India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsIf Races Are Cancelled, Who Will Benefit?
By Raghavan | 02-May-2021If the race programme of 2019 or earlier is any indication, then races should resume at these centers on the dates mentioned.
BNG 2nd week of May.
MYS 3rd week of May.
KOL 1st week of July
HYD 2nd week of July
PUN 3rd week of July.
However, it will be a biggest surprise even if one center resumes races as per schedule. The sweep of Corona in its 2nd wave is already terrible & many feel that it has not yet peaked. It is really a big surprise that defying all logic & common sense, we are seeing Ooty races running smoothly!
We can safely presume that there will be no summer/monsoon races and punters will have to be satisfied with only the current Ooty races.
Now, the question arises. If races are cancelled, who will benefit?
The bookies offer you tempting odds. Even on horses that pays you only moneyback at the tote, the bookies offer you 40ps to 50ps odds. And on horses that pays you 16 or 17 (for a tenner) at tote, the bookies may quote even money, 11/10, 5/4 or even 6/4.
How the bookies are so generous? Simple. They do not enter the transaction in the bet sheet & instead ask you to pay only 10% premium. To 90% of the punters, this is an extremely big bargain.
Every punter must have saved minimum of one lakh rupees every year because of the discount he gets with each & every bets. I am talking only in respect of punters who bet maximum of one or two thousand per race. Savings of those who bet higher & higher are still more. And, bookies are doing this for more than 12 years. So, every punter must have saved 15 lakh to 25 lakh rupees.
The bookies desire to tonsure every punter. And, it must be said that they are at least 75% successful every race day. At worst they may end up in loss in 2 race days out of 30 race days.
The club has to pay licence fee to Government, salary to its staff, stake money to winnng horses & daily wages to temporary workers. And, it has to pay royalty to other clubs whenever there is off course betting.
The owners/trainers have to maintain their life style & also pay the riding fee to jockeys.
It is presumed that all bookies will end up plus season after season, year after year. The punter may be successful lawyer, chartered accountant, software engineer, businessman or industrialist. (Lastly, I am tempted to add to the list successful tipster with razor sharp aptitude to locate winners!). But, inside the race course, all will get new identity. PUNTER. The only difference is in the volume of bets, which may be 500/- or 50,000/-.
Let us not mention here about two or three book makers who will be losers.
The Club and the Government will never lose. The punters will get their dividend only after the club confiscate its commission, gst and income tax wherever applicable.
So, whose loss is guaranteed in race course? Those guaranteed losers are the biggest beneficiaries whenever races are cancelled for whole season.
32 Replies
Ab-delhi said ...
09-May-2021Raghavanji
it was certainly not directed only at u . there are many who always complain. See every body knows there is fixing in racing and there is illegal betting. These two are different issues. Fixing will always be there , bet is legal or illegal . but I dont beleave every race is fixed. You have live with it there is no option. But to blame bookies for all the fixing is not correct. They are also responsile bur they are not the only responsible.
As far as illegal betting is concern it is because of the authorities and they know everything .it for them to stop why to blame only the bookies for this.
Raghavan said ...
09-May-2021Spade,
When a punter bets at tote, the payout will be only after deducting the income tax wherever applicable.
Do not try to defend bookies by pointing out the mischief by punters. Anybody who indulges in any kind of tax evasion should be charged under the relevant provisions of law.
Anilxk,
I am not sure whether it is legally permissible to bet on international races online. I also do not know how many horsetalk members are trying their luck in such races. Best of luck to those punters.
Anilxk said ...
07-May-2021Dear Raghavanji,
Except in India all over the world racing is continuing, and with help of internet every body was busy in online betting.So now there is no loss/profit equations as all are online round the cloack. Anyway enjoy lockdown by increasing exercise and pass time is the best option.
Spade said ...
06-May-2021All punters including tote punters are required to follow the law and pay income tax on their winnings. Not a single punter is doing this tote punter or ring punter. Why ask only bookies to follow the law?
Raghavan said ...
06-May-2021Ab-Delhi,
So, no one should be complaining against bookies. Excellent. A punter is free to work out the profit or loss and if he is satisfied that race betting is not viable, he should quit betting. But, no one should be complaining against any kind of malpractice indulged by bookies.
I take it that you are referring to me.
At the outset, I am unable to understand your logic. Why shopuld you be peeved if I I am targeting bookies. Let the bookie/s question what I have written.. I will reply them suitably.
So, you are asking me to leave racing. Well. If all punters who are in loss quit racing, then there will be only mosquitos, eagles & crows inside the race course. Address the issue on merits. Never get personal.
