Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

One App To Fix The Punting Itch?

By Turf News | 30-May-2020

Horse racing in India is in a state of disarray, and the future does not seem much too promising either. In fact, some experts in the field conveyed that this could well be the end. The only solution, they say, is legalising online betting and creating an inttegrated application.

With stringent social-distancing SOPs in place, owing to Covid-19, footfall at venues across the country is set to come down further. A large chunk of revenue generated by turf clubs is dependent on the number of punters entering these venues. Since that isn’t an option, clubs are stretching themselves thin to find answers.

“I am not sure we’ll be able to get the government to reduce the tax, but what we can do is fight to legalise online betting,” explained Zeyn Mirza, the racing manager for Kunigal Stud Farm and a respected voice in the fraternity.

“An online betting application linked to the clubs’ totalizator is the only way forward. If this is combined into a national Tote with combined betting collections from all Turf Clubs across the country, punters could make bigger profits, as the volume would be greater.”

Mirza explained further: “For example, should someone bet 10 rupees at a 10:1, in the current system they’ll make 100 rupees and then lose 30 rupees of that to the GST. But if you make a 1000 rupees for the same 10 rupees invested and then you lose 300 rupees, it won’t hurt as much because you would have made 700 rupees on a 10-rupee bet. It’s simple. So if they have a collective tote, people stand to make more money.”

Horse racing in India has been subject to scrutiny for the duration of its existence in India. But once the Supreme Court announced in 1996 it to be a ‘game of skill’ and not ‘of chance’, the sport was given a new lease of life, or so the administrators believed at the time.

“We haven’t been able to shake off the sin sport tag,” said Vivek Jain, the former chairman of the Royal Western India Turf Club in Mumbai. “That’s one of the reasons it’s this diffucult to reason with the people in power. Most officials think racing is a nuisance."

Clubs in an individual capacity have spoken about a future with online betting at the forefront for a couple of years now, but by their own admission, they didn’t pursue the project with the seriousness since they were able to ‘generate income withou substantial changes to their module." I presented them (Turf Authority of India) with an application two years ago," fumes Mirza. The didn't take it up".

Administrators across all clubs have now come to the realisation that they cannot possibly function without a collective application.

“We cannot do without online betting,” says Dr N Nithyanand Rao, the chairman of the Mysore Race Club. “If the government doesn’t approve this, I’m not sure what we can do. Also, with OBC’s (Online Betting Counters), it completely eliminates illegal betting. All punters will be given cards and numbers and they’ll be punting through that and they can keep a tab on their money.”

Providing an explanation as to why the TAI didn’t push for online betting earlier, Nithyanand, who was on its board, said: “Punters are usually of a lower socio-economic status and it’s tough for them to work in a digitised space, but now everyone has a phone and that makes the app very useful.”

That said, Nithyanand did reveal that the TAI is working on an online betting application in association with a tech firm, and are close to applying finishing touches. The application will be run across centres which have acquired permission from their respective state governments once the centre passes the proposal.

“I don’t see why the government wouldn’t want to help legalise online betting on horse racing as it has been the only legalised form of gambling in India since independence and it is well regulated,” said Suraj Narredu, one of India’s greatest jockeys. “Fantasy gaming sites have used the 1996 Judgement to their favour and they’re raking in millions.”

“For horse racing to continue, all clubs need to work together and fix this problem. I am worried for our future,” he added.

Courtesy deccanherald.com

Post Your reply

19 Replies

Iimblue said ...

03-Jun-2020

There has to be  something called "Punter 's Curse". Just watch.... It is going the burn away these unscrupulous bookies,  racing officials,  trainers, owners and jockies!. It is early days yet!! ... You ain't seen anything  !!!

Raghavan said ...

03-Jun-2020

Ajay Shah,

Boycott the betting en masse?  That is outright impossible.

As long as there is no racing in this country, punters are safe.  But, once the races resumed, there will be flood of betting and it is only the bookies who will be laughing all the way to the bank.

