Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Raising Roi By Achieving Higher Average Odds: Truth Or Myth?

By Glasgow Prince | 23-Jun-2021

In his post of 18.6.21 under the thread 'Mistakes That Punters Make' by Ab-delhi, Ksmrow has made some very interesting observations. I had tried to clarify the subject matter albeit in passing, in my last topic 'The Racing Puzzle: Food for Thought'. Ksmrow's post has brought it into focus once again nudging me to share my thoughts more elaborately.

A disciplined and meticulous punter normally has a system that is based on well acknowledged factors such as weight advantage, form, track work, jockey caliber, suitable distance, etc, that are too well known to be repeated here. When such a system gives out a selection, its odds will be in the range of on money to a maximum of 4 to 1. There may be exceptions where the odds may be higher but they will be negligible. ( I am precluding the realm of hunch and instinct wherein a punter will bet on horses with 8 to 1 or 10 to 1 odds as this can work both ways, positive or negative more often than not negative, with the punter losing all control over his net score.) In such a scenario, it is impossible that the punter can achieve average odds of 4.6 per winning bet. In the light of the foregoing, the practicality of achieving the returns calculated on the basis of the 72 races of Bangalore Winter Season 2018 needs to be reviewed.

Now let us consider a system that gives a strike rate of 30% (3 winning bets of 10 total bets). The system will throw up selections irrespective of the odds. The actual odds may be anywhere between on money to 4 to 1 as explained in the preceding paragraph. Further, the system does not give the winning probability of the selection. In other words, each selection will have the same winning probability. They system will yield a strike rate of 30%, only if all its selections are religiously bet on. In this case, the average odds needed to break even will be 2.67 (8/3) assuming 10% tax.

Let us now see what happens if the punter decides to pass selections that are on money in a bid to lift his ROI. When he passes a selection that is at on money and if it turns out to be a winner, the strike rate will further drop down to 22% (2 winning bets out of 9 total remaining bets). The average odds of these two winners will have to be 3.95 (7.9/2) for him to break even. If we assume a uniform increase in odds for each successive bet starting from on money to 4 to 1 across a span of 10 successive bets, it can be readily seen that the punter will incur a substantial loss over a period of time.

Similarly, if the system gives a strike rate of 40% (4 winning bets out of 10 total bets), the average odds needed to break even will be 1.75 (7/4). If the punter foregoes an on money winner, his strike rate will drop down to 33% (3 winning bets out of 9 total bets) and the average odds of these three winners will have to be 2.3 (6.9/3) for him to break even. It is unlikely that he will make a very substantial profit over a period of time.

Obviously, if the on money selection that the punter has passed fails to win, he will be much better off but he has no way of predicting whether it will win or lose. If he tries to force the odds, he can fall into a trap of his own creation.

Post Your reply

91 Replies

Glasgow Prince said ...

25-Jul-2021

Chanakya,

Your post of 23.7.21 / 8.49 pm: 

Even if I am selective (which I wouldn't be) it would only improve the outcome. So, Hakuna Matata.

Your post of 23.7.21 / 11.48 am: 

The answer to your question 'why can't another punter do the same?' has already emerged in my summarization - each punter is unique in many ways as demonstrated by the diverse responses even from a limited number of participants. If that is your aim then all this time consuming mathematical exercise will be fruitless. No one can replicate your system unless you teach them how you make your selections. 

Chanakya said ...

23-Jul-2021

GLASGOW PRINCE,

you can use the  worst  performance  as  a  referece from HT and  my  blog  to assess the  performance  of  my selections - I have  no  objection at  all; but  don't  be  selective  use  ALL the postings  from  both sites...

Chanakya said ...

23-Jul-2021

GLASGOW PRINCE,

You are  welcome  to  carry out  your  checks  on  my claims by  using  worst  performance from  blog/HT posts - I have  no  objection. Your  point of discarding  12/3/20 post is  also  accepted.

Many times I've  not  posted  my  selections for Mumbai & Bangalore races  due  to  long  travel  time as  you  pointed  out and  few  times  I've  posted  my  choice on  my  blog  only and  not on HT.

My intention was and  still is  to make a  punter  realise  that  it  is POSIBLE to make  money  from  races and for  a smart  punter  it is  even  possible  TO LIVE  ON  THE  EARNINGS FROM RACES! By  improving the  system  alonwith the  betting  strategy IF it  is  possible  for  me WHY  CAN'T  ANOTHER  PUNTER DO  THE  SAME!

Ofcourse  it  took  me  years rather  several  decades  to  achieve that because  of  no  exposure  to  computer and  internet  it  may  take  only  months for  a  sincere  punter  to  achieve  that today...

Glasgow Prince said ...

22-Jul-2021

Chanakya,

I am going into the details only because you have made certain assertions with some supporting data. My intention is to make an objective assessment. If I were to take the worst performing selections between HT and your blog and even then if they were to give positive results, the outcome would have been beyond question. That was the reason why I felt that the worse performing selections should be taken. Be that as it may. Since you don't agree, I will not do so.

I agree with your suggestion that selections from either HT or your blog should be taken. In any case, the selections on your blog are too few and far between. During the period 29.12.19 to 12.3.20 you had given your choices on HT only on 14 days out of the 17 days of racing of the Mumbai season. However, in your supporting data, while giving the outcome of the Mumbai season, you have considered 15 posts which also  take into account the choices given on your blog for 12.3.21. These choices were not given on HT. Consequently, these should be excluded and the outcome of only 14 posts on HT should be considered.

Chanakya said ...

19-Jul-2021

Glasgow Prince,

The closing odds are given  by BOL & also  by Cole for  all the  centers. Bookies -official or  unofficial  operate everywhere including  Pune! Closing odds of  Bol are  my  reference...

HT takes time, sometime more than  an hour to  publish and  it takes  me  one  to  1 1/2 hour  to  reach Mahalaxmi by  car, therefore during  this  period  I do  carry on  my  study and  sometime post  different choices on  my  blog which  are  for  my  friends who  live  far  off  places - Delhi, Bangalore  etc. I can't  waste  time  for  attending telephone  calls...

Finally an advice- you  can't jump  over  from one  ship  to  another; i.e., either choose  HT or  my  blog for  your  observations. In my  cals I've selected  only  those postings which have appeared  in HT, though many  of  my  choices  giving  positive ROIs are not added  because they  were  NOT posted  there...

However, you  are  free to carry out  checks and  use the worse performances as  standard  for  your  observation like  kautilya which  does  not affect  me...

In fact, I am totally  disillusioned since  long  and reducing to  barest  minimum my  interaction on  these  sites which serve no  useful  purpose for  punters  like  me and  glorify the losers which  no  other game in  the  world  does!

you are  bit  late, otherwise  if  you  had asked  this  question while  on  1st. page the  thread  would  have  easily  crossed 3 figure mark while  it  may  not  even touch 90... 

Glasgow Prince said ...

17-Jul-2021

Chanakya,

While studying the performance of your system I found that the odds for Bangalore races for the period 29.12.19 to 13.3.20 are not given on IR perhaps because the bookies may not have been operating. Which odds have you taken while calculating the profit?

While doing some spot checks, I noticed that sometimes your choices given in HT are different from those given on your blog. Can you please clarify?  I found that on 8.3.20, there was a profit of 2.75 units as per the choices given in HT but a loss of 5.15 units according to the choices given on your blog. In my opinion, the worse performance should be considered for working out the overall profit and loss in the case of such differences in choices.

Glasgow Prince said ...

16-Jul-2021

The Doc,

I am intrigued by the performance of Chanakya's system. I am studying the data available on Indiarace and HT and will come up with my observations shortly. Hope to find something meanigful and revealing.

 

The Doc said ...

14-Jul-2021

GP sir has managed to stir up a good discussion. It has been a very healthy discussions without any untoward posts. After a long long time i have witnessed this phenomenon. I hope the HT members will always maintain this decorum and keep pushing the momentum forward. 

Eagerly waiting from another thought provoking post from GP sir. 

If pune season happens then I will catch up with you. 

Raghavan said ...

12-Jul-2021

Sun,

I do agree that one can not challenge the odds as long as Chanakya is referring to the odds published in BOL or official results page.

But, in his profit claims, he has not cared to account for the 10% tax collected by the bookies.  For the sake of credibility at least he should have reduced the profit amount by 10% commission charged by the bookies.  When Auditor or myself pointed out that, he says that he is betting at much higher odds than what is published in BOL.  

I am least bothered whether Chanakya wins 10 lakhs or 100 cr.  All that I am asking him is he should not crow about the pluses and minuses after the race.

Chanakya has not stolen one rupee from my purse.  Nor I have stolen one rupee from his purse.  There is absolutely no dosti or dushmanee from my side.  Let him not misuse this site for self glorification.

******

You are sufficiently senior.  May be you are couple of years younger or older than me.  Absolutely no problem.  I am questioning anyone who is making such profit claims.  When other horsetalk members who are tipping here do not boast about their winning/s why should Chanakya act differently?

Several people have advised me to stop bashing Chanakya.  Let me take a decision on that aspect at an appropriate time.

Sun said ...

12-Jul-2021

@GP,

   Perhaps I should have said Normally I don't look at Right Side of the Card unless  a horse comes into reckoning under my System,Secondly I am obsitnate in the sense I don't change my choice looking at factors like Change of Shoe.Distance Suitability etc because as you rightly said that if on all counts a horse qualifies for bet it can only happen to be Odds On Favourite.I am flexible in revising my method of calculations

Thanks

@ Chanakya,

I should have written that the Time I allocate for Racing matters does not permit me.

