Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Class, Rating, Handicap And Timing

By S C Sharma | 16-Mar-2020

Success in racing is much depends upon assessment of class, rating, handicap and timing apart from knowledge of bloodline, suitability of distance of participating horses and present fitness of the horse and intensions of the stable. Many stables are known for loosing when their wards running favourites and winning when they are offered good odds. Keeping such intentions in mind make your selection process easy and success percentage high.

CLASS of a horse is determined as per rating allotted by handicapper and generally handicapper determines rating of a horse after three runs. But to understand RATING you can assume the rating of a debutant colt around 30 points and the rating of a debutant filly around 27 points. Than after every run depending upon the performance ( win, place or unplaced ) fresh ratings are allotted on the basis of  two points of rating equals 1kg formula. Based upon the RATING the CLASS of the horse is determined and normally the classication will be as follows:

1) 0 to 25 or 0 to 30 points rating denotes bottom class ‘V’ or class ‘B’.

2) 20 to 45 points rating equals to class ‘IV’ or class ‘A’.

3) 40 to 65 points rating equals to class ‘III’ and ‘IV’

4) 60 to 75 points rating equals to class ‘II’

5) 75 to 90 points rating equals to class ‘I’ and above

Ratings of a horse can be from 0 to 125 and above. Higher rating denotes higher class and lower rating denotes lower class. Ratings are valid in handicap races only . In terms, graded or classic races weights are determined as per age, sex, number of wins or stake money earning wise and as prescribed the terms and conditions in prospectus.

The purpose of RATING AND WEIGHT in other words HANDCAPPING is to  ensure each horse gets a equal chance of winning. After every run fresh ratings and weights allotted to horses by the handicapper to get equal chance to all horses  in compare with other horses. Handicap-weights effects the running of a horse and according to weight and handicap each horse completes running of a particular distance in slow or fast time. Weight matters most in middle and long distance races . SPEED  matters most in short distance races and STAMINA matters most in middle and long distance races. The suitable distance of a horse can be indenfied  as per bloodline or previous runs or as per track preparation and performance of the horse. You cannot expect a sprint horse to deliver best in long distance race and a long distance horse to deliver best over sprint distance races. Whenever  a horse runs in extension or reduction of a distance of more than 600 to 800 mts his bloodline, past performance and latest track-work preparation is to be taken into account for arriving at best results. Number of times the trainers confuses the punters by entering their wards in wrong distance races  or in terms races where their wards are not advantageously placed. Trainers intentions, talent and shortcomings are also to be considered. 

How does weight effects the RUNNING  and TIMING of the horse ? For simple calculation purpose we assume as follows: 5kg increase or decrease in handicap or weight effects the running of the horse by 1 second upto 1600 mts that is 5 lengths. Similarly from 1600 mts to 2400 mts the effect will be 1.5 seconds that is 7.5 lengths and for 2400 to 3200 mts the effect will be 2.0 seconds that means 10 lengths. But some horses when they are at peak or at upgrade and in good form and condition they can defy such penalties. The company in which the horse won and winning margin and winning style also matters most. The class level at which the horse entered to run and the opponents often provide clues to the determine the horse performance in next outing. Slow and fast timing also depends upon the pace, weather and track condition, false rails  and penetrometer reading of the particular race day, so many times comparative timings of other races held on the same day also matters most.

In racing the position of the horse at various stages is important. Number of lengths the horse leading or trailing at different stages of the race and the finish position is important. Finish position is the crucial part of the horse performance and gives clues about future likely performance. Speed and stretch of covering ground is very crucial for future runs over different distances. Bloodline matters least when the horse struck form , than distance and timing matters most and the improvement horse showing in each and every tun. 

Peculier habits of the horses revealed in race day reports and incidents and info regarding treatment  and ailments is also an important issue before finalising and selection of bets.

Finally number of times lot more debated on whether one should attend or leave racing. In my opinion it all depends upon individual ‘s liking and risk taking capacity.  No one is under coercion or in compulsion to attend races. Everyone is well aware about his doings and actions and also aware that he is only responsible for making or destroying of  his own fortune. If you are in limits and playing cautiously and responsibly without effecting your daily livelihood, family responsibilities and social obligations than no one have the right to enter in your freedom and preach or advice you anything. My only advice is  do whatever you like, whatever your conscious permits but with responsibility and  with patience, control, planning, budget and selectiveness  without much involvement in all races and on  all race days. Non betting races you can watch and enjoy also. Each race is not for betting and winner picking in all races is not possible. Don’t take anything granted. Certainties do not exist in racing and the only Certainty in racing is ‘Uncertainty ‘.  If you are preapared for the worst and know the risk factor and taking calculated risk than you are bound to gain, but keep your expectations low without blame game awards. 

Post Your reply

88 Replies

Sun said ...

05-Apr-2020

@ksmrow,

Thanks for your post.I do recognise that Speed Ratings and Official Ratings cannot be mixed.

My feeling is Each Class has a Range of Times and to some degree of accuracy we can arrive at a Standard Time for a Class.Before we do the we must adjust the Time for Weights Raised OR Lowered.A horse carying say 60Kg at the Rating of 45 Clocks a different Time than when it runs at 61.5 Kg with Weight Raise because the  Rating 45 represents some strength of the horse.This Rating is not earmed just like that.

I know you have done extensive stusy on Timings.In respect oof 3 Years olds we find that Rating alloted after first season takes into account the Races it Won.A pure Maiden versus where a Winner goes up b 3 Kg and other Maidena run at 2 Kg less that the Maidens Weight of say 55Kg .The  winner can to into 40-65 Class depending on the margin of Win.

Thanks.

Sun said ...

05-Apr-2020

@PDS

I fully agree with you to attempt to project an Expected Time for a horse based on its previous Weight,Time and Distance Parameters is impossible.My interest in Timings is to make a choice out of say 3 horses which are closely matched on Ratings.I use my system of Ratings and compare with Handicapper's Rating.Now out of these horses I compare Timing of each horse from that Day's Average which is to Datum of 1600 Mtrs and add Advantage/Disadvantage in Ratings to the already arrived at Rating to make the final chice.

My Rating method is based Weights&Separating Distances and is reasonably accurate,To cite an example Snowdon Rating went up from 82 to 108 after its win in Rno 92 on 4th Jan at Bangalore and matches with my working.

 

 

L.shyamsunddar said ...

04-Apr-2020

Race 84 (Mumbai) Rating = 45, wt = 61.5kgs, time = 70.84 seconds.

Race 148 (Mumbai) Rating = 55, wt = 56.5kg, time = 71.28 seconds.

Please look at the above timing VS ratings of Anatevka in race numbers 83, 53, 38, 84 & 148.

In race 83 The rating was 38 with wt = 58kgs and the time displayed was 71.36 seconds and it placed first, the Handicapper raised the rating to 45 in race no 53, but the weight was dropped to 51.5kgs (low weight compared to the previous run with 58kg weight).

The time clocked goes high with increase in rating and drop in weight here and the horse placed 9th in this case. (Promotion)

Under the practice of handicapping method, the handicapper has decremented the rating to 46 from 47 with a weight of 61kgs in race number 38 and he expects the horse to win in this race, The horse clocked 71.87 seconds and placed 3rd with just a drop in 1 rating point (demotion).

In race no 84, the handicapper dropped the rating to 45 expecting the horse to win this time at least and the horse won with a time of 70.84 seconds. In this case the handicapper has raised 0.5kg to a final weight of 61.5kgs by reducing a single rating from 46 to 45.

In the final run in race no 148 (promotion), the weight was 55kg and the time clocked was 71.28 seconds.

From the above observation these are the questions rising in my mind:

1. Why the time clocked is higher than the lower class even after drop in weight and when the rating is incremented? This happens almost with all the horses. This case is just an example. In fact what is rating, I don’t think it’s just a number allotted to the performance of the horse!!

2.       Why a horse is expected to place or win with a drop of 1 or 2 rating points by the handicapper when there is no drop in weight?

3.       Why there is a difference of such a large clocking time of 1.03 seconds just with a drop of 1 rating point in race no 84? (46 rating to 45 rating). This happens in most of the cases, only the thing is that the time clocked per rating is not the same or nearing values for all the horses and this varies from horse to horse.

4.      In the final run race no 148 ( during promotion) the rating was raised to 55 from 45 with 56.5kgs weight and the horse placed 1st and it clocked 71.28 seconds with increment of rating points. The difference in time is 71.28 – 70.84 = 0.44 seconds with addition of 10 rating points. In all these cases we observe that the clocked time goes high or low with the rating and not with the weight exactly. Then what does the rating system exactly mean? That is to say that, while the promotion why the clocked time is high even with the drop of 5kgs to 10kgs? Here it is 5kgs in this case. PNR values and FR or NFR differences does not influence much on rating VS time. But the PNR and FR or NFR influence the total clocked time of all the horses and all the races on a particular day.

Could anyone justify these issues?

 

Pds said ...

