India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsThe Racing Puzzle: Food For Thought
By Glasgow Prince | 14-May-2021Of late there have been some healthy exchanges about strike rate, in and out running, fixing and so on. Why is it so difficult to crack the racing puzzle? I have a simple understanding. When a punter tries to predict the likely winner based on past performance, weights, ratings, timings, etc; he tacitly or unknowingly assumes that all other conditions and factors are the same although this is never so. Some punters try to overcome this by making certain adjustments based on PNR values, false rails and horse condition but is there any way to make adjustments for other factors?
I am putting forth the following simple but conceptual examples to highlight the challenges involved for the consideration of all race goers - beginners or veterans.
1. Imagine that 10 horses from any class having the same rating and the same suitable distance are made to run a race at equal weights over that suitable distance. Will the result be a dead heat of all the 10 horses?
2. Now imagine that the same 10 horses are made to run the race under the same conditions but with different draw numbers. Will the result be the same as before?
3. Now imagine that the same 10 horses are made to run the race under the same conditions but with the jockeys interchanged at random. Will the result be the same as before?
4. Further imagine that the same 10 horses are made to run the race under similar conditions but at a different venue. Will the result be the same as before?
5. Further imagine that the same 10 horses are made to run the race under the same conditions but after a month or a year. Will the result be the same as before?
Now imagine the additional complexities that get introduced if the number of horses are more, weights allotted are different, suitable distances are different, track conditions are different, horse conditions are different, strategies are different and so on and so forth.
When a punter be it a beginner or a veteran, formulates a system and starts betting on the basis of that system, he does not know which of his bets are going to click and which are going to fail, whether his even money bet is going to win or his bet at 4 to 1 is going to win. This is essentially because he does not know what the winning probability of each bet is. He therefore qualifies his selections with comments such as 'if the connections are serious' or 'if the horse runs true to form', etc. He simply makes a selection based on his system, places his bet and hopes for the best. Given this scenario, is it really possible for him to target a particular strike rate at selected odds to emerge successful? While the table provided in an earlier thread by Abbas is a ready reckoner that gives an idea about what is required to emerge victorious in the long run, can it really be used to target a particular strike rate at selected odds? In this respect, what a punter achieves in terms of strike rate and odds is largely by default rather than design.
Views are welcome from beginners and veterans alike.
51 Replies
Chanakya said ...
03-Jun-2021all,
Retday Goebbles has told some lies which needs refutation.
1) Malvika case is dead as Dodo, reminds me of a mother monkey who carried his dead child for several days till it starts stinking.
2) Losing 10lakhs in 25 years means losing 40,000 every year- that was the annual income (salary) for a middle level govt. officer. Was he & his family starving during this period? Commonsense is really un-common with some...
3)Another lie.I NEVER said that I bet at highest odds...
4)Favorite to 'eat'/lay-name/no; was always given BEFORE race...
5) another twisted lie. Bookies went on strike in 6th. and 7th. race when there was a raid on them during the 6th. race. They were accepting bets and paying from 1st. to 5th. race. Proof. The result books - BOL, Cole, Original Vel will show the odds of 1st. to 5th. races only...
Lastly, the frustration of a perennial loser is so evident in this person's numerous postings on these forums that it is difficult to retrieve him from the abyss of despair...
Can anybody help ??????????
Lightningstrikes said ...
03-Jun-2021Why is there always shadow boxing between certain members over here , irrespective of their age or experience can they learn to be civilised and respectful than been personal , one certain Member is dominant with brazen attacks , please respect other members in this forum and practice decency .
The Doc said ...
02-Jun-2021Good strike rate may not translate into good ROI. If you are playing favorites (avrg odds 2 to 1) then with a strike rate of 30% you will have -10% ROI and with 40% SR u will have 20% ROI. I have not taken taxes into the calculation. But if u can picke winners at decent odds (Avrg odds 5 to 1) then you are at breakeven at a lowly SR of 20% and at 30% SR your ROI will be 80%. So the winning odds decide whether you are winning or not and not the strike rate. Its a simple illustration, detailed table has been posted by Mr Abbas J in another thread.
It doesnt matter what startegy you are utilizing, what matters is picking winners at good odds with good risk reward ratio.
Raghavan said ...
01-Jun-2021Chanakya,
Of course, you may or may not reply to my observations. But, whether you reply to my post or not is not at all relevant. You reply or do not reply or shout shrill abuses. Of course, keep a watch on your blood pressure. I am least bothered about your rantings.
No punter can be in plus if one bets in all races. And, you are betting in all races, sometimes 2 or 3 horses in a single race. At an average you are betting on 18 to 20 horses daily. So, no mathematics genius of Arya Bhata, Shakuntala devi. Simple common sense. You can not win. You can scream otherwise. No one believes you.
