India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsPathetic Tote Dividends- 33% Take Out Is Ridiculous
By Vj | 29-Jan-2021Tote dividends for winners are so pathetic, whoever is betting against tote is a sore loser even before the race starts. 33% take out from win pool is so high punters are simply wasting their money in horse racing by betting against tote. Look at the below dividents for ex:
| s.no | Horsename | tote divident | tote odd | Private bookie odds |
| 1 | LIVE BY NIGHT | 16 | 3/5 | 2 1/2 |
| 2 | Cellini | 15 | 1/2 | 1 |
| 3 | Beemer | 36 | 2 3/5 | 8 |
| Chennai | ||||
| 1 | Secretive force | 16 | 2 1/5 | 7 |
| 2 | Rippling water | 18 | 2 3/5 | 6 |
These are just few examples: all centers are like that.This is a serious problem that government has to consider otherwise punters who rely on tote will go bankrupt.
33% tax on betting is absoultely ridiculous, whether you pay at tote or a bookie.
Just Imagine to bet 1000 rupees, punter has to pay 350 rupees tax is so ridiculous thats why there is so much illegal betting in the country. Government and Race clubs have to consider this issue serious before tote collection drops to 90% and everyone choose to play with private bookies.
25 Replies
Vj said ...
04-Feb-2021Chanakya,
punters who are playing 100-200 rupees bets no body can help them unless govt reduces the tax so that they can get better dividends. ( Of course when they reduce tax dividends will be better for everyone.) This is for the ones who play more than 1000 rupees or multiples of 1000 rupees on a single straight bet at tote I caution them not to play at tote because of bad dividends. By saying this am I encouraging illegal betting?yes I am. Government left me no choice. Rather be a smart punter by playing with a bookie for better price than be a dumb playing at tote. So choose an honest bookie who is prompt and accurate in payments, play with him with 5-10% tax whatever they charge.
Chanakya said ...
04-Feb-2021VJ,
It is not 1100 type punter who bet with bookies, few stall bookies accept even less, i.e., 550 also. One or 2 stalls in Mumbai are doing this openly. 3 years back even at Bangalore a bookie accepted my 550 bet on a 10/1 fluke- ofcourse i was introduced to him by a friend who is a Bangalorean and lives in USA. Private or 'un-authorised' bookies accept even 220 bet on favorites or flukes readily in Mumbai.
It is also a fact that like punters, many greedy bookies have also perished. In 80's and early 90's there were 35 to 36 stalls in mumbai and more than 15 were on waiting list because the shed could not accomodate more than 36 stalls. Today, i mean a year back there were onlt 18 stalls left which operate on Mumbai/Pune/Bangalore racing days, while on other centers not more than 12 or 13 stalls operate. If the punters lose bookies also lose dueto greed and now not more than 2 or 3 old timer's stalls are active - rest are all new..
Survival of the fittest - Darwin's theory, is truely applicable on punters as well as on bookmakers...
Vj said ...
03-Feb-2021Ragahavan,
Punters/bookies win or loose that depends on their luck and their handicapping skills. Whether they are selling their wifes managalya or their grandfathers dhoti is also not of my concern. When you want to gamble you should prepare for consequences too.I am not here to teach how to gamblig lessons.
You play a horse with bookie you are getting 5-1 for the same horse you get getting 2-1 at tote. You loose 150% of your winnings when you bet against tote because of high rake of tax.
Not 4000 people if you open race club for all there will be atleast 20000 people will show up at the race club that doesnt mean all the 20000 people are winning at tote nor all 20k people are playinng at tote. If your horse is one of the top 3 favs, when you bet at tote you are a loser even if your horse wins.
I cannot be any more clear on this.
Vj said ...
03-Feb-2021Raghavan,
No matter how many times you try to take support of govt in this aspect of 33% tax, my answer would be no. Neither i will never agree with you no I will never ever support such a high rake when it comes to gambling.
Gambling is not a consumer product.
Chanakya said ...
