Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

“ Who Is Better Than Whom? “ - Part -ii

By S C Sharma | 31-Jul-2020

Everyone's experiences and views are different on horse racing related matters and every individual is better judge of his or her own activities, deeds and actions. I owe my thanks to all those who are sharing their experiences on HT forum with me openly and manytimes covering my  leftover or untouched areas of posts to make it more useful and meaningful  . The undeniable  fact is no one is perfect and is perfectly good or completely bad. Even the most successful ones in the business have areas of their strength and weaknesses. My focus is mainly on those areas which are generally   weak -- to identify and find a remedy for them . Winning really matters to everyone  but after winning to protect and ensure the best use of winning is lot more precious for me.

Success cannot be a walkover and fortunes cannot be made overnight. I have seen many punters and owners and trainers  who intended to become multimillionaire overnight but the end result was their unexpected early exit from the racing field . Many even became defaulters, insolvents and many retired hurt due to their own actions and deeds of not managing money and emotions properly. Value of investment on time and money always matters most and everyone needs to pay attention to this. . Overconfidence that races can't be beaten disallows you to make a determined effort to learn more, so I believe -- patience is the key of success. Success will never lower its standards to accommodate you but you have to raise your standard to achieve success. I mean to say God provides food to every bird but not into their nest. The hunger and desire to learn more, keep opens the door for success . My puzzle starts with these few areas which needs extra focus to understand  "Who is better than Whom  ? If this is your weak area - than  rectify it. And if this is your strength than congrats and compliments to you and wish you good luck. 

BLOODLINE:  The price of unrated youngsters are based on their Pedigree / Bloodline. Pedigree reveals past performances of Sire, Dam and maternal grand sire. At the time of purchase of horses owners and trainers pay more attention to this area. In actual race too, this area matters most. First time starters are judged by their bloodlines only  and than by their preparatory workouts. The bloodline provides the key to judge the staying potential of a throughbred. We often refer the name of stud farms just to ascertain the successful bloodline  and records. Few popular and successful stud farms  of our country are -- Poonawalla, Usha/Mehra, Manjri, Kunigal, Nanoli,  Deshmesh and Hargovind, Hazare etc etc., 

PAST RUNS AND RECORD: Horses are judged as per their past runs and records and as per the company in which they ran and also the quality of opposition they face. Understanding of different types of races is must to ascertain whether a horse is advantageously placed or not.  

SCIENTIFIC SYSTEM: Speed  handicapping or speed rating or win marks percentage theory are such systems. These systems /  method translate  previous performance of a horse into a numerical rating in consideration with various parameters like - weight, distance and time  plus bloodline, trainer, jockey etc etc., to arrive at best possible conclusion. 

SPEED AND STAMINA:  Preference to speed in short distance races and stamina in middle and long distance races is a feasible working formula. When a horse changes the distance from short to middle or long or from middle or long to short, than  keep the variations of distance  in mind . Major or wider change in distances  results in negative. For this, refer preparation in workouts ,  whether a horse is prepared as per the distance of the race or not. 

HANDICAPPING AND TIMING:  Allocation of weight is known as handicap. After each run horses are allotted fresh rating either increased one or decreased one,  based upon their performance and based upon handicappers assessment . Fresh and new   rating denotes horse's  class and weight and accordingly horses participates in various distance races.  The increase and decrease in weight effects the slow or fast timing of a race. Some times going also effects the timings.  Handicapping is to ensure the equal chance of winning of all participating horses. . Horses participate and  runs as per the eligibility criteria mentioned in race club prospectus. In terms races  and in big or graded races they run as per age, sex, stake money earning or as per criteria mentioned in prospectus.

CLASS AND COMPANY: Class and company are two important factors . Here the quality of opponents is important to assess the relative ability of horses. Horses are prepared for optimum as per the class and opponents they are likely to face. Running line and finish positions are obviously the crucial part and accordingly the next entry , class and distance is determined. 

TRACK: This is a simple exercise to keep the horses fit. If a horse is not seen on work regularly means he is not fit or suffering from some ailment or  problems. Work is must for horses and reveals the fitness and readiness of a horse for competition.  Exercises  on trade -mill or in swimming also a part of fitness and workouts. 