However, you are a senior citizen. It is ethically binding on every person relatively younger to show some courtesies and respect to a man who is aged 80+. But, I make it a point to question your claims. What I say is entirely based on common sense. If you feel that I am totally disrespectful, I have no objection. To put the matter in proper perspective, you may be 80+, but I am not thumb sucking toddler. Even I have seen racing for more than 3 decades.
1. You claimed place dividend on Malavika, the horse that finished 3rd out of 6 runners. Of course you "admitted" to your mistake at a later date. But, you had absolutely no choice, no alternative.
2. You said that by betting 10s & 20s, you lost 500k to 10 lakhs and started recovery only after that. Live 100 years and beyond. As long as Almighty may desire. But money lost in race betting is lost for ever.
3. You say that you always bet on a horse at the highest odds. This is an outright lie.
4. You say that you "ate" favorites when the concerned races were over much earlier.
5. There was bet from you when bookies were on strike.
My point to you is - enjoy racing..enjoy betting & winning. Why are you winning only in millions? Start winning in crores! But, after the races do not brag about your imaginary winning/s. You are welcome to tip. You are welcome to speak about horses, races, trainers & jockeys. You are welcome to slam anybody among trainers or jockeys who is playing foul. But, avoid the temptation to boast about your winnings. People will cheer you whenever you tipped a long shot. Be satisfied with that.
You claim that you gave the tips BEFORE races. My goodness! What you are saying is quite amusing. Which tipster has given tips after races?
In my young days, I had heard the story of a man who was claiming that the rabbit he caught had only three legs.
Chanakya said ...
01-Jun-2021dear Crypticblue,
Thanks for your concern and good wishes. I'm not sure whether my mobile no 9870786233 will be publishe by the site; however you can get in touch on my email -chanakyakoshik@gmail.com. Many newcomers have joined to keep he forum alive and interesting, but the old aroma is missing - anyway change is the law of the nature...
Chanakya said ...
01-Jun-2021dear Crypticblue,
Thanks for your concern and good wishes. I'm not sure whether my mobile no 9870786233 will be publishe by the site; however you can get in touch on my email -chanakyakoshik@gmail.com. Many newcomers have joined to keep he forum alive and interesting, but the old aroma is missing - anyway change is the law of the nature...
Chanakya said ...
31-May-2021Glasgow Prine,
NO one has touched the central theme of your main post, however in your post of 20/5/21 in your last para you have clarified what your intention was. In present Indian scenario it is not easy , rather not possible, to adhere to a predetermined strike rate at a particular spread of odds.
As we know that favorites win only 30 to 35% races - the odds in this method should be more than 5/2 to break even and more than 3/1 to show a positive return. My betting strategy, I think, gives me this opportunity when instead of betting only on my first choice I sometimes bet on 2 or 3 runners in the same race. My past experience proves that.
Though my ROI is nothing to crow about but getting decent positive returns is enough for me...
Crypticblue said ...
31-May-2021@Santosh Kumar VK, thank you. Nice to still see you around here. Long time. I see a lot of new writers, and am happy to note HorseTalk is still flourishing
@Indian_Turf_Record, agree. I'd definitely add the 'instinct' skillset along with "intellectuality"
@GP sir, couldn't agree with you more
@Chanakya ji, I tried reaching out to you on your mobile to check on your health with no success. I hope you are doing well. You've always been an epitome of great determination & extraordinary knowledge
Regards
Chanakya said ...
27-May-2021all,
I consider it a waste of time even to respond, to the frustration of a perenial loser. Even a player is left with to share 62 to 65% of the invested money in every race which is offered to the winning ticket holders after tax and club commission... only those who don't know how to find a winner continue losing and keep crying like a child in every posting!
Since 2014/15 on this forum I've been posting my selections BEFORE the races were run and proving that iIT IS POSSBLE TO WIN FROM RACES a good amount over a period ; EVEN IT IS POSSIBLE TO LIVE COMFORTABLY ON THE EARNINGS FROM THERACING... But it is possible only if :
) you have a good handicapping system
2) evolved a good betting strategy(method)
3) has a corpus money of about Rs. 40,000
4) bet always a unit amount - 1,000 or 2,000
Raghavan said ...
26-May-2021Buddy,
So, a tote player is sailing in a boat different from the one who is betting with bookies! And it is extremely difficult for a punter who bets with bookies to discuss racing with a punter who always bets at tote.
My goodness. A great realisation on your part. Reminds me of Sidhartha (Budhdha) who got enlightenment under a bodhi tree.