Betting on horses is a sin according to Government. Only Court can quash such ruling of the Government. If Court does not quashes such understanding, then as a citizen, you are supposed to obey that rule and pay the required GST. No discount permissible irrespective of your bet size. Let your bet be 1,000/- , 1,00,000/- or one khoka. The GST must be paid. If anybody evades such gst, the penal provisions are attracted.
Do not try to browbeat me. It is highly irresponsible on your part to ask me to leave racing. This site is for healthy debate & discussion on racing related issue. AND IN THIS SITE ARROGANCE HAS NO PLACE.
Ab-delhi said ...
05-May-2021There are people on the ht who are always complaining. They are more concern about others loosing . oh ho since every body is loosing then its ok if im also loosing. They will always complain all races are fixed by bookies and no body can win here. See when you open a shop , are you concerned about others making a profit or your profit or loss. If you are continously in loss you will have to close your shop.
Same is with raceing , why you are concerned who is winning or loosing. Calculate your profit or loss. If the losses are continuous leave racing. But stop complaining.
Raghavan said ...
05-May-2021Ab-Delhi,
You say that bookies are not responsible for the present day mess. Well. In that case you pin point who is responsible. Is it punters? Or is it the officers of the turf club, stewards? Or is it vigilance department of State/Central Government/s, commercial tax officers?
I agree that we can not blame any one section in the racing world for the mess. The blame should be apportioned to each and every fraudster. BUT, I am blaming the bookies. If they insist on full gst + club commission from every punter, then others will fall in line. There were no bookies at BNG in maximum number of race days during last year (2019-20) winter season. Many punters were betting at tote coughing up gst.
You are telling that there are losers even among book makers! OK. But, such book makers are very low in number. My sympathies to them.
I neither love bookies nor hate bookies. All my objection is against their act of accepting bets at 10%. Let them learn to obey the Government rules. It is not for you or any other to point out the huge gst that is slapped on bets. Let the bookies or punters knock the doors of Court and get relief. There are many punters who are in red hot rage because I am vocal on this count. NOT A SINGLE BOOKIE HAS CARED TO REACT.
If bookies were to insist on full gst, will there be no illegal betting? There will be. Let such illegal betting be in billions. That is not my concern. What I am demanding is rules shoud be followed strictly inside the race course. There should be transparency, accountability inside the race course.
M B M said ...
05-May-2021Strong fixations may not work to great extent
How elections are conducted in India
We will participate
How hospitals work during pandemic
These are only examples
Even the air we breath is contaminated
But we have to breath
Breathing
Gt said ...
05-May-2021NONE...period is
Gt said ...
05-May-2021NO ONE WILL BENEFIT period..
Ab-delhi said ...
05-May-2021Mr RAGHAVAN,
You are right when you say there is not a level playing playing field between bookies and tote but who is responsible for this. Are the bookies responsible for this situation absolutely no. The club and every body knows that what is happening. Even if you disallow bookies then also it will continue.
As IIMBLUE very rightly said bookmaking is not a easy job and all the bookmakers will win all the time is nit correct. So many have closed shop in last 3 years. Just blaming is bookies is not correct.
Raghavan said ...
05-May-2021iimblue,
Superhumans!? Absolutely not.
I strongly feel that the bookies have ruined the game beyond repair and some credibility can be restored if bookies are banned completely.
Compared with totes bookies give higher odds. So, punters prefer to deal with bookies. Till 30/6/2017, at BNG, there was a healthy competition between tote & bookies. Now, thanks to gst, there is very low sales at BNG tote also.
IF BOOKIES INSIST ON GST AS PER GOI RULES, THEN THERE WILL NOT BE MUCH VARIATION BETWEEN THE TWO PAYOUTS. And, it is precisely this point that I am highlighting in all of my posts.
Punters are irritated. And they feel that I am harping on 10% tax unreasonably. I am only asking the bookies & punters to obey the rules framed by the Government. No question of being reasonable or unreasonable.
You say that many bookies have became paupers. O K. You have seen bookies being reduced to doing some low paying jobs. My heartfelt sympathies to those bookies. But, if you can show me one bookie who is now bankrupt, I can show you 100 punters who have vanished with no forwarding address.
"Very few have survived in this cruel game"! Right.
Buddy,
Totes are never in loss. Whereas, bookies lose too often!
Your statement about totes is 100% correct. Everybody knows that. Let us not worry about anybody and everybody. Take my own case. I am THE HAPPIEST MAN if I can acheve 15% strike rate.