TRAINER'S ROLE : The breaking and training of horses are carried by trainers. Judging the potential, speed and stamina and keep the horse fit for the competition is trainers responsibility. Sometimes trainers purposely enters horses over inappropriate distances to prepare them for some future targets. They enter long distance horses over short distance and short distance horses over long  distances . Horses runs differently over different distances. Here your knowledge of handicapping and judging them on various  parameters matters most. You have to judge the correct / suitable distance of a horse to get best result. 

JOCKEY:  Jockeys not only gives exercises but also gives feedback of strength and weaknesses of a horse. They maintain their weight and know the skills of pace judgements and how to extract the best from a horse. Usually they follow instructions of owner and trainers in this regard. Another important point is to be noted is if a horse has been ridden in previous races by an incompetent or inferior jockey and then gets the services of a top jockey than it deserves special consideration. Whenever a horse finishes second or third or close to winning horse  with incompetent rider and when races in next outing with a superior jockey that means he is trying to win and likely to deliver as the  last performance is treated as half hearted effort.  

OWNERS LIKE : Horse owners always likes big stakes and big purses attracts them to enter the horses for the competition and even if they get a placing they are content and happy. 

APPEARANCES AND PADDOCK LOOKS: The dullness or shining of coat / skin of the horse is the indication of form and readiness of performance. Wetting or sweating, tossing up of head ups and down or side by side, stamping of feet, pinning of ears back , rearing or not allowing the jockey to sit or furious or unruly behaviour rated as negative points. Too much increase or decrease in body weight of the horse is also not considered as good. 

PATIENCE: One secret of successful betting is extreme patience and betting selectively and intelligently. One of my old colleague, who is no more now, use to bet few bets a week. He use to sit immobile, race after race and day after day, waiting for the occasional spot  that offers a golden opportunity. Whether he wins or loses, his equanimity is unaffected. He return to his seat to wait, wait, wait for the next solid situation. Overall he was very successful because of his extreme patience. . 

Apart from the above you have to read carefully the race day reports  and incidents and veterinary reports, change of equipment details and shoeing  and pay attention towards class whether a horse is running in lower or higher class,  because all these factors also effects the running of the horse. 
 There may be more such  points and areas which I have not touched due to time and space limitations. I never believe in preaching . I believe everyone is having sound and good knowledge but we share our knowledge and experience. Why ? sometimes some new may emerge and if it benefits to everyone than nothing wrong in putting these things straight forward. . I understand this may be repitation to many but this is with good intentions and to discover the best, if still anything  remained hidden. When we go for  better and opt for the  best than only we can survive and sustain and enjoy in a competition and emerge as successful ones. Our research, study and analysis, skills and intelligence only leads us to find  "Who is better than Whom "  and once we know the formula than the puzzle is solved. As mentioned by my colleagues,  I too believe in merit. Merit can be defeated or cheated sometimes but not all the times. I never predetermined myself that the game is unfair, I believe in fairness and my research and study is based on these parameters only that the results of the races are true.  I analyse races after they had been run and many times it helps me for good. By and large my theory gives  me good results and if some exceptions are there I ignore them and they are negligible for me. 

I am thankful to God. He gave me the capacity to enjoy and I wish you all to have it. God bless you all.

Post Your reply

22 Replies

Cruise_b'lore said ...

03-Aug-2020

Hello JP,

Nelson Reuben rode Bold Soveriegn when it ran 2nd to Track Lightning. That's what you have quoted as the horse being ridden by Nelson Reuben.

regds,
Cruise

P.S. All are recalling from their memories except for ITR who has the racng records 1970 onwards. It is understood of that ( quoting from memory ).

Jp said ...

02-Aug-2020

Thanks ITR and Cruise. I am correct regarding Track Lightning and Currento running together. Maybe the Hyderabad reference was a memory error due to age. I also do not have any record. Purely from memory.

Aravind said ...

02-Aug-2020

Mr.Cruise I never said boring or not interested. Just requested Sharmaji to pour more on other various subjects concerning in the race instead of the article written which in many time shared in this Forum. Now Sharmaji himself started new thread on jockey Karl Umriger.

Cruise_b'lore said ...

02-Aug-2020

Hello folks,

Trainer Shabir Khan was a jockey before being a trainer. He struck gold early as a trainer by winning The Fillies Trial Stakes with Corrente De Ouro and his ward Bold Sovereign ran 2nd to Track Lightning in The Colts Trial Stakes.
Mind you, this was when Byramji was considered unstoppable.

