Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Life Becomes Boring

By Husaain Mirza | 18-May-2021

Is coming month Bangalore will start or not?  Life becomes boring no racing no cricket 

 

Stay safe 

Post Your reply

48 Replies

Raghavan said ...

30-May-2021

Dancing dynamite,

"It is the bookies demanding lower tax.  Punters are paying that much.  Therefore, punters are not evading gst/tax".

You have a bretter sense of humor.  Well.  I am certainly not up voting your ideas.

"Punters can not plead ignorance of law if caught by IT officers".  100% correct.  If IT officers caught the tax evading punters, then they should cough up the tax payable plus the penalty.

You hate tote because it swallows huge portion of your bet as GST.  Yes.  I am jealous of Amitabh Bachchan, Aamir khan, Rajnikanth etc because they earn in 100s of crores.  But, our emotions should not be an excuse to evade tax.  One must honour what the law has specified.  

Raghavan said ...

30-May-2021

Ayyarnet,

Avoiding tax & evading tax are two different things.  There is no penalty for avoiding tax.  But penal provisions are attracted when you evade taxes.

So, about 20 years ago you staked 1,000/- in buying 10 tickets of 100/- each.  Well.  The dividend declared is 283.  So dividend per ticket of 100/- is 5,660.  And for 10 tickets it is 56,600/-, a profit of 55,600/-.   The threshold then was Rs. 2500/-.  I do not know how the tote clerk disbursed that much dividend.

Everyone goes into the racing to earn money.  But, bookies are responsible to collect the GST and club collection.  You are telling that it is perfectly all right on their part to collect lower tax as long as you do not insist for bet ticket.  I am totally against this.  Both punters and Bookies should respect the law of the land.

Betting small amounts that too on exotic & multileg pools is not remunerative.  Right.  But, to me the dividend declared though small is quite sufficient.  And, whenever my bets fail, I am losing small. 

And, I am advising all punters to follow this approach.  To teach a lesson to bookies.  But, I know there are not much takers for what I am preaching.

Raghavan said ...

30-May-2021

There was some problem in my computer.  So, it seems that the three letters that I posted have not reaches the destination.  So, a repetition.

Spade,

You are saying this much.

Suppose a punter bets 500 each in 20 races in a year; Only two bets pass giving him dividend of 1500 & 2500.  So, the profit in these two races is 3,000.  Of course, the other 18 bets failed & the loss is 9,000/-.

You are saying that a punter has to pay the tax on 3,000/- even though he is overall under loss.

I do not agree with your interpretation.  So, it is better if you give some additional information.  Please illustrate with at least 2 case laws where the court judge, tribunal judge or appellate authority has passed a speaking order upholding your point of view.

I still maintain that a pencil thief should not be placed at par with a bank robber.  You are disagreeing.  Not at all a problem to me.

So, I am getting personal with you by asking not to defend bookies.  Very good.  I do not see it that way.

You are asking me to stop speaking against bookies and instead concentrate on something constructive.  Sorry.  I continue in the same style that horsetalk members are familiar.

Raghavan said ...

30-May-2021

Ayyarnet,

Avoiding tax and evading tax are two different things.  There is no penalty for avoiding tax.  But, there is penalty for evading tax.

You say that you purchased 100/- worth of tickets 10 times that too 20 years ago.  The threshold limit then was 2500/- only and for 20 tickets your returns are 5660/- or 5560 profit per ticket.  Ten such tickets mean 56,600 or 55,600/- profit.  How the tote clerk paid you so much dividend without any TDS is beyond my imagination.

The jackpot winning tickets are bought for premium by many bookies also.  You are not telling anything new.  Certainly I have no objection on this aspect.  I am not  a purist.  I am not Harish chandra.

Every punter is coming to races only to earn.  And he is supposed to observe & respect all the Government Laws.  If, in the process of earning money, you are evading tax, then you must face the music whenever caught.   There is no escape. 

And, I consider it a blatantly illegal to bet with bookies and evade GST. 

For you it may be perfect arrangement on the bookies' part to collect bet at 10%, where both bookie and punter are benefited.  A majority of punters are in agreement with you.  I agree that my thinking is different.  But, absolutely it is not philosophical.

I  know I can not make money by betting low that too in exotic pools and multileg pools.  But, I am quite satisfied with the little dividend that I collect and smaller losses whenever my bets fail.  I am also advising punters to bet low and avoid falling in heavy debt trap.  That is the second best option.  The best option is to stop betting altogether.

"The club is offering so many pools to drain the pocket of innocent punters"!  