03-Apr-2020

Dear Sun, Please dont get involved in these minute calculations, just keep handicaps(weighs alloted) as a factor affecting the speeds of the runners, because even a computer can not give you accurately the actual affects i.e. so many KGs and so many lengths over so much distance etc etc. because every Horse has a different capability of carrying weight, some are weight carriers, some are not, some are strong built, some  are medium build and some are light built. All types have different capacities to carry the weight. Also fillies have less capacity in general, naturally being ladies. HOW WILL YOU calculate all the affects and mind you accurately. Please keep this factor as an important factor affecting the speeds, but use your practice, experience    and intelligence to work out the affects as no figrative thumb rulues or formulae can give you correct results. Just think about it on a serious note. Good luck

Ksmrow said ...

03-Apr-2020
@sun,

Rating of official handicapper doesn’t impress up on horse timings it can be for speed rating,a horse is promoted for his previous performance,request promotion or eligible to run in upper class what ever it is when a horse is running that way we have to add+0.5 sec to 3yr olds and others +1.0sec why should we add because the promotee

has to cope with faster pace of the race,faster quarter timings may effect his speed.

For your point for study Example add class difference time as above. and in my work out always take 1kg=0.1sec.

Ksmrow said ...

03-Apr-2020

A After going through responses of some experts I came to certain conclusions

I may be wrong but not totally here one by one:-

I T R , HE IS LEGEND AS FAR AS KEEPING RECORDS,almost always responds and furnish records some times  as courts take cases he took up assumo-to and corrects the facts with records. One who never done any mathematical calculations in 30years racing noses in to weights & timings and comes to conclusion of drop in weight doesn’t make horse run faster!

Ruchi, dynamic rating expert who gives 4top dynamic rated horses and gives logical reasons eliminate chances of one or two horses and bring choices to two or three for race and enjoying good success rate. But why Now a days he is trusting astrology and numbers more why? However good a Doctor in his field no match to civil engineer or a mason in construction work.

Sun said ...

01-Apr-2020

Just a point for study.Suppose we take a 1600 Mtr race the typical time for 1/2 Kg is around 0.1 Secs.So for 20 Rating points which is Class Difference the time adjustment is 2 secs.So if we consider Class 0 to 26 to Highest Class 98 to 124 (All for RWITC Bottom Weight 49 Kg) for 5 classes we get 10 secs difference which we don't find in practice ie if highest class clock 1 min 36 sec on a day the Lowest Class Time is 1 Min 46 Secs which is rarely the case.

So Class to Class the drop appears 10 Kg but in practice the Times difference is not to this extent.I have observed we need  to add 3 Kg to the Upper Class Handicap and do the claculation.This has some thing to do with the 3 Kg overlap between classes.

Another point is if the actual drop is 10 Kg the Trainer should always prefer to enter the horse in Upper Class once it crosees 39 that is 40-46 of Lower Class.

Glasgow Rpince said ...

01-Apr-2020

Ksmrow, Chanakya, Sun, Ruchi, PDS, L Shyam Sunddar and all others interested,

While comparing the timings of Jetfire in R Nos. 84, 118 and 148 I happened to compile the following data.

JETFIRE

R No – Date / Serial No / Time / Weight carried / Timing / PNR / False Rails

R 84 – 9.1.20 / 4th race / 4 PM / 60 / 1.11.82 / 3.9 / 3.1200 – 5.1000 – 6.800 – 7.WP

R 118 – 1.2.20 / 6th race / 7 PM / 61 / 1.11.92 / 3.8 / 3.1200 – 4.1000 – 6.WPth race / 4.30PM / 51 / 1.11.86 / 3.9 / 2.1200 – 3.1000 – 5.WP

The above data reveals that the PNR values for 9.1.20 (R 84) and 16.2.20 (R 148) are exactly same. False rails for R 9.1.20 are marginally wider. However, despite this, to my surprise I found that the timing of Jetfire in R 148 is substantially slower considering the weights as already pointed out by L Shyam Sunddar. 

Same is the case with Anatevka.

ANATEVKA

R 84 – 9.1.20 / 4th race / 4 PM / 56.5 / 1.10.84

R148 – 16.2.20 / 6th race / 4.30 PM / 53.0 / 1.11.28

In fact the timings of all the races run on 16.2.20 are substantially slower than those run on 9.1.20. The timings on 1.2.20 seems to be more or less in line with those on 9.1.20 considering the PNR values and width of false rails. This raises serious questions about the reliability of the PNR values for the day as published by RWITC. It appears that punters who use this data have an added responsibility to first ascertain whether the published data is correct.

 

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

29-Mar-2020
Chanakya,

Sharper the bend more pronounced and visible will be the effect.

Sun,

I think at Mumbai they are using moveable rails. In the old days, there used to be permanent rails and false rails used to be put up as and when required.

L Shyam Sunddar,

I don’t know if you have got the answers to your questions.

I hope the explanation given by Sun clarifies your first points about ratings. I think you are saying ‘the handicapper revised the rating to X and expected that the horse will win’ because of the principle that the handicapper is supposed to give equal chance of winning to each horse. Well, technically you are right except that each race that any particular horse runs is neither run identically nor run in identical conditions. In one of my earlier posts I have highlighted the effect of the path that a horse takes. Each extra stride will cost him about 6 meters. The Turf Authories of India has recently uploaded on YouTube the video of the 1997 Poonawalla Breeders Multi-Million won by Forest Fantasy (S Narredu) beating Archimedes (Aslam Kadar) in a close finish. While Forest Fantasy was drawn 1 Archimedes was drawn 13 and had to travel wide throughout losing precious lengths in the process. Forest Fantasy on the other hand made a beeline for the winning post right from the word ‘go’ and just about scrambled home.  This video provides a telling demonstration of the importance of the path taken by a runner.

Your other question is why in R No 148 run on 16.2.20 Jetfire did not clock 1 second better time while carrying 10 kg less as compared to R No 118 run on 1.2.20. If you compare the timings on those two days you will find that the timings of all the races run on 16.2.20 are significantly slower than those run on 1.2.20 for identical distances. You can also take the example of Anatevka to understand this point. Antevka clocked 1.11.28 carrying 53 kg on promotion in R No 148 as compared to 1.10.84 that it clocked while carrying 56.5 kg in R No 84.

Pds said ...

29-Mar-2020

Dear friends, once again please pardon me because again I am pointing out a wrong information furnished by your favourite writer, and it is about Pune Race Track, Pune Race Track also has a straight chute, but this chute is only for 1200 mtrs, so pune can also have races of 1000 mtrs and 1200 mtrs from the straight chute and will have only one bend at approx 500 mtrs, beyond that distance pune will have two bends. So now we have chutes in Bombay Race Track, which is upto 1400 mtrs and in Pune Race Track it is upto 1200mtrs.  One more point,because of this single bend races, the timimgs of Bombay and Pune upto 1400 mtrs and 1200 mtrs respectively will be faster. You can study this, it will help you when you compare the timings of various Racing Centres, vis a vis these two centres.Good luck

Chanakya said ...

29-Mar-2020

@ PDS,

Mumbai HAS  a  mile chute which  RUNS STRAIGHT  for  1000m  till  bend and  races of  1600 & 1400m  WERE  RUN  from  that  point  in  the  past...

Proof?  Read  the  record  timings  for  1400 & 1600m  given  in  COLE racebook...

I'm  sure  you  have  not  been  to  Mumbai  racecourse and  seen  the  two DISTINCT racetracks which  MERGE  INTO  ONE  AT 1050 OR  1100m...

Ignorance  is  not  bliss in  horse racing...

 

@ SUN,

False  rails  are  CONTINUOUSLY  INCREASING   rails in  the  sense  that  if  at 1400m  they  are  1m  away  and  at  1200m  at  4m  away means  that  their  distance  from  the  permanent  rails  is  being  increased  and  becomes  4m at  1200m while  it  was  only  1m  at  1400m and  so  on...

Pds said ...

29-Mar-2020

Dear Friends, Just a small correction in the on ground details given by a learned friend in respect of Bombay Race Track, the total distance  the Chute  enables the races to be run with a stretch of straight 1000 mtr  is maximum  1400mtrs and not 1600mtrs as given in his write up. To ascertain this, just see the video of a 1600 mtr race and 1400 mtr race of RWITC and you will clearly see the starting points to know this. Just a small point for our friends to know and learn correct things as far as possible about our hobby.

Chanakya said ...

25-Mar-2020

GLASGOW  PRINCE,

I accept  your  points  but  would  like  to  add that, if I remember  correctly; Hyderabad  racecourse  is  not  elliptical as  most  of  the  other courses  are  but  is  akin  to  a  wide head  triangle with  the  narrow  head  closer  to  the  final  bend which is  responsible  to  spreding  of  the  field entering  the  straight of  the  course...

 

@ SUN,

Mumbai  racecouse has  two  options  to  run races  of  1600m  and lesser  distances.. It  has  a  'mile'chute which  is  actually  1000m long  straight   track  till bend and a normal  2400m  long  main  track with  4  bends. Mumbai  can  run  races  upto 1600m  with  only  one bend  at  600m  while  no  other  race course  has  this facility.