Thanks 

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

11-Jul-2021

Hi All,

The sheer diversity of responses in terms of beliefs and conclusions has been revealing as well as intriguing. It shows as nothing else can, how each punter has a unique understanding of this game.

Sun says that he doesn't look at the right side of the card (jockey etc.) while some punters who follow jockeys look ONLY at the right side of the card to see who is riding. He sees obstinacy as an advantage while Ksmrow clearly values flexibility considering the different selection methods and betting strategies that he has been trying.

Chase feels this is not a business. This is not cricket or a tennis game. ROI and Strike Rate don't apply here. On the other hand, many analysts feel that a punter doesn't succeed mainly because he doesn't approach race betting as a business. ROI and Strike Rate have been used for decades to evaluate the effectiveness of a punter's system. There is no restriction on the tools that a punter can use if they help him. In fact an innovative punter will always look for tools that haven't been used in the past. 

Sun is of the view that the discussion has been educative. On the other hand Raghavan feels that this discussion of ROI, Strike Rate, etc. is purely theoretical in nature. In reality, the only thing that counts is your bet on a horse and where that horse finished. 

HP++ made a very poignant observation that for every 25 SELL windows there is only 1 PAY window. If we assume that the average footfall per window is uniform, it means on an average 4% of the punters are winners. He very emphatically feels that no method can make you win in races.

The Doc has opened a new thread about the psychology of a punter citing an article which says that the fundamental flaw in the psychology of a punter lies in thinking that HE IS SPECIAL. My take is that if a punter simply says to himself 'I DON'T KNOW', he opens up the POSSIBILITY OF 'GETTING TO KNOW'. He signals to himself his willingness to explore, to try different ways and to harness new tools in his quest to join that group of 4%. He creates a whole new mindset for himself. How many punters can honestly say that they have given their best shot, tried their hardest before coming to the conclusion that no one can win in racing?

Sun said ...

10-Jul-2021

@Raghavan,

 In place of Shp one can Eat the favourite which can be Shp equivalent with bookies.

Regarding why i have not commented earlier on his posts  My answer is there is no point in driving home that point on Profitability of his selections which is clear to anyone who is a member of HT, Here I may add that we can calculations based on Tote Dividends only, He does not Play on Tote and Bookie Odds in Race Books are Closing Odds only.If he says he played at higher Odds than Closing Odds there is no means to check.

I don't know whether I am senior to you in age or not but my advice to you is to leave this topic  and  concentrate on other aspects of Racing.

Thanks.

Chanakya said ...

10-Jul-2021

@ Sun,

You claimed - 'seldom see .... suitability etc.'. In that  case  acceptance are published on  thursday, declaration on friday, for Sunday races. You have plenty  of  time to analyse  7 or 8 races in 2 1/2 days till the  actual  race time.  'Short of time'  excuse  does  not  fit in with your claim...  

Hp++ said ...

10-Jul-2021

https://www.quora.com/What-is-considered-a-good-ROI-in-sports-betting

Raghavan said ...

10-Jul-2021

Sun,

Shp may give decent dividends.  But, why mention this to Chanakya.  He will never bet at tote; and bookies do not take bets for shp.

So, your bets are at tote.  Betting at tote is OK if you bet some long shots (odds 8/1 or above).  If you are betting the horse that are 1st, 2nd or 3rd favorite, there will be disappointment only.  Even when your bet is passed.   Because, the win dividend is normally 30% to 40% less than what is quoted by the bookies.  

There was bet of 1k from me at tote during the early days of gst.  The horse was quoted 5.0 to 5.5 by bookies at Mysore.  There were no bookies at BNG that day.  My bet passed but the dividend was just 30/-.  This forced me to stop betting for win or place at tote.  

Anyway let us watch the dividends at BNG hereafter.  Whether  the management passes the benefit of Court order to punters or simply jack up the club commission!

However,  relatively SHP dividends are better.  Though the rate of gst for shp pools are the same as for win/place pool.  

"Favorites may lose.  Favorite may find it difficult"  Statements like this flow from Chanakya's pen very often.  He claims he won 10 lakhs by eating favorites.  In a space of 15 days.  And, I questioned his claims.  For more than 5 years.  Because I am sure of one thing.  That he has not won 10 lakhs.  

Today, yourself, Kautilya, Champ etc are questioning Chanakya.  But, all of you were silent earlier.  I do not think you people questioned Chanakya even when he made a shocking claim of place dividend on Malavika!

I have no dosti or dushmanee against Chanakya.  I only ask him not to use this site for self glorification.

Sun said ...

09-Jul-2021

@ksmrow,

Thanks for sharing my past ROI figures.In those days there was no internet betting and my mind ruled my Selections.As rightly pointed out by GP when real money is involved the heart rules the mind and sometimes the selections flater especially when you wait for movement Odds to decide between 2 equally qualified horses.

Fortunately for me I am an obstinate person and i give more importance to Calculations.I seldom see to the right of the Race Card for Jockey or Pedigree,or Distance Suitability etc

I hope improve my strike rate at Good Odds and be in profit in the ensuing seasons.

In 2019 it was not required to give X number of selections and hence I could participate in the Context.The new contest with  scoring similar to Hongkong Jockey Chanpionship method is also good but to give 6 choices on a day it is little tiresome.

I can analyse 2-3 races and for the remaining races I can nominate the Favourite but somehow it was not appealing to me.

Thanks.

Raghavan said ...

09-Jul-2021

ksmrow,

I refuse to visit HYD either personally or through any representative, to check your claims of winning bets.  I think I have made my point clear in my earlier posts also.  But, you seem to be determined to ignore that point.

The question I asked is simple.  Out of 195 double bets, how many bets actually  passed that gave you dividend of 2,30,000/= .  Of course, you are fully at liberty to ignore that question.

Yourself beating the drum?  Myself crowing?  Absolutely unnecessary words/sentences from you.  I neither disbelieve you nor believe you.  You please resist the temptations to project me as doubting Thomas.

You desire to overcome the various pitfalls?  You continue searching answers for that.  Best of luck to you.  Not only you; all punters are searching that elusive answer.  

You are not the first person I have questioned.  You will not be the last either.  People who claim wins should be ready & willing to answer some straightforward questions.  If they are not willing to answer, that is their right.  I fully appreciate their right. 

But, they should avoid responding to questions with additional questions or impractical suggestions.

Ksmrow said ...

09-Jul-2021

 

@SUN,
Just look at your record it is by any standard very good performance
On : 24-08-2019 08:03 pm

ROI+ List Pune 24/8:-

Sun  2/3  Roi+301%
On : 23-09-2019 10:10 pm

23 sep Hyderabad selections +ROI List;

SUN   3/3  ROI+121%

On : 11-09-2019 07:25 pm
Selections of Mysore11/9 ROI+List.

J W C  5/13  ROI+117%????

Prinit  2/4   ROI+84%????

Raj B  5/12  ROI+82%????

Againstodds  3/7  ROI+43%

PK Nandan  1/5  ROI+27%

SUN   1/5   ROI+27%

Shriyan  2/8   ROI+24%

Jai Kumar  4/13  ROI+20%

C R K  2/7  ROI+15%

Ksmrow  4/9  ROI+6%

Ashok Mysore  3/16  ROI+3%

others with less than roi-10% are

A $ B(4/8) and Racebrio(4/8)
Selections of Mysore11/9
Ksmrow said ...

On : 19-08-2019 08:44 am

Sun 3/3 ROI+424%
On : 02-09-2019 07:49 pm

@SUN, yes I missed your score is 3/5 ROI+192%

 

Kautilya said ...

09-Jul-2021

@ Sun

 

you are right. I have proven the bogus claims of the pathological liar and  megalomaniac. By selectively picking few race days of positive ROI he is claiming he has won. But the facts shout otherwise. One thing i now, real winners are watching this circus quietly and smirking. 

Raghavan said ...

08-Jul-2021

Glasgow Prince,

Betting on a high priced horse is desperation.  Because of the pounding a punter has received at the hands of bookies, the cash balance at the end of 4th or 5th race of the day will be around one-tenth of the amount that he had before the start of 1st race.

There is no rule that a 15/1 horse or a 20/1 horse should not win.  But, the hapless punters can never bet on such horses as a matter of routine.  At best, a punter who normally bets 2200/- or 5500/- per horse may try a small fling.  Around 550/- to 1100/-.  

It is my firm belief that a regular punter (that means one who visits race course at least 2 days in a week) will be always running short and will be desperately searching for his friends, relatives, private money lending Shylocks to fund his gambling habit.  The chances of winning with such borrowed money is BIG BIG ZERO.  

For 3 or 4 years, I have functioned as in-charge of PTR contest.  I have finished in top four many times.  The reason is simple.  I used to stake heavily the short priced favorites that fortunately clicked.  But, in real races?  I was never betting on paisa favorites.  I was betting on favorites or 2nd/3rd favorites and the one condition that I insisted was the minimum payout at tote on the horse that I bet should be 20/- for a tenner.  

I was betting 500/- or 1000/- at tote.  I was never tempted to bet with bookies.  At tote, the payout was marginally lower or marginally higher than what bookies offered.  But, the new gst rules disturbed that equation, Tote payments in the new gst era happened to be 30% to 50% less than what bookies offered.  So, I stopped betting for win or place at the tote.  