This is an unfair allegation.  Whether the club is inviting you?  Are they holding pistol pointed towards your head and forcing you to bet?  You should bet within your limits the money you can afford to lose.  If you overbet, you should blame only your indiscretion.  Should not be blaming the club.

"Please do not waste time with useless debate/s".  I do not consider the debate as useless.  If however any horsetalk member considers my musings as useless, so be it.  We are living in a free country.

Raghavan said ...

30-May-2021

Dancing dynamite,

"Punters pay less tax as demanded by the bookies.  They are not at all evading GST".  

You have good sense of humor.  I will definitely agree with your contention if bookies remit at least the 10% that they are collecting to GST authorities.

You are 100% spot on when you mention that ignorance of law can not be pleaded as excuse if and when caught by IT authorities.  I fully agree with you.  If IT people caught me evading tax, then I have no alternative but to pay as per their demand the income tax due & penalties if any.  But, I shall be extremely thankful if you can highlight some speaking orders from court, tribunal or arbitrator regarding tax liability.

You do not pay gst and tax on your bets and winnings.  I pay gst.  There is no escape.  The moment I punch ticket at tote, it will swallow the GST.  And tax is deducted at source if the winning exceeds 10,000.  

I had mentioned an hypothetical case of a punter winning 59,40,000/- but not paying even a single paisa tax.  A deafening silence from you on that point.  O K.  I fully agree that there are some tote players who are avoiding tax.  And, I will definitely appreciate if you start a new thread on that aspect.

The bookies have done a great disservice to punters and also cheated the Government & club.  If you prefer to gloss over such mischiefs by bookies, you can continue to do so.  But, do not try to argue that punters avoiding tax and bookies evading gst are one and same.  Several bookies from MUM, PUN, BNG etc have been caught evading tax and are now parading between courts, police stations  and lawyers.

Raghavan said ...

30-May-2021

Spade,

You are arguing that-

"If a punter bets Rs. 400/- each in 25 races in a year, loses 20 bets & gets dividend of 800/- each in the remaining 5 (including his investment of 400/- in those 5 races), then he has to pay income tax on the 2000/- that he won,

He should not expect any discount, relief etc because he lost 8000/-  in 20 races.   The win amounts should be treated in isolation and taxes must be paid. The losses sustained in races earlier or later does not discharge him from the liability"

I disagree with such interpretation.  Of course, if you have any case laws supporting your views, you can just highlight the order of the judge from Court, Tribunal etc.  (2 or 3 cases).  I may not be good like a Chartered Accountant or company lawyer in interpreting law.  But, I can certainly grasp the central idea of a speaking order from an appellate authority, judge,  or an arbitrator.

So, my suggestion that you should not defend bookies is personal attack on you.  Abdsolutely no comments.

I stand my my argument that a pencil thief should not be put at par with a bank robber.  You argue like a purist.  In that case, I would like to hear from you the quantum of income tax paid by you on your winnings from race betting/s.

You are also suggesting that I pass unsubstantiated judgements on stewards or turf club supervisors.  O K.  You continue with the idea that they are all honest & goody goody babies.  I have absolutely no objection.

You are asking me to introspect and be constructive.  Evidently,  you are asking me not to be too critical of bookies.  Certainly I have no idea to agree with your theories and advises.  I will continue in my own style.

In fact, earlier also, there were several responses from horsetalk members asking me to down play or ignore the mischiefs of bookies.   I am writing like this for at least 9 years.  But, so far, no bookie has refuted my arguments.  All hysterical responses are only from punters.  It is really amusing to note that there are so many punters who are so loyal and devoted to bookies.  O K.  Let them continue to stay "faithful for ever"  towards bookies.

Ayyarnet said ...

29-May-2021

Sri. Raghavan 

I refer to your response for Spade and others. Govt. needs monry to run the country to do all development work and to support its citizens. They have to collect money as taxes from every possible sources categorising the necessity sectors and luxury sectors. Taxes are levied with a less burden for common people or poor people. A person drinking alcocol may pay higher tax because alcohol is considered as a luxury item. Whereas a poor person buying a cloth or dress may pay less amount than his counterpart

buying alcohol.  GOVT. ITSELF OFFERS MANY AVENUES TO PAY LESS TAX ES by investment in many ways. Today we have many consultants to advise how to save money by paying less taxes.  You should not consider all these people are tax evaders and deserve punishment.

Around 20 years ago I was at Bangalore During March/April Bombay Races were going on. In one Race Jockey Marc Gallagher was riding horse belonging to Late Dr.MAM. I fancied his Horse. Tv screen showed Tote for a fiver dividend was Rs 283.00  I purchased Rs 100.00 bet for ten times  that is instead of  buying Rs 1000.00  I punched ten times Rs 100 tickets. 