To  save  the  main portion  of  the  track closer  to  permanent  rails  for  important  and  classic  races;  the  false  rails  are  placed along  the  main  track as well  as  along  the  track  starting  from  the  'mile' chute. While races  upto  1600m  can be  run  stright  from  'mile' chute   longer  distance  races  are  to  be  run  on  the  main  track. Hence  different width  of  rails may  be  used   for  straight course and  main  course  till 1000m wherefrom  the  distance upto  winning  post  is common...

To  understand what  is  a  mile  chute : draw  a  perpendicular  tangent  at  600m curve  and  extend  it  to  1000m - you  will reach  the  starting  point  of  the  mile  chute....  

 

Chanakya said ...

25-Mar-2020

Ruchi  has  made  a  very  correct  statement  that  with  the  use  of  rodometer the 'increase'  in  the  distance  has  been  nullified  by  using  different widths  of  false  rails. But  I  must  point  out  that  in  Mumbai the  false  rails  width  can  reach 13m and  will  definitely  affect  the  final  'raw'  time  of  a  race, irespective  of  the  PNR values. Therefore  for  final  calculations and  adjustments these  factors  must  be  taken  in  consideration....

 

Sun said ...

25-Mar-2020

So we have the last word from our learned Glasgow Prince on the subject.Two opposing factors one smoother curve passage&firm ground on outer track the other crowding of space due to restriction of track may result in better OR poor timing depending on which factor dominates the other.

This raises 2 questions for me With Longchamp Method of Penetrometer Reading taking do we need to have 2 values one near rails and the other away though RWITC informed that with this Longchamp Method they take 3 readings at any point of the track and is a superior method.

Second point is about the mention of forces If my memory serves me right the Outward directed Force is Centrepetal and Inward directed force is Centrifugal and both are equal&opposite.So ???

 Since we are anyway not able to Normalise the Times with any degree of Consistency better do not attempt to quantify both PNR effect and FR effect.We can qualify the Times Clocked something like   1 min 12 secs for 1200 mtrs (@PNR 3.4,NFR) OR 1 Min 13.4 Secs (PNR 3.7,FR) like in Co-ordinate Geometry.

 

Pds said ...

25-Mar-2020

Dear Friends,

I will offer only a few points in respect of false rails and also to clarify the doubts of a friend about" why Bangalore Turf Club does not hold 1000 mtr races and why Bombay Turf Club holds 1000 Mtr races and does not hold 1100 Mtr races?

a) Lets not get involved with the riddle of working out the affects of false rails on the distace of a race, because you can never do it accurately and even if you try to work it out it can only be an approximation which is also not required as the distance has been measured and quite accurately so by the rodometer ( the only exception being Delhi Race Course where rodometer is not used) and please dont use the formula which was used by one learned friend, it is all wrong.

b) The second point raised by one friend was," why Bangalore Turf Club does not hold 1000 mtr races.) It is, because the layout of Bangalore Race Track does not permit it, in here after 1000 mtrs bend come too early at about just 125-150 mtrs from the starting gates which is considered un safe for the horses and their jockeys.

c)RWITC, they hold 1200 mtrs races because they have straight chute from 1400 mtrs and they can hold 1000 mts to 1400 mts races which are standard distances on that stretch of chute.

I hope this clarifies the points raised.

 

 

 

Sun said ...

25-Mar-2020

@ Chanakya,

For academic interest if one wants to compute extra distance if any due to False Rails

1.It is easy for Bangalore Mysore and Hyderabad as the FRs rail start at few places and the width is one or two numerical values.

2. For Kolkata we have no information as they just mention FRs from 1200 to 400 Nothing more

3.For Mumbai and Pune it is most complicated and I am not able to make head or tail of it,

  For example 17th Nov first day of Mumbai season it reads FRs were place 1 mtr at 1300 Mtrs 4 Mtrs at 1000 6 Mtrs at 800 thereafter 10 mtrs up to Winning Post FRs were placed 3 Mtrs in the chute.

From the above description I get the impression that it is not a curve but linearly increasing.Further Chute is parallel to the rails How to intrepet it OR Ignore?

Can you please throw some light on this?

Thanks.

Glasgow Prince said ...

25-Mar-2020

In my opinion the effect of false rails is as follows. 

1. There is negligible impact as far as distance to be traversed is concerned since the use of rodometer was started.

2. The false rails make the bends smoother and help the horses to maintain a relatively faster speed along the bends without being dragged out by the centrifugal force. In the absence of false rails riders have to start decelerating some distance before the bend and accelerate once they are through it. The impace of the centrufugal force is very much visible especially at Hyderabad around the final bend when the horses sometimes appear to have been thrown about and out of their strides. In totality therefore this factor may tend to marginally improve the timing with false rails.

3. When the going is soft the portion of the track on the outer side is harder than the one that is along the rails. Whenever it rains we have seen that riders try to take the outer ground since it is relatively firm and the horses are able to get good traction. Hence this could lead to a fractionally better timing with false rails.

When the going is good, the portion of the track along the rails is harder and hence false rails can slow down the timing fractionally.

4. False rails naturally narrow down the galloping space as Ruchi has pointed out. The impact is more pronounced on the tracks that are already narrow such as the one at Pune resulting in horses not being able to get a free run especially when the fields are large.

In my opinion, it is very very difficult to quantify the effect of false rails on the timing of a race as it can vary according to different circumstances and does not lead to meaningful conclusions.

 

Chanakya said ...

25-Mar-2020

 

 

@ Ksmrow,

You  have correctly  summarised the  various  opinions  of  punters  in  your  points. In  actual  practice  false rails  do  increase the  final  time although use  of  rodometer enables  the  distance  ro  be the  same as  with NFR. In  my  opinion  it  is  because the  race with  wide(6 or  7m)  false  rails  is  run on  'unraces'  part  of  the  track which  is  not  so  'hard' as  the  'no  false rails'  portion  of  the  track....

@ SUN,

Your  calculations  are  personal  and  you  have  elaborately  explained in  earlier  postings  the  methodology  used  by  you. I  want  to  make  a  point  about  your  24/3 at  3.54PM post.

Yes,  R theeths radians is    a better  option, no  doubt  but  we  have  to  look  at  the  topography  of  various  race courses.  Mumbai  is  a  2400m  course while  Bangalore  is  a 2000m  course  - both  are 

 

 

correctly  is  a rather  triangular  course and  not  elliptical. For  Mumbai a  1600m  race   if  tarted  from  mile  chute  covers  in  a  sraight line 1000m  distance  from  the  chute  to  the  bend and  then moves  exactly  90  degrees  to the right  in to  the  straight which  is  roughly  550 to  600m. Even  if  the race  is  run  from  the  'backstretch' at  Mumbai  from  1800 to  winning  post  the  bend  at  1100 and  600  is  almost at  90  degrees  and  not  at  100+ degrees . Same  is  the  case  at  Bangalore  turf. About  Hyderabad  and  oher  tracks  local punters  will  be  in  a  better  position  to  elaborate  the angular  peculiarities  of  the  bends... 

Sun said ...

24-Mar-2020

I fully agree with the comments of Ksmrow on the subject of False Rails and people's opinions.Howver the fact remains that on a study of Timings clocked on days with Frs and without there is variation.This variation can be attributed to a host of factors.

Like in the case of Penetrometer reading on Timings where a Times with PNR of 3.9 are better than PNR of 3 we can also see Timings with FRs are sometimes better than NFR times.

So ;et us leave it at that.

Ruchi said ...

24-Mar-2020

False rails now days makes no difference as far as distance is concerned because the starting gates are placed after calculator with rodometer

The only difference FALSE RAILS make is the width of GALLOPING room which does have a impact on the running in big fields

Sometimes before classics even at Bangalore one notices that the false rails are so wide thst GALLOPING room is very SCARY

Sun said ...

24-Mar-2020

@PDS,

 I expected you will comment on the need to calculate  Extra Distance when Rodometer is used to measure Distances and mark the points for positioning the Starting Gates.Instead you commented on the difference in Radii at bend postions at various centres.

My take is like this

Angle of 90 degrees at the bend appears too sharp Perhaps 120 Degrees is more likely

The FR of say 5 Mtrs is coming over the Radius of the bend which is much larger and instead of 2 Pi R the correct method may be R Theetha in Radians So 120 degrees is 2 Pi by 3 raians Taking Pi as 3 we get 2 So for 1 Mtr it is 2 Mtr .

We can take 2 Mtrs as 1L but it may give wrong results if we take it as 0.16 sec or 0.2 sec standard for 1 L. For 1200 Mtrs if the race is run in 1 Min 12 Secs for 1 Mtr the time is 0.06 Sec but 1600 Mtrs for typical 1 Min 40 Secs it is 10000/1600 0.0825 So for 1 Mtr FR we need to add time equivalent of 2 Mtrs.

These are my views.Your comments are welcome.

 

Ksmrow said ...

24-Mar-2020

@PDS

How can you or for the matter anyone in this forum who are asking can expect Answers For full satisfaction of their query no body is master only give answers from their study,experience and knowledge on the subject false rails impact on running variations no mathematical system quantify 100% to actual impact,

1)Some believe there is 0 impact because there is no extra distance to run.

