Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Will 'fire Power' Get Back The Lost Voice Of 'speaking Of Which'?

By Cruise_b'lore | 24-Feb-2021

Hello folks,

The gets of stallion Speaking of Which has been rather quite this winter season across the country in various race courses. Very tame performance from them all.

At last he gets one to get him back in action. The horse happens to be Fire Power ( Speaking of Which x Roses in Bloom).

One look at the video replay of his debut run just sets the adrenaline running fast and hard. He came from way off the pace to cruise away to an effortless victory. That indeed was truly an impressive victory.

My gut feeling says that Speaking of Which may get back in action with him. The one that he needs to keep an eye out for is Kensington as he too has the bloodline to thwart the bid of Fire Power.

What do you have to say?

regds,
Cruise

Post Your reply

32 Replies

Ksmrow said ...

02-Mar-2021

@ ITR, Thanks for detail information, 

The Doc said ...

01-Mar-2021

@ ITR & Cruise Banaglore

Gentlemen, just agree to disagree. 

Indian_turf_record said ...

28-Feb-2021

@Ksmrow

Internationally, the statistical way of appraising a stallion is by percentages. You can find these statistics in several publications like Stallion Registers and Auction Sale Catalogues. A typical entry for a stallion would be like:-

Alnasr Alwasheek - Live Foals 432 Named Foals 417 Starters 384 Winners 313 Black-Type Winners 35

Quality of a stallion is measured by BT Winners to Starters percentage. This is arrived at by multiplying his BT winners (35) by 100 and dividing by Starters (384). In this case it comes to 9.11 % Stallions who have a BT index of 10 % or more are considered to be very good.

Similarly, Winners to Starters percentage defines the winner producing ability of a stallion. In Alnasr's case it is 31300/384 = 81.51 %.

You have asked about Everyday II and Mathematician. Their Winners to Starters percentages are:-

    Everyday II - 171/188 = 90.95 %

    Mathematician - 56/77 = 77.77 %

Good stallions generally have good Winners to Starters percentages. I am giving percentages of some good stallions in case you are interested:-

     Grey Gaston - 89.02

     Common Land - 85.00

     Razeen - 85.66 

     Placerville 84.07

     Multidimensional 74.76

You will have noticed that Common Land and Razeen have almost same Winners to Starters perentage percentage. However, Razeen has a much better BT percentage. 

In case I have not been able to explain something, please feel free to ask.

 

Ksmrow said ...

28-Feb-2021

@Indian_Turf_Record,

Nice information can you give  statistics of  Everyday ll and Mathematician,Iam not sure how the calculation done But I think the real calibre of stallions should be taken on performance of their  progenies age up to 4 or5yrs.

 

Godzilla said ...

28-Feb-2021

Gentlemrn

Don't become personal, as after all the Races are decided by connections and not horses and so called pedigrees. 

Cruise_b'lore said ...

27-Feb-2021

Hello ITR,

I have not spent 40+ yrs of life in racing by quoting from record books or following some international norms or concepts.

Have a look at what you have quoted of stallions that qualify as 'Consistent in performance" sire.
I dunno whether to laugh or cry when I see most of the names given.
 

Ask any owner whether he would prefer an offspring of Phoenix Tower or of most of the stallions mentioned in the 'esteemed' list of 'consistent' sires. You will get the answer loud and clear.

I believe in 'power of Observation' and not in 'ratings', theories', 'norms' or concepts'. I leave that to geeks.

All norms and concepts are man-made. Made by human beings like you and me. One follows them only when one lacks the will to excel on their own..
 

And, that, mind you, come with only with 'Power of Observation'. Nothing else.

I have reasons for believing that Phoenix Tiger is Mr Consistent stallion of all time. It is based on my own observations and not in any international norms or concepts.

If you feel it is not so then fine by me.

I will hold steadfast to my belief. I hope you will have no problems with that.

Let me live with my 'mistaken' notion about racing. Please do not interrupt me on that.

Feel free to give your remarks but see that it is not addressed to me.