THE GST RATE FOR HORSE BETTING IS REAL GEM OF A RULE.  AT LEAST TO ME.  THE OFFICERS WHO ADVISED THE GOVERNMENT THE GST RATES DESERVE ALL ROUND PRAISE.  Many punters who used to bet at tote stopped betting outright or started betting with the bookies.  Now, I bet only on forecast pool and win one out of 7 or 8 races.  

But, what angers me is the non stop boasting of self glory that one punter is indulging.  He says he bets 12 to 20 races everyday and yet commanding a healthy ROI of 35%.  I have demolished his win claims.  But, that punter succeeds in finding one or two believers (suckers) among horsetalk members, in front of whom he is unleashing his rather unconvincing bravados.  He says his strike rate moved between 22% to 55% and rewarded him with 35% ROI.  A big big lie.  Let him mention at least 3 race days during the period 7th November 2020 and 9th  April 2021, (5 months)  where his strike rate was 50% or more.  I will tender my apologies to him.  

Barring those who were lucky enough to win single ticket jackpot, all punters are in loss only.  The winners are bookies, club & Government.  A punter requires not more than 1,000/-  to win one lakh in one month.  (theoretically). But, how many punters can boast of 8  to 10 lakh profit in one year? In one year's betting,  punters may be in loss of 50k to 20 lakhs.  This discussion of ROI, strike rate etc are purely theoretical in nature.  In reality, the only thing that counts is your bet on a horse and where that horse finished.

So, I have just one advise to the punters.  Never bet more than 1% of your bank balance.  You have earned that much money because of your hard work.  Do not liberally donate it to bookies.  And, at no point of  time give credence to those who traps unsuspecting suckers with sugar coated lies of big profit/s.

Glasgow Prince said ...

08-Jul-2021

(Continuation 3)

Each punter is unique in that he has his own understanding of the game, his own preferences and inclinations and his own expectations from betting. All these aspects shape a punter's selection method not only in terms of the parameters he uses but more importantly in terms of the weightages he assigns to those parameters - formally or intuitively. Some may give more weightage to pedigree, some to ratings, some to track work, swimming and tread mill data, some to video replays, some to trainers' strategies and so on. Consequently, the selection method of each punter can throw up a different selection for the same race.

Since the selection method used by each punter is unique, it follows that each punter's method will work best in certain situations wherein it will give the best results. These could be those races wherein the parameters he gives higher weightages to, outweigh other factors. Over a period of time a vigilant punter will be able to recognize his 'winning zone' wherein he will get the best returns with his particular selection method and betting strategy. How much money he can make in the long run will largely depend on how well he can recognize this winning zone and how disciplined he remains in sticking to it. A punter's temptation to overreach or to drift from this winning zone in quest of long shots is often the cause of his downfall.

I have seen a lot of punters frantically betting on what is popularly called 'colour' in punters' parlance. 'Colour' is a double edged sword and if read wrongly, it can be extremely harmful to a punter's financial health. Having said that, I dare say that the bookies are the best 'informants' that a punter has but neither the punters nor the bookies are aware of it. This is my personal experience and no offence meant to anyone.

Finally, at this moment, I am reminded of one of the more erudite but unpretentious erstwhile writers on HT - Barbaad Punter. When asked why he had selected this unusual moniker, his wry reply was that he wanted to be reminded over and over again that a punter is his own enemy. 

Thanks

Glasgow Prince

Ksmrow said ...

08-Jul-2021

Raghavan,

I gave  sentence wise answers  to your post dated 1/7 in My post of 6/7 please read what You wrote  and my reply for that one By one, asked not to divert and

Accept my proposals.

Option one my invitation for your Personal visit and meeting me and my bookie clearing  all your doubts you turned  down ok what ever the reason,

Option two asking some body to represent on behalf of you and verify for this you

Have not said yes or no till today.

Iam not beating  the drum  about my feats in racing one thing i can say  iam just measuring the depth of various pitfalls and trying how to over come ,  never  made any comments on your beliefs about racing or objected on your crowing on ths issue almost every day .

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

08-Jul-2021

(Continuation 2)

A punter goes through an evolutionary process starting from being a total novice to being a casual punter and finally to being a serious punter. The stage at which he stabilizes depends on his psyche. A novice is blissfully unaware of the intricacies or the pitfalls. He is content with taking in the thrill of the grand spectacle and having a kick with a bet here and there while gorging on snacks and a cup of tea or a pint of beer. A casual punter may or may not be a serious student of the game, usually bets low and is happier with the thrill of betting rather than the returns that he garners. He gets more intoxicated by the high of landing long shots than by the thrill of streaming in modest but steady returns. He is not much bothered about the moderate win or loss that he may incur. A serious punter is more focused on his returns and consequently more conscious of the tools he uses to make his selections. The effectiveness of his selection method dictates his betting strategy. He is constantly on the lookout for ways and means to improve his selection method and refine his betting strategy.

Sun said ...

08-Jul-2021

@GP.

  There can be no two opinions on that Wagering with one's hard earned money and using Points sanctioned OR posting on the Selections thread are all together different.

When playing with Cash fear of losing the money  takes precedence over getting higher returns.

Only when one is wedded to his System can he bet on high priced horses irrespective of the Odds and more so if such system is based more on Quantitative Methods tham Qualitative pointers.

Thanks for educating punters on Strike and Profit Scenarioes.

@Chanakya,

I know you give 2,3 and sometimes 4 choices per races.What I said is  based on the Calcultions done even at 40% strike rate the marginal Odds increase steeply and one may not be able to get such strike rate consistently.

Though I have not calculated your returns for any longer time.A cursory glance after many eace days I found it to be a loss.Many times you comment saying that in so and so race Favourite may lose.The word May and Favourite are vague terms.If 2 horses are well placed,the Odds keep on changing and on Results page which is shown as Tote Favourite can be any of the 2 horses.For me it happened so many times my choice is not Faourite to start but I get poor returns,Next time you may name the horse and a positive statement that it will lose will be appreciated.Sometimes you also add Astrolpgically by which are we supposed to infer that Handicapping wise it comes into reckoning but will fail

Perhaps I did not make myself clear on the third point raised by you.My endeavour has been to select only one horse in a race.Sometimes when a longer Odds horse is selected it may come second but the Dividend is Good so to have a porfit in such races even after betting on Win,Shp or Place OR a combination of 2 but on a particular horse.This will improve the strike and also Profit 

I find Shp dividends on Favourite are normally good and for that matter Shp dividend is always good. So as Favourites are Winning 30% of the time will a Win&Shp on favourite will it improve my strike rate.We have 30% Wins we may get dividend of say Rs 16 and out of 70% if Shp success rate is 45% say 30 dividends will my profit improve.When Favourite Wins my loss is Rs 4 only.

Does this make sense veterans to comment.

 

 

 

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

08-Jul-2021

Correction:

The last sentence in the second last paragraph of my previous post should read as "Statements in the selections thread such as 'favourite may win or favourite may lose' are totally ambiguous because such probability exists for each race."

Error is regretted.

Glasgow Prince said ...

08-Jul-2021

(Continuation 1)

Deal All,

This is in continuation of my previous post.

Various contests are conducted on HT and there is also a selection thread wherein tipsters give their choices. However, it would be unrealistic not to recognize and acknowledge the difference between a contest / selection thread environment and the real life betting environment. The approach and strategy to do well in a contest can be radically different from the one adopted in actual betting even by the same individual essentially because the objectives are fundamentally different. For example, in a bid to score high, a contestant can easily nominate a fluke and take his chances because no monetary stakes are involved. In actual betting, the same contestant may reduce his bet or not bet at all when he finds his selection at fancy odds! Of course there will be some contestants whose primary objective will be to genuinely test the effectiveness of their selection methods.  

A contestant never comes under financial pressure and the resultant mental pressure as he would in real betting if he happens to lose at a stretch. Even then we find that there are a number of contestants whose capital gets eroded by the end of the contest. Even if some tipsters make a profit on a given day, what is more important is whether they do so consistently. Otherwise even at the race course the tote declares winning dividends every day indicating that there are some winning punters each day. 

Similar is the case with the selections thread. We have seen that at times tipsters give their selections and if they fail, they casually say that they had given their selections without study or at a cursory glance or before the odds were known. Would they voluntarily say that if their selections were to click? Some tipsters even subsequently claim that they bet on some totally different horse (obviously the winner) than the one given in their selections. It shows a completely different approach as compared to real betting.  Statements in the selection thread such 'favourite will lose or favourite will lose' are totally ambiguous because such probability exists for each race. 

In essence, it is necessary to realize and acknowledge that the contests and selections thread do not simulate real life scenario. There are inherent limitations. This however takes nothing away from the efforts of the contest organizers who try to do their best within the constraints of the situation.

Raghavan said ...

08-Jul-2021

HP++,

I agree with you.  There are no winners in horse race betting.  If anyone claims that he is a winner, then he is cheating himself.  Of course, we can give some exceptions to those lucky punters who solve single jackpot ticket.

Chanakya says that he will help horsetalk members to convert 50k to 500k in a time span of one year.  One thing is certain.  Those who believe him will be poorer by 50k.

Anyway, there is much confusion about the resumption of races; BNG & HYD have announced that races will resume on July 18th & 26th.  One should just hope that such dates are real.  I have my own doubts.

By the by, you said that it requires at least three years for rwitc to come out of its financial strain.  What actually you mean?   Are you telling that there will be no races under rwitc for three years?

Will you please share your thoughts on the feasibility of Pune races during the current year?  Will there be races at Pune in the current year or will it be a total washout?