03-Feb-2021VJ,
You are right. In fact I feel tote players are doing 'Harakiri'- a Japanese word for 'honourable suicide'. During world war II while Europe was 'liberated' by allies (UK, France, USA etc.) army Japan was the only country which resistedand used its pilots to commit harakiri. A Japanese pilot wilth loaded bombs will dive down on advancing US fleet of ships, select a target and hit it with fully loaded plane and destroy it - of course getting killed in the process. Many allies warships were destroyed . which forced Us to hold its armada and made them to drop atom bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Coming back to tote punters misadventures I've no sympathy because knowing fully well that their strike rate is 15 to 20% they, out of sheer habit, can not stop then they have no reason to whine on a public plateform and accept that they have been enslaved by this game.
It is difficult but not impossible to make money, and even live on the earnings of bets till a punter dies but that requires guts, slogging and hard work for several months now( earlier it was decades) to ' create' a handicapping AND a betting system...
Very few punters have done it and quietly using it. They don't talk, nor share their ideas or methods - those who try are scoffed by perenial losers. The evidence is there. No NEW PROVEN AND SUSTAINABLE idea, system, method has been posted during LAST one or 2 years on public forums...
why?
The answer is : will you GIVE 2000 rupee note or a 2 rupee coin to a begger?
Whatever the answer may be - 2 rupee will win over Rs. 2000...
Raghavan said ...
02-Feb-2021VJ,
You say that all punters who can afford 1000/- bet will switch over to private bookies! And the Government will be at loss.
Let me repeat what I said in this thread.
"People are betting small amounts viz 200, 500 etc because bookies insist minimum bet of 1100. And, the Government is in no mood to appease such small punters".
"Government is happy with the pittance it gets as revenue. If it is further reduced, the Government does not worry about the same".
It seems you are agreeing with my thinking regarding tote betting.
Raghavan said ...
02-Feb-2021ayyarnet,
Yes. No body is forcing us to bet either with official bookies or illegal bookies or private bookies. If these bookies give you highest odds and you are happy with that, then no one stops you.
But the bookies are doing illegal or unauthorised business by taking bets at 10%, and I am objecting to that.
I can not understand why punters should so fiercely defend the bookies. What I say should be refuted by the bookies.
VJ,
"Raghavan is winning in exotic wagers once in a blue moon!"
Right. No arguments about that. In fact I am more than happy if I cash 15 bets out of 100. I have never complained about the low payout from the tote.
33% tax is ridiculous! Point noted. Actually it is not rocket science. Everybody knows that after hefty gst deduction, tote payout is low, much lower than what bookies offer. A small section of punters are still betting at tote. Whether it is viable or not, only those tote punters should decide. Why you should be concerned about that? Enjoy your betting with the private bookies and leave tote bettors to their fate.
I think bookies are taking bets at 10% for the past 12 years. (there was talk of half tax bets earlier also; but was not so rampant). Every bookie must have pledged his bungalow, car, family jewels including his wife's mangalya to discharge his obligation towards punters. And every punter who is dealing with bookies must be driving his own mercedes-benz & be owning half a dozen houses in prime location/s. Let the punters enjoy prosperity & wealth.
I know what I have told in the previous para is totally wrong. Actually it is the punters who are chased by banks, chit fund operators, co op socities, credit card providers and private money lenders. And if they are doing business with bookies on credit, the bookies also demand money from those punters once in every week. The bookies are not modern day Karna, Bali chakravarthy to pay to the punters hefty dividends day after day, week after week.
On derby dat at BNG, there were more than 4000 punters who paid hefty entry fees and were cheerfully placing their bets at tote. You say it is ridiculous to bet at tote. Well. There were at least 4000 people who were not agreeing with you.
Ayyarnet said ...
02-Feb-2021Fiends :
No body is forcing any of us to bet on TOTE. Only novice will bet on Tote.
Dividend depends on the collection and number of winning tickets. I am told that Club staff themselves punch many tickets I do not know how far it is true because once the race is started they are supposed to close.
