The article ‘Outrunning the Pedigree’ by Major Nargolkar made interesting reading. It brought up two issues in my mind that I thought readers at large may like to reflect on.
Srinath had made a statement in the week prior to the Pune Derby that Lady In Lace would find it hard to win because she was unlikely to stay. He was making a statement specifically in the context of the Pune Derby as a responsible and highly experienced professional knowing very well that the Pune Derby is run over 2000. He was well aware of the merits of the competitors and was also well versed with the topography of the Pune track. His assessment was soundly thrashed by Lady In Lace who slammed the field out of sight by 8 ¾ lengths at healthy odds of 7 to 2. Srinath could have enjoyed the benefit of doubt even if the Lady was to gain a closely fought verdict. That Lady In Lace did not win over 2400 meters cannot vindicate his assessment since it was made specifically in the context of the Pune Derby. In fact, it is too much of a coincidence and a disturbing trend that such assessments are frequently made by experienced professionals prior to prestigious races. Recently, before the 2000 Guineas, trainer Altaf Hussain had opined that he rated Sultan Suleiman alongside Desert Warrior and Starfire Girl and that Sultan Suleiman will come back home with flying colours. Incidentally, Sultan was installed favourite by the market when the odds opened but finished in the ruck.
The other point that raises itself is who is to be called a stayer. Is it a horse that wins over 3000 or 2400 or 2000 in good company? For example, it was said that Sergeant At Arms did not stay because he lost the Indian Derby to Hall Of Famer although by only 1 length. In the same race though, it beat Temerity by a head. Temerity subsequently won the Invitation Cup wherein she beat Lady In Lace by almost 7 lengths while conceding two kgs. If Temerity is to be considered a stayer why would Sergeant At Arms be considered a non stayer? Generally, a horse that wins the Indian Derby is considered to have stayed but does that mean that those that finished second or third did not stay unless they were far behind the winner? It seems that the term stayer is flexible and relative and is used with reference to the context. There is no clear cut definition as to who is to be considered a stayer.
13 Replies
Cruise_b'lore said ...
24-Feb-2020
Hello folks,
Given below are what constitutes a sprinter, miler and a stayer.
SPRINTS:
Races run over trips of 5f to 6f are referred to as sprints. These are the events where the real speed merchants showcase their abilities.
MILERS:
The next class of horses after the sprinters are referred to as miler.
This is where we see some of the highest class and most exciting races of the year. Speed is still required at this distance but also the stamina to see out the additional distance.
STAYERS:
Stayers are those horses whose strong suit is stamina. In general as horses age they need a longer trip to perform to their best.
Also, do note the other one used in our country: The 7f-Specialist
The intermediary distance of 7f is viewed as something of a specialist distance being a sort of half-way house between a sprint and a mile.
===============================
The above are the terms used commonly in Indian racing.
regds,
Cruise
Cruise_b'lore said ...
24-Feb-2020
Hello Glasgow Prince,
Sprinters, Milers and Stayers are 'DEFINITE' terms in racing. They are not 'relative'. They are conclusive terms.
The Sprinters Classic is a test of speed, Likewise for milers in The Supermile Classic and The Stayers classic for true stayers.
In no way can the above be termed as relative Sprinters Classic or relative Super Mile Claasic and neither can The Stayers Classic be deemed as relative Stayers Classic.
With regads to ratings, they play no significant role in deciding the outcome of a classic race or Terms race. They can be best said to be pointers. Nothing more.
What you gave in your lead post was of classic races and the ratings, I repeat, play no significant role.
In fact, they often mislead in believing that the top rated one is the one supreme but it has been proven wrong more often than not. ( in classics and Terms races ).
Only in handicaps do they ( ratings ) play a pivotal role.
And ratings never prove who is a champion or good sprinter, miler or a stayer ( in a race ).
regds,
Cruise
Rajaraman said ...
24-Feb-2020
All experts can write how much they want finally no Pedigree is certain only we have to take a call with whom That's the trick they adopt finally they will give you only vada curry I have seen it all along in my Racing life even peers must have experienced the same
Glasgow Prince said ...
23-Feb-2020
Hi Cruise
In my experience, ratings can be useful if used judiciously. I also accept that everyone may have a different experience.
Lady In Lace did sufficiently well over distances ranging from 2000 to 2400 although she did not win beyond 2000. As such she qualifies to be a called a decent stayer. It is all relative.
S.k.sagar said ...
22-Feb-2020
I will be at the Pune Race Course tomorrow. If you are coming, we can meet at the usual place.
Look forward ... There is a lot to discuss with you
Best wishes
S.K.SAGAR
Cruise_b'lore said ...
22-Feb-2020
Hello Glasgow Prince,
The main focus ought to remain on the questions or queries you posed in the lead post i.e what factors quantifies a stayer.
Ratings don't and will never will.
Champion sprinters and milers have in the past gotten much higher ratings than the derby winners. As such, one should not bring ratings into play in this topic.
It is ir-relevant.
The ability to perform consistently well at longer trips ( 10f and beyond ) is the sole criteria to decide a 'Stayer'.
regds,
Cruise
Neerajnanaiah said ...
22-Feb-2020
Yes, the term Stayer is relative. I agree
Cheers
Glasgow Prince said ...