Even I am also not interested to discuss racing with those who are men with high index of superiority complex. (swa-pratishte). But, I will always slam, tear apart the narratives of such hypocrites. It was an unpardonable indiscretion on your part to side with Chanakya in a bid to put me on defensive. That Chanakya claimed place dividend on a horse that finished 3rd in a six horse field.
Ramiyer said ...
26-May-2021Nice to hear Chanakya sir you are getting fine.
Indian_turf_record said ...
26-May-2021The legendary punter Barney Curley died earlier this week. There is plenty about him and his methods on the internet that is worthy of reading and digesting. Interesting to note that Curley was not a system addict. It was his instict (not his intelligence) as well as his ability to get grip on aspects that he could control which were cornerstones of his coups.
Chanakya said ...
25-May-2021thank you Vincero for your good wishes...
@ Ramiyer and Sun
I'll be back soon,,may be within a fortnight...
Buddy said ...
25-May-2021Raghu- if a tech guy were to talk about coding with me it would be difficult for us to understand each other ... just like if i were to discuss racing with you you are floating at a different level , its a different ball game there ..... probably half the people coming here go to the tote .....thats pk its their money but its different with good bookmakers ....to know that you gotto reach there ..just reaching there and getting started can be difficult for most punters .....
Raghavan said ...
24-May-2021Buddy,
"Race results are known before start of the race to some select few".
Do not know whether to cry or laugh at such silly statement/s.
Trainers & connections definitely know before the start whether their horse is winning or losing certain race/s. Some of the connections may even sell such information to trusted few. This is the case in 75% of races.
What is your idea in speaking such open secrets as if you have done a big research and expecting Phd for your thesis?
Raghavan said ...
24-May-2021Buddy,
Bookies not caring to refute. Right. And, you are siding with them. O K. That also not a problem. But, why are you speaking against my argument?
Is it with the idea of shouting me down?
"Tote players are confused lot if tote goes out of action". What about those dealing with bookies? I have come across 100s (may be even 1000s) punters who were queueing in front of tote when bookies were given marching orders during 2016-17, 2017-18 & also on too many race days during 2019-20. Bookies were compelled to sign agreements that looked arbitrary or unreasonable and loaded heavily against the bookies.
Yes. We tote players will be really confused if and when totes are shut. But, so far, in 30+ years of punting I do not remember to have faced such a situation. Let me think about crossing the bridge when I come across one.
Glasgow Prince said ...
24-May-2021Crypticblue,
Nice to see you back after long. Yes, very true. Intellectuality is very important. I feel additionally, aptitude for horse racing and innovation in winner finding will take a punter much further.
Chanakya,
Thanks. Hope it helps the newcomers to realise that it is no bed of roses and pitch their expectations accordingly.
Abhay Singh said ...
22-May-2021Raghavan sir very true that only a very small percentage bookies loose but a majority of punters are in lose. But why are we concerned about the bookies , whether they win or loose.. Races are conducted in a particular manner and it will always be like that whether you like it or not. Fixing will be there .
We have to look at our selves whether we are winning or loosing. Constantly loosing is not possible one should leave horse race betting
Buddy said ...
21-May-2021Racing results in certain races are known before the race starts to a select few -the seclect few have control over certain races and 90% of the time they are correct ..they design the race .
Santosh Kumar V K said ...
21-May-2021Crypticblue
The only way one can beat this game is through one's own intellectuality".
You Nailed It,Regards
Buddy said ...
21-May-2021No bookie has ever refuted your arguements raghu toteman -really? why should they does it matter to them will it effect them ... the real problem with old addicted punters like raghu is -dont know where to go what to do if tote goes out of action ...most elderly guys feel lost after a certain age ...if they don't plan well for their twilight years ... most important take care of your health ...spend time work out . walk/ jog /cycle/ play ..whatever you can do.
Chanakya said ...
21-May-2021dear bonding008,
nice to see you after a long gap. Many thanks for your good wishes.Those were the good old days when like-minded people used to interact irrespective of their position or status. Sagar has gone into silent mode and Dr Nath has withdrawn after he got the membership of BTC...
Chanakya said ...
21-May-2021dear GP<
I should say without hesitation that this thread is very informative and vey well presented. No one could have done it better. Many newcomers and even seasoned punters will benefit.
Thanks for your good wishes....
Thank you, Vincero...
Chanakya said ...
21-May-2021Thank you very much Dancing Dynamite and Sun,
dear Ramiyer,
Yes I vividly remember that Invitation weekend arranged by Dr. Nath, where I met some wonderful people. You and Mrs. Ramiyer were very helpful and considerate.She offered me her seat when there was no place to sit!
Yes, I am recovering slowly- what else an 82 yrs. plus can expect. It is the good wishes of friends like you which has heelped...