To my surprise the horse won by half a length. I have cashed Rs 100 tickes separately. Suppose if I have punched Rs1000 in one ticket I may have to fill up form and pay TDS at the counter.  These are all part of the game.

You should not feel we are doing something wrong.  Years ago when I was working in Bombay many people used to come to Race club just before the last Race  with lot of money to buy Jackpot winning tickets with a small premium.  I am told that they are buying Jackpot winning tickets to cash Black into white. Theseare all Business Activities. You should not feel bad. After all we are all coming to Races to earn easy money money only !!!!! We should not be hypocritic.  Making money is indeed  an ART . You have to master it.  You have to think a bit Why you are going to Races. I will not accept that you are a Horse Lover that is why you are going to Races. If your intention is to make money you have to be an Business man or an Investor. You can never make money by buying Rs10 or 20  Forecast orTanana or playing at all Races. Majority of losers are small players only. You have to use your brain to to calculate the ROI  (Return on Investment) If a Bookmaker offer 50% tax concession what is wrong in giving a bet to him.  Basically you are coming to Races to make money only. If you thing philosophically this is wrong etc. you will never make money in Races.  Club is also offering too many pools to drain the pocket of innocent punters just to earn their commission only.  Many of us do not realise this. So please dont strain your mind by useless debate or discussion. Focus your attention on your target to EARN MONEY.

NO MONEY NO HONEY

Best Regards

ayyarnet

Dancing Dynamite said ...

27-May-2021

@RAGHAVAN, Punters are not evading tax. They are paying less tax (as demanded by the bookie).  its the bookies, who evades tax.

Secondly, nobody is here to teach income tax regulations.  There are income tax consultants to do that.  If IT people catch you for evading tax, you cannot claim that you dont know the provisions.

As regards evading tax, we both are in same boat.  I dont pay tax on bet and winnings.  You dont pay tax on winnings.  Both are unlawful activities.  I dont love bookies but yes, i do hate tote for eating our money shamelessly (on the pretext of commision tax etc.)

Buddy said ...

27-May-2021

raghu , no one is defending bookies , why should anyone , told you many time - the vendors - bookies vs tote - bookies are better -even there there are different class of bookies - do you think i or anyone would care [even a bookie feels happy when another bookie loses]  .....told you this 100 times but it seems idoes not register with you ... everyone tries hard to win its the most alert sharp brains that manage to win ,even among the bookies - manny bookies struggle to break even ...even after years of experience -

Spade said ...

27-May-2021

@Raghavan-

You agree that you are ignorant of IT provisions. You agree that you don't know the difference between TDS and income tax.  In other words you are agreeing that your statement 'when a punter bets on tote the payout will be only after deduction of income tax wherever applicable' is out of ignorance. Fine. Your honesty must be appreciated. Same is the case with the claim that the question of paying income tax does not arise because you have only been losing all the time.

I had given the section nos. you had asked for. Given that you are totally ignorant of income tax provisions, it is natural that they have not been of much help. My explaining further will be equally futile. It will also not be perceived to be authentic enough for your requirement. If you are serious about it you can refer the matter to competent local tax consultants.

You say that it was rash and irresponsible to suggest that you are breaking the law. No sir! Certainly not. Recently in some other thread you had said that you would be happy to achieve a strike rate of 15% indicating that your strike rate may be something like 10% or 12%. In any case even the dumbest of beginners keep winning off and on. That means you are winning one bet out of every eight or ten bets. These winnings are taxable even if overall you lose regularly. The losses can't be adjusted against winnings. Now imagine how many years you have broken the law. My statement is neither rash nor irresponsible.

You say 'You will appreciate that bookies' liability will not be exempted because some punters also violate the law. Agreed. You say in capital 'DO NOT EQUATE A PETTY THIEF WHO STEALS A DOZEN PENCILS WITH A DIEHARD THIEF WHO STEALS SEVERAL CRORES WORTH OF JEWELLERY'. Agreed but at the same time the petty thief can't point fingers at the bigger thief saying ' THE BIGGER THIEF SHOULD NOT STEAL. OH I AM ALSO STEALING BUT I AM ONLY A PETTY THIEF'. The petty thief as he thinks of himself should leave the job to the concerned authorities. In you latest post you have tried to drum up the support of other tote punters but you have to remember that you and you alone have been complaining about this issue. Not a single other punter has complained likewise.

You have also advised me 'Always stick to the subject matter. Never get personal. ' Agreed but you have yourself made it personal by telling me in your earlier post not to defend the bookies and now calling me their defence lawyer. You are yourself deviating from the subject, calling me names and giving me unsolicited advice.