But, I do not agree with what you say about bookies. Whenever favorites win, the bookie will be under loss if the collections & dividends paid in that particular race is consdered in isolation. But, such losses are only for that particular race. Bookies will in all probability wipe out that loss & remain in surplus by the end of the day. In 30 race days, the bookies may be in loss on two race days.
"Bookies do lose and punters there do win even in the long run"!
I have difficulty in understanding this line. Are you suggesting that punters are eventual winners in the long run? If 'yes', then this is the most silly and absurd statement that I have ever heard!
Wild card entry,
Staying back at home because of no racing is the biggest punishment to each & every punter. But, there is no other option. Corona is devouring each and everyone. Even the IPL organisers have thrown up their hands and surrendered.
Ayyarnet,
Money earned from race betting is always double sweet.
But, money spent on any activity other than betting is actually savings.
Eat the money earmarked for betting, but never bet the money you have earmarked for eating.
Iimblue said ...
04-May-2021Raghavanji is painting the Bookies as if they are super humans. They are not.If races are run fair or tha race is an open race , the bookie will be the happiest person as many horses are running with a chance I bet on one horse ,rest are his.He is a winner fair and square.
In reality ,the races are run in a peculiar way in India.Most of the horses in the race , can not even run with the bunch ,leave alone fighting for a win.If half of the field is not in the reckoning , bookie will find it impossible to balance the books.The reality is that bookies donot fix the races.It is the connections that decide if their horse is on the job or not.If a bookie does not have inside information of at least one leading stable ,he will be out of business in double quick time.
At BTC , I saw many bookies going bust .That is a fact.Some became 100 rs Punters at tote.Some others became assistants of surviving bookied.Betting is a cruel game a cruel game alright ,whether you are a punter ,bookie ,owner ,jockie or a trainer.Very few survived the game.
Buddy said ...
04-May-2021Raghu -number 1 tote players All of them 100% of them will benefit- tote never loses - bookies do lose and punters there do win ,even in the long run- ....but tote never loses -tote player never wins .....all regular race goers know this ..except some tote players.
Raghavan said ...
04-May-2021The Doc,
Absolutely no difference whether one bets with bookies or bet at tote.
The volume of bet at tote is low compared to the betting with bookies.
No problem on that. A punter betting at tote may collect 2200/- for 1100/- risk. Whereas if he bets with bookies he may collect 2500, 3000 or even more.
But, there should be level playing field. Why the punters betting at tote should cough up 34% tax and those bettors with bookies should enjoy by paying only 10%?
LAW OF THE LAND MUST BE RESPECTED AND FOLLOWED.
I do not blame bookies just because they win heavily. I attack them because of the fraud that they are indulging.
Ruchi,
All races are not called off. Ooty turf club management still hopes to run the derby races on 22nd May.
So, at Government level, there are still men with common sense.
The argument from many horse talkers was when IPL matches are allowed, why ban on horse racing? It seems the bubble is burst and IPL matches also postponed.
Raghavan said ...
04-May-2021M B M,
"No bookie will invite anyone to bet",
"No race club will compel anyone to bet online or bet at tote"
"why so much preaching regarding the sport"
Well said. There will be no invitation from liquor shops to anyone. Yet, people go there on their own and consume liquor.
Same is the case with race betting. Punters voluntarily enter the race course and bet anticipating that the horse will either win or finish in place. I have absolutely no objection on this aspect.
To be frank, I will also visit the race course, stand in queue and promptly bet at tote if the betting is allowed.
Let all the race clubs start accepting the bet/s at tote. Let the clubs enforce strictly the idea of "social distancing". Let the betting be done as per Government rules & as per turf manuals. I will stop sermonising.
Not a single race course is running totes. And, Madras race club is persisting with Ooty races. WHY? Obviously it is encouraging people without scruples to accept illegal bets. An arrangement that should be termed extra ordinary. You may love horses & races and readily gloss over such monumental fraud. But, I have some strong fixations.
Wild Card Entry said ...
04-May-2021@ Raghavan Ji,
Good thread narrated, if there is no races, definitely the punters are benefitted, i bet no punters are on the profit side till date even if he has played for more than 50 yrs of his life,, how ever the new commers will be on the loosing note because of the intial craze on racing which builds, use races as a entertainment sports and play to with ones limit, you bet high even though you win that day you will loose the next 2 to 3 days, that is racing..
But with out racing is also boring. King of entertainment.
The Doc said ...
04-May-2021Is there any change in outcome whether we play with bookies or on tote??
Even if we assume they manipulate races with the help of owners trainers etc, is it really going to matter where we place our bets?? Outcome of bets placed on tote and bookies is same, win or lose. Why demonize a single entity??