Crypticblue said ...
20-May-2021Hello GP sir. Hope this message finds you in the best of health.
To put it simply, from my own experience, I've reached a stage in this sport from where I can confidently advocate, "The only way one can beat this game is through one's own intellectuality".
Rest everything is available for free in public domain
Regards
Bonding008 said ...
20-May-2021Chanakya ji , wishing you a quick recovery from this virus and hoping you get back stronger than ever , yes I missed the GT of Madame’s Lagad many times but still message this wonderful Lady , many of the long timers are missing , Dr Krnath and Sagar Sir and many others , hoping all are safe and blessed
Vincero said ...
20-May-2021@Chanakya Sir
Get well soon sir
Raghavan said ...
20-May-2021Abhay Singh,
Right. Bookies also lose and punters also win. This statement may apply to 2% bookies & punters. The other punters are losers only.
I hope you will appreciate that it is much more reasonable to generalise 98% losers as 100% losers. On the other hand, you are highlighting those 2% punters who are in plus,
"Everytime blaming the bookies for your loss is wrong"! This is an unfair statement from you. When I have blamed bookies for my loss? I am betting at tote only. With bookies I might have played maximum 10 bets (paying full tax) in three decades.. Presently, bookies have neither courtesy, nor patience to accept bets less than 1000/- even if the punter is ready to play full tax! So...bookies have not gained one phootee kowdee from me! And, thereby the question of blaming bookies for my loss does not arise.
"Certainly winning at races is difficult, but not impossible"! If you are dealing with bookies and also in profit, then just ignore my posts and bet to your heart's content with bookies. My posts are targeted mainly to those hapless losers.
Perhaps you may not believe me if I say that bookies are my best friend/s. Majority of my bets are finalised only after seeing the odds quoted by them. I have nothing against bookies. Nor do I blame them for winning gunny bag full of currency month after month, season after season, year after year. It is their profession.
I believe in the logic that if as a punter you want to loot their (bookies') cash, then identify the winner & bet. Do not bet on a loser and criticise them for your indiscretion. Certainly, punters should not expect bookies to distribute cash to punters in a routine manner.
But, I demonise them, criticise them, because they flout the law of the land with impunity & cheat Government and the club . And the punters sheepishly bet with bookies. I am not blaming punters either. It is their cash and how much to bet, with whom to bet is entirely their prerogative.
It is really amusing that my posts are questioned by punters only. Not a single bookie has so far considered it necessary to refute what I write.
Glasgow Prince said ...
20-May-2021First of all, let me wish Chanakya a very speedy recovery. Hope you get well soon and are back in action at the earliest.
The Doc, Sumant Dalmiya and Chase, many thanks to you.
Cinch, I agree with you. I have not included many factors since that was not the intention of the post.
Thank you all others for your valuable responses.
The main objective of my post was to present in a simple but conceptual way why a punter finds it difficult if not impossible to make money consistently in the long run. The ides was to make readers especially newcomers aware of the pitfalls in a simple way as also if possible, provide a trigger to all readers at large, for thinking of new and different ways of approaching this puzzle.
To win consistently, a punter has to achieve a good strike rate at attractive average odds. These are the two parameters on which the effectiveness of his system rests - the strike rate it can generate and the average odds it can muster.
Let us first consider the strike rate. The idea of the lead post was to present through simplistic examples how the basic concepts of handicapping as well as certain additional adjustments for track condition, width of false rails and horse condition are not adequate to give the punter a high strike rate nor is it enough to enable him to accurately assess the winning probability of his bet. The intention was to bring out how even the basic factors are sufficient to affect the outcome of a race in different ways. Different permutations and combinations of even these basic factors can lead to varying and unpredictable results. The complications multiply if we take into account the finer points and reflect on the cumulative effect of all the factors. Even after taking into account myriad factors, the best of punters are unable to exceed a win strike rate of around 40%. This is the general limitation as far as the success of bet selection is concerned. A majority of punters are unable to achieve an acceptable strike rate leading to sustained losses.
To keep matters relatively simple, I have refrained from going into other important and interesting topics such as race characteristics, horse characteristics and preferences, venue (track) characteristics, track work interpretation, non linear effect of increase in weights, trainer / owner strategies and tactics, jockey strengths, punter psychology, role of bookmakers and the much misunderstood utility of bookmakers' odds. There are occasions when even the top jockeys make genuine errors even in graded races or run into traffic problems which affects the outcome of the race. On the other hand, there are occasions when a jockey wins unexpectedly by his sheer brilliance. All these additional factors serve to compound the confusion of a punter and add to the uncertainty and unpredictability of the result. When a punter is unable to fathom the reasons for an unexpected result, he is bound to suspect foul play and feel cheated.