I can understand if the washout is due to corona threat.  On the other hand, if the washout is due to incompetence or mismanagement of rwitc, then they should gracefully admit their commission & omission and surrender the land (race course) to the Maharashtra Government.

Chanakya said ...

08-Jul-2021

@ Sun,

I think  you  have  not  read  carefully  all  the responses.

your  first  para is  wrong. I have  been  betting  1 sometimes  2 and  even 3 runners  in  a  race and getting  positive  ROI.

Again, your  second  para  also needs  correctiion 'Getting...... is  a  mirage'. Reality shows  that  it  is  possible.

Combination  of win  & place  or  shp & place - if  you  use  all  three one  unit  loss  is certain, therefore be  explicit....

Ksmrow said ...

07-Jul-2021

Glasgow Prince, 

LSB of 1k means Level stake betting of 1thousand rupees, 

Roi can be calculated even one wagered different  amount on his selected horses . 

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

07-Jul-2021

Dear All,

The discussion has been largely healthy and fascinating and as expected, has thrown up diverse opinions. That is the beauty of this game. It is so enthralling and at the same time so challenging. Let me summarize my thoughts.

ROI (Return on Investment) is a tool that is used to compare the attractiveness of various investment options. Further, ROI does not specify any particular holding period of an investment. Since this discussion is limited to race betting, let us use the term 'profit' instead of ROI to avoid confusion.

Strike rate is a tool while profit is the goal. They are not comparable. Strike rate and profit have to be computed over a sufficiently long period of time to gauge the effectiveness of a selection method and / or betting strategy. The performance of a business enterprise is normally assessed over a year so as to take into account the effect of seasonal fluctuations. In my opinion, ideally, strike rate and profit should also be computed over a period of one year. This is because the performance of horses and trainers does have seasonal fluctuations and that of the punters is also prone to periodic fluctuations.

There seems to be a misperception associated with a high strike rate. Somehow people tend to feel that a higher strike rate implies landing more favourites. In that case a higher strike rate would not add much to the profits. As I had explained earlier, a selection method based on well known parameters will normally give out selections which may be quoted at odds varying from on money to 4 to 1. Occasionally, it may give a winner at higher odds as well. If a punter can improve his selection method to give a higher strike rate even within this span of odds, his profits will be greatly improved. If he happens to land a very high priced winner at 10 to 1 and over once in a while, he should consider it as a bonus or windfall. It would be far too uncertain for him to DEPEND on it to increase his profits.

Strike rate has a bearing not only on the profits but also on the CAPITAL REQUIRED. The higher the strike rate the lower is the capital requirement. Just for ease of understanding and to avoid tedious calculations, let us take a hypothetical but simple example. If the strike rate is 100%, it is easy to see that the capital required will be the equivalent of only one bet and the bet size can be any amount one can raise. At the other extreme, if the strike rate is zero, the capital requirement will be endless and after a certain point there will be no bets but only debts. Capital amount and bet size become extremely important if a punter does not want to run out of funds when he strikes a lean patch.

(To be continued)

Ksmrow said ...

07-Jul-2021

Glasgow prince,

Finally what is conclusive opinion we observed.here is

Mine looking forward to your

Closing remarks.

1)Type of betting 

10&12 bets may be tried for 7&8 races by punters who bet in every  race,This can be expected to give More wins  we are not missing our 2nd choices winner often they are value bets.               

2)Avarage odds 

It is surprising the avg odds or so heigh For a winner in a season is 3.8 to 4+(one can try for3+)

Don't chase big odds  it all depends on the sysyem you have one should be realistic if in the past identified the possible upsets & longshot

Winners then only 3+ avg can be possible.

3)Strikerate 

It is how many bets you are won from total bets wagered

35%strikerate for single bet above 25% strikerate from multiple(two)bets played races 100% Guarantee good 

Positive ROI,this results not possible every day how to improve consistency but the target One should try to reach.

4)ROI

Final result or profit&Loss,

From August  2019 for few months calculation of roi of all tipsters who gave three or more win selections In the Ht thread was worked out by me, every day List of +ROI

Tipsters  posted by next day

There was  no day less than 5  +roi names some days 20 Tipsters had +Roi.at that time not calculated average odds one got on winner but Now when one see in that angle many  manged 3+avg odds on their winners,what i tried to Convey is everything not looking as dark as many imagine. .

 

 

Hp++ said ...

07-Jul-2021

@Chase 

It;s simple logic, In any race course around  the world yu will have just one PAY window for every 25  SELL windows..

In any race course a punter is  very happy if he is  able to recover half his money lost,  by the  end of the last race

In any race course ,a punter prays more than he has prayed in a temple

Glasgow Prince said ...

07-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

Please also clarify what is meant by L S B of 1k

Thanks

Glasgow Prince said ...

07-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

Reference your posts of 6.7.21: 9.11 am and 10.28 am. Please clarify what exactly you wish to convey.

Raghavan said ...

06-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

You said there were 195 double bets of 1000/- each and you received the dividend of 230000/-.  I asked you the number of double bets that you won.

There should be no difficulty to answer this question.  

The 2nd question was purely academical.  Instead of 195 double bets of 1000/- each, if your bets were on the same 390 horses at 500/- each, what  would be the notional loss or gain.  This is only theoretical interest.  Of course requires some hard labour on your part if you desire to answer.

If you are able to answer well and good.  If you can not answer for whatever reasons, then just ignore.  

Perhaps you are of the opinion that I am disbelieving you.  I have no intention to clarify on your opinion. 

I will just mention that in racing, all punters are the losers in the long run.  A punter can win 2 or 3 days in a row.  But, he will lose in the next 10 days.  And surrender the won amount with compound interest to the bookies.

However, it was totally unnecessary on your part to imagine that my questions are flowing from the disbelief.   

Let me mention that my belief or disbelief will not result in gain or loss of even one rupee to either you or me. I have no intention to visit Hyderabad to ascertain the correctness of your claim or personally interview the bookie.  

Chase said ...

06-Jul-2021

@HP++  You Nailed It.

It is a Gamble. Each Race is Independent. No connections, No continuity. No pattern. 

You either win or lose. Nothing in between. 

There is No investment. Except your decision to bet or not , no other factor is under your control. 

This is not a business. This is not a cricket or tennis game. 

ROI and Strike rates don't apply here.

Sun said ...

06-Jul-2021

After going through all the posts it appears there is no way to make money at races by one or 2 or 3 choices in a Race.

The statistics provided talk about what should be the Odds if strike rate is so and so OR vice versa.Getting a higher Odds at the typical strike rate between 30&40%  appears a mirage.So one has to aim at higher Strike Rate ie getting some return for high percentage of bets.

Then the only way to improve the strike race is  by a combination of Win,Shp and Place bets.In each race one plays Type of bet Place or Shp or Win depends on the Odds in the ring because those figures reflect combined wisdom of the Punter population.

Hope I make some sense.

Chanakya said ...

06-Jul-2021

GLASGOW PRINCE,

Your  reply to  me  on  3/7/21- my response.

your para 1.

PracticabGLASGOW  ility  of catching high  price winners is  ZERO if a punter picKs or  selects or gives  only  ONE  CHOICE. .Sometime  back  in    different  thread  you  have asked  me  to  give my  'returns'  on  a  'OPEN' race. I  had  given  the  list  of  18 races wherefrom by  BETTING  ON  ALL 3  RUNNERS of  a  race I have  won  35( 45-12) units as  per  the  closing  odds during  29/12/19  to  12/3/20...

Agreed that  30  to  40% winners  may  not  be  odds on , they  can be  from  5/10 to  5/2 but  will their AVERAGE return  at  40% can  COMPETE with 10  or  20% return  of  those  winners  who  win  at  6/1 or  8/1... I'm  not  sure....

your  last  but  one  para  of  3/7/21...

I didn't  and  I don't  misunderstand you.  I know/knew that it was  not  meant  for  me - but just think  of b that  poor  and battered punter who  pays for  everybody  and  'occasionally'  when  wins  shows  his  emotions 'like a  normal  human' should  we  not give  him  a  'silent'  support by  not  denigrating  him?  The  least  we  can  do  is  give  a  smile  and  look  the  other  way...

Racing  truths says that  losers  will  ALWAYS OUTNUMBER the  winners - this  truth   has  never  been disproved  from  the  FIRST  day of competitive racing  or  games  have  started. This  site  is populated  by  them- nothing  wrong. But  an  addict wants to 'improve'  his 'take'  and is  not  interested in  reducing  his  outgo by  betting  less or  low.............

your  last  para:

My ROI was  not  35%   but  it  was  'strike rate'  which  was  giving  an  average  of  35%- It moved  between  a high  of 55% to  a  low  of  22% and also included  a  0%  return on 5/3/20 indicating  thereby  that finally  what  matters  is A POSITIVE  ROI  AT THE  END...

  

 

Ksmrow said ...

06-Jul-2021

Related to subject betting type &Roi

 

ksmrow said ...

On : 08-10-2019 09:03 am

@BHARAT,

A day before I started day roi+ List this was my request “

Ksmrow said ...
On : 11-08-2019 10:43 pm We give selection here believing our tips have chance to win our methods or different  selected horse is our choice to play but how many for the day one bet a race or two in every race  what will our financial  fate if we back each& every choice of ours. Genreally  Our Strike rate is two to four in a day card of 6to8 races,  Tipster worth only can come out calculating ROI for month or more,Restrict yourchoices 10 to12 per day”

Some have changed and restricted their choices I think multiple choice selections are useful for JP& other polls only not advisable to back all their selections for win let them enjoy and back their tips live in their world.

every day more than ten tipsters are doing very well follow them for profit.