The more reasonable request/advice that you can give to punters is to ask them bet low.  The bookies, particularly from Bangalore are so arrogant that they do not take bets less than 1100/- (some bookies are insisting 2200/- minimum) even if the concerned punter is ready to pay full tax.

That apart, the punters should take a royal oath not to back horses that are quoted at cramped odds.  I still can not forget the hapless punter who backed 50k on Searjent at Arms at 30ps in Mysore derby race.  Of course, there may be more than dozen punters who backed heavily on that horse.

The horse finished 2nd to Ice glacier.There were only 5 horses in that race, of which 3 were dummy pieces.

Right from the day the betting started, it is only the punter's money that is in circulation.  

 

Ajoy Shah said ...

02-Jun-2020

This is the best time for punters to collectively boycott races i.e whenever it starts,with or without spectators. Let the club's try and run even a single day without any bets on any horses. They will now understand the value of the punter. It is we who are helping them earn and not the other way round. This the best time for our grievances to be heard.so let us take it further.

Ayyarnet said ...

02-Jun-2020

MSG Sir:

I do not think our punters will have so much patience to process all requirements to enter the Race Course  just to lose their money !!!They can comfortably betwith other mode available. 

Regards

Ayyarnet

 

Ankush said ...

02-Jun-2020

Horse racing isn;t about gambeling. Its aout breeding, it will begin soon,dont you worry :)

Unknown said ...

01-Jun-2020

Nobody is going to pay 28% GST even if there is online betting. It's like you're losing almost 1/3 of money on each bet on tax alone. Forget about people betting online unless the GST is brought to 10%. Already majority of the punters are losers and losing almost 1/3 on taxes does not give them a chance to survive. Even if online betting is legalized the GST will see the end of racing. Racing can only survive if the GST is re-evaluated. When companies like Dream11, etc are legalized online and allowed to operate where there is no skill, how is racing not allowed when it actually requires skill? This is India, this is the our government, the ignorance and corruption goes to extreme levels. 

Hp++ said ...

01-Jun-2020

who wudn't go for chinese goods at qtr cost;;;likewise who won't love the luxury of a 10% bet..

Soo simple

Msg said ...

31-May-2020

To resume horse  racing, both race clubs and punters need to cooperate for smooth functioning.  I give my points below.

1. Race club can have more no. of  tote counters and and bookie counters.

2. Club can allow more no. Of ticket issuing counters outside the club also so that crowding can be avoided.

3. Combined tote of all clubs can be arranged so that volume will be more and revenue will enhance for both the clubs, Govt and for punters also.

4. Entrance tickets .ca be issued two hours before race time instead of 1 hour. Season tickets such us advance tokets.ca be issued for about 30 days, so that punters need not stand in queue daily. 

5. Each race should have a gap of 45 to 50 minutes instead of 30 min. Also one centre racing Dr day. If need be clubs can have morning and evening.. Also only 5 to max 6 races per day.

6.Before conducting racing, race clubs should be ready by cleaning the places. More seating arrangements will definitely avoid crowding. Otherwise punters will be roaming. Canteen and tea stalls should be arranged in a way social distancing is followed. 

7. For the first time all punters should tested for covid19, for which all arrangements should be done before the  1st day of racing.

Punters should follow various instructions.

Punters should not stand in any counters for a long time. They should avail the vacant counters.  

People in the race course should not spit smoke or drink.  Strict order will be forced. Mainly tearing and throwing tickets bottles papers cups should be avoided. People should not fight  each other in the course. People should have mask and follow social distancing. People should not handshake.

Overall, race clubs should furnish all facilities to the punters and others first.

If GST is reduced club centres will be happy. Online betting and combined tote  betting can be reviewed now itself.

 

 

Raghavan said ...

31-May-2020

Epsom ace, the race correspondent of Indiarace writes about RCTC:

"Neither the institution, nor the owners have the financial ability to sustain paying the heavy cost of maintenance"!