The other hurdle or limitation to winning regularly which was highlighted in the lead post was the fact that a punter cannot aim to develop a system by setting a target of say X strike rate at Y average odds. A system can only attempt to maximise the number of winners that it throws out irrespective of the odds. It has no say in the odds of the recommended bets. Of course, a punter has the option of betting only on such system recommendations that he finds attractive in terms of odds. This however can backfire as the system does not give him the winning probability of each bet. Consequently, he may end up making only the losing bets. In view of this, he has to keep improving the strike rate of his system as much as he can. Some punters try to overcome this lacuna by backing the top two or top three choices given by the system in each race so as to enhance the winning probability of the composite bet. This strategy however warrants much higher average odds on winning bets to be successful in the long run. Whichever way one looks at it, a punter cannot start developing a system with the aim that it will achieve a certain predetermined strike rate at certain predetermined average odds. Whatever average odds he manages to muster are by default and not design.
Abhay Singh said ...
20-May-2021RAGHAVAN SIR
To say that 100 percent punters are loosing and all bookies are winning is wrong. Certenly most of the punters are loosing. Every time blaming the bookies for your looses is wrong. Certanly winning at the races is very difficult but not impossible.
If u feel bookies are always winning then lay dont play as the bookies are doing. One will loose more by laying than playing.
Ramiyer said ...
19-May-2021Dear Chanakya sir
When I last met you at Bangalore you were as good as a youth and I wondered how fast you were moving in and around the race course with full of energy.You made a late dash for the GT.Finally you made money bag full and returned to mumbai ngt. I still remember your choices of 8 races .7,Won and 1 placed.
Now you are fighting with corona bravely and you will triumph as a true warrior.Wish you a speedy recovery.
Raghavan said ...
19-May-2021Horse racing puzzle is very very easy to solve. AFTER THE RACES.
But the problem is every punter desires to know the winning horse before the races. And the pity is there is no formula to solve that puzzle.
Let us be practical. Normally a punter bets based on past performance, jockey capability and odds. If he wins 1 out of 5 bets he is a punter of average intelligence. If he wins 2 bets out of 5, then he is really a genius.
There are some crackpots who claim they had 3, 4 or even 5 winning bets out of 5. These are the biggest cheaters.
In race betting, the bookies are the guartanteed winners. And, the PUNTERS ARE GUARANTEED LOSERS. This is the case right from day one when betting started. And, it will remain so as long as the betting on horse race is permitted by the Government.
Gc Raj said ...
19-May-2021Iam in this field as a punter since 20 years, i lost enough,but still continuing.There is NO simple formula /single method by which you can pick a winners here. Off course for my experience i can pick 2 winners in most of the race cards,2 places, but the the problem is DISCIPLINE and patience in betting, I GET CARRIED AWAY BY SOME other persons opinion(when he says inside information),i lost bets,at that my fancied horse has won, BEST EXAMPLE I WILL GIVE FOR THIS IS SC JAIN sprinters cup ran on 21/3/2021, my fancy was CORFE CASTLE, because i was following this horse from chennai, THIS WAS THE ONLY confident bet for me on that day. I should have gone to the race course only just for that race, without meeting any one,i would have bet only that horse, mistake was i went for the first race itself, one of my close friend said IRON AGE is going to win as per the information from stable connections, so i changed my mind went for IRON AGE, imagine my situation after the results, after this I DECIDED TO GO only for limited races, and not to meet any one inside the race course.
Lightningstrikes said ...
19-May-2021In Indian horse racing nothing works , it’s only the power of money that makes the horse or selected one win , not all races but most , owners , trainers , jockeys and bookmakers only know from which draw or or numbers the selected horse is going to win , sometimes sinister plans are designed for a particular horse to win and its perfected with the knowledge of the script edited and the so called script directors , nothing works in Indian racing especially the pedigree , ratings , horse form and excellent track works , if everyone is to pick the right winner then 200% winner , then racing would abruptly end in India , bookmakers are not fools to open their money boxes and distribute money that easy ,in as much u have you have a definite winner so as much you have a scammer to bring or to make that horse lose , we have seen thousands of examples , it's all money power and resources that can help you to win and basically you need luck even if you select the right winner , for example say if I know a owner and get valuable information from all three the owner , jockey and trainer , still from the start the horse leaving its stall with a good jump , the jockey riding , and nonhinderemce met and moreover the smooth running by the said horse , even horse moods count on the particular day till it crosses the finish line, and thus what's make this sport an exciting one to watch and wager your gamble either for fun or a serious money minded bet no matter run on merit or run to plunder the hopeless , you have brought out nice pointers , but the question is , does it work over here in Indian conditions the answer will always be a big fat No, one factor that always reminds me amidst various incidents is the invitation cup where Southern empire lost to Diabolical, was this a diabolical disaster or as its name sounded , after the race and during the presentation one official said all these things happen in racing , so the question remains what's the point of buying a racing book going through track work doing your home work related to picking up a winner and just like that your selection goes for a toss , as I said most races are just framed for the big guys Iv seen many sports like this flounder , it's very easy to say maybe it was a set up but by in large it could have proven otherwise , it's all the luck factor for either to win a jackpot or any money on racing.