Let others benefit from your esteemed knowledge of racing. After all, it is a public platform.

regds,
Cruise

Indian_turf_record said ...

27-Feb-2021

@ Cruise_B'lore

     It goes without saying that everyone is free to follow their own concepts. When you make a statement on a public forum you either state the concept on which the statement is made or field the comments made on your posting.

    Just as you are free to post what you like, others are also free to comment on your posting. So as far as 'hence on' is concerned, it would depend on what you post. If you make preposterous statement like labelling Phoenix Tower "Mr. Consistent of ALL TIME" (capitals mine), I reserve my right to respond as I deem fit. 

    

Cruise_b'lore said ...

27-Feb-2021

Hello ITR, 

The fact that Noverre sits on top of the table tells the validity of the so-called 'Internal Concept'.
I base my judgement on my own concept and I judge by that. I stand by what I stated and will not be misguided by so-called factors mentioned by you.
Fell free to follow your concept and leave me to do mine.
Trust you will do so hence on.

regds,
Cruise

Indian_turf_record said ...

27-Feb-2021

@ Cruise_B'lore

      I have absolutely no dobts about your passion for racing and I also have a regard for you as a punter who is also interested in the breeding aspects of the game. Passion often leads to blind perceptions which do not correspond with reality.

     Like you, I also have highest regard for Phoenix Tower. He is one Classic winner short of qualifying for Stud Book's "Wall of Fame". You have labelled him "Mr. Consistent Stallion of All Time".

     Consistency of a stallion is measured universally by a barometer called "Winners to Starters" percentage. Based on statistics published in Stallion Register of 2018, Phoenix Tower has a percentage of 67.45. Statistics of some other stallions (I have excluded some stallions like Razeen, Placerville, Grey Gaston, Multidimensional and others) are:-

      Noverre 89.79

      Glory of Dancer 84.82

      Admiralofthefleet 84.44

      Royal Kingdom 80.00

      Greensmith 79.31

       Lord Admiral 76.11

       Kly Green 75.53

      Win Legend 71. 42

      No problems with Phoneix Tower being called "Mr. Consistent". "of All Time" does not sit well.

      

      Young Senor 77.15

 

The Doc said ...

27-Feb-2021

@ Cruise

You are absolutely right about Phoenix Tower. 

Cruise_b'lore said ...

26-Feb-2021

Hello folks,

If consistency were to be the yardstick, then PHOENIX TIGER will win it hands down. He rarely gets derby winners but at the same time, neither does he give out duds in high numbers.

His offspring have been amazingly consistent in performance. So has Phoenix Tower's record as a stallion.

He represents true value for money. I have no hesistancy in declaring PHOENIX TOWER as Mr Consisatent stallion of all time.
Mind you, the above just pertains to performance in day-to-day races. Not of classics and black-type race but in that too, I am sure, his rewcord is pretty decent.

He could have joined the list of All time great stallions but for his inability to impart stamina into his gets ( few exceptions, as usual, are there ). Nonetheless, in terms of consistency, there is none to match his record.
Has got winners regularly with every crop of his with amazing consistency.

Phoentix Tower - Mr Consistent Stallion of All Time

regds,
Cruise

Indian_turf_record said ...

26-Feb-2021

@ The Doc

     You have mentioned names of some stallions. I thought you might be interested in their career stats:-

Razeen - 57 Classic winners from 575 starters - 9.89 %

Alnasr Alwasheek - 15 / 384 - 3.90 %

Placerville - 42 / 678 - 6.19 %

Burden of Proof - 28/ / 530 - 5.28 %

Multidimensional - 32 / 290 - 11.03 %

Win Legend - 7 / 186 - 3.76 %

Godzolla said ...

26-Feb-2021

ITR

The debate raised by Cruise is only on Sire  SPEAKING WHICH  and not on dam Roses in Bloom or Roses in Snow. I would reiterate that Roses in Snow is a bigger dud than Sire Spreaking of Which.