 
BHARAT said ...

On : 07-10-2019 09:35 am

First of all my congrtulations to Siva Ramakrishna and libero for nominating excellent selections winning at high odds. 

Now my appeal and request to all experts and readers on Horse Talk to suggest me a remedy for my doubt/problem i.e. in which ratio one should play 3 horses that in the event of more favorites winning on any race day, how one can ensure some profit on Return of Invest(RIO).   I submit below following illustrations:

Suppose we play 3 selections in all the 7 races on a race day. Investment would be Rs.1100x3(horses)x7(races)=Rs.23,100.

It is almost impossible to win all the 7 races within 3 selections each race.  So we presume we assume a bit liberal figure that we win 6 races say every race day and RIO on such days will be as per details given below:

Assumed Investment in 7 races = Rs.23,100

(1) Average winning odds 3/2(1.5) x6=Rs.9000+Rs.6000=Rs.15000

(2) Average winning odds 2.0 x6=Rs.12000+6000=Rs.18,000

(3) Average winning odds 2.5x6=Rs.15,000+Rs.6000=Rs.21,000

(4) Average winning odds  3.0 x 6 =Rs.18000+Rs.6000=Rs.24000

(5) Average winning odds 3.5 x 6=Rs.21,000+Rs.6000=Rs.27,000

(6) Average winning odds 4.0x6=Rs.24,000+Rs.6000=Rs.30,000

From the above details, it is clear that to square up our investment we need to win minimum 6 out of 7 races @ average odds of 3.0 and to make minimum expected profit minimum avearge winning odds should be between 3.5 to 4.0.

There will be several race days when 4 or more favs will win @ average odds  of 1.5 and on some days one may win (only 3or 4 races) i.e. less than 6 races even by playing 3 selections in all the 7 races.  IN SUCH CASES AS TO HOW ONE CAN ENSURE RETURN OF OWN INESTMENT OF RS. 23,100(3 HORSES X 7 RACES X Rs.1100).

SINCE I DO NOT FIND ANY DEFINITE WAY TO ENSURE MY OWN INVESTMENT OF Rs.23,100 REQUIRED FOR PLAYING 3 SELECTIONS IN 7 RACES, I AM FRIGHTENED EVEN TO NOTE DOWN SELECTIONS OF THOSE TIPSTERS WHO NOMINATE 3 OR MORE HORSES IN A RACE.

BY WRITING THIS POST I REQUEST AND INVITE ALL EXPERTS AND HT READERS TO FAVOUR US WITH THEIR VALUABLE SAGACIOUS ADVICE WHICH WOULD HELP US IN BEATING THE BOOKIES BY PLAYING MORE THAN 1 HORSE IN RACES.

KINDLY HELP ONE AND ALL

BEST WISHES

BHARAT

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

06-Jul-2021

The Doc,

Your post of 5.7.21 / 11.09 am:

That is precisely the point I am making - the 'practicability' of achieving higher average odds to increase ROI is questionable. That brings us to the importance of achieving higher strike rate because designing a selection method is in a punter's hands. There is another dimesion to strike rate which I will deal with subsequently.

The Martingale method is fraught with great risk and the calculations to understand this are pretty straight forward. The most important aspect that it does't take into account is the psyche of a punter. Imagine a punter who is temperamentally comfortable to risk an amount of not more than 1000 per bet being confronted with the task of having to bet an amount of 8000, 16000 or 32000. It amounts to nothing but rash betting that can cause not only financial damage but physical damage as well to a punter. In fact, to me the Martinagale method is a classic example of 'chasing one's losses'.

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

06-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

Your post of 28.6.21 / 12.57 am:

It is true that avoiding bets on 'odds on' horses will not affect the 'TARGETED STRIKE RATE' but it will lower the 'ACTUAL STRIKE RATE' of any 'GIVEN' selection method. Not only that but it will also demand HIGHER average odds from the remaining bets given by that particular selection method in order to maintain the same overall average odds. This is what I have explained mathematically in the lead post. 

 

Ksmrow said ...

06-Jul-2021

 