2)some are of opinion even there is no extra distance to cover there will be significant impact at bends or curves 

3)some times in Kolkata & Hyderabad false are placed only up to 400mts or Final bend this will force horses to change path run towards rails

4)Due to false rails bend position eased up and degree of the curve will change and effect unknown.

Algebra taught us if you don’t know the true value you can say it as X and try to find it.

I am of the opinion you have worked hard on this false rails subject and may have came to certain conclusions.

Chanakya said ...

24-Mar-2020

@pds,

I,ve  understood  what  you  are  but  I  don't care  who  you  are...

Just  tell  the  readers  why  Bangalore  cannot  run  1000m races and  Mumbai  does(can?)  not  run  1100m  races...

 The basic or  main  or  real  purpose  of  false  rails  is  to  save/restore to original condition  the  portion  of  the  race  track ALWAYS  used  by MOST of  the  runners  of  a  race...

 False  rails  are  NORMALLY  placed  from  1200 oe 1000m  from  the  winning  post  and  sometimes  from  1400m or 1600m (Mumbai) ...

Runners in India, keep  on  changing exchanging  their  position/(s) as  per  the instructions till  they approach  the  final  bend and  the  real  racing starts...

The  distances  are  measured  by a  'rodometer' (find  from  the  net what  it  is?) and  the  accuracy of  distances  depend  on  the sincerity  of  the  clerkofthecourse and  hism staff...

I know  the topography as  well  as the  variations and  drawbacks, of  all  the Indian racecourses, except Delhi and  chennai  

Want  to  know/learn/understand something behave and  post  sensibly and  properly...

learning  or  earning  does  not  come free unless a person proves  his  true(not  correct) intentions... 

 

Pds said ...

23-Mar-2020

Dear Chanakya, I am sorry to say, you dont know what calculations you have done. Relating these calculations of yours to our discussion about false rails of a Race Course you will be given zero marks. I would request you to discuss with some high school student this problem and then discuss the subject, as this explantion of yours is all wrong.( what you have given is just the parameter of 6 meter radius circle divided by 4) Sorry I may be sounding rude,but we can not be telling our friends all wrong things.

Pds said ...

23-Mar-2020

Dear Chanakya, I think I have to further clarify my question. Please study the actual sketches of the layout of a few Race Courses of India e.g Bangaluru, Mumbai and Pune, after 1200mtrs/1400mtrs we have two bends and not only that, in case of Bangalore race course the radius  is much smaller, there fore the net effect of false rails in increasing the distance will be more. You can plot their sketches on a graph paper and you will know the difference other wise it is only guess work and approximation which can confuse our race loving friends, because every one of us will not go into all these nitty gritties which are irrelevent in actual running of the race.Just food for thought. Take care and goog luck. your sincerely.

Chanakya said ...

22-Mar-2020

dear PDS,

We  know the perimeter  of  a  circle is equal  to  2'pi' R where 'pi' is  equal  to  3.14  and R is  the  radius  of  the  circle. Now  a  bend  is  normally  taken  as at  90  degree which  is  1/4  of  360 degree  of  a  circle. Therefore, False  rails along  bend  can  be  considered as  part  of  another (outer) circle concentric to  the bend's  circle which  at  90  degrees (1/4 of  360 degree) and  the  diffference in perimeter of  2  concentric  circles  is  given by  2'pi' (R1- R2) where  R1  is  outer  and R2 is  inner  circle .Perimeter  difference  at  bend (1/4 of  360 degrees)  for  a  6  meter outer  rail  will be  (2*3.14*6)/ 4 = 9 meters for  a  6  metre  false  rails... 

Sun said ...

22-Mar-2020

@ITR,

 Noted your comments.I base my calculations on Time per 1/2Kg(Rating).I do consider the body weight of the horse.As you referred to the article of HD Lee my obsevation is Higher the body weight Lower the Tipe per Rating.But if I take the Body Weights of the 4 horses finishing on the board I was finding it to have an uniform Timing and hence I switched over to an Uniform Weight of 450 Kg(451 Kg for RWITC races) so this converted to 1/2 Kgs at the bottom weight of 50/49 Kg gives a round figure of 1000.

I just did the exercise for Iron Age Here I calculated the Final Normalised time with Body Weight of 450 Kg Handicap 55 Kg and PNR 3 False Rails Not Adjusted for.The results are

My 29Th Feb to Pune 7th Sept 5 races

My Sprinters Cup 6953 (Nfr) Placed last

Mu 6754(Fr) 6691(Nfr) 6558(Nfr0 6749(Fr)

 

Pds said ...

22-Mar-2020

Dear Chanakya,

Could you please explain, how you have worked out the hypothetical increase of distance as the effect of false rails of width 1mtr and 6 mtrs where as the radii of all Race Courses is quite different from each other, there fore  the net effect of false rails has to be different for each Race Course. Also how about the adjustment of distaces done with the rodometer? You have confused me, can you please explain as to how it can be worked accurately? Shall be very grateful, your's sincerely.

Chanakya said ...

22-Mar-2020

@ crk,

Yes,  what Nick Mordin  has  said  is true. To  say  it  in  other  words the affect  of  the  weight  on  speed  is  not  a  straight line - increase/decrease  in  weight will  not decrease/increase the  speed  in  the  same  ratio but changing carried  weight  will  follow  a  exponential curve. 5  kgs.  change from  45  kgs.  to 50  kgs.  is  not  same  as  from  55kgs.  to  60kgs...

 

@ sun,

Kolkata monsoon  track  is  different  than  winter and standard timings on  them  may  differ  o  some  extent. Performance at Pune grass  track  is  different  than monsoon  track. We must take  into  consideration  this point  while  assessing a  runner's  performance...  

 

 

 

Indian_turf_record said ...

22-Mar-2020

@ Sun

   Because there is time lag between posting and it appearing on the site, you had already done the work. Your effort is  much appreeciated.

   I have not worked on any mathematical systems for about 30 years and I am not familiar with your system so remarks may well be off the mark. Multitude who won all his five races shows a varation of 241 points (8577 - 8336) while Amorous White who won none shows 224 points (7360 - 7136). It is for you decide whether this variation is significant. This could be called horse variation.

    More important variation is between systen predicted performance and actual performance. This could be an indicator or system efficacy.

    I am more interested in macro aspects. My example of IndianOaks/Indian Derby timings by fillies was meant to highlight that drop in weight does not always lead to increase in speed. 

    While going through records of Multitude and Amorous White, I noticed what appears an anomaly. On 16 Nov (pen 2.3), Multitude clocked 1:25:21. On 26 Dec, carrying same weight, same false rails and pen 1.8, he should have clocked faster time but actually recorded slower time of 1:26:13.. Amorous White ran in same two races, carried same weight and clocked faster timing.

 

Sun said ...

21-Mar-2020

For Amorous White for 1200 Mtrs at PNR of 2 the Normalised Times at 55 KG are

8th Feb 18th Jan 26th Dec 7th Dec 16th Nov

7181 7136 7360 7165 and 7308 respectively

 

Indian_turf_record said ...

21-Mar-2020

    There is a very interesting research paper by H.K. Lee and K.D. Park titled EFFECT OF RATIO BETWEEN CARRIED WEIGHT AND BODY WEIGHT ON FINISHING TIMES IN THOROUGHBREDS. 

    Google can help those interested to locate it.

Sun said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ITR,

A small correction The Normalised Times for the races were at the Weights Cariied but for an Uniform Weight of 55 Kg they are 8336 8563 8386 8577 8404 respectively.

Thanks.

Sun said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ITR,

I did the home work for Multitude 5 runs as below

18th Jan 61.5 Kg   7124  PNR 1.7  NFR 1200

 26th Dec 60 Kg     8613  PNR 1.8   FR   1400

 16 th Nov  60Kg     8521  PNR  2.3  FR   1400

 10 th  Sep  60 Kg    8628  PNR 1.8  NFR  1400

  20 th Aug   60 Kg    7261  PNR 2.4  NFR  1200

Now for these 5 days for a Standard Distance of 1400 Mtrs and PNR of 2 with respective Body Weights as recorded in the Results page of Kolkata Web site the Timings are 8441  8646  8470  8662 and 8488 .

There are 2 races from Monsoon .You can do your intrepretations on the Consistency of the horse/Method of Working/Range

Indian_turf_record said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ Sun

     Very kind of you to even think of taking up the assignment. As I said, my interest is only academic and you should take up the task ONLY if it is of any benefit to you.

     I t seems to me that good horses like Multitude and Amorous White will show  smaller range of variation than lower class horses. This is an impression not backed by any study.

     Thanks once again. 

    

Chanakya said ...

21-Mar-2020

(contd.),

Many  times a  punter  thinks  that false rails(FR) increse  the final  time because  they 'increase'  the distance  run. That  is  not  correct. Because  due to  FR the  runners  have  to  run  on a  'less'  travelled  ground which  is  not  as 'hard'  or  'smooth' as  the  one  adjoining  the  permanent rails the  time taken  by  runners  with  different FR's  will  be  marginally more than  the one taken  along  the  permanent  rails.Of  course,  it  is  true  that 1 metre FR will  increase  the  'travelled'  distance  by  1.5 metres and  a 6 metre FR  will  increase  it  by  9m, equal  to  3  lengths..Therefore, in  my  opinion timings for PNR of  3.9 & 3.8 should  not  differ much- they  may  be  even  identical...