Once while I was at the betting tote purchasing my tickets at the counter I just seen two old men holding and book and coming to conclusion that In that particular race to begin horse number 7 had the best chance , I just had a glance and to my utter dismay found it was pathetic that these elderly men selected a 20 /1 shot horse to a 13/10 horse and favourite , and it was the first leg of the jackpot , I just felt sad for them bought my tickets and played rightly to my own selections but just for their sake I waged a fiver just one ticket on that horse they felt had a chance , as the commentary started the favourite was always leading and knowing it had a 5 length lead I just went off to buy a coffee , suddenly I heard voices as though reminding me thst revelation was about to happen and the heavens opening up and low and behold silence was like a deafening factor at that moment till I got the information through the system that horse number 7 won , what sought of logic was that , no track , pathetically I can say as the favourite was 5 seconds better in timing no recent form or placed and pedigree for that fuke hosre to ever win , clearly no explanation at all , all the factors , explanation and detail script writings and brief descriptions went for a toss , Iv seen many so called experts giving various causes on many said races and yet go wrong , that's why my conclusion is that races is all made up on most occasions very rarely if goes right for you and if that happens it's just one word luck was on your side ,
I was still petrified as to how these old Gentleman selected this horse and somehow managed to catch them up after the seventh race , I asked , Sir please tell me what was the cause and explanation in selecting a rank outsider on the first leg of the jackpot , they just told me it was some numerical logic or rather numerlogy understood by me , I said , Sir your lucky I'm sure your Jacpot will pass and wish you the best to which they in a sad face , and said we lost on the secound leg as we did not keep the favourite , such is the impact of racing , that's why no amount of expert selections or calculations can give you a feeling you will win , it's high time the so called experts stop giving these 100% winner selections and reasons that this horse can win or lose , yes I did take part on some contest here on horse talk and given selections but it was just on my instincts , no track work or pedigree explanation that's it , their are reputable writers whom I admire on HT and they are kind enough to share their racing theories , and equally or perhaps more their are some who either contribute towards the downfall of a HT member with their pathetic choice , very easy to say it's towards are own opinion on choosing or ignoring , but I still feel it all boils down to racing luck , in a nut shell , racing in India is like a bird flying blind , hoping better sense prevails and would request our HT members to contribute the saved racing money to the prevailing Corona virus to the government that's still causing havoc in our country , this money could save a life and in return the life saved would pray for you dearly , wishing all the HT members to stay safe and blessed in these troubled times ...
Sun said ...
19-May-2021@ Chanakya,
Get fully fit soon We miss you
Northern Dancer said ...
19-May-2021IImblu
I agree with you about following the handicapper. He knows best.he will guide you to the contenders. In this way you can save time and analyze the contenders only.now wait patiently for race day. Good luck
Dancing Dynamite said ...
18-May-2021Chanakya said ...
18-May-2021After fighting with corona-19, for more than 50 days i am not in a position to give detailed comments but can say that this is a thoughtprovoking article and nedds deeper understanding to unravel the racing puzzle...
Ksmrow said ...
18-May-2021Hi all
Glasgow Prince generally in classics or bottom class races horses frequently clash with horses which have ran together totalling to 1/3 to1/2 of runners(A) in less than a month, there may be another set of 1/4 horses which ran together(B)and few remaining horse(c)now we have to do calculations to A,B,C Set of horses,for A set coditions are uniform then now do +or- according to weights,jockey,Draw,distance and see track after last run for venue change style of running may be considered,
After calculation of quantitative data together with quantify assumptions we arrive and identify Best in the set'A' same way we pick Best from Bunch 'B' now pick a horse from 'c' preference to be given to jockey riding,now
Most difficult part comparing
Toppers of A,B,C and picking
One among them looking in to distance&jockey.
Example 1
Indian derby2021
Eample 2
KOLKATA race(139).
Now about strike rate the table from J Abbas post is
Mathematical calculation nothing to defer.the winning strike rate differ on the way we pick winner and bet for me 30% strike rate is good, for Krish,Libero 15 to20% for
BKD&Mad Max little lesser than 30% Darmesh,Ab-delhi need 40% to say winning strike rate,it vary from tipster to tipster.