Sometimes i did observe difference in dividend displated in TV screen just before Race start and after the Race.
ayyarnet
Sps said ...
02-Feb-2021Raghvan
Thanks a lot for the information.
Few rare person like you only have this much information. When ever you get important information on this subject or any other subject keep us informed.
Vj said ...
01-Feb-2021It doesnt matter what the calculations are. Overall 33% take out from pool amount is absolutely ridiculos. Gambling should not be taxed as GST product. Here we are not buying any product which inturn has a rupee value for it. If government doesnt consider this as a fact then trust me i am not the one who is at the losing end,nor my bookie it is government will be at loss or punters like raghavan who think that they are making out of tote bets with their once in a blue moon winning exotic wagers. All the 1000 rupee punters will defintely switch to private bookies and illegal betting. Sooner they realize better it is for them and thanks to the government for encouraging illegal gambling.
Raghavan said ...
01-Feb-2021sps,
I told you that the calculations are complicated.
Suppose for win pool, there is 10,000 collection. Apparently, the club has to pay 2,800 gst. But, the gst is not calculated like that.
Out of 10,000/- collection, the bet is only 7,810/- & gst is 2,190/-.
(2190/- is 28% of 7810).
From the bet of 7810, club takes around 410/- as commission, and the balance 7400 will be disbursed as dividend to holders of win tickets. For shp & thp, the commission is slightly more. May be around 500/-.
Whereas for forecast, trinella etc the club commission is still higher. May be around 900/-.
For treble pool also the same logic. From 10,000 collection, 2190 is paid as gst, & whopping 2510/- as club commission. For jackpot pool, the club commission is 2410.
This is my understanding. I am just visiting race course during morning hours (between 10am & 11am) and at that hour there is nobody who can give correct or authoritative information.
Let us hope covid-19 is tamed in the near future & normalcy restored by summer season of 2021. I will then enquire the Accounts personnel at BTC and hope they will give right information.
Sps said ...
01-Feb-2021
RAGHVAN
Thanks for replying on the important topic.
(A) General information which, we all have :-
28% GST has been fixed by Central Government. It is menadatiry & club cannot do any thing.
Club is fixing only their commission.
1) For general bets ie
WIN, SHP, THP & PLACE Commission is 5%. and there fore it is:
GST 28% + Commission 5 % Total 33%.
(B) Information received from you:-
2) Jack Pot (JP) :-
GST 28% + Commission 18% = 46%
3) Treble (TBP) :-
GST 28% + Commission 19% = 47%
4) Other Exotic Pool (Forecast, Quinila, Trinila, Execta):-
You have mentioned :-
GST + Commission = 30%
Do you mean that Club Commission in this case is less than general pool bets mentioned at (1)?
GST 28%+Commission 2%= Total30%
(+) 2 % more (may be)= 32%
Then also it is less than 33%.
Request to collect correct information (if you don't have all ready) and post.If it is late then in a new thread. These important information we all should know.
OTHER INFORMATION also can be posted.
Raghavan said ...
31-Jan-2021sps:
I do not know whether the club is recovering additional amount towards covid-19 cess.
Till March 2020, the club commission+GST on jackpot pool was 46% & that of treble is 45%.
For other exotic pools (Forecast, trinella, exacta etc) the club commission was 30%.
Presently, the club commission + gst for treble is 47% and that of jackpot is 46%. (For treble, they are collecting 1% more than what they collect for jackpot)
For jackpot winner, they pay 70% to the winner & 30% consolation. A person who has solved all 5 legs of jackpot, gets both 70% share & 30% share.
I have mentioned the total of club commission & gst in respect of treble and jackpot. What is the breakup? The calculation is slightly complicated. Will try to answer that point shortly.
For exotic pools, as already mentioned above, the club commission
plus gst was 30%. I think, they are now collecting 2% more. I am not sure what is the actual recovery at present.
Sps said ...
31-Jan-2021Raghvan
It will be nice of you to increase my knowledge on Tax Structure of various type of bets at BTC.