He also says, the illegal bookmakers had a field day because of the draconian GST (28%).

Online betting if introduced will be clean and transparent!

Everything agreed.  But who will pay 33% tax and bet.  They will search the illegal bookmakers.  In fact the licensed bookmakers are the greatest cheats in the race club who take bet at 10%.  

No body will care if racing is stopped.  As on date there are only 6 states that conduct racing.  No racing in remaining states.  Even in those 6 states there was no racing for the past 80 days.  Sky has not fallen!

C. R. Dass said ...

31-May-2020

It's online betting or offline betting if the GST 28 percentage the betting collection going to decrease further more. Only solution betting tax will be reduced to be minimum. If it's is not done there is no future for Indian racing 

Iimblue said ...

31-May-2020

Those who are looking for early resumption of racing,  with online betting are only daydreaming ! .No such thing is going to happen in a hurry.!! 

The Clubs best bet would have been to ask permission to start racing without spectators ! .The Clubs are not capable of running such a show,  purely for financial reasons.!!  All these years the Clubs treated punters like ' dirt ' and took them forgranted. For the first time the Clubs have realised that they too need the punters. But probably it is too late. 

The Government that down not allow more than 50 people for marriage function,  is most unlikely to allow racing with even a minimum attendance. Afterall,  who wants to take risk?  I foresee the small owners disappearing and small time trainers surrendering the licence ! The Clubs and breeders will be left holding the baby,  but then they too have their own constraints. Unfortunately,  they cannot even demand any package from the Government !

Ayyarnet said ...

31-May-2020

Friends:

For on line betting in addition to GST - mandatory KYC  Pancard Aadhar card Registration procedure ill be a problem for many.

Since all your transactions will berecorded your Banker will have a second thought when yiu ask for a credit next time with your identity as a Race goer. These are te main practical problem embedded with on line booking.

Regards

Ayyarnet

Dancing Dynamite said ...

31-May-2020

i get a hearty laugh when person thinks that online betting will eliminate bookies.  online betting is basically tote betting sitting at home.  How will it evade bookies, who give better rates, is question, which no one has the answer.

Sai said ...

31-May-2020

Online betting will be successful because it's so simple if a punter 10? per second inall over India there are more than  1lakh punter s as such government will be in profit.

Mahesh Jetta said ...

31-May-2020

Sir as mr Mirrza and mr nityanand rao said online betting is the only solution....if there is only one national tote then absolutely it helps the punters as well as turf clubs....moreover illigal betting is surely going to end if this online betting gets into action......

Sureshot said ...

31-May-2020

Racing will never come to end.

Racing industry is esablishment since centuries.

Any comments/air against it,is imaginary doubt.

Horses will run,bookies will be back,punters will cheer at jockeys will their sporting colours sooner or later.

 

Loyal Races Is Our Right said ...

31-May-2020

2 min. silence for those who thinks club now got proper business model

No way,with high gst impossible

 club just show off for online betting,back the door they make deal with bookies,& taking cuts for run the horses.(licensed bookies could convince easily,even many directly offer them)..

I dont think its wrong cos,at any normal day bookies used to give stall fees..

But the problem is club could loyal will bookies ,providing inside information (gold),

False competitiveness,gambling,&few races for only punters

I advised to punters its bookies efforts to start racing so be careful for betting race,a races who attract more punters should avoidable,atleat check pervious races results & then bet on fav..or flucke

Hp++ said ...

31-May-2020

Its easy to get a blue whale thru the eye of a needle,but very tuff to convice the Govt on online betting

So just stop dreaming..

Gc Raj said ...

30-May-2020

Dear Friends Forget about online betting in India.It will not be successful/practical. As per the guidelines issued by the central government today in 3rd stage,they will give permission for all political gathering,large-scale marriages in August/september.so at that time race clubs also will get permission and they will say maintain social distance , but see what happened with BMTC buses.no social distance.like that race clubs also will function.

Whom ever wants to take the risk of getting corona can visit the racecourse