the favorite. Such ambiguity could be easily avoided if one mentions the name of the horse.
Chanakya is a master in doublespeak. Sometimes he comes with a statement that "favorite may lose". Irrespective of the race results, he will be proved 100% correct in such dubious tips! But, I doubt whether any punter will be able to profit in any way with such non sense statements.
Mukesh said ...
03-Jan-2020
In first race 12$3 horse no will win in any race on that day note you will never lose only win
Glasgow Prince said ...
03-Jan-2020
Favourite is taken as the favourite at race time.
Chanakya said ...
03-Jan-2020
Night favorite, morning or noon favorite have no relevance when the betting takes place - it is the bookie's favorite which is taken in consideration...
5) 365 open race favorite will fail
there are various methods of handicapping - speed, pace, weight, comparative, astro, numero etc. Sometimes, more than one runner appears to have almost equal chance to win and in that case I paraphrase my selections as 'open race'....
In this case three choices are given, but with a warning(advice) that it is an open race meaning thereby that all the three choice have almost equal chance of winning the race. However, the phrase - 'the favorite will fail' clearly indicates that no. 3 (the favorite) will not win and either 6 or 5 will win; therefore favorite must be excluded from betting ( or can be 'layed' or 'eaten').....
No. 6(20/1) won the race provig the correctness of the handicapping system
Cruise_b'lore said ...
03-Jan-2020
Hello ITF,
Star Appearance was certainly not the favourite.
There was dual betting on that particlar day. Kolkata being the other.
If my memory serves me right, the tote paid around Rs 48/- for win.
The MRC display showed bookies odds being 9/2 to 5/1.
regds,
Cruise
Ruchi said ...
03-Jan-2020
Mr Record since when did you change from keeping records to tracking FAV and Non Fav.