Your knowledge on race related matter is very good and also you regularly bet on exotic pool races.
Please refer my earlier post on this thread for more details.
What is BTC comission on Exotic Pool Races in addition to 28% GST.
Iimblue said ...
30-Jan-2021The Club commission on exotic pools including the jackpot has always been around 40%• If it is fair , how the government bringing betting tax at highest bracket of 28% is unfair ?
It is always the policy of the clubs to fleece the unsuspecting punter.Now the shoe is pinching !
Raghavan said ...
30-Jan-2021vj,
Some items are taxed less and some items are taxed more. There are 4 slabs in GST & gambling attracts highest slab. That is 28%.
People are betting at tote small amounts viz 200, 500 etc. because bookies insist minimum bet of 1100/-. And the Government is in no mood to appease such small time punters. You are betting with a private bookie. That is your wish & your money. Enjoy your betting. In the same way punters are ready to take the low payout offered by the tote. And, why should you criticise?
With the passage of time, there will be only 50/- & 100/- bet at tote. Well. O K. Presently there is bets up to 1000/- at tote. Government is happy with the pittance it gets as revenue. If it is further reduced, the Government does not worry about the same.
Suppose the Government fixes gst at 5%. Then bookies will take bets at 2%. That is the ground reality!
Iqbal ahmed,
I do not get any tips from the jockeys & trainers. And I am not at all in plus. When I have stated that I am always in profit? If you read my post once again, you will notice that out of 13 bets in 5 days, only 2 passed. There are several days where I have gone home without cashing even one bet.
The point at discussion is high gst & low payout at tote. What VJ says may be 100% correct regarding low payout at tote; but, his suggestion that lower gst means higher revenue is totally unrealistic.
Captain Cook((((kolkata))))) said ...
30-Jan-2021I don't agree with this at all...we have to decide it first ,,which horse to play with bookies and which to not..couple of weeks ago I planned to bet on a horse MYSTY RIVER at Hyderabad....I BACKED IT EACHWAY WITH A PRIVATE BOOKIE AND REST PLAYED SHP THP AT BETINDIARACES..IT PAYED A HOOPING 122RS FOR A SINGLE TICKET FOR SHP..SO ITS ALWAYS UPTO YOU ,,YOU HAVE TO DECIDE,,YOU HAVE TO BE YOUR OWN FINANCIAL ADVISOR..
Sps said ...
30-Jan-2021What is BTC comission on Exotic Pool Races.?
I understand GST for ALL TYPE of betings are 28%. BTC commission for WNP, SHP, THP & PLACE is 5%. Total 33%.
What is BTC commission for FRP, QNP, TNP, EXP, TBP & Jackpot?
I understand it is more than 5%.
Vj said ...
30-Jan-2021If govt considers it as a sin then they should stop running the show completely. Because of this 33% tax do you know how much tote collections must have dropped lately.It doesnt mean that people are not betting at all, they are betting with private bookies illegally with 5-10% tax . What does govt get from that not even a single penny. There will be crores and crores of betting happening around the country and govt gets only peanuts from tote becuase of its greedy GST. Rather if they drop tax to 10% atleast it will you will see improved tote collections. It will better for punters, better for public. Now that doesnt mean people will not stop betting with private bookies, but this will atleast revenue. Sitting at home doesnt solve the problem, racing industry is a source of income of thousands of people. Whethere you like it or not, legally or illegally people gamble. Rather slapping people with such a high tax, make it reasonable and encourage more legal betting. I have my own private bookies with whom i play and i have no complaints on that. My post was to bring this to fellow punters who are wasting their money playing against tote. Race clubs and govt should start thinking about this otherwise tote will be left with 50rs -100rs punters only and real betting will happen outside of race club. Exotic bets are not the solution to generate money in tote.
Datturao Kulkarni said ...
30-Jan-2021Rghvan sir Thanks you are absolutly right.
Iqbal Ahmed said ...