Eventually the combination of Speaking of Which and Roses in Bloom can only produce a bigger dud.

The Doc said ...

26-Feb-2021

Its been a while since indian racing has seen a sire which has thrown black types winners regularly.  The mantle of Razeen, Alnasr Alwasheek, Placerville, Burden of Proof is yet to be carried forward. Some sires like Multidimensional and win legend has show some promise but lack consitency. 

Vroom Vroom said ...

26-Feb-2021

It's been known from reliable sources that Fire Power's testicles ascended ( went up ) during the race. 

It's not an uncommon issue among some young Colts. You lot should think of the various issues that can come up during training or running of a race before shooting off big write ups & condemning stallions/ farms etc

Godzilla said ...

26-Feb-2021

lightningstrikes

I am not a Scholar. Someone asked me the procedure in picking winners, I only responded.

As far as my predicting as Days Best, Excellent Bet and Too Good bet,, I have no intention to boast myself. Its only my style of writing. A change in expressing oneself should be appreciated.

Its my opinion that Speaking of Which is a flop. If you think, its a great pedigree, express it with statistics. No one stops after all.

I would again request you not to misunderstand my style of write ups. If you are hurt, then accept my apoligies please.

Regarding yesterdays Madras choices of mine, I can only say that its difficult to predict cent percent winners. 

Indian_turf_record said ...

26-Feb-2021

@ Cruise_B'lore

    That you have spoken only of Speaking of Which  and not any other stallion is a fact. If in your postings you had mentioned any where that a Usha Stud stallion was expected to to do more it would have made the context clear. In any case the management of a stud farm is more aware of how its stallion is doing than all of us.

    My point is that every stallion goes through good and bad patches. Similarly, not every stallion of even leading stud farms is a Champion. Usha Stud had China Visit who was neither a total failure nor a Champion Sire. Same with Poonawalla Group whose Greensmith and Ace failed to come up to expectation. 

 

Indian_turf_record said ...

26-Feb-2021

@ Godzilla

First thing is I am not  tipster and nowhere I have said anything about FIRE POWER winning yesterday. Your first choice Days Best was ROYAL PEARL later changed to KENSINGTON. FIRE POWER finished ahead of both ROYAL PEARLand KENSINGTON. 

You have asked me to check records and I have. From ten starts ROSINA won 2 races including Calcutta Oaks and placed 7 times. That Oaks was a "gifted" race is not mentioned in records. Anyway, my point was not only of ROSINA. It was about dam line. So let me give dam line details.

ROSES IN BLOOM (dam of FIRE POWER). 5 wins incl. Golconda Derby, Gr.1). ROSINA and FIRE POWER are her only foals to race so far.

ROSES IN THE SNOW (dam of ROSES IN BLOOM). 3 wins. Dam of 9 winners including ROSES IN BLOOM, Royal Falcon ( 23 wins and 3rd in Golconda St. Leger), Royal Affinity (3 wins and 3rd in Nanoli Stud Pune Derby, Gr.1), River of Stars (15) wins, etc.

CEDAR HONEY[USA]. (dam of ROSES IN THE SNOW). Dam of 6 winners including AMAZING FANTASY (2 wins including Alcock Barb Stakes, Gr.3; grandam of HARTNELL, 5 wins including Calcutta St. Leger, Gr.2), etc; grandam of REUNION (5 wins incl. South India Stayers' Trial Stakes and placed 2nd in Indian St. Leger, Gr.1, President of India Gold Cup, Gr.2, South India St. Leger, Gr.2, etc), etc.

OUR WINDY WEEKEND (unraced; dam of CEDAR HONEY[USA]). Half-sister to RUMBO ( 5 wins incl. Lawrence Realization Stakes, Gr.2 and placed 2nd in Kentucky Derby, Gr.1, Hollywood Derby, Gr.1, Santa Anita Derby, Gr.1, etc), etc.

Immediate maternal grandsires of FIRE POWER are Multidimensional (Champion Sire), Razeen (Champion Sire) and Sharpen Up (stallion of international reputation). 