Timing  for  classic  races, e.g., 1000G, 2000G , Derby,  even  sometimes,  for  million  races  will  be   better  than class  I  or  class II races  for  the  same  distance.

In 70's  and  perhaps 80's also  there wqere  no  rating  points or  'numbers'  20,44, or  122 etc  were  assigned  to  runners. They  were  classified in  classes - I,II.III, IV, A & B1or B2(lowest  class).. Dependinding  on  their  performance  they  were  placed  in  a  class. After  the  rating  system was  introduced,  perhaps  in  90's each  runner  is  assigned  a  number depending  on  his  performance. This  number  is  increased  or  decreased by  the  handicapper depending  on  the performance. The  fourth place  runner is  taken  as  standard and  I,II & III placed  runner's  rating  is  increased  whil lower  placed  runner  rating  is  decreased. This  increase/decrease in  rating  depends  on  the  placings - type  of  run  and  number  of  length behid  the  winner as  assessed  by  the track  handicapper...

Every  class has  a  standard  time, which  can be  calculated  by  studying and  tablating  40  or  50  runs  at  that  distance  by that  class on  that  track...        

Cruise_b'lore said ...

21-Mar-2020

Hello folks,

The pace of the race decides the timing with PNR reading playing a significant role.

regds,
Cruise

Sun said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ITR,

 The assignment you have given is really a tough one.

    1.That horse for which we want to look at for variance of 10 runs cannot be like War Hammer Juilette etc.Starting for the first run they are on Improving trend and hence the range can be too wide.

   2.If we take older horse which have reached a plateau then it is possible to attempt The problem here is the horse may have run at different distances and different centres on days with varying PNR and False Rails.As of now I have not come to grip with these variables.Further runs need to be in a reasonable time frame like 2 seasons beyond that the range can be too wide.

  3.May be I can try with a horse like Multitude of Kolkata Centre for a Standard Distance of 1600 Mtrs and PNR of 3 and Handicap of 55 Kg which will give some idea of how consistent its performance is.Even here we need to take only those timings when it finished on board.

  Amorous White is another horse.

Let me try and get back to you.

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

21-Mar-2020

In the context of timings there are two other important factors which have a significant impact on the timing clocked by a horse. One is the path that a horse has to weave as the race unfolds and the second is the effort put in by the rider. The draw naturally has an impact on the path taken by a horse. The first factor namely the effect of the path taken by a horse can be quantified by the number of strides taken by the horse during the race. The second factor namely the effort of the rider can be measured by the number of times the horse was pushed or whipped during the race. These are very fine refinements that are difficult to capture but they have a very significant impact on the outcome. This can be gauged from the fact that while one length is considered to be about 2.4 meters, one stride is considered to be about 6 meters. Over a 1200 meters race therefore a horse would have to take about 200 strides if he is able to keep a straight course. Every additional stride would cost him 6 meters which is equivalent to about 2.5 lengths. The thumb rules for average length or average stride may vary but the essence of the consideration remains unaltered.

Crk said ...

21-Mar-2020

An input from Nick Mordin would be in order :

1. Horses carrying a greater weight will be slowed down more than what less weight will speed a horse up.

2. Once a horse has dropped down in weight to a certain point, then any further reduction in weight will not make it run any faster than what it is capable of.doing.

3. Horses of a higher class generally weigh more than horses of a lower class.

4. Weights affect lower-class horses to a greater extent than those of a higher class.

It is also true that the higher the weight a horse is being set to carry in a handicap race, the more likely it is to win.

Chanakya said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ Sun,

Raw  timings or  timings  published  for  a  race  in racebooks  or by  media in  frint  or  on  forums  or  blogs  are  basic  reference  for  further analysis  of  a race  to  understand  handicapping. The  timings will  be  influenced  by  PNR  values, which  are  appreciably away (plus  or  minus)  from  the good (or  mean) values  which  are  different  for  different  tracks. A change  of  +/-  0.1 or 0.2 will  not  attract  or  affect  of  final raw  time...

As a  proof  or  an  example  please  check the   track  record  times  of  various  distances  at  various  centers  and  note  the PNR  value  of  THAT  DAY.   You  will  find  it  lower - perhaps  much  lower than  the  PNR  value ASSOCIATED  with  the  phrase -  going : good. 

For  example ,  going  'good'  for  Bangalore  is  from  3.7  to  4.0 and  from  4.  t0  4.4 or  4.5  it  is  'fair' . Below 3.7 or  3.6  it  is  'fast'  going. For  other centers  it  is different. With  ALL  OTHER  PARAMETERS  remaining    CONSTANT   the  timings  will change  if  PNR  values  changes  by  +/-  0.2 units...

False  rails :,   always  creates  false  impression.  False  rails  are placed  to  SAVE  the  surface close  to  PERMANET( OR  MAIN)  rails due  to  the  tendency  of   most  of  the  runners  to  run  close  to  it  to  travese SHORTEST   distance during  the  run.  As    an UNIVERSAL  RULE OF  RACING  the  race  club using  false  rails  must  use a  'rodometer' to ENSURE  that  false  rails  which  INCREASE   the  distance ALONG  THE  BENDS. is  used  to  make  the  travelled  distance  EQUAL  to  the  published  distance  of  the  race...

( contd.) 

Sun said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ L Shyam Sunder,

 I still maintain that your post on Ratings etc is not correct.You are reading too much into the Revision of Ratings by Handicapper.There is not much to look at becaause I calculate the Revised Ratings before they are announced and in most of the cases they match.Now coming to your observations

 1.For Unplaced Horses the revisions are not based on any calculation but follows a general downward revision.So Race 38 he just dropped 1 RP

 2.Race 76 Dropped Rating 1 and the increase in Weight as you see it is 61.5 Kg If you look at Acceptances of 15th Dec (Rno 38) you will find the noting Weight Lowered by 1 KG So 61 Kg of Rno 38 is actually 62 Kg  and hence next weight is 62 minus 1/2 Kg for Drop in Rating.

3.Coming to your queries How Jetfire can place by just 1 point drop It is because in Rno 64 of Pune it was a Winner. Next Handicapper did not promote it As its Rating is above 40 and below 47 it can run in either of the Classes.Trainer also thoght that by a drop of 10 Kg it can have better chance in higher class but it did not happen because all higher class animals have also  come from 20-46 and they have potential to beat Jetfire even after pull in weights as all other horses have also dropped by 10 Kg.

On Timing I have no comments Ksmrow has already given the working to show the consistency.I already commented that 0.1 sec for 1200 Mtr is not correct.More accurate figure is 0.07 sec

On Ratings and Weights always remember there is a standard scale 20-46 with Weights of 49 Kg to 62 Kg and if you see the Weight is different from this scale it must be a case of Weight Raised OR Weight Lowered Case.Hope I made the point clear.

Handicapper cannot use much discretion rather should go by generally accepted rules and the condition of the horse and its preparation is what gives a horse the advantage.

 

    

Chase said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ I T R:

In the Oaks , the fillies mentioned all had a realistic chances winning or placing. Juliet and We'll Connected tried and did their best. Armairy and Thailand were outclassed by the above duo.

In the Derby , Well-connected and others opted out trying inview of the competition only Juliet tried but was hampered at the final stages.

The short gap from the oaks to Derby did not give room for any further improvement.

Then there is the Regression To The Mean. A horse , a live being can be peaked for a particular race by preparing it systematically but can not be expected to give its best everytime at shirt notice. It will slip up in performance. The classic horses slip up marginally. The rest slip up enormously.

In winning the Derby War Hammer showed what a champion he was . Running within a week and winning even when he did not exert himself fully. And running an intelligent race strategies by the trainer and jockey .

Juliette and Trouvaille are the next best in the current crop.

And there is one surprise from Bangalore who is biding for his time. Who is that ?. 

Indian_turf_record said ...

21-Mar-2020

@ Sun, @ksmrow

      Thank you for your response. My interest is only academic and I do not want to take much time or space. However, there are some points I would like to state.

      1.  Principle of "less weight, more speed" is empirical hypothesis and not universal law like Newton's Laws of motion. Can it be basis for a system ?

     2.   All systems are too much concerned with micro analysis and overlook macro happenings which can neither be predicted in advance nor quantified. (Juliette being tightened, Armaity being carried out, etc,)

     3.   Horses are not machines and cannot be expected to perform to split second levels all the time. ( @ Sun, I know you keep detailed reecords. After a horse has run say 10 times, is it possible to establish a day to day variation range  in performance ?)

     On lighter noite, my explanation for the four fillies clocking slower timings with lesser weight -- Juliette was in season, Thailand had a headache, .Armaity was angry with her syce and Well Connected had not slept well previous night. 