22-Feb-2020
@ Neeraj Nanaiah
When Srinath said Lady In Lace will find it hard to win the Pune Derby because she was unlikely to stay, he was referring to her staying ability over 2000. When Serjeant At Arms lost the Indian Derby it was said that he did not stay. In this case the distance being referred to was 2400. The official race to determine the best stayer in the country viz. The Stayers Cup is run over 3000. This shows that the term stayer is flexible and relative and is used with reference to the context.
In the Roger Federer example we are talking of specifics i.e. clay court. That is precisely my point. When the term stayer is used the distance is not specified. From the context it can be anything from 2000 to 3000 and more.
There is always the chance that a prediction will go wrong. The question is by what margin. Even if Lady In Lace was to win a close verdict, it could have lent some credence to Srinath’s assessment at that time. Similarly, Sultan Suleiman who was rated alongside Desert Warrior and Starfire Girl by the trainer on the eve of 2000 guineas, finished 9th in a field of 10 almost 11 lengths behind the winner. All professionals are aware that their statements are going to sway public opinion and sentiment.
@ GSL
I don’t know where it was reported that Lady In Lace won the Pune Derby in heavy going against an under prepared field but it was not so. I was present at the venue with a bunch of friends. If we were to say that Srinath summed it well, it would mean that Lady In Lace did not stay 2000 but still hacked the field by almost 8 lengths.
The other point I have reflected on is about the flexible use of the term ‘stayer’. It is not about pedigree or winner finding although they can be separate topics of interest in their own right.
@ Cruise
My reply to Neeraj Nanaiah would have provided further elaboration on my lead post. It is not my intention to contest the ability of any particular horse to stay but to say that the term stayer is relative and is used with reference to the context.
Coming to Serjeant At Arms, the bigger picture can provide different insights. True he won only twice over 2000 but he ran 2000 only thrice and his one loss was attributed to injudicious riding. He ran 2400 only once when he came a close second. On the other hand he ran 13 times in races up to 1600. Even when he lost the Indian Derby by only one length, the winner Hall Of Famer was rated 100 and the third placed Temerity was rated 97 which were reasonably high ratings at that stage of their careers. Contrast this with the ratings of Trouvaille (78) and Wizard Of Stocks (65) who placed second and third behind War Hammer in this year’s Indian Derby. Even the average field rating then was 83 as against 72 of this year’s Derby. Serjeant At Arms was decisively superior to the opposition over 1600. The connections would naturally take a call on its itinerary considering his chances of winning depending on the quality of the opposition he would face.
Cruise_b'lore said ...
21-Feb-2020
Hello Glasgow Prince,
A confirmed sprinter, miler or a stayer is the one that performs consistently, I repeat, consistently well, over the particular trip.
One odd performance cannot be the criteria to judge.
Major is absolutely right in stating that Lady In Lace was not a true stayer.
With regard to Srinath's statement, he gave his opinion which was proved wrong subsequently in Pune derby but proved right then on in her subsequent starts at longer trips.
Speak to the top professionals before a big race and you will get varying analysis, mostly different from one another. Each one has his or her own assessment factor. Most are proven wrong and a handful few get it right.
With regards to Serjeant At Arms, here is my take:
Serjeant At Arms won 14 races - more than 80% was at mile and below. He won only 2 races at 2000m and nothing beyond.
So, the question of marking him as a stayer never arises.
This in response to your query on the same.
regds,
Cruise
Gsl said ...
20-Feb-2020
@Glasgow prince Ji..You r right when u mentioned about srinath saying before the pune derby about lady in lace. .yeah she won it by 8lts @ 2000 Mrs on a heavy going when the rest of them maybe were not as wound up as her..With all due respect sir..srinath summoned it well..she did not stay. .n the second point u mentioned was who runs 2'nd or 3rd but not by much in the Indian derby should or should not be considered as a stayer is totally n individuals knowledge..yeah it is always hard to decide but I think there's a clue .. I.E (THE PEDIGREE ) It works for me n most. ..Most of times if not in few cases. .So what MAJOR wrote in his article is not how u have expressed ..but in no way I'm against ur thought coz they do come in the mind. .But this is an interesting debate which is worth few brains. .To say the least for the followers of real handicapping pls read MAJOR SRINIVAS NARGOLKAR article on pedigrees n his 3 decade experienced views. .coz much more than half the puzzle is solved ..Rest is ur form n fitness. .IN REAL WORDS, it is how u r prepared for that particular race n ur mindset. .Always b patient for the right races n you most probably be on the winning side..Can go on ..Gud luck to all dedicated followers of form with luck...
Glasgow Prince said ...
20-Feb-2020
Erratum :
The Invitation Cup in which Temerity beat Lady In Lace by close to 7 lengths was not won by Temerity. It was won by Kangra and Temerity was second. Sorry for the error.
Neerajnanaiah said ...
20-Feb-2020
Also I think it was very brave of Mr. Y S Srinath to express his honest opinion. Before saying his opinion, he said 'I may be proven wrong'
Neerajnanaiah said ...
20-Feb-2020
Roger Federer has won the biggest tournament on clay.. The French Open
But still he is considered 'a notch below the best' on clay.
Hope this comparison answers your question.