I am leaving it to readers to decide whether this is "ordinary" dam line.

Lightningstrikes said ...

26-Feb-2021

One need not criticise on this platform , everyone has their own theory and views as to which horse can win or won't , if everyone can can predictb100% bets that don't lose then , I'm sure everyone on HT following these tipsters could become millionaires in a weeks time , one particular Member keeps proving he is some scholar here on HT , Iv been seeing most of his tips and it's like getting your ticket instantly  to hell , where was the bets as follows , for Chennai , "quote"

My Days best 

Excellent and Too good choice , all went down the drain , so it's better to keep in silence than to be like a person shouting and selling fish in the market .

Cruise_b'lore said ...

26-Feb-2021

Hello ITR,

I expect the best when one is associated with Usha stud farm.

Grey Gaston, Common Land, Treasure Leaf, all-time champion stallion Razeen, currently the best in the country Multidimensional. were/are all part of Usha stud farm.

Hence, I expect more from a stallion standing at Usha stud farm. Simply because the expectations are high.

Why would I belittle any stallion or horse when racing is my passion. Please get that straight and stop attributing uncalled for accusations or motive.,

regds,
Cruise

Win Legend said ...

26-Feb-2021

There was no fire in the power....

Sanju said ...

25-Feb-2021

No Fire or Power speaking of who is better to leave alone mostly duds. Ok for their local centers.

Paddy Fan said ...

25-Feb-2021

Yes agree with gadzila sir

Speaking of which is undoubtedly flop breed 

 

Cruise_b'lore said ...

25-Feb-2021

Hello folks,

It seems Speaking of Which needs more Fire Power. His poor run continues. Dunno when he will get his voice back.

regds,
Cruise

Godzilla said ...

25-Feb-2021

ITR

Where was your Fire Power today? 

Godzilla said ...

25-Feb-2021

ITR

Rosina won only two Races in its life span. First on debut and next one Oaks, a gift Race. Go thru records. 

Bangboy said ...

25-Feb-2021

its ULTIMATE ITS CRUISE 

HE IS ULTIMATE

 

Indian_turf_record said ...

25-Feb-2021

@ Godzilla

       FIRE POWER is full-brother to ROSINA who won Calcutta Oaks, Gr.3. Their dam ROSES IN BLOOM won Goldonda Derby, Gr.1. Would you still say dam line of FIRE POWER is "ordinary one" ?

@ Cruise_B'lore

      It is true that SofW had three Classic winners in his 2016 crop and none in 2017 crop. Air Support also had three Classic winners including unbeaten War Hammer in his 2016 crop but zero in his 2017 crop. Why are you speaking only of SofW ? All stallions have their ups and downs.

     FIRE POWER did come from way back in his debut run but he went wide and had to be whipped to get going. That is excusable for first run of two year-old. But I think two Bangalore SofW progeny are more impressive. Allamanda who won by length of Brigade Road and Stockbridge who placed third on debut in black-type race beating two time winner Scruples. Everyone has their own opinion. 

Yash said ...

25-Feb-2021

Hi Cruise,

Fire Power full brother to Rosina kolkata oaks winner and his dam won the hyd derby. Bred in purple, by seeing it's last race coming from behind and winning 2lenghts ahead undoubtedly this horse is a classic contender. 

Ameeta Mehra holding a share and i think she believes in this horse and will be the one to prove speaking of which pedigree this season.

Thank you

Munesh said ...

25-Feb-2021

 Previous winning time.Does it inspire the confidence?

Zeddzzz. said ...

25-Feb-2021

Hi Cruise,

Fully Agree With You. My Money Iz On F P.

Even I Tipped These Two As 1 And 2 With Chashni As 3rd.

Lets Pray n Hope For The Best.

Godzilla said ...

25-Feb-2021

Cruise

Leave aside Speaking of which [which undoubtedly is a flop], the dam side is Roses in Bloom, which is also an ordinary one..

Inspite of these draw backs, if the horse wins, credit must go to TREVOR.