The Doc said ...
18-May-2021
@ Glasgow Prince Sir,
It’s always been a pleasure to read your write ups. The current post is no exception. The absolute clarity of thoughts is testament of your sound understanding of the game.
This game doesn’t just happen on track but also in betting rings and punters mind. The key to success is better amalgamation of all the above factors.
So the better understanding of variables enumerated by GP sir in the post takes cares of things happening on track. Betting ring gives the odds for your fancies and it’s up to you to decide whether the odds offered are reasonable or not. Many times odds does give you indication how the race is going to pan out. The third and most important factor is your mental aptitude and emotional intelligence. The last factor is major contributor towards the losses one suffers. Patience and perseverance pays in any field and racing in no different.
It doesn’t matter what strategy you follow, important is to stick to it. No strategy is full proof here and so frequent changing of your strategies is not going to help. Understand your strategy well, find out the circumstances in which it works better and then wait for the opportunity, for things to fall in place. It’s easier said than done but not impossible.
Personally I like to bet on all races. I follow the unit bets system as far as possible (being as human I sometimes err). So even if I pass 2 good bets at decent odds, I come up in plus or at least doesn’t lose much. If I get one single long shot then nothing like it. If I am in plus in first few races then I always make sure that I take at least 50% of the profit home. One never knows which bets is going to pass and which not. So I never pick any days best bet and play all bets with similar amount. This doesn’t give spectacular results so as to fly around the world but it also doesn’t make me bankrupt. This thing works for me as I am more of enthusiast than hardcore punter. It allows me to enjoy racing without losing. I don’t mind if I don’t earn from racing, but I mind losing my hard earned money in racing.
Cinch said ...
18-May-2021GLASGOW PRINCE I DONT AGREE WITH YOU. THERE UMPTEEN OF FACTORS YOU HAVE MISSED IN YOUR ARTICLE.
Sun said ...
17-May-2021Very interesting post.The Puzzles posed are under 5 different scenarioes with the important parameters being same.
The underlying question is why there is no dead heat for the 10 horses and tries to underline the importance of Variables and hence the complexity of Winner picking I propose to discuss the first one in the last.
2. Same calibre Diffrent draw numbers If horses are made to run in their tracks throughout the race and assuming that calibre of all jockeys is same then horse in Draw no 1 will win
3. Different Jockeys To expect a Photo Finish negates the very concept of Jockey Skill and premium commanded by a Jockey. So Winner is one among the horses with same level of skill
4.Different Centres It is not possible to assign correct Rating coming from different centres and hence the assumptions does not hold good.If there is a common Rating system and Track Profile and Firmness, bends and their Radii are same this hypothesis can be checked
5.Time elapsed between runs On one side we have Handicap Taces where a horse running after a long gap is definitely at a disadventage
On the other extreme we have prestigious Terms races like Invitation,Sprinters and Stayers Cup where last year winners make their presence felt even carrying more Weight.
So it depends on Class of horse.
Now coming to point (1) The assumption here is horses with same Rating are of equal calibre.
From my study of Ratings I have the following to offer.
1.A horse has to earn its Rating that is it has to graduate to that level.It is like a Student getting double promotion but he finds that he is not upto the of Top in the class in next assessment.Similarly in next one or two races the horse cannot live upto its Rating.This normally happens when a horse places in Classics/Terms Race and in the next Handicap Race carrying its assigned Handicap fails to deliver In simple terms the horse has not matured.
2. In other cases a Winning horse with a handsome margin is penalised corresponding to margin of Win but in practice it may so happen that the Placed horses are not fully extended.So here also there is abberation in Ratings which cannot be ateempted and also not desirable as it will robs the thrill of Racing
Your views please
Iimblue said ...
17-May-2021GP Sir , why 10 ten horses ? Even if only two horses of same age and same rating run in a race , they will not be able to finish togeher.
That the Handicap system can never be a perfect system is well known.Hypothetically if a horse with 80 rating runs with a horse of zero rating r in a handicap race ,the former will not even see the finishing line !
The handicapper is only trying to make best out of a bad proposition.The system is defective ,no doubt but there is no other option.
Yet , the person I believe the most is the handicapper.The reputation of the Club depends on the integrity of the handicapper.I caught many winners by following the handicapper.Except in term races for 4 year olds (where handicapper is acting on scanty and limited data available to him and horses are fast improving type ), the rest of the races Handicapper is right most of the time.Thanking the handicappers for their thankless job.
Ayyarnet said ...
17-May-2021Dr Harun:
Sir, medias are always bribed to put misleading Healines by the vested interests and hyping report on wrong horses.
Majority of punters without any info from connections follow media report only.