You are also prone to passing judgments on others like the stewards and the race clubs. Here also you are giving them your unsolicited advice which you may think is terrific. Those judgments and advice are your personal opinions and that also makes it personal. On top of it the judgments are based on ignorance instead of sound knowledge as we have seen here. You comments which you consider are correct are a personal affront to each steward and each member of the managing committee of the club including the Chairman.

You have given me your unsolicited advice. I hope you will be ready to accept some in return. Instead of passing ignorance based judgments on others all the time it would be better if you introspect and judge yourself. At least there will be hope of some constructive activity then. Think about it and chill.

Raghavan said ...

26-May-2021

Dancing dynamite,

Spade is trying to paint all tote punters as tax evaders & specifically targeting me.  It seems you are also trying to fire from his shoulders!

It is OK if you two try to put me on the defensive.  Best of luck to you. 

As far as possible, withhold your temptation to jump to the aid/defense of the bookies.  If you desire to start discussion/debate on the issue of punters evading tax, the best course shall be to open a separate thread on that.  Let there be debate, heated debate on that subject. 

Let us suppose there are 2500 races in a year and a punter bets in 600 races.  If he wins all the 600 bets and wins 9900/- in every bet, there will be no tds.on his winnings eventhough his actual winnings are 59,40,000/-.  

So, it will be an interesting topic.  Start that topic and slam those punters who are evading tax.  But, try to educate horsetalk members of the tax provisions.  

People often confuse between provisions of income tax with provisions of gst.  Remarkable.  Bookies are really blessed for having such faithful defence assistants.  Of course, during the last two years, gst officers & commercial tax officers have given a resounding kick to bookies on their backside and have slapped the charge of economic offence/s against them.  Let all the experts in Law defend them.  Absolutely no problem.

It is really heartening that even in current days there are no non sense officers at key positions.

Dancing Dynamite said ...

25-May-2021

people often confuse between the provision of tax and provision for TDS at source.  They think that since TDS is not deductable before a certain amount, then that income is also not taxable.  They are so wrong.  

Raghavan said ...

25-May-2021

Spade,

Ignorance of I T provisions will not discharge me from liability to pay tax.  O K.  I do not know TDS & income tax.  That also O K.  I presume you are well versed in the subject of income tax.   So, tell me what has been told in Section/s 2(24)(ix), 115BB & 194B of income tax act,  what is TDS & income tax.   With illustrations, case laws. I have gone throiugh the rulings of sections that you have mentioned.  And, it is not of much help.  

It was indeed rash & irresponsible on your part to suggest that I am breaking Law.  There are some Laws which I flout.  For eg smoking while riding in auto, pillion riding without helmets etc.  But, be assured that I have never evaded paying taxes on winnings from races.  Race after race, day after day, year after year, I am only losing in the race betting.  So, the questuion of paying income tax does not arise in the first place. 

Whereas bookies do collect bets at half tax in total violations of Law.  And, when I am pointing out that you are acting as their defence lawyer.  But, I am sure you will appreciate that bookies' liability will not be exempted just because some punters also violate the Law.

Of course, I agree that there may be some winners among tote players who evade tax with impunity.  You slam them, tear them apart.  No problem.  As far as I am concerned, every person who cheats the Government must & should be punished.  And the punishment must be commensurate with the tax avoided/cheated.  But, do not  place those few punters who might be evading the tax by a few thousand rupees in the same category as bookies who may be having turnover in several crores.  DO NOT EQUATE THE  PETTY THIEF WHO STEALS A DOZEN PENCILS WITH A DIE HARD THIEF WHO STEALS SEVERAL CRORES WORTH OF JEWELLERY.

And always stick to the subject matter.  Never get personal.
 

Spade said ...

24-May-2021

@Raghavan - 

I don't know whether it will help to give the reference of IT rules since you don't know TDS from income tax. You will have to refer to sections 2(24)(ix), 115BB and 194B of the IT Act. You are always pointing fingers at others whether bookies or stewards even without knowing your own responsibility and liability. You are also breaking the law. Not knowing the law does not absolve anybody of his responsibility. It is necessary to understand the fundas properly whether it is about racing or income tax. 

Raghavan said ...

24-May-2021

Pradeep Pune,

Pleased to hear that  your son has succeeded in his fight against the virus disease.  I presume, he is younger and relatively has higher immunity.  

You have also seen death of your friends, relatives.  So, we should not hysterically argue for either resumption of races or cancellation of races!

You strongly believe that SHOW MUST GO ON!

There is nothing wrong in what you desire.  And you are not the only person who desires that racing should resume.  80 to 90% of punters desire that racing resumes in all possible centers.  And, I hope you will believe me when I say that I am also among those 80%.  I am not rallying behind those minority who prefer cancellation of all races.