He was very talented but his addiction to intoxicating liquids proved to be his downfall. I still remember his ring as the only one with the master missing during the late-afternoon/early-evening roll of horses.
For those unaware, horses would be brought to their designated rings during the mentioned time every day, barring Sundays, for inspection by their concerned masters. I recall having asked about that and they would invariably reply that this habit was common of his.

Word got around and he soon lost the entire string of horses owned by AJ Fernandes.

Thereafter, he hit the bottle more vigorously and that led to health complications resulting in death soon. Another talent lost out due to addiction. He died in the arms of trainer Md Khan, present trainer at Bangalore. Md Khan did try his best to counsel him but Shabir chose not to take heed.
That is the sad tale of Shabir Khan.

May his soul rest in peace!

regds,
Cruise

Cruise_b'lore said ...

02-Aug-2020

Hello JP,

Now that you have been the correct facts about Corrente De Ouro, thanks to ITR, try to recall of the 'correct' horse.

regds,
Cruise

Smart-still-poor-punter said ...

02-Aug-2020

@ Arvind

     You have every right to pass your remarks on other's posts and that is the basis on which HT is functioning. Please don't be worried about the one-sided observations of "bruised" Cruises, and you must have the ability and guts to point out mistakes of others, including me. 

     I have been long since saying that S C Sharma has been grinding the same material, passed on by others in the past in these same columns, just in an attempt to hog the limelight so that he can look forward to carry them his way when real-time racing starts he turns into a tipster.

     People like Cruise seem to be having a godown full of old stocks from which they keep pulling out records and healing their innumerable wounds. Neither they have the spine to come out with their loss-profit tally nor the guts to call it quits. The ongoing attempts by these people, therefore, are aimed at 'spoiling' others, particularly the NewGen punters, who hardly know anything about the inherent dangers of betting.

     

Raghavan said ...

02-Aug-2020

S C Sharma,

Right.  You have written a good essay.  

I used to check past performance, jockey merit, odds, trainer's merit, track record.  Not all times.  But most of the times.    

Of course you have spoken about patience.  What patience has got to do with racing is a big mystery to me.  Majority of people have patience in large quantity.  That is why they will keep their money in fixed deposit that pays a measly 7-8% interest per annum.   (they do not bet on horses).  Whereas in racing, even for 90% sure horse, you get the odds of  35ps. 

But, on horses that have a bright chance to win, but not 90%, you get 70ps to 11/10 odds.  

I do not think race punters have patience.  At best, they may be cautious to not overbet.  For eg, a punter accustomed to bet 2200/- per race may enhance the stake to 5500/- or even 11000/- on a horse with decent chances to win.  But, he will not bet 2 lakhs on such horse.

I do not know what scientific system means.   Bloodline, trainer's role  speed & stamina, handicapping & timing, class & company, owner's like, appearences & paddock looks etc may be good pointer but all those aspects are considered and discounted in odds quoted by the bookies.  

If you are looking all these aspects before betting, and have tons of patience to ignore 2 or 4 or even 6 races in a day because of doubt, then you are entitled to the title "betting raja" .  One can achieve strike rate upto 50% and his bank balance will be  5 times at the end of a year.  That is if he starts with a bank balance of 2 lakhs, he can definitely boast of 10 lakh bank balance at the end of one year.   Check what your balances were during 1st March 2019 and compare it with your bank balance on 1st March 2020!

All punters are good at theory & also post race analysis.  But, their fate is sealed on the first day of their entrance to the race course.  The bookies call the shots. He pockets a decent amount if 2nd/3rd favorte wins and astronomical sums if 15/1 or 25/1 horse wins!

People call me a man of negative mindset.  What answer I can give them?  They are refusng to accept the reality.  They are cheating themselves.  

So, the war of words between a man good at theory & a man of seemingly negative mindset is bound to intensify.

Of course, you can prove that you consider all the points you mentioned before betting.  Give your tips along wth your explanation for selecting a horse for ten race days.  If you can achieve a strike rate of 50%, then definitely you are a very good punter cum tipster & not just theoretician.

Cruise_b'lore said ...