L. Shyam Sunddar said ...

20-Mar-2020

Hello Friends, 

This is again concerned with Jetfire, please forget your method of calculations for a while and follow the placement of the horse in the angle of the Handicapper. 

In Race 38 Rating of Jetfire was 46 with the weight of 61 kgs and placed 8th. 

Then the Handicapper rated it to 45 in Race 76 and loaded it with 0.5 kg extra with one rating less than the previous one expecting it to win or place, but the horse finished 4th.

But Mr Sun, your point of argument is 0.5kg +/- /Rating. But in this case the Handicapper has increased the weight by 0.5kg with decrease in one rating point, which shows that the In the Handicapper's view it has nothing to do with rating and the weight.

The horse placed 4th in both the races 76 and 84, 1000mts and 1200mts respectively. 

When the horse is placed 4th, the Handicapper wants the horse to win or place in top list. (ofcourse the Handicapper equalizes the handicaps for all the horses to win) but here it's about Jetfire. 

So he gives a rating point of 44 with 61kg weight in Race 118 so that it should win at this rating, but it placed 3 with a timing of 71.92 seconds. Now the Handicapper promoted the horse to class 3 but he rated it with the same 44 points and loaded with 51 kgs. 

Now my question starts here

1: how can a horse place just by reducing the rated points? 

2: when promoted to higher class ie from class 4 to class 3 

The rating remains same at 44 but the weight is 10kg less, ie it is 51 kg in class 3.

Logically after reducing 10 kgs the timing should be 10 x 0. 1 seconds = 1 second less than the previous time at 61 kgs. 

The final time should be 71.92 - 1 second = 70.92. But the final time was 71.86 seconds even after reducing 10kgs which is almost same as in the previous run at 61 kgs. So why the timing is not going down during the time of promotion? No horse gets a better timing during the promotion even after reduction in weight, why it's like that in all the cases? 

3: Everytime the Handicapper decreases a single or double rating points and expects the horse to win though the horse would be distance behind the placed horses. Always the Handicapper does not reduce the weight after reducing the rating of the horse. Then what does the rating points really mean to the Handicapper? 

If we understand the Handicapper's point of view on equalization, we can go for the best results. 

Ksmrow said ...

20-Mar-2020

Namsthe to all,

Many big names asking questions which are more Interesting and difficult to get right answers I think only to keep HT FOLK away from boredom and pass through present difficult phase. we are going to get answers from big guns very soon as @Ruchi did.

@INDIAN_TURF_RECORD, half of the answer you can get from stipe report 

Soon after the start, TROUVAILLE (Nicky Mackay) shifted in thereby tightening TOPNOTCH (Imran Chisty) and SOUTHERN RULER (C.S.Jodha), causing the latter to be checked.  Thereafter, SULTAN SULEIMAN (Neeraj Rawal) shifted in on to WAR HAMMER (Suraj Narredu) thereby starting a chain reaction, due to which TROUVAILLE (Nicky Mackay) TOPNOTCH (Imran Chisty), SOUTHERN RULER (C. S. Jodha), VICTORIOUS SERMON (A. Sandesh) and JULIETTE (Colm O’Donoghue) were tightened for room and had to be checked. Jockeys Nicky Mackay and Neeraj Rawal have been fined Rs.5,000/- each.

Soon after the start, ROYAL CRYSTAL (S.John) shifted in and went across TRAFALGAR (Y.S.Srinath) and tightened the field on his inside, due to which JUSTIFIED (A.Imran Khan), NORTHERN ALLIANCE (Yash Narredu) and  SIR SUPREMO (N. S. Parmar) were inconvenienced and ARMAITY (C. D. Hayes) was tightened and had to be checked and dropped back. Jockey S.John has been fined Rs.5,000/-.

Passing the 2000 metres, TRAFALGAR (Y.S.Srinath) shifted in thereby tightening JUSTIFIED (A.Imran Khan) causing the latter to be checked and drop back, due to which ARMAITY (C.D.Hayes) also had to be checked. Jockey Y.S.Srinath has been fined Rs.3,000/-.

Approaching the 600 metres, NORTHERN ALLIANCE (Yash Narredu) shifted out and carried ARMAITY (C.D.Hayes outwards. I wants to add Thailand poor run may be due to draw 19 jockey unable to keep with Front bunch

Ksmrow said ...

20-Mar-2020

chanakya ji thanks,

@sun, Iam trying to give here my way of workout may or may not helpful,

54.5 is nothing but mean weight[47to62] so for example took 54kg,

The time clocked and what we seen in results has to be standardised to normal course and track conditions for this you have to go through penetrometer reading,false-rails,+or-input we get this is uniform to all the horses ran that day.

1)Penetrometer reading +or- we have to start from any fixed reading,

Bang  3.8=0

Kolkata 1.4=0

You can take any reading as fixed  PMR for season but it cannot be changed for day or month.

2)False rails now has to be calculated according to width and with any-uniformed way considering bend curves,increase or decrease in between points and in some cases abruptly ending at 400mts or so from winning post.

3)After completions of these steps we get temporary stranded time which has to be further checked and compared  with previous performances of two or three runners 0f the day in few races according to our findings add or subtract with our experience and we get standardised time(variation may be+or-0.5to 1.0 mostly)

Pds said ...

20-Mar-2020

The races of Multifaceted on both days of the Invitation Cup week end. Friends, I dont understand why you are missing the point about the odds of Multifaceted on these two days? On first day the odds were 55 paisa only and there is no other reason for the dismal show by this excellent sprinter. This horse is very clever and din't want to exert at such short prize by way of rates, thats all. Please keep this in mind for the future.

Sun said ...

20-Mar-2020

@India_Tyrf_Record,

  You have raised a million dollar question.This is what I meant when I replied to L Shyam Sunder on Timings of Jetfire at 61 Kg and 51 Kg.

   Ruchi has already answered in an indirect way.If we go to another race Invitation Cup here Juilette clocked a better time but at PNR of 3.1 on Mysore Course.Can any one apply correction for Track Variance and show that they are consistent Next to impossible.I observed that for changes in PNR the times get better from say 3.5 to 3.9.So we have to leave it at that.No plausible explanation.

Assuming that in Races like Oaks and Derby the horses are exerted fully perhaps a Computer Model can take into consideration the Timings for first 200 400 600 mtrs etc and predict the finish time.Not possible manually.

Ksmrow has applied some factor for bend position to finish postion to project times.They are perhaps just  empirical values based on his experience.

I request Chanakyaji to throw some light on this.

Sun said ...

20-Mar-2020

@Rksh,

After seeing your post I am reminded of a joke on the Bridhe Table. A person says to his partner

   " Partner take your own time,review the bidding carefully assess your own cards and then decide upon the lead.Now keep that card aside shuffle your cards thoroughly and select a card at random and lead this card which will turn out to be best lead"

 Similarly do all the analysis,select a horse and play any horse other than that.

Just a joke

Ruchi said ...

20-Mar-2020

PACE and the way race is run is the key

The first day in sprinters cup MULTI-FACETED paced with another more speedier IRON AGE and had nothing left in tank at 200 All late rushers , including MAURITANIA whom he had beaten by 9 lengths previous run,finished ahead of MULTI

Next day when MULTIFACETED was allowed to settle and run as per it's pace and not hurried, it trounced the field

This is the KEY why horses previously beaten cone out and run a different race next outing

Indian_turf_record said ...

19-Mar-2020

     Four fillies who ran in Indian Oaks also ran in Indian Derby. In Derby, they all carried 1.5 kg less weight. No false rails on both days. Penetrometer reading on both days 3.9.

     Carrying 1.5 kgs. less, they should have clocked better timing. Actual timings are (Oaks first):-

     Juliette                        2:29:864    -- 2:30:077

     Well Connected         2.30:838    -- 2:31:912

     Thailand                     2:31"216    -- 2:34:302

      Armaity                      2:31:680  --   2:32:831

     All four fillies clocked slower timings and difference was different for each filly.

     I will be grateful if someone can explain why this was so.

     Armaity

Sun said ...

19-Mar-2020

@ksmrow.

Thanks for detailed working showing consistency of Timings of Jetfire runs.I have  few queries on the working.

   1. Synchronised Time  Do you mean the time clocked by the horse carrying 54Kg What is the signuficance of 54 Kg?

   2.You have indicated Combined Correction Time for Penetrometer and False Rails Can they be separated.?

  3. The width of False Rails among the 3 days is  different.Apart from variations at different points.at WInning Post they are 7,6 and 5 Mtrs respectively.Is this ignored OR taken into account in the figures of 1.5 1.6 and 1.6.

4 I feel .for 1Kg difference 0.1 secs is on the higher sise for 1200 mtrs.

5.Penetrometer readings are 3.9 3.8 and 3.9 but corrections are 1.5 1.6 and 1.6 Any reason ?

6.Whip or No Whip  0.5 is constant OR is it only for 1200 Mtrs.

As I am working on Timing and Ratings and it will go a long way in refining my system  if you can provide some inputs on the above

Thanks.

Ruchi said ...