But, what we desire, what we hope should meet the demands of common sense and reasonableness.   Bars are closed; (liquor sales only for 4 hours a day from 6 am to 10 am).  Restaurants are closed.  Cinema halls are closed.  Public parks are closed.  So, how can you expect the races to resume?  The items that I have mentioned are only illustrative; not exhaustive.  And, when those things limp back to normality, races will also restart.  

There are some die hard critics & pessimists whose narratives are always on the negative side.  It is rather pity that I am bracketed with those people when I try to be realistic.

Horse lover,

So, you are excited about the prospects of Indian horses in triple crown, Melbourne cup, Japan cup etc.    You sound highly optimistic.  Best of luck.

You are arguing that racing or casinos did not stopped at America.  May be.  But, do you believe that Indians are as much disciplined as US citizen?  Indians spit at everywhere.  Smoking everywhere in spite of "prevention of smoking in public places act".   And social distancing?  Punters should maintain distance of minimum of 2 meters.  But, at BTC near ticket issuing counters, there were at least 10 people in every 2 meters.   I was extremely worried that BTC will also become one of the hot spots that spread corona disease.  Thank God, Almighty has protected me till date.

In any case, we declare curfew, lockout etc based on situation/s prevailing in India.   America may be bold & confident, and permitting economic activities without any restrictions,  But, why we should imitate America?  We take decisions based on the expert committe advise in India.

There are too many instances of speedy recoveries among celebreties.  No comments.  May be you are correct.  Celebrities are definitely better off though some big names have been swallowed by the virus.

"Those who are ill should take treatment at hospital/s".  You are 100% correct.  But, in spite of the treatment being costly, there is a long queue of patients waiting to get admission in the hospitals.

"Why lock healthy youngsters"?  People should follow the rules / guidelines during lockdown/curfew.  You may be fully satisfied that lockdown/curfew are wholly unnecessary.  But, government does not worry about individual likes & dislikes.  The lockdown is imposed on citizen only after getting extensive feed back  and expert opinion.   Certainly I do not fault the government on this aspect.  It is true that youngsters feel as if they are under house arrest.  Even some elderly people may be terribly bored.  But, in a society, we must obey the rules & laws.  If anyone feels that the Government is arbitrary, dictatorial in declaring lockout,  they have to file a case in Court. 

Horse Lover said ...

24-May-2021

Dear ayyarnet 

Developed Nation Citizens can wager on following list online and offline. 

cricket,football, tennis, basketball,esports,hockey,baseball, ufc, golf,american football,boxing,cycling, darts, formula1, greyhounds, handball, horse racing, motor sport,politics,pool,rugby,swimming, pool, snooker and infinite list goes on.

Do you think every1 wager all sports at the same time? Practically not feasible! They wager the sports they like the most and know inside of its and skillfully pick the winner. Some are challenging if wagering is purged from horse racing they will not watch it. How will Indian escalate to the tag of Developed Free Nation with this type of mindset? So funny... For US and UK Govt. it does not matter which sports you like but they encourage to wager only the one, patrons love the most & are comfortable with. Hence, Horse Lovers were, are there and will always be there.

Same goes with Horse Racing. We like the speed,stamina, strides, stretching of horses, nose and neck wins, one horse race winner beating all by lengths, sounds of crowd,owners,trainers,jockeys backing their skillful picks & work. Not to forget the Fashion & delights come complimentary with it. People love to dress nicely during events. Patrons make new friends. Foodstalls owners wait for their repeat customers to order their favourite beer or eatables. 

Have you ever payed attension to the strong or weak front mascular shoulder of horse and when  you spot the difference one horse running with no effort in race to win while others struggling to chase its tail. That very moment we all either say "Yes, I picked Correct Handicap" & rest "Oh, I did not gather all information correctly and with full undivided focus".

Ruffina, Dersert God, adjudicate are few ones watch for repeat replays. Trust me you will lke to watch them again too. Good luck

Mohammed Nawaz Khan said ...

23-May-2021

HELLO EVERYONE AS OOTY RACES WAS RESUMING FROM 5JUNE 2021 BUT IN VIEW OF EXTENSION OF LOCKDOWN THE SEASON HAS BEEN CALLED OFF BAD NEWS FOR PUNTERS. THANK YOU. 

Syed said ...

23-May-2021

With TN Govt now enforcing complete lockdown until end of May OOTY races are almost wiped out, after June the rains start with kerala monsoon bringing plenty of rains to Ooty.. 

Horse Lover said ...

22-May-2021

The Goddess Andal will surely bless us all soonest & surely. 