01-Aug-2020

Hello Aravind,

What stops you from opening new threads on 'interesting' topics?
It is not nice to come to someone's thread and say that. If you find it boring and repetitive then do stay away from the topic. Let the ones interested give forth their views on the so called boring topic.

In fact, one should appreciate SC Sharma for setting the pace on 'horsetalk'. He sets a cracking pace and keeps rest busy on their toes.

regds,
Cruise

Indian_turf_record said ...

01-Aug-2020

@ Cruise_B'lore

       A minor correction since it involves Classics.

       CORRENTE DE OURO was out of Celandine; not Amber Forest. She was first trained by Sabir Khan; not Shabir Ahmed. Later she was trained by K. Raghunath and finally by Bezan Chenoy. The first Classic for that crop was the Nilgiris Fillies' Trial Stakes.

Rksh said ...

01-Aug-2020

Sharma Saab.. 

When anyone loses amt, he starts to preach others , tries to tell his achievements rather than losses...

Now only I understood y there have been continuous preachings from u...Feel extremely sorry for u....Its universal to lose here..

Tc...Regards

Rksh.

Aravind said ...

01-Aug-2020

Mr.Hals

You misunderstood my point,I never said don't discuss such issues. What I m telling s these points were dealt in length many times and even Sharmaji knows well. So why shd discuss same point reoeatdly when we can write many new subjects and keep this Forum interesting to all members. Many has poured there success/failures to know to all so that they can aware of all types in racing.  Sorry if I hurt any one.

S C Sharma said ...

01-Aug-2020

@ Cruise -B'lore : I mentioned about trade mill and swimming exercises under side heading 'Track' but not elaborated in detail as you nicely explained in your reference of an example. 

Cruise_b'lore said ...

01-Aug-2020

Hello JP,

 

Corrente De Ouro( Cavo Doro x Amber Forest ) was a filly and she did win the first classic available for her age group - The B'lore Fillies trial stakes.
She was owned by AJ Fernandes and trained by Shabir Ahmed.

You are perhaps referring to Bold Sovereign, who too was owned by AJ Fernandes and trained by Shabir Ahmed.

Do try to refresh your memory.

regds,
Cruise

Cruise_b'lore said ...

01-Aug-2020

Hello IIMBLUE,

Yes, I do agree that Cooji Katrak was in a league of his own. Extremely talented but equally unpredictable.

The jockey that rode many of his outsiders was Altaf Sayyed.
First before he took a break from racing he gave me farewell gift in NIGHTFALL, ridden by Altaf Sayyed. Paid a mouthering-watering sum of Rs700+ at the tote here in Bangalore.

My favourite trainers for outsiders were Cooji Katrak and I.A.Sait at Mumbai.

regds,
Cruise

Abhay Singh said ...

01-Aug-2020

Sharma sir

Points u have described about handicapping are very revelent but how to apply them in the final selection of the winner is the key.

These are very generalised points and every punter now's them and even after selecting the winner all ur study will go for a toss when u will see the odds movement on the board

So the crux of the story is giving ur selction is one   thingand actually placing the bet another

Hals said ...

01-Aug-2020

Well said SCS, these are common points every punter should consider before making any bet and some more points also to be considered in the final momets like changing odds, going etc. Still if we lose there may be some other factors, out of our reach, that is racing. Yet as you said merit cannot be cheated all the time, one need patience. I totally disagree with Arvind ji who says not to discuss such points - may not his line of thinking/racing. But every punter should consider such points and discuss which will definately be of great help. Thanks.

Chanakya said ...

01-Aug-2020

@ SC Sharma,

 A nice and  informative  article. Good to  read and  remember some advices, forgotten  due  to  time. 

The  present  BREED   of punters wants quick  results, is  impatient and wants only positive  returns without orking  hard which  old timers  profess...

The  problem  or  divergent  interests  create a  no solution  situation...

think about  it..... 

Jp said ...

01-Aug-2020

All your parameters many do possess but I feel what they lack is patience. 

Why patience? Most of punters think that all the horses entered in a race are  and tried and the connections try each and every race the horse is entered. They forget that as soon as the prospects are released by a club,each trainer takes stock of his horses and plans for a target race for each or races depending upon the horse,class, handicap and probable oppostion and if promoted the opposition. He should also calculate Invaders if the race involves outstation entries. Accordingly he plans and targets the race/races. So do the gambling persons know the target race for a horse/trainer/ owner. As per their plan the horse is run maybe once/twice or more till the target race. Some times the horse is run to lower it's weight as well as handicap. For example,Adjudicate's run in most of the races in Kolkata was all to keep the horse racing fit according to me. It's target race was the Invitation and won it for the second time. I never backed this horse in Kolkata but backed it each way in the Invitation,7/1 for win and 16/10 for place. 