30-Jan-2021mr ragavan,
what vj says is true,you are very happy playing punter getting tips from jockeys and trainers so you are least bothered of gst tax any way you are always plus in betting bro,never compare with liquor tax, or cigratte tax brother it is not income who smoke,here punter are depending on income or profit
Tota said ...
30-Jan-2021Best way to keep control these type of activity stop betting bet either on bookies or even tots, even stop watching live races also
Azim said ...
30-Jan-2021I agree with u and I have been in racing since 7 to 8 years but I never bet on tote. It is really rediculous. It's the bookies in the ring who always give u a great return and tax is only 10% in any ring where I have bet like Mumbai pune or Delhi race clubs. There was a time when Bangalore tote was giving more dividend than the bookies but now that tote is also not punter friendly. Now a days I am betting onlime but dividends here is not so good but still it is far better than tote dividends. However I personally feels that if you want to bet a good amount its always better to place bet in a ring when all bookies are active. Because they always give good odds whether in place or win because of their inner competition in a ring. But bookies always try to manipulate the punters mind so be careful with that too.
I would suggest you to open an account on betway or bet 365 these sides are good for betting and they are focusing on Indian racing now a days and they are feeling that India is a great market for betting in sports. U do not need to go anywhere for betting just study on your mobile and play on your mobile take the return in your bank account.
Raghavan said ...
30-Jan-2021VJ,
Everybody knows that tote pays less than what bookies offer. The most common sense approach in such circumstance is to avoid tote betting altogether. However, if you can not resist the temptation to bet, you can go for some exotic bets like forecast/trinella or multtileg pools like treble or jackpot.
On 28th, I had three bets. Only forecast. Each Rs. 400/-. Collected 2000 on the single winning bet, 5-4 forecast in 5th race. Earlier, I had about 10 bets of 300 each in 4 race days. Passed only one bet. That paid 73/- on forecast 5-1 in 7th race on 26th January. The strike rate is poor. But, there is not much loss. In fact, I am happy if my strike rate is 15%.
What I am speaking is, the Government can not address your problem in isolation. The Government considers race betting as sin and is slapping sin tax 27%.
At present, I think there are bookies only at Chennai. There are no bookies elsewhere. (of course, horsetalk members are welcome to correct me). I am amused at your mention of "private bookies"! No such persons exist. It is only some frauds & rogues who offer you better odds. And, you are dignifying them as "private bookies".
33% tax + club commission is ridiculous. To whom you are complaining? Fellow punters? The government is not asking you or will not ask you even one rupee. You can watch the races in TV or live for which you have paid entry fees. (It is 150/- & 250/- at BNG). And walk out. No tax to you. But, if you want to bet, then you have to cough up GST and club commission. Do a small calculation. And bet only if you are satisfied that the returns are worth the risk.
Is the Government is justified in exploiting the weekness of punters and fleecing them unfairly? You see, there is a ruling. And as long as you are citizen of this country, you must obey the Laws of the land. Even for liquor the Government is slapping high tax. Whether anyone is complaining? There are many punters interacting here who may be addicted to liquor. Ask them whether they are evading the GST on liquor? Absolutely no! Same is the case with smokers. All smokers pay the GST without caring to bargain. Then why should you question the taxation policy of the Government regarding race betting alone?
If you desire to bet with bookies only, who offer attractive odds & also accept bets at 10%, you should wait. Perhaps, the current restrictions may be eased by the time BNG summer season starts. Presently, the Government is asking you to move out only in compelling reason/s. Do not visit the race course. Problem solved. However, if you desire to visit the race course, then forget about 2200, 5500 bets. Enter with 1000/1500. The Government has no desire to oblige you by permitting the bookies to function.
There may be 100s/1000s of punters who are in red hot rage because of 28% gst. But, there are also very few punters who have no problem with that much tax. I am among those punters.
Vishal Raj said ...
29-Jan-2021This is a serious matter.
Chose the Tote betting so you are waste of money .
If Tote is giving you two rupees, then you are getting one rupee from it because you have already planted one rupee. So bookies are best for bet.
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now