Its Just so much fulfilling & lovely to watch Stylish strides & impeccable runs of cool sprinters likes RUFFINA( We all love catching undivided glimpse of this Miss Danehill(IRE) progeny Winning with little or no effort from jockey.  )

I wish post 5 years from now our indian horses mixed mutant improving breeds will beat US & UK Horses dashingly raising pride of our Indian Horses to next level & Shine accross the world.

The US horse, dog, car & other Racing Never paused since March 2020 when Indian went into a SUDDEN Full Lockdown Desocialisation just like previous SUDDEN Demonitisation of INR Notes. Every is Sudden since 2014 Now. The Racing was & is still creatively with organised safety protocols are occuring in USA these days. Infact Arlington Centre is also open USA now where jokey suraj narredu stole a win there too.

Is Corona not There in US?

 How Horse racing & Las Vegas is feasible in USA thes days also? We must learn from them atleast rather then after full 1 year Shutting Down & breaking all economic activities.

 

BLAMEing innocent public for not wearing mask etc is one the last tool of a looser. Blaming others rather than accepting inadequate medical preparation of the pandemic is just an excuse. Is USA blaming its citizens for not wearing mask and still runnning Sports comfortably? 

Sometimes I get a gut feeling that Corona & all its evoling mutants are 100% Biased. If film Stars's Family, Top famous Politicians', Top famous Sports Stars' are diagnosed Corona , they come out healthy with happy face after 15 days But if  poor or general citizens went to near hospital for corona treatement they died in 15minutes. This will remain a mistery forever for sure.   

Hope Horse Racing & All Sports Resume Soonest because pandemic & epidemic has now more become a Safe Tool to hide inefficiencies & improper management. Rapid Efficient Vaccication is the key to curb pandemic not blaming innocent for not wearing & doing repeated lockdowns.

If anyone is ill they should visit hospitals for treament Why lock healthy young generation unemployed inside home & make him/her sick too?

The only issues with Ooty Race Track is the "hort Straight" compared to the "long one" that of the mumbai one. The True potential of a horse is visible in a long straight. But to enjoy Racing at a hill station is its own fun so some compromise is ok with sharp turns of Ooty Race Tracks. Its good news if it starts in the first week of June. 

We love & miss Indian Horse Racing a lot during lockdown for sure & I am getting bore too without horse racing.

God Bless you all 

Pradeep, Pune said ...

22-May-2021

Dear All,

I too have suffered from the pandemic. My son had it & is now back to work. I too have lost few relatives, close friends & people around. If anyone approaches me for help, I do it to best of my capacities & capabilities. BUT, I strongly believe in one sentence-

SHOW MUST GO ON.

We have not stopped any routine activities in & after the pandemic. We have to work to earn our daily bread & butter(if possible).  World is having politics, Wars, International rivalaries & India is also facing the wrath of it. By good or bad ways Indians are also doing everything as usual to the extents- Hospitals & crooks are looting the public in general without bothering the wrath of the Almighty GOD. At the end of the day if one looks for any sort of entertainment, WHICH IS ESSENTIAL FOR MENTAL & PSYCHOLOGICAL STRENGTH  to fight the next day chore,let us not be too critical.

World & India has seen many such pandemics & has come out of it.

Finally if racing has to start, it will & those who want to enjoy it will do it. Rest critics are abundant all over the World for anything & everything, as it's their job( Do nothing constructive & but CRITICIZE).

India has not stopped after Gandhiji, Nehru ,Indiraji & Atalji & the list is unending.

Best thing is Work Hard, Help Hard to the needy & ENJOY HARD to live the life give by God.

See Ya!!!!

Ayyarnet said ...

22-May-2021

Please read my earlier posting as below

It got mutilated and wrong context joined. Thanks

Ha Ha

People say they love horses and races. 
Ha Ha

I doubt very much !  Just remove the betting from Races

Let us see how many horse or Race lovers turn up for Races !!!!

To be honest we are all lover of NOT Races or Horses but easy money !!!!!

There are many things that can replace Horse Racing. I love music both Carnatic or Pop music. I listen to music. Music is an excellent therapy to calm your mind and forget yourself.  Of curse we do have Kingfisher Premium also !!! Whenever I sip Kingfisher I remember our Dr.Vijay Mallaya for having created this nice drink and won many Races for us to make little money too. I am  really sorry for him. I pray that one day he will return to India to lead his winning horses again !!!

DrVijay Mallaya sir we have not forgotten you. you have a place in our hearts. We wish you a peaceful life wherever you may be.

Best Regards

ayyarnet

Golden Viper said ...