When we enter the course or online portal to place a bet we are gambling and mind you, we not playing any game of skill. First of all we need to get out of this illusion that racing is a game of skill. It’s just a form of gambling where we have better odds of succeeding than other gambling options like lottery.
There are three basic elements in gambling.
1. the uncertain event of which the outcome is chanced
2. the stake (wager or bet) that is deliberately placed,
3. there is a winner and loser.
When these three elements exist you have gambling. If it doesn't fit this model, it is not gambling.
Horse racing fullfills all the criteria of gambling.
Gambling involves an inordinate desire to have what belongs to someone else. This is the sole motive for wagering. Why cry when it goes other way round?
Its an addiction and we do whatever to prove that it is not. We use denial as the tool to justify or rationalise the addiction. This addiction may be mild, moderate or severe but an addiction none the less.
So blaming bookies, owners,trainers etc is not going to solve our problems. It’s not the question whether resumption or cancellation of racing benefits the punters. Only way to benefit is to stay away from race course.
The so called winners and the perpetual losers in racing are all in the same train albeit in different compartments going towards same destination. Only way to escape is jumping off the train.
Ruchi said ...
04-May-2021AT LAST THE CRUSADER AGAINST bookies can celebrate.....OOTY RACES CALLED OFF
Golden Viper said ...
04-May-2021Ooty races over the week end cancelled.
IPL shamlessly carrys on shifting to mum for the remaining games
Race punters now IPL fans. small ones in gaming contests One of them runs as many as 11 contests roping in about rs 35 crores take a 25 % profit each game.
Racing is left far behind
Libero said ...
04-May-2021Dear Raghavan sir
Thanks for your prompt reply
Santhosh
Pradeep Sethi said ...
04-May-2021JUST GENERALLY SPEAKING.
IF BOOKIES TIED UP WITH TRAINERS,JOCKEYS AND OWNERS FOR INSIDE INFORMATION, HOW COME NO BIG BETTING WITH BOOKIES AND TOTE WHEN FLUKES AND RANK OUTSIDERS WIN? AND LASTLY BOOKIES SELDOM LOOSE DUE TO ODDS OFFERED,OWNERS MOSTLY WELTO DO PEOPLE,TRAINERS AND JOCKEUYS PAID,CLUB CHARGING ENTRANCE AND COMMISSION,ONLY LOOSERS PUNTERS,WEATHER RACESARE ON OR OFF.
Sps said ...
04-May-2021Dear Friends,
In this difficult time please come with interesting topics and new ideas.
This will help in passing time alone. Racing is good or bad but it gives food to mind and keep buisy. Due Epidemic, We cannot go out and some thing or other is required to keep buisy.
Lightningstrikes said ...
04-May-2021Mr Ragavan thanks for the write up , a very thought provoking article , like you I'm still amazed that Ooty races is carrying on despite the Corona effects and still bewildered as to how the IPL is played in many cities where the Corona virus is on rampage, just wondering if the Government is making a mockery to the system on trying to curtail the virus or by spreading it more thus destroying precious lives ,
Come May , June or till the end of this year I'm very much sure that there will be no races unless solid and reasonable efforts are made to curb the spread of this virus , vaccinations for all citizens is a must .
Im not so knowledgeable like you regards racing details but to my opinion Bookies never lose money and if that happens it must be one in a million , the book makers are very talented and skilled in their work , about odds it doesn't matter as long as you make money , most bookmakers are connected to Trainers , Owners and Jockies and the inner information they get makes them more comfortable on displaying sinister odds and this makes them very prominent to give the perfect odds , yes sometimes they do risk paying out that's seldom but on average they always end up with profit. .
Regarding the IPL I'm very sure under the prevailing problems that it's the end for this sport time being unless the power of money takes over and nothing can stop the power of money , let's hope better sense prevails and hoping that extreme measures taken to either run Horse racing or in fact any sport with absolute strict regulations and guidelines given by the government to run any businesses, social distancing , wearing of mask , gatherings at market places , wedding halls , shops and at wine shops are not properly followed by the people it's all taken for granted and that's why we are in this situation , I remember last year in the month of March end when section 144 was imposed a complete lock down when there was just a mere 500 case totally in the country , my question is why now with lakhs of cases every week there is no complete lock down , hoping the best strategy is implemented to avoid further problems and hoping races will one day continue like before and all other activities , my hope and prayers for the people who lost their lives the near and dear ones and for those who are still struggling financially to pay their bills regards the virus and other means , praying for all our HT Members and their beloved families, stsy safe and blessed .
Rmd said ...