My habit is that I back 2 or 3 races in a day and not all the races. I have gone so many days to race course just to see the running of few horses to note for future engagement. In those days no TV relays to see the races recorded.  I have not backed any horse that day though I had enough money. I still remember,I went to see Track Lightning running and so too another horse Currento de aura( I am sorry if there is spelling mistake). This horse was ridden by Nelson Reuben. Track Lighting won easily by 7 or so lengths. But what impressed me was this horse ridden by Reuben was kept at end of the field and finished full of running 2nd. This horse went to Hyderabad and won a classic there at 8/1. I was lucky to be in Hyderabad and I backed this horse. 

Iimblue said ...

01-Aug-2020

@ cruise _Banglore  ,

  Talking about outsiders  , sometimes they are caught by design but many times they come in search of us. But how can one play an outsider confidently? 

S M Johnson whom you have mentioned used to ride Cooji Katrak 's horses. Katrak would prepare the horses by giving swimming exercises or giving repeated mock races. Everytime he landed with a coup on S M Johnson,  the odds would not be less than 50/1.

I had no interest in Ooty races yet I used to follow the trackwork given by The Hindu. Accidentally I saw two horses of C D Katrak and owned by K N Dhunjibhoy  in Ooty trackwork. Both of them were older horses and obviously had not landed in Ooty for Classics. I noted the track in my diary and soon forgot about them as the horses were never entered in a race. 

In the month of August  ,I hurriedly reached BTC for offcourse betting of Pine races. I had not studied the card and trying to do some choice. An outsider ridden by Jockey T. Mahesh and trained by Katrak won a race at odds of 20/1 .It struck a chord with me and I immediately searched my dairy and found that this was the same horse that was tracking in Ooty. I went through the race card and found that the second horse too was running with same T. Mahesh in saddle,  two races later. That horse too won and I had hit the paydirt without effort.Interestingly both horses had not tracked in Pune. 

    I have seen all types of trainers  ,but none like Katrak. 

I have seen 

Seetharama Rao said ...

01-Aug-2020

SHARMAJI,

WHATEVER SAY IS CORRECT.

HOW TO PREDICT THE WINNER IN A CORRECT WAY?

IN MY EXPEREINCE, 100 RATING IS ALWAYS GOOD TO PREDICT THE

CLASS.

 

Cruise_b'lore said ...

31-Jul-2020

Hello Sharma,

You missed a crucial point - Swimming record.

Let me cite an example of that:

Years back I happened to be on a losing streak on one particular race day. All the above given formulas failed me to get a winner. Then a flash of thought occured - why not check out the swimming record for a change to get the winner.
I failed to get the winner in the first attempt but in the very next race I struck gold. The horse happened to be Lion of Judah. This was seen giving swimming exercise consistently almost on a daily basis. The horse, if my memory serves me right, was piloted by S.M.Johnson and perhaps, owned by Darius Rafaat.
Like I said, this horse turned my fortune around on the stated race day. It paid a mind-boggling sum of Rs 1200+ at the tote for win.

One needs to keep an eye on swimming exercise of horses. They are generally unsound ones and most lack a decent track record. If a certain is is exercised at the pool regularly then that horse definitely reckons a look.

One good way to get 'outsiders'.

regds,
Cruise

Aravind said ...

31-Jul-2020

Sharmaji. This topics discussed several times in this forum and it's not new. Also what exactly expect from Members of this forum to say abt your articles? Punters are not just going to race courses as picnics, they study everything, refer books, IR ,interact with known sources and invest bettings. So what ever you are trying to suggest points to be taken are already in practice. I will ask one simple question, even if one is prepared perfect as per all your suggestions and bet as per norms of Racing if he fail what is your answer? Coz nowadays even we as punters well equipped it's owners trainers decision change entire rule of law. So it's simple if you win one race ur lucky. If you lose its bad time. I feel we shd stop discussing all pros and cons of racing instead we can share best things happened in racing and our fortunes as punters.