19-Mar-2020

Relying only on timing will not work

If that were so then MULTIFACETED would never have lost the sprinters and with that theory NO HORSE WILL NOW BEAT THE POONAEALA HORSE OVER 1200 MTS

These things don't work,every race is different,depends on how the race is run,pace, position and TRY OR UN TRY and lastly support of day numbers

Chanakya said ...

19-Mar-2020

 @ KSM Row,

Very well explained . good  job. Keep  it  up...

B.v.s.prasad said ...

18-Mar-2020

Dear sharmaji

Most of the punters will purchase books & papers in front of the race course on the race day itself. Only 5% of people like you will work on all angles in racing. But most people will follow only book makers ring strategy, whatever horses betting strongly in the ring and beta blindly looses badly nobody can change this criteria. 

 

Ksmrow said ...

18-Mar-2020

@SUN   @L.Shyam Sundder,

Don't set aside timing as useless for me and many it is yardstick to measure the strength of horse ofcourse one has to calculate synchronised time.

 JETFIRE  RUNS IN RACES 84,118,148 ARE MORE CONSISTENT RUNS THE CONNECTIONS GO FOR PLACE ONLY HAVING SEEN LAST YEAR BRFORE SHEDDING MAIDEN TAG FINISHED SECOND 8TIMES. 

R NO 84 CLASS(20-46)(whips not allowed)finished 4th bend 9th weight 61.5 CT 60 time1m11.8[pentro&false-rails time+1.5]=1m13.3sec

R NO 118 class (20-46)(5yr old&over)finished 3rd bend 9th weight 61 time 1m11.9[pentro&false-rails time +1.6]=1m13.5sec

RNO 148 class(40-66)(5yr&over) finished 3rd bend 4th weight 51 time1m11.8[pentro&false-rails time+1.6sec]=1m13.4sec

Now we calculate what will be the jet fire timing weighted at 54 in class(40-66)

R no 84=1m13.3-0.5(for no whip)-0.5(for bend 9th to4th)+1.0(class>)-0.6(-weight)

I.e  1m12.7sec+0.5+0.3=1m13.5

R no118=1m13.5-0.6(bend 9to3)+1.0(class>)-0.7(weight)

I.e 1m13.2sec+0.5=1m13.7

RNO 148=1m13.4-0.1(bend4to3)+0.3(+weight)

I.e 1m13.6

We arrive to jetfire potential time(strength)

for R NO 84=1m13.5

for R NO 118=1m13.7

for R NO 148=1m13.6

[please read as for 5yrover+.0.5][+0.3jockey AP]

Pds said ...

18-Mar-2020

Dear SCS, I am afraid, I am not satisfied with your explanation about the false rails and I genuinely dont know how the false rails can increase the distance of a race, but your answer has not convinced me. Please try if you can think of a more convincing and appropriate reply I shall appreciate it. Thanks regards.

Sun said ...

18-Mar-2020

@ksmrow,

 First 2 equations I could not understand but on the third I would like you to see at this method.

  From 1200 to 2400  We first pro-rate it then for 2400 it is 2 min 28 secs.

 As we know in 1200 Mtr race the horse can afford run at full steam but if it cannot run at the same speed all through 2400 mtrs  so for arriving at the time for 2400 we need to add extra time after pro-rating it.

 I use a Distance Normalising Factor for extrapolating times.For 1200 mtrs from which we are extrapolating the factor is 5.Extra time to be added is 5 Multiplied by (24- 12) (the change in Distance in 100s of Mtrs) Multiplied by 7.4 in 1/100 sec Units (the Time Per Rating ie 7400/1000) Multiplied by 2400/1200 which is 888 Or 8.88 secs

Here I assumed a body Weight of 450Kg and Handicap of 50 Kg which gives 450*2+50*2 ie 1000 in Units of 1/2 Kg OR A Rating.

So its time is estimated as 2 min 36.88 secs.which may be a typical time for Class B animal.

Mak_95 said ...

18-Mar-2020

Sharma ji,

You have not touched upon  one importatnt aspect, i.e., placement of jockey. For example one of the champion jockey was mounted on Itsamookow , R V Gowli's ward on last race at Kolkata. Also money,  it came on Namakhalal at the later part. These are the two important factors besides points mentioned by you. Winner picking at class 4 & 5, 3 y old maiden races are hazordous. 

Ajoy Shah said ...

18-Mar-2020

Anyways the Club's official Handicapper has done all the thinking and given the handicaps of a race taking into account most of the parameters except FR's an P readings.

Hp++ said ...

18-Mar-2020

HATS OFF Rksh

Yu hv hit the nail on the centre of the head..All this race study is BSHT..

Rksh said ...

17-Mar-2020

Nicely put up msg...congrats sir...but Am afraid it's useful theoretically but not in Practicals..

Full handicapping including False rails, penetrometer reading, new distance adjustment, swimming track , weight handicapping.....all to be correctly done , 1 day gap between the races is not sufficient for any one....

Even if thoroughly studied and attend race with full home work....SURPRISE BUDDY....THE UNICORN beats MYRTLEWOOD by 12.5 Lengths.....

If we r saying the sentence , Nothing is certain in this sport, there is no option that Handicapping wins us money......Anyway The Club guys leave 1 RACE FOR PUNTERS TO WIN and come back tomorrow ....One doesn't need Thorough handicapping for that race, Just FOLLOWING ODDS IS ENOUGH...Even in that one race ,They withdraw one or more Horses to reduce pay OUTS to minimum...

Understand this World....Not handicapping...

Itsmyview 

 

Shantha Mysore said ...

17-Mar-2020

Sharma jhi you forgotten to tell about entries most of the horse get life throws promotion entry.. 

 

Rajaraman said ...

17-Mar-2020

@ Respected Sharma jee nothing will  work  in Horse  Racing  that's  my Experience  no harms  

S C Sharma said ...

17-Mar-2020

We study, analyse and consider various parameters and aspects of racing  with a hope to get best results. I listed and highlighted some areas in my  post which  may effect the running of horses which are not considered  normally. As mentioned by me earlier also  I do admit that everyone’s approach, view point and study angel  is different and if they are getting satisfying results in their own methodology  it is really very good. Number of questions and queries also raised after my post and if I submit a detailed reply it will become another post. In brief I wish to thank one and all whether they appreciated or criticised because they gone through my post seriously and expressed their views with openness and fairness. 

As far as false rails are concerned — False rails are placed parallel to the permanent rails ( railing side area of main race track ) to reduce the width of race track and to protect railing side area and normally FR are  laid before big races are scheduled. It do effect the timing compare with races held in no false rails. In big field it results in rough and unclear passage for horses likes to run from inside, mid-bunch or from the rear and look to come from railing side. Number of times this may result  a danger of clipping injuries and chances of stumbling too. To avoid this many times jockeys forced to check or shift their mounts and prefer to run from outside which results in some increase in distance for them as they covers more distance and they travel in the unused area  of the track . Alongwith many parameters of study  FR is also a parameter for those who wish to study in depth and minutely with a hope to get best and accurate results  and if they do so and if such things give them satisfying results, I see nothing wrong . It is good to cover maximum untouched areas to clear doubts about possible minus points before finalisation and selection of bets. This will also result in avoid of regret or blame after the races. Thanks. 

Sun said ...

17-Mar-2020

@ L Shyam Sunder

By raising the first query you have exposed your lack of understanding of Ratings.Though I have not verified the record book the 2 races must be from 2 classes The first one 40-66 Class and secomd one 20-46 Class .At the rating of 44 in 40-66 class it will be assigned 49 Kg (for 4 rating) plus 2 Kg for 4 Rating points above 40.For 20-46 class you can work out.

Second query To understand this just take any horse and start plotting the Times Clocked at different weights.They   very rarely show consistency with the empirical value of 1 sec for 5 Kg.This is the reason why Timing Analysis is not good method to predict Winners.

R.ramesh said ...

17-Mar-2020

HT needs these type of people who really contribute. This is platform to discuss about winners and Pretenders. One man thinks he is the God here and giving useless lectures.

Sharma sir, can you write about Terms races ? some horses straight away runs in Maiden and then runs in Terms races. Eventhough a good handicap horses which has cleared 80 and above finds it difficult to match strides with Terms horses. Why sir ?

 

Pds said ...

17-Mar-2020

Dear SCS, I have a doubt and I have not been able to get it clarified. Shall be grateful if you can throw some light. Plese let me know how the false rails can increase or decrese the distance of a race? Thanks

Rishu said ...

17-Mar-2020

Thanks Sc sharma sir....for ur valuable post....Sir can u suggest any good book for handicapping indian horse racing.Any other experts who know it.

Pds said ...

17-Mar-2020

SCS, Quite detailed writeup, I am sure it can help lots of Horse Racing lovers/ followers. However, I must suggest all readers that these are the guide lines to be able to make some headway in the field of Horse Racing. They should read this write up three, four times and ponder and digest these points, under stand these requirments and try to learn the actual aspects mentioned there in. I would also like to bring out that it is very essential and very difficult to learn these and implement these on ground in case they really want to succeed in Horse Racing. Good Luck

Saidas Kher said ...