Desr all, 

In August 2019 tried to give Tipsters

performance through their selections, win/bets and roi% for that raceday.
Mode of cal Calaculation;
L S B of 1k+tax,
Closing odds
Daily wise +roi list available
In daily selcton thread from 2019Aug12th, have a look.

~~~~~~~~~
Ksmrow said ...

On : 21-09-2019 10:07 pm

Pune 21/9 Selections ROI List:-

Rahul 71  2/5  ROI+200%

Againstodds  3/7  ROI+160%

A $ B  4/6  ROI+139%

Two Dees  2/3  ROI+130%

Sivaramakrishna  4/6  ROI+116%

Jai Kumar  3/6  ROI+98%

Racebro  3/6  ROI+75%

Guru Circle  3/6  ROI+75%

Farhatulla Khan  1/6  ROI+66%

Abhay  3/6  ROI+56%

DMSR  3/10  ROI+55.4%

Rajaraman  3/12  ROI+44%

Ram  1/7  ROI+42%

Libero  3/14  ROI+30%

Shiv Mys   2/6  ROI+22%

Baazigar  4/12  ROI+8%

Others ........

Tiger  2/6 ROI(-6%)

God of Racing  2/6 ROI(-6%)

Ksmrow  3/10 ROI(-6.3%)

C R K  3/9  ROI(-11%)

Wild card entry  3/12 ROI(-11%)

Manoj Kumar Agarwal 2/17ROI(-12%)
-------+-+--------+
Ksmrow said ...

On : 29-09-2019 12:19 am

Pune 28th(Sep)Tipster List With positive ROI::-

CHIDA  2/4  ROI+155%

FAHAD SHAIK  3/4  ROI+150%

BOBBY  4/6  ROI+146%

CLEARCUT  2/3  ROI+119%

C R K  4/10  ROI+106%

J W C  3/6  ROI+96.9%

HARSH  3/6  ROI+96.9%

ABHAY  2/6  ROI+96.9%

TV REDDY  1/3  ROI+81%

RIKASHAKI  3/9  ROI+81%

GS BHATIA  2/6  ROI+77%

MadhuSudhanReddy 2/6 ROI+70%

SULTAN  2/7  ROI+65%

VINCOTORE 2/6  ROI+40%

HorseBestJockey 2/6 ROI+40%

ManojkumarAgarwal 4/12ROI+38%

RAM  2/6  ROI+36%

DARMESH  2/6  ROI+29%

Goldman Cayabyab 2/6  ROI+28%

HIPPIBOY 2/6  ROI+17.4%

VENKEY  2/6  ROI+17.4%

D T T  2/7  ROI+16.8%

Raveesh Sikka  3/11  ROI+7.4%

J S I  3/13  ROI+6.6%

STARONE  2/6  ROI+6%

TIGER  2/8  ROI+2%

** Only Win Selections are counted
------------------

 

Hp++ said ...

06-Jul-2021

No methods can make yu win in races.ROI can be achieved in business and not in gambling

Raghavan said ...

06-Jul-2021

Indian turf Record,

You are talking about tote dividend.  But, I presume the majority of those interacting here do not bet at tote.  Of course, I agree that my presumption may be wrong.

But, I am 100% sure that Chanakya does not bet at tote.  He will always bet with bookies.  And, if for any reason, the bookies do not take his bets, he will stay aloof; but will never bet at tote.

About two & half years back, he remained completely detached because there were no bookies at the race course.  They (bookies) were in police lockup.  Because, they were accepting bets but not entering the transaction in official bet sheet.  But, Chanakya did not cared to bet at tote even then.

I have seen Amitabh Bachchan, a no non sense police officer, refusing to accept the bribe from a mafia don.  He was upholding the noble principle of not accepting the bribe.  I have seen Rajnikanth, who seems to be father of Amitabh Bachchan in upholding principle, not to accept even small gifts like mercedes benz, from gang of criminals.  But, those worthies are virtual non entities in front of Chanakya.  CHANAKYA DOES NOT BET AT TOTE.

So, when races are being run with only totes running, Chanakya did not compromised on his principles.  He was just noting down the tote payouts.  There were two horses that he liked.  One is Bold March that ran at Mumbai on 30/12/2018.  And the other was Jezzabelle, that ran at Kolkata on 1/1/2019.  (after two days gap).   If bookies were accepting the bets, Chanakya would have tendered his bets on those two horses.  But, because there were no bookies, he simply watched the races.  

Bold March paid 442 & Jezzable paid 1289 for a tenner.  A 100/- roll & Chanakya would be counting more than 5.5 lakhs.  But, Chanakya was unmoved.  Money can never influence him to compromise on his principles.

Chanakya shared his commendable experience with horsetalk members,  You also can revisit the thread titled "horse racing - merit wins most of the time" by Chanakya posted on 1/1/2019.

I appreciate his approach of firmly upholding a noble principle of not betting at tote.  Of course Chanakya can afford that.  He is winning millions every 2nd day.  So, he can definitely ignore the tote.  

Ksmrow said ...

05-Jul-2021

Raghavan,

It matters if you disbelieve my doubles betting and say so or then for the sake of my self-esteem i have obligation to prove it has happened  for this i have evidence in the form of Bookie who took my betting what wrong in it, you can send or request any one Whom you trust to meet me I will clear your doubts, as this betting is done 2010-11 iam trying to find enough  evidence from my racing  old monthly review papers.

Let me go through sentence wise of your last post iam trying to give my remarks.

1) yesterday in the check of

Old Papers i was able to find some slips of double betting

With horse names and with bookie calculations on back side of paper, a slip of 11/10 

So It started  in November 2010 another slip of 7/2011 so it is from winter seasons  to right in to the monsoon races,not as Bangalore(s)& Hyderabad(m)seasons  

2)yes you are wrong he charged tax

3)exact figures i can give you

If i can get my 2011diary.

4&5)your(1)i used to write my betting On a paper with date centre  win&loss luckily i found Entire betting record of 12/2010 in three heads (a)Tote betting

(B)Doubles (c) jackpot

With this record and from some bet slips the result  is 13 wins from 55+tax double bets won68k  returns.(this also you can check)

6)  your (2) why should 

I calculate this?what do you want to teach me, instead if you  ask about yourself on your Betting i do for you.

7)already invited  come as for your convenience get the answers.

8) i think addressed this. Right

Note:- dont divert,my request

Stands accept my proposals.

Hope you Say yes we fix date &time.

 

 

Indian_turf_record said ...

05-Jul-2021

 One case study on this topic.

Selections/tips of one tipster who gives single choice in some races and multiple choice is some races checked for period 14 November to 27 December 2020. Selections/tips cover 19 days racing at all centres but not Chennai.

Single Choice - 63 bets 25 won (39.68 %) 17 favourites ROI minus 181

Multi Choice- 117 bets 22 won (18.8 %) 13 favourites ROI minus 340

Total - 180 bets 47 won (26.11 %) 30 favourites ROI minus 521 

This period no bookies in operation so ROI calculated on Tote dividend. Unit bet of Rs. 10. Bookies give better odds on short price horses but Tote gives better dividend on longshots. Betting with bookies you get different odds from different bookies and two people will have not have same ROI. ROI is for reference and not fixed value.

If this sample is considered small, similar details can be worked for longer period because details are available till 28 March 2021. Calculations are manual and E.O.E. (Errors and Omissions Excepted) disclaimer made in advance. 

 

The Doc said ...

05-Jul-2021

Glosgow Prince Sir,

There is no easy solution to the puzzle you have taken up. Theoretically it may seem possible to raise ROI by achieving higher average odds but the practicability is quaestionable, just like the Martingale method. 

Many may be aware of the Martingale strategy. On paper this strategy looks solid but the for to deploy it one need huge bank roll. IF loosing streak continues for long then the bet amounts become impractical. With base bet amount of 1000rs, after 5 consecutive losses one needs 32000 rs for the 6th bet and by that time u already have lost 31000rs without taxes. So for the sixth bet you need to have 63k bankroll and if still fails in 6th attempt then for next bet of 64k you need to have 123K bank roll. Also you need someone who can take this huge bet. So this startegy to practically work you need to strike every 3rd or 4th bet. 

SO there is no easy fix for winning in races. To be profitable at races one needs to have a betting startegy which is theoretically sound and practically applicable. For me it is still a fantasy.  

Glasgow Prince said ...

05-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

I am reproducing below my post of 3.7.21/ 1.54 pm as it has appeared distorted.

Your post of 2.7.21.

Let us look a little more closely in two different ways at the implications of 33% strike rat at 3.5 average odds.

1. As detailed in my earlier post, there were 17 winners (which works out to 23.6% of total 72 winners) having average odds of 12.3 among the 72 winners at the beginning of Bangalore Winter Season 2018. If we assume the same pattern of distribution of odds among the winning bets, we can see that the 17 winning bets will have to include at least 4 bets (23.6% of 17) at the average odds of [12.3x (3.5/4.6)] i.e. 9.4. This means that on an average at least one winning bet in every 4 winning bets will have to be at the average odds of 9.4. How far this looks possible is anybody's guess.

2. Let us now assume that the pattern of distribution of odds among the winning bets is not the same as that among all the 72 races.

For ease of calculation, let us consider that a punter wins 4 bets on an average out of every 12 bets that he makes since the strike rate is 33%.

If he makes the first winning bet at say evens, his next three winning bets will have to be at the total odds of 13 i.e. 4.3 per bet for him to achieve average odds of 3.5.

If he makes his next winning bet at say 2.5, the next two winning bets will have to be at the total odds of 10.5 i.e. 5.25 per bet.

If his next winning bet is at say 4 to 1, the remaining winning bet will have to be at the odds 6.5.

That means he makes 4 winning bets at evens, 2.5, 4 and 6.5. Does this look likely on a CONSISTENT BASIS? Every time he makes a bet at any odds less than 3.5, he has to play 'catch up'. You can consider any permutation and combination of the sequence of bets or simply ponder whether it is REALISTIC for a punter to ENSURE that he makes every winning bet at the odds of 3.5!! 

 

 

Kautilya said ...

05-Jul-2021

So for Dec 2018 the high IQ person had negative ROI of 11020.

If lying and manipulating means having high IQ and really proud that i have  lowly honest IQ.  

I would any day prefer a pedestrain IQ rather than high 'Malavika'que IQ.. lol

I am not inclined to go any further unless i am made to. All depends on the megalomaniac. 

Raghavan said ...

05-Jul-2021

Ksmrao,

Let me make myself clear.

(1). I firmly believe that a punter can not win 30% of his bets, if he is betting on horses that are quoted at average price of 4.6 (that is between 4 to 6).

(2) No punter can win consistently 3 to 4 races in a day.  Of course this applies to those who bet just 1 horse per race.  This does not applies to those punters who bet 2, 3 or even 4 horses in a single race, and bet in all races, 

(3) It is immaterial whether I believe you or disbelieve you.  You are asking me to visit Hyderabad & personally check the veracity of your claims.  So much exercise not required.  I asked you two questions.  1 question easy to answer & the other one somewhat difficult. 

Of course, you have the option of ignoring my question. 

Glasgow Prince said ...

03-Jul-2021

Chanakya,