These are all part of the game rather tricks of the trade.
Regards
ayyarnet
Chase said ...
16-May-2021I like the title of the post. It is a puzzle alright. Whenever I approached it as a puzzle I had a good stroke rate. Whenever My intent switched to betting and winning, I always slipped. There is always this distinction between solving a puzzle and the greedy bet.
Dr Harun said ...
16-May-2021Much of the misleading happens when the media hypes up some horses beyond their real ability and the punters end up losing.In the UK this happens every year take for instance 2018 they hyped up Saxon Warrior he was ridden so damn hard for the Quipco 2000 guineas in last 100 m while Masar came from last bunch to finish 3rd full off running. IN the Epsom derby SW a poor 4th Masar the winner.The winner 25 to 1 Fav 55p lost.Same with Pinatubo never was a mile horse forget derby.Could not last 7 furlongs. There as well punters lost badly saying he was brought on late and will make amends .Racing king and now u hear about Boshi Ballet looked ok , stayed the trip but is it that good to get the Epsom derby.I dont think.So.The hype goes a long way in punter making his pick.Back home i haven't seen any horse hyped yhat much to end up no where they stood good enough for the billing.As a punter u should not lose when u hike your bet and i have lost when ever i incresed the bet.Bets getting through were more but the ones lost were heavy ones
Fearless Punter said ...
16-May-2021Nice topic put forward ..since you have called upon beginners and veterans for discussion I personally welcome veterans like Godzilla, raghavan ,chanakya and TRANSPARENCY to give their views about a fixed strategy that they use.
I , having been in racing field for 10 years have made a simple strategy as my habit and that is I go one hour before start of the races and buy race card and look for morning odds favs.
Later during the race if opening odds match morning odds I go for a good punt.
Please let me know other's thoughts.
Ayyarnet said ...
16-May-2021Friends
Horses are not Machines to reproduce the same speed at different situation. It all depends on the riding instructions given to the Jockeys.
In India in a Race of 10 Horses only one or two or at the most three horses will be on the job. Rest are just to help the Club to conduct a Race program or just to give company to other rhorses or even for just to claim Food Subsidies allowed for participating horses !!! or even to reduce their weigh for demotion to lower class. So behind the scene of any Race so many things takes place.
We are all fooled by the vested interests. People get addicted after tasting one or two wins. Many times Fancied horses are winning just to attract or seduce the Punters. The authorities knew very well public will come.
Club take advantage of this weakness of the Punters and so the show goes on for years. Punters are like AGARBATHI burning themselves to spread
profume for others !!!
90 percent of the punters are coming to Races without understanding the very basic concept of conducting the Races with an idea to make easy money. The club will have to balance all involved Punters/Bookmakers/Owners/Patrons Big Wigs etc.,
They have to honour he VVIP Big wigs who have a passion for Racing their Horses ! They will never lose. They may not indulge in betting also. Only small punters always lose. That is why our Legend SSPP was vehemently advocating all to forget the races since there are many avenues available for our Revenue.
On a Race day certainly two races are fixed or pre planned to filter Jackpot tickets !
two races mainly fancied favorites to satisfy the public and two Races to honour the Patrons of the Club and the rest for Bookmakers. My observations are based only in an average basis only. It is possible some times many favorites can come.
In Tote any horse can be made as Favorite to mislead the punter by dumping certain amount at the tote. This happened many times wrong horses have been made as Favorite at the Tote. Book makers with vested interest play this miscief many times.
Only those who can understand the tricks of the trade some times do make money and the probability of this earned money also will fly away soon from their hands in due course of time !! They will continue to visit races again and again. This is the magic of Horse Racing.
Regards
ayyarnet
Ayyarnet said ...
16-May-2021Hrses are not machines to reproduce the samespeed at different situation.
It all depends on the jockeys and the riding instructions given to them.
In Indiain a of 10 Horses only one or two Horses will be on the job and the rest are for conducting a Race or just to give company or even for claiming food subsidies !!
W are always fooled by the
Buddy said ...
15-May-2021The right thought process which comes with some amount of success good system is ...even if my play bet loses it will be right there in the thick of things[finish line] ... frankly a connoisseur of indian racing will know just before the bend how the race is going to unfold ....should not bet till you know the characteristics of each and every horse in the race ...how ready each horse are in the paddock ...and competition ....your selected horse ran in better or inferior company last time and the present lot ...compare ..... problem will arise if comparisions are not proper or ...you cannot judge the script/fitness in the paddock ........
Sumant Dalmiya said ...
15-May-2021Congratulations Glasgow prince
if I leave out the last para - The remainder of of your post in an extremely lucid introduction to the basis principles of handicapping
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now