17-Mar-2020

Totally agree with you sir; a good punter is one who looks at handicap; and class... But do you believe now a days racing is done on it. For example in Kolkata races are done mainly on give and take relations. Here nor handy matters nor class it matters is that who needs money. It's like commute you take now n we take next. Do you believe Mysore conducted fair invitation event. The horses which won do they really deserve to win. The day horse racing starts on handicap n class be sure punters will also get something. But unfortunately racing in India is settled between owners n trainers only

L. Shyam Sunddar said ...

17-Mar-2020

Hello Sharma ji, 

R no 118, R no 148 proves the class vs weight. (Mumbai Jet fire).

I am sure that rating of a horse is not just in points as you said, its something beyond it and a confusing issue. In Race number 148 (Mumbai), Jetfire rating is 44 and the weight is 51 kg, same horse in Race number (118) has a weight of 61 kg at 44 rating and both the cases have almost the same timing, same rating and 10 kg difference in weight . How will you justify this issue with the weight vs class vs speed vs weight?

And

Refer to Pune Race no 155 and 122 Shae (horse name) 

At rating 36  1-41.12 seconds/56.5kgs (R 122) 

At rating 35  1-40.07 Seconds/57kgs (R 155)

Why the difference of 1.05 seconds with 1/2 kg difference and this is equal to 6.5 lengths. This doesn't justify the rating vs weight and the timing. 

Date ref 6/10/2019, 26/10/2019.

 

Besafe said ...

17-Mar-2020

Can anyone please let me know when this Handicapping  was origined.what happens if all the horses running have equal weight or handicapping system.

Can we expect genuine racing 

S C Sharma said ...

17-Mar-2020

Lot more debated on Vulcan winning C N Wadia Gold Cup and Capriska loosing.  I touched a point in my post that present form of the horse matters most  and accordingly many times results are not to our liking .  Secondly both the horses were not youngsters they were 7 yr and 6 yr olds and form of any horse can improve or deteriote after a certain age.  Both horses were running over mile and half that too with 6 kgs weight difference and on paper present form of Vulcan was ahead of Capriska .  If you go through all these points minutely you will get the answer.  When I say certainties do not exists in racing means even a highest rated horse or best horse  can be beaten on a particular day if he looses the form and fitness  or not racing fit on that particular day just as the case was of Sir Cecil and many times horses entered in wrong distances and where they are not placed well.  Winners and losers teaches us lot of lessons  to improve and further focus better  on our  review and analysis and rectify the mistakes if noticed any. Racing is not about only blame game.  You have to come out successfully from all these complexities and uncertainties by applying your best possible intelligence  and when you start blaming it makes your task much  tougher.   Individually I have nothing to say in favour or against anyone as everyone's approach and view point  to the problem is different but ultimately success counts and gives immense satisfaction. Take good care and stay healthy.  God bless you all .

Ksmrow said ...

16-Mar-2020

S C SHARMA JI, 

 excellent  write up of sharing your workout and experience of racing with HT readers,now coming to the point up to 5kg equals to 1sec & 5lenths up to 1600mts each additional 800mts add 0.5sec& 2.5 lengths. what I understand is like this

5kg= 1sec = 5lengths  up to1600mts

5kg= 1.5sec= 7. 5lengths from 1600 to 2400mts

5kg= 2sec = 10lengths from 2400 to 3200mts

suppose A beat B at level weights 5ls in 1600mts race with timing of 1m 39sec

now both are running in 2400 mts race A carrying 5kg more let us calculate,

A=1m39.0+1.5=1.40.5+0.52(13sec for 200mts)=2m32.5sec

B=1m39.0+1sec=1.40+0.52=2m32sec 

B beats A by 2.5 Lengths.

one thing not able to get Answer  all these years of racing in Mumbai any class B winner can clock 1m14sec  for 1200mts race if we calculate for 2400mts 2m 28sec derby winning record time even we add 1.5sec still it can be 2m29.5sec?

 

 

Rethvik said ...

16-Mar-2020

@SC Sharna Sir 

What a good and great writing of you, I am A big follower of you. An excellent explaination of handicaps ,distances, allowances, weight measurements and conclusion. Pls don't mind all rubbish talking about you. Continue your postings with respect to all punters

L. Shyam Sunddar said ...

16-Mar-2020

Class rating points vs weight vs speed is still not convinced. 

I am sure that rating of a horse is not just in points as you said, its something beyond it and a confusing issue. In Race number 148 (Mumbai), Jetfire rating is 44 and the weight is 51 kg, same horse in Race number (118) has a weight of 61 kg at 44 rating and both the cases have almost the same timing, same rating and 10 kg difference in weight . How will you justify this issue with the weight vs class vs speed vs weight? 

Gc Raj said ...

16-Mar-2020

Dear Sharmaaji

Thanks for sharing your knowledge.very useful one.

Narendra Pillala said ...

16-Mar-2020

What is the best bet strategy in horse racing is only win'are win and place please clarify me.

Rajaraman said ...

16-Mar-2020

@ Respected Sharma Je you  have  missed  30 to 45 just to say I agree  with you who ever follow record  , everybody is watching  or going through  records if damn you say only Blood line  or  Cass just one example Vulcan  how its loose  to Caprisca only authorities  as per  record it cannot be beaten I am  a very small fry  I  do know racing Admissions Reserved ,the  last one posting by your self Delhi  races canceled  what a information from the great tipster  iam saddened may your good works go to  rest RIP Thank you  Gentlemen you are also there 

Naveen said ...

16-Mar-2020

Thanks Sc sharma sir for very useful information.... which horse bloodline is good according to distance wise?

Any other experts if someone has any other useful information....so share with us.Thanks.

Sun said ...

16-Mar-2020

@Sharmaji

 You have covered very nicely all relevant points.I have the following points to make.

  1. Ratings determine the Handicap Or Weight to be carried in a Handicap Race and Weights&Ratings are not 2 entities.

   2. You could have touched upon the point of "A Winner being penalised by 5 or 6 Kg " before the Handicapper revises its Rating.Normally happens when a winning horse runs on two consecutive races.

  3. The assumed Ratings of Maidens is correct but there can be  small variations across clubs.The point I want to learn from you is How the First Rating is alloted to a horse after 2 to 3 runs.Is there any method?

  4. The Grade of a race for 3 year olds like say Breeders Million has any significance.Even Terms Races for 4 tear olds & upwards also have Grade mentioned.Does it signify any thing.

@Dancing Dynamite You have a very valid point that why the highest rated horse does not Win the Terms Race always.Yes if such races are run at the same weight for all horses except for Gender Allowance.

Ratings serve the purpose of grouping horses on a Common Scale instead of bothering about which horse bet which horse at what weight and what was separating distance between them and again compare withe another horse which has no common horse to take as reference.

By asking this question you raised a very valid point if Horse A which is a Maiden or with few runs Clocked Timing equal to Claas 1 Timing carrying say 60 Kg  can it by the strengeth of this performance Win a Class 1 race.Our experience is a Big NO.If you can find a satisfacory answer to this question you can find the answer to your other question.

The point you raised is answered in a negative way when Unrated horse Wins first season Classics  Races like Colta Trial Stakes etc Sometimes even Derby

Ramanujan said ...

16-Mar-2020
@Sharmaji

Your crisp writeup, intended for the benefit of freshers and the less-experienced, nut shelling the principles and practice in general of racing art and science, speaks volumes of your vast knowledge, expertise and a bit of presumably a fair amount of success you must have had to your credit out of the game is not far to seek. Your earlier posts here and there inter alia offering congratulations to the professionals incidentally also establishes your credentials as to the rapport and association in the circuit. It is indeed admirable that you have thought it fit to provide the basics and also unravel the nuances for the benefit of needy buddies. Having said that I do carry  a piece of cautionary advice nay appeal.  The dominating pick from your side, though very cautiously made in a moderated tone  as announced in this forum is loud and clear not necessarily confined to the punters but finds access to ‘others’ as well. The result is anybody’s guess between the lip and the cup. Even a valid and well-intended pick goes awry due to vested mechanizations not even sparing the author. Your unassailable credentials draw more than ordinary attention. Earlier one Mad Max had a free run with his marvelous picks for a brief while to retreat inexplicably.

Pity while highlighting this I don’t have viable solutions on hand to offer. Empowering the punter community with well-founded knowledge instead of freebies in the form of tips, authenticity notwithstanding seems to be the answer for now. Shall feel blessed if taken in right spirit.

Tks and rgds

Ramanujan

Surajit said ...

16-Mar-2020

Very valuable discussion you did. Thanks a lot.

Dancing Dynamite said ...

16-Mar-2020

Handicapping of horses is the most silly thing.  Why a winning horse be penalized, I don’t understand.  Never in any sport, handicapping is done.  Take example of cricket,  if India beats Bangladesh, will India play in the next match with a handicap of one player or will Bangladesh start with a score of 50/0?? 

And if punters think that a horse would beat the same set again and again, if not handicapped, then it’s a myth.  Because if that been the case, the terms race would always be won by highest rated horse…..

N.balraj said ...

16-Mar-2020

Very useful write-up.