First of all, whatever I have said in the lead post applies to punters at large and the emphasis is on the PRACTICABILITY of being able to land high priced winners sufficiently frequently to be able to raise ROI by achieving higher average odds. Additionally, the calculations of profits and inferences from the data presented by Ksmrow on 18.6.21 in the other thread were also wrong which he has now admitted. If you have been successful in capturing high priced winners sufficiently frequently, this wouldn't apply to you.

Your post of 25.6.21: Yes, 30 to 40% of the races are won by favourites but they are not necessarily on money. They can be at 2 to 1 as well. The rest 60 to 70% will be at higher odds than the favourite but not necessarily at very high odds. Even if there is a fair sprinkling of winners at more than 10 to 1 as it was there in the first 72 races of Bangalore Winter Season 2018, the crux of the matter is how FREQUENTLY they are captured by a punter's selection method. I am sure no punter abhors long shots (as you feel) if he can get them. My posts of 1.7.21/6.04 pm and 3.7.21 morning addressed to Ksmorrow throw more light on the PRACTICABILITY of this occurrence.

Your post of 27.06.2021/7.59 pm:

I had LARGELY agreed with IIMBLUE that a punter is a loser because of his own ego and likes to boast about his wins. This is a general statement and you don't have to take it personally. I am sure you must have seen many people at the race course boasting about a high priced winner that they had backed.

There seems to be a contradiction about the ROI in your posts. In this post you felt that an ROI of 2 (which is 200%) is difficult to achieve if we move between evens to 4 to 1 odds frame and mind you a ROI of 2 is not at all bad.....but your own ROI for Mumbai was 35% (which is 0.35) as given in your post of 25.6.21/12.44 pm and Mumbai had given the maximum profit of 58 units.

 

 

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

03-Jul-2021

The Doc,

Many thanks for your post and compliments.

This reply of mine to Ksmrow takes a look at the 'paracticability' of attaining moderately high average odds even when there is a large component of high priced winners among the total sample.

Glasgow Prince said ...

03-Jul-2021

 

Ksmrow,

Your post of 2.7.21.

Let us look a little more closely in two different ways at the implications of 33% strike rate at average odds of 3.5.

1. As detailed in my last post, there were 17 winners (which works out to 23.6% of total 72 winners) having average odds of 12.3 among the 72 winners at the beginning of the Bangalore Winter Season 2018.

If we assume the same pattern of distribution of odds among the winning bets, we can see that the 17 winning bets will have to include at least 4 bets (23.6% of 17) at the average odds of [ 12.3x (3.5/4.6)] i.e. 9.4. This means that at least one winning bet in every 4 winning bets will have to be at the average odds of 9.4. How far this looks possible is anybody's guess.

2. For ease of calculations, let us consider that a punter wins 4 bets on an average out of every 12 bets since the strike rat is 33%. 

Let us now assume that the pattern of distribution of odds among the winning bets is not the same as that among all the 72 races.

If he makes the first winning bet at say evens, his next three winning bets will have to be at the total odds of 13 i.e. 4.3 per bet for him to achieve average odds of 3.5

If he makes his next winning bet at say 2.5, the next two winning bets will have to be at the total odds of 10.5 i.e. 5.25 per bet.

If his next winning bet is at 4 to 1, the remaining winning bet will have to be at the odds of 6.5.

That means he makes 4 winning bets at evens, 2.5, 4 and 6.5. Does this look likely on a CONSISTENT BASIS? Every time he makes a bet at any odds less than 3.5, he starts playing catch up. You can consider any permutation and combination or even simply ponder whether it is realistic for a punter to ENSURE that he makes EVERY winning bet at the odds of 3.5!

 

 

 

Kautilya said ...

03-Jul-2021

in contiuation... here is Dec 2018  data

 

 

 Bangalore 01/12/2018

 

Rce  no.  3 favorite  may  lose - astro  says so...

 

 

Favourite won at 60p

 

(NET): (-600)

 

 

Kolkata 1/12/2018

 

Race  no  8 favorite  will  lose . 

Simon Templer  should  place;  may  even win....

 

Favourite lost n Tmeplar plced at 1.5

 

(NET): (+2400)

 

 

Hyderabad 3/12/2018

 

Born Greek

Reunion

Realmoffantasy

all 3 win

Money time, Lavender, Prime time -PLACE...

 

Born Greek lost, Lavender / Prime time plc out.  Money time withdrwan

Reunion won @ 30p Realmoffantasy won @ 1.2

 

(NET): (-2000)

 

 

Mysore 05/12/018

 

1)Honey Queen  looks  good  for  each  way

3) County fame  should  win  if  on  job

4) I''ll not  bet  on  Brabourne

5)  Tamara & Maduro - I  prefer Tamara eachway . may  hedge with  Maduro...

 

 

Honey Queen withdrawn

Countrys Fame won @ 5.5

Tamara plc out , Maduro won at 3.25

 

(NET): (+6350)

 

 

 

Bangalore 7/12/2018

 

Here & Now, Panama hould  win...

Gypsy each way & Q Latifa  place seems  good...

Psychic  warrier  if  behves  may  win...

Yerwazen should  not  win - astro....

music Divine

 

Music divine won @ 6.25, Panama won @1.9, Q Latifa plc @ 1.75

Here n Now lost, Gypsy plc out, Yerwazan won @ 1.1

 

(NET): (+5200)

 

 

 

Kolkata 8/12/2018

 

adjudicate will in 2000 G...

won@ 70p

 

(NET): (+600)

 

 

 

Mumbai 9/12/2018

 

1)  (14)       Jodi lost  -2200

2)  4            won @90p   +800

3)  238   2 won @ 1.8  +1700

4) 367    3 won @ 1.1   +1000

5)41      4 lost    -1100

6)1         won @ 58p    +480

7)  5       5 lost   -1100

8)  53     5 lost -1100

9)nil

 

(NET): (-1520)

 

 

Hyderabad 10/12/2018

 

R1  - 8 3    8 won @ 2.25   +2150

R2 -(41)    Jodi lost   -2200

R3- (214)  Trio Lost -3300

R4 -812     8 won @ 7    +7900

race5 -2      2 lost    -1100

race 6-  (814)  1 won @ 2.5 +100

Race 7 - 8 3  8 lost   -1100

 

(NET): (+2450)

 

 

 

Mysore 12/12/2018

 

R1-  (67)     Jodi lost  -2200

R2  - 9 4P -5   9 won @ 1.1 4 plc out +0000

R3 - 9   2 4     9 won !@ 2    +1900

R4 -9 4           9 lost    -1100

 

race 5 - 9          9 lost    -1100

race 6- (5 12)          Jodi lost    -2200

race7 -  7 9          7 lost    -1100

 

(NET): (-5800)

 

Bangalore 14/12/2018

race 1 - (7 31)    3 won @ 80p -1500

race 2 - 6   8P    6 lost 8 plc out   -2200

race 3(6 10 3)    Trio Lost -3300

race 4 - 2  10      2 lost   -1100

race 5-bad race

race 6-  6   3         6 lost  -1100

 

(NET): (-9200)

 

 

Hyderabad 17/12/2018

race 1-  2   2 lost  -1100

race 2 – 3   3 won@ 70p  +600

race 3 -  (23)   Jodi lost  -2200

race 7 - (10 5 4)  Trio Lost -3300

 

(NET): (-6000)

 

 

 

Kolkata 21/12/2018

 

1)Fireburg may  not  win.

4) whistlwlker may also  lose.

 

Firbeberg won @ 2 and Whitewalker won @ 1.5

 

(NET): (-3500)

 

MONTHLY NET FOR DEC 2018 is  -11020..

 

By selectively giving 2-3 days postive returns you cant not claim postive ROI at the end of season... that too grand 35% or so... 

Ksmrow said ...

02-Jul-2021

Raghavan,

In Ht there are some persons who have great command in

English language to name a few Glasgow prince,I T R,  Ramanujan,chankya,iim blue,

TheDoc,S kumar,Bkd,Godzilla Raghavan and many more i like the way they write even the content i disagree, i know my limitations in this field if you spotted any grametical or any missing or proper words to be added please do, Right.

Now be straight if you don't  Believe say so, i don't say it is left to you believe it or not, you can Have Personal check on this  Come to hydrabad any time as for your convenience i will take You to Bookie he is still in the business who will tell  you and assure obout  my doubles betting.

Referring to my last Quote sentence what i meant is "there may be many people's Actions which are beyond  one's imagination" please Understand.

 

 

 

Sun said ...

02-Jul-2021

@ Chanakya,

  Thanks for your advice.I will follow in identifying such races.

@ksmrow,

I am thrilled to get the compliment from a Veteran Punter like you.

Though retired and lots of free time I spend sometime on Race Analysis and equal time in updating my Ratings file after every Race Day and in a busy season like Winter it is almost 2-3 hours a day 

My selections are purely based on Calculations and as is expected in all Handicap Races 2-3 horses come into reckoning.To separate such horses I am trying to integrate Timings and Ratings with some success.

Waiting for Racing to start to refine my system.

Thanks.

Raghavan said ...

02-Jul-2021

Kautilya,

Hats off to your perseverance.  

Many people would have stopped talking to Chanakya after his boorish replies.  The simple truth is no one can be a winner if he bets 12, 15 or 20 horses everyday.  Chanakya says that he gets better ROI though his strike rate takes a beating.   Well.  He can as well claim himself as the betting champion.  No body is impressed.

Ksmrow said ...

01-Jul-2021

Glasgow Prince, 

Yes there was error in calculation, but still get positive results, instead 

Of calculating with 4.6 avg odds Here I tried to work out now with reasonable strikerate and avg odds for positive Roi with 50 races single horse bets and in 50 other races on two horses(100)bets totally 100 races 

 

1)33%wins50single bets=17

 

Average odds3.5×17=59500

 

ie 17+59.5-50=+26500-tax-5000

=+21500

2)40%of50races100bets=20 

(20%strikerate,20wins from 100bets) 

ie20+70-100=-10000-Tax10000

=-20000

1&2=21500-20000

=+1500

Combined strikerate of 1&2

=24.6% scope for improvement 

Avg odds=3.5 may be little higher

Remarks>in 1&2 strikerate have to be calculated separately because ln double horse betting even if you win on one of the two other horsea utomatically loose if one win all the races strikerate is only 50%

 

 

Ksmrow said ...

01-Jul-2021

@Sun,

If a punter give selection for 2-3 races a day or 5 races we Can calculate Roi, when it is contest we all have to fallow uniformity, in lesser numbers races There is more chance to choose from favourites for getting +Roi naturally higher Strikerate needed, But in your method  of Handicapping l have Noticed you get good odds& fair percentage of longshots also  continue what you are doing if time doesn't permit.

 

Raghavan said ...

01-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

So, it took nearly 5 months to bet 195 races.  (May to September).  I had said that must be more than 4 months.

"My calculation wrong because I missed tax component"!  

I thought that bookie might have given you 100% tax discount.  My friend also used to bet  500/-, 1000/- or 2,000/- per race in advance.   And, he was claiming that such bets were without tax. 

So, tax aspect I missed,  and your actual profit is much less than 35k.

But, you have not answered the other two related queries.  

(1) How many double bets actually passed?

(2) Instead of making 195 double bets of 1000 each, what would have been your notional win or loss if your bets were 390 single bets of 500 each?

Among the above two queries, query (2) is rather difficult.  O K.  Take your own time to answer.  OR ignore it.  The choice is yours. 