21-May-2021

Boredom  is  just  a  state  of  mind/

lmost  all states  are  in  lock  down mode hence  crores  are  effected yet  they  learn  to  live  with the  situation.

No  racing  does  not  end  of all  activity Plenty  of  other  sports on  TV 

Enjoy  life  as  it  comes ,there is  one  life so  make  the  best  use  of  it.

Resumption  depends  on  Covid cases I  do  ot  think  June  may see any  racing  at  all.

Raghavan said ...

21-May-2021

Spade,

So, even if a punter gains 10/-, that also should be declared and tax should be paid!  Well.  I am not aware of this aspect.  

If there is such a provision, then tote punters are also are cheating the Govt.   They should be charged under the relevant provisions of law and punished accordingly. 

So, please mention the relevant Income Tax rule, sub rule or any case law in support your interpretation.   

Bookies should not be exonerated just because punters are also indulging in tax evasion.  

Sps said ...

21-May-2021

Dear GODZILLA

Nice to see your presence after a long gap. Please keep visiting with something or other regularly.

Dear RACEBRO

After OOTIE races you have become RARE METAL, not at all visible.

Hope all is well. Please do visit the HT regularly.

Anoasku said ...

21-May-2021

Hopefully racing will resume by the end august, once 2nd wave sudsides, till then keep watching old horseracing videos in youtube,

Arunav said ...

20-May-2021

well done munesh bhai

Lightningstrikes said ...

20-May-2021

Godzilla is right , not 1000 a day but more than that , when will are HT members mourn these deaths , it's all my home , my children , my money who cares as long as I'm safe and my family and the race should go on , there is absolute no conscience with these Members only the knowledgeable and the meek and humble understand , 

Raghavan said ...

20-May-2021

Horse lover, 

The current scary situation may end in 3 months from now...OR it may drag on to three years.  No body knows.   

When will the Tamilnadu Government end its lock down?  If they consider that lock down is not at all necessary beyond 24th May, then there is some slim chances of  3 or 4 days' Ooty races.  The 1000g, 2000g & the Derby races may be held.   But, that is to hope very strongly for something although one knows it is not likely to happen.

Whether Ooty resumes or not is irrelevant to me since BNG is not taking bets on Ooty races.  To be frank, every punter should consider himself lucky that there are no races at Ooty.   Anyway, you seem to be highly excited, energetic.  Let your wishes come true.  Just pray Andal for your wishes to translate to reality.  (Andal, is the Goddess at Srivilliputhur.  And in the emblem of Tamilnadu there is an image of temple tower based on Srivilliputhur Andal temple)   

Spade said ...

20-May-2021

Raghavan I had replied you on that thread but it was not put up.

You say 'when a punter bets on tote the payout will be only after deducting the income tax wherever applicable.'

No sir. Only TDS is deducted if the payout is large I think more than 10k. TDS is a fraction of the tax payable. If the payout is lower than 10k no income tax is deducted. Even if a punter wins 10 rupees he is supposed to declare it by law and pay tax as applicable. There is no exemption. Not a single tote punter is doing that. They are also breaking the law. Everybody is in the same boat this way or that way. You are telling me that I should not defend bookies but at the same time you are defending tote punters.

Kabir said ...

20-May-2021

Mizra saheb

Ask the people who are in ICU,gasping for breathe what boredom is..ask a person who is waiting for long hours to hear from concerned people about well being of his loved one what boredom is..bhai you getting bored is a blessing in disguise,thank almighty as you are not in their shoes...forget racing atleast for this year...stay safe & be healthy throughout

Raghavan said ...

20-May-2021

Mohd Nawaz Khan,

"Ooty races will resume  on June 5th".

Really?  Very good. 

M B M said ...

20-May-2021

Let us be optimistic

Now covid 2nd wave

3rd wave is romoured

So on 4th wave

Then 5th have so on

We have to live with Corona

Let us hope races will start at the earliest as soon as all sports begin

Ooty  Bangalore.....

Will start soon

Be optimistic

 

Trevor L.. K said ...

20-May-2021

My journey as a punter started in 2013 with 10k i have only 2l liabilities at that time now i have 30l in mean while i loose my house some properties still i have 30l liabilities before pandemi i have only way to clear liabilities is race now i realised if i am think about race affter pandemic also then suicide is better option for me i loose every thing in racing i will give party if thise below persons dead

1-nelidarsha

2- ss attalohi

3-s narredu

4-Trevor 

5- suraj narredu

6- m boby

1-nelidarsha

 

Ayyarnet said ...

20-May-2021

Ha Ha

 People say they love horses and races. Ha Ha

I doubt very much !  Just remove the betting from Races

Let us see how many horse or Race lovers turn up for Races !!!!