04-May-2021DEAR RAGHAVAN SIR,
OBVIOUSLY THE END PERSON WHO IS TITLED AS "PUNTER" IS THE BENIFICIARY.
A RUPEE SAVED IS EQUAL TO A RUPEE EARNED.
REGARDS:- R. MURALIDHARA
Ayyarnet said ...
04-May-2021Friends
Money is an unstable product. It will not remain intact. Just because Races are cancelled Punters may not save their money except instead of spending on Races they will be spending in many other ways.
Since so many Races were cancelled in theory every punter should have a lot of money in their pocket. But in practice it is not so.
Holding the money, manuaring it to grow further is an ART very people could do this. Whether we have Races or not Punters will always maintain their status quo position !!!
Regards to all
ayyarnet
M B M said ...
03-May-2021I can not understand why there are so much of preaching regarding the sport
No bookkie in any center compel anybody to come and bet with them
No race club compel anyone to come and bet in totes or online
It is left to everyone's will to bet anywhere
Those who are fond of the sport they will play the game
Is there no betting in cricket ?
There are races in so many centers in abroad which are conducting at these times of pandemic
If we are not interested we should not pray for spoiling any sport
Let the things move on
Are there are no irregularities in any other sport?
Raghavan said ...
03-May-2021Libero,
The bets recieved on 5 or 6 horses in a race will be normally sufficient for a bookie to discharge his liability & also leave him with a surplus.
Bookie need not print his own currency. Say once in 50 to 60 races, the total bets may not be sufficient to pay the winners. In such cases, the bookie will happily pay from his own pocket.
If a fluke wins, there will be just one or two bets on the winner.
What if bookies are always on the losing side?
Such things will never happen. The horse race in this country is at least 100 years old. And, I have not come across any bookie who has gone bankrupt. If there are very small number of bookies who are in loss, so be it.
Do all players play same horse same amount? The bet size varies. But, maximum bets will be on favorite. And the average strke rate is 33%.
"What is the minmum investment needed to become a bookie? What will be the volume of bets in a 10 horse field? What will be the profit to the bookies if 60% favorites win in a day?"
These questions are addressed to a wrong person. You should ask such questions to a bookie or his accountant. I am only a punter, entering the race course and betting at tote.
You have stated that you are not betting with bookies. People who bet at tote are in hopeless minority. Why should we bother about bookies' net worth? The bookies cheat the club & the government. They loot the punters by entering in unethical tie up with rogue trainers & jockeys, And, that is the reason I write some hard hitting posts targeting them.
Vijaykumar,
I always request punters to bet low, within limits. Do not know how many are taking my request seriously. Certainly, I am not friend, philosopher, guide etc.
Every horse punter with about 2 months exposure n betting might have learnt that winning in races is not at all easy. But, the gambling habit will stay with him till his death. O K. They can not stop betting. But at least they can bet low.
Of course, there are some crackpots interacting in this site who are shouting that they are winners...winners...winners! And, I have demolished their claim.
Vijayakumar said ...
03-May-2021@ RAGHAVAN,
You are absolutely right. If races are cancelled for the time being citing pandemic situation, punters are the most beneficiaries and they will lead a contended life with their kith and kins peacefully without wasting their hard earned money in wagering bets on horse races.
In the absence of the legend SSPP, you play the role as a mentor , philosopher ,and as a guide to all innocent punters who are still believing racing a source of income for their livelihood but the things are other way.
I profoundly salute your noble services to the racing public.
Libero said ...
03-May-2021Dear Raghavan sir & all other knowledgable persons in horsetalk
Everytime there is any race in anywhere in the country, all say that bookies are always in profit (I never played with bookie so far and not intented to play in future too)
But please clarify my doubt if possible
1. Where do bookies get money to pay when the punter wins, do they print their own notes
2. Do all punters play same horse, and same amount?
3. What will be the volume of bets on a 10 horse field on each horse
4. When 60% favorites and 30% second favorites and 10% upsets win on a race day (vice versa too) what will be the profit/loss for bookies?
5. What is the minimum investment needed to become a bookie?
Thank you in advance
*If anybody feels that I hurted them, I apologise to them in advance as it is not intentional
Golden Viper said ...
03-May-2021breaking news
todays ipl match cancelled as some players test positive
IPL likely to be cancelled
BNG races no go in May wait til june.
Ooty races in jeopardy
Bobhotha said ...
03-May-2021Mr.Raghavan i do not accept punters will be gaining irrespective of race is being cancelled . If you observe majority people purchase book and read a lot of time and travel to race course or totes which will cost them . Be happy atleast their families will be happy as they spend time with them .
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now