To be honest we are all lover of NOT Races or Horses but easy money !!!!!

There are many things that can replace Horse Racing. I love music both Carnatic or Pop music. I listen to music. Music is an excellent therapy to calm your mind and forget yourself.  Of curse we do have Kingfisher Premium also !!! Whenever I sip Kingfisher I remember our Dr.Vijay Mallaya for having created this nice drink and won many Races for us to make little money too. I am  really sorry for him. I pray that one day he will return to India to lead his winning horses again !!!

Dr. Vijay Mallaya sir we have not forgotten you. you have a place in our hearts. We wish you a peaceful life wherever you may be.

Best Regards

ayyarnet

 

Pg said ...

20-May-2021

First and foremost Thank God that we are still living, while many of our family, relatives and friends are no more with us. 

Regarding other countries having racing, their govts were very strict and contained this damn virus, right at the beginning itself,while many amongst us are still roaming without masks, nor distancing.After most being affected, our leaders are now having lock-downs. Are our Netas following the proverb " Better late than Never " .

If we also could be strict and take early anti-covid action, we could be attending races today.

Enjoy this time with your family, for one may not get so many months time again to be with them.

God protect all.

Munesh said ...

19-May-2021

My 1st horse IVA Bhat won.It was backed down to 4/1 at the race time,

 

Mohammed Nawaz Khan said ...

19-May-2021

HELLO FRIENDS WHEN THERE IS NO RACING EVERY PUNTER FEELS BORING BUT OOTY WILL RESUME FROM JUNE 5TH 2021.SO LET'S WATCH AND SEE. THANK YOU. 

Godzilla said ...

19-May-2021

Mirzapur Saheb

Millions are suffering from COVID, thousands are dying, I am aghast, you are worried about Cricket and Racing. 

Have a heart. 

Horse Lover said ...

19-May-2021

Indeed, its like all lovely colors are forcefully snatched away from a rainbow in the sky after rain!

We are missing Immortality, Star Superior,CONSIGLIORI,COORG REGIMENT,SALAZAAR, CAVALLO VELOCE & KNOTTY ASH a lot.

Thse Lockdown Waves will continue like 1,2,3,4, and 5 so on till 2024... IT does not mean we pause sports like horseracing which can be conducted with all safety protocols.

We are waiting to see the all in action with later fashion.

Plzzz resume racing soonest at atleast at Ooty!!!!! to watch MEGASTHENES,& TUDOR TREASURE in touch and close fight neck to neck win


Please Vote to Resume FOREVER all sports again soonest with safety protocols. thats it...

Ganesh said ...

19-May-2021

Is Ooty racing is closed?

Deepak Jadam said ...

19-May-2021

What u said is really happening brother very boring 

Munesh said ...

19-May-2021

Scan English and Irish flat racing

 

Today two good bets

Cork 7.40 IST 4th race 6 IVA Batt 10/1

Ayr 5th race 8.50 IST 7  Radrizzani 12/1

 

Hussain said ...

18-May-2021

Hi Mirza Bhai,

                           It all depends on the graph of Corona virus in Karnataka.By the grace of Allah the decline is sharp.Lets keep our fingers crossed till end of this month.

 

Pilla Sathish said ...

18-May-2021

Next month any races started or not tell me bro

Raghavan said ...

18-May-2021

Hussain mirza,

"Stay safe"!  Repeat that 1000 times. 

Please forget about BNG, MYS summer season.  Monsoon races at HYD, KOL & PUN extremely doubtful.  Consider yourself lucky if winter season commences during November 2021.

People say they are bored.  People say they love horses and races.  And they will start asking the club/s to start racing.  If races commence, then they will start pestering the club to give permission to bookies.  And when bookies start functioning, they will hysterically blame owners and trainers for their act of unleashing doosras/theesras.  

Even I am also interested in races starting punctually at all the centers.   But, what I desire and what I desire not is totally irrelevant.

The Government has veto power regarding starting or halting the races.  Let us presume that the Government applies its mind and take a well reasoned decision.  Let us pray that covid 19 2nd wave and the upcoming 3rd wave is tamed effectively.

Ruchi said ...

18-May-2021

EARLIEST racing in INDIA will start by August, September

Buddy said ...

18-May-2021

Lots of cricket coming from june - the hundred ball cricket will make the game more exciting ,some new rules being framed .                                                     As long as you cannot move freely life will be boring ...nothing can replace that.

Sammy said ...

18-May-2021

Yes that's true. Even ooty races felt like Mahalaxmi races, to be in these desperate times. I think again the cycle of racing starting and ending will be same as last year. No summer races at our favourite BTC

.