But, there should not be any difficulty in answering query (1).  My queries stand.  If you prefer to refuse to answer the queries, then it is up to you.

"you should understand there may be many people's action which are out of our general imagination".   Right.  

Glasgow Prince said ...

01-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

Let me start with your post which I have cited in my lead post i.e. your post dated 18.6.21 under thread 'Mistakes that punters make' by Ab-delhi. Your post read as follows.

Quote "Just for curiosity i took a sample of 2018 BNG Winter Races conducted for 10 days in the beginning of season of 72 Races totall winning odds are 333 with the average 4.6Win odds;

Let us calculate 10 or12 bets:

1)33%wins36single bets=12

Average odds4.6×12=55

ie 12+55-24=+43000-tax

2)40%of36races72bets=14

ie14+64-58=+20000-Tax

43000+20000-10800Tax

=+52200 in Ten racedays.

Remarks>From this if one has money, time,energy to excute plan with this abov Average selections system one will be in gain if one has ability to win 3 to 4races in a day(3.5avg)." Unquote.

My observations:

To start with, there seems to be an error in the calculations. For example, with 12 successful bets out of total 36 single bets and 4.6 average odds, the net profit would be 55000(profit on 12 bets of 1000 each at 4.6) - 24000 ( 24 bets lost) = 31000 - 3600 (tax at 10% of 36000 total betting) = 27400  and not 43000 - tax.

Similarly, in example no 2, there would be a loss of 6000 - 7200 (tax) = -1200

The remarks would also change appropriately. Please correct me if I am wrong.

I have also not understood why you have added the outcome of the two betting strategies. I thought a punter would follow either one of the two strategies.

Be that as it may! 

The average odds of the winners in the 72 races conducted during the first 10 days of the season were 4.6. However, I found that these included the following high priced winners.

4 winners at 7, total odds 28

5 winners at 8, total odds 40

2 winners at 10, total odds 20

1 winner at 12, total odds 12

3 winners at 20, total odds 60

2 winners at 25, total odds 50

Total total number of winners from 7 to 1 up to 25 to 1: 17, total odds 210, average odds 12.3. 

The number of winners with odds of 7 and above is 23.6% (17/72) of the total winners  (72) at average odds of 12.3

You had taken average odds of 4.6 of the all 72 races  to calculate the profit that could be earned by successful bets. In other words, the bets that won had to have exactly the same proportion of winners across the whole spectrum of odds from on money to 25 to 1. For this to happen, the 12 winning bets must also include at least 3 bets (23.6% of 12) at average odds of 12.3. In my opinion, this is as good as impossible. This was the reason for my comment that the 'practicality' of achieving the calculated profit in 10 race days needed to be reviewed.

(To be continued)

 

    

 

 

 

Chanakya said ...

01-Jul-2021

I consider ROI  is MUCH  MORE   important than strike  rate  or any  other parameter  or  condition. consider 100 races  data  given  by  Ksmrow. Upto  odds of  2/1   55 races  were  won  while 45  races  were  won  by odds > 2/1.  Now  let  us  assume (or  presume) that  not  55 but  70  or  75  races  were  won  by winners  of  odds equal or less  than  2/1 and on  30  or  25  races  were  won  by winners  of  odds  >2/1. The  return  on  these 30  or  25  winners  will  be  more  than those  70 or  75  winners. 

But  the  issue  does not  end here. Every analyst, specialist or  a prudent (?) punter  thinks  that strike  rate  is  MORE   important  than  the ROI. And their  thought  process  is  augmented  by  the  statistics provided  by  Ksmrow! 

The  data given  by  Ksmrow CLEARLY  proves  that more  than  70 % races  are  won  by winners  having  odds of less  than  3/1 but it  also  indicates that the rest  30 %  also better  returns - sometimes  much more,  than  those majority (70%)  winners...

But  here  comes  the  million dollar question... how  to  find  these  30 % winners...

With  30  or  even  40%  strike  rate a  punter can  not  find these  'elusive'  winners. If  he  bets only on  one  runner in his 'selected'  races, 2, 3 or4 races  of  a  day...

How  many  tipsters and  how  many times, have  given 4/1 or  5/1 or  more  odds  winner as  their  FIRST  CHOICE? tips  are  available  in  tips thread of  this forum  from  2017 to  2021...

Earlier  I  said  that  many  years  ago  I used to  bet  on  selective  races  and  my ROI was  OK but was nothing  to  crow  about.  Since  last  few  years I changed  my betting  method( strategy) by  betting  on  ALL RACES  and in some  races  on  MULTIPLE runners. This  strtegy  has  given  me  MUCH   better ROI  but  reduced  the strike  rate...

This  brings us  to  a  cross road - which  should I follow...

ROI or  strike  rate?  

 

Kautilya said ...

01-Jul-2021

My last reply to Mr C not posted by admin, whatever the reason. Mr C will be glad that I visited his nov dec 2018 selections. 

 It hasb een your habit Mr C that if someone counters ur false claims you call them low IQ people. LOL this has been your modus operandi which i noticed while i was scouting ur previous selections.  You will not naswer me on your lasy year ROI cos there is no denying truth n hard cold facts.  

So here is Nov 2018 data. Unit bet 1000 plus tax 100 = 1100

Bangalore 3/11/2018

wining heart & Kvasir should win

Panama & S Berrdino are flukes...

All lost

(NET) : (-4400)

Bangalore 23/11/2018

Favortes  of  races  no 2 ,4, 7 & 8 are likely  to  lose

Favorites of 2 (2.25) and 4 (1.8) won. Race 7 and 8 were cancelled

(NET): (-4050)

Kolkata 24/11/2018

Punjabi girl should win. (Lost)

(NET): (-1100)

 

Hyderabad 26/11/2018

Ashwabahula  and  sarvatra have  a  fighting race . better jockeyship will win

Nazariya  should  place; can  win if E Prince falters...

AshwaBahula won @ 1.7, nazaria place out

(NET): -(500)

Mysore 28/11/2018

Race  no 2 . Eudora has  best  chance  to  win.

Race  no  5 . Bonito can  beat  them  all , except Blazing Touch which  is  a  live  threat...

Eudora won @ 2.75

Bonito and Lazing touch borad out

(NET): (+400)

Mumbai 29/11/2018

Tasawwur  and  Outrageous  are  my  choice for  win. Madagaskaris  next  in  the  list. 

select  anyone  you  wish...

Tasawwur won at 95p while Outrageous and Madagasr lost

(NET): (-1350)

Bangalore 30/11/2018

favorite of races  no.  3,4 are  gong to lose - astro says...

raceno 5  will also  face tough  competition - may lose...

Favorites of 3 n 4 lost

Favourite of 5 won  (1.5)

(NET): (+500)

 Bangalore 01/12/2018

Rce  no.  3 favorite  may  lose - astro  says so...

 

 

Favourite won at 60p

 

(NET): (-600)

So net for the month of nov 2018 was -11000 

So whatever methods you apply reality if different that expectation. 

Will post dec 2018 data in next post. 

Anybody can cross check the data which is freely available in HT. 

I have no qurrel with Mr C, i have problem with him calling people names and saying they have low IQ who beg to differ with him and who expose him for what he is. 

And it is relevant here as he is boating about his ROI and foreign trips. Even the toddler wont believe it but the people with very special IQ like MR C can only make profits out of losses.

Chanakya said ...

01-Jul-2021

Ksmrow,

I understand your  effort  to  maximise return by  doubling once  or  twice  a  day and  appreciate  that  you  are  still  continue to  do  the  same. Few  years  ago  I was  also  doing  this, rather  rolling on  2or 3 selections; one  or  sometimes 2  of  these were always  at  higher odds >4/1 or  5/1. Even  if  1 bet  out  of  10  succeeds  I used  to  get  good  returns. But  it  created  lot  of  tension and  now  I rarely  do  rolling, switched over  to  plain win betting. You  are  lucky that  you  got  a  honest  bookie, here  in  Mumbai these  unofficial  bookies  are  rogues - for  4/1 they  will  offer 38/10 & for  5/1 it  may  be  9/2 ! 

By multiple  betting,i.e., betting  on  10  or  12  runners  in a  card  of  7  to  8  races I have found  that  my  ROI has  improved  though strike  rate   has  come  down. But  I  prefer this strategy...  

Ksmrow said ...

30-Jun-2021

Glasgow prince,

Break up odds for winners of 2018 Bng summer meeting for first100races:-

15 races 8/10 or less

23 races 9/10 to 1.25

8  races 1.25 to 16/10

9 races  up to 2

18 races 2 to 5

2 races odds of 5

6 races odds of 6

4 races odds of 7

6 races odds of 8

4 races odds of 10

1 race odds of 12

1 race odds of 15 

3 races odds 20

Let us use this data here 

100 win odds are 400(4avg)

100-15(8/10)races=85

400-12odds of 8/10=388

85 races left to bet 

388÷85 =4.5 avg odds

A increase of 0.5 odds on each of 85 remaining races after passing15 oddson races,

For break even we have to win 25 races at 2.5avg win odds with 30% strikerate is sufficient, the actual avg odds are 4.5 from this we can easily expect 2.5 to3avg  win odds 

 

Ksmrow said ...

30-Jun-2021

Raghavan,

I thought some remarks mayCome from CK i was responding to his comment On multiple Betting, in my racing tried many types of betting this plying doubles is one of them, it started in may continued until September end, your calculation wrong missed tax, there was tax on first bet if won have to pay tax on the amount backed  on second horse also This is how my bookie charged. This unique (extreme)exercise done by me, you should understand there may be many people's Actions which are out of our Genral imagination. 

 

 

Chanakya said ...

30-Jun-2021

Sun,

To  find races  with better odds you  can  follow 2  approaches.

1) 3 racebooks - BOL, Cole, Vel  are published. Select  the  races where  their choice differs  widely - example : Bol gives 368, Cole  gives  427 and  Vel  gives 319...

2) many  tipsters give  free  selections  in  the  tips  thread of  these  forums as  well  as  on  U tube. Select  the  races  where  5 or 6 or  more  choices are given  in  a  race  which  has only  7 to  8 or 9 runners.....

 

another  point:  for  races  run  on  Sunday the acceptance is  on  thursday, declaration  is  in  friday and  the  racecards  or the past  races  data is  available  on  saturday in racebooks  or these  forums, giving  enough  time  to  a  punter/analyst.  Improve  your  system  to  analyse  at  least  60  to  70% races of  a  day...

However,  even  your  method or  system enables  you  to  analyse  only  2  or  3  races of  a  day your  ROI and  strike  rate  must pass the  'laxman rekha' -  it  must  give a  substantial  ROI...

 

Raghavan said ...

30-Jun-2021

Ksmrow,

195 bets of 1000/- each; returns 2,30,000/-.  35,000/-  profit.  Not at all bad.  Much much  better than what banks pay as interest on FD of similar amount.

You please state the time taken by you for 195 bets.  I think it is more than 4 months.  

Have you ever worked out what would have been your returns if you had single bets of 500/- each on 390 horses instead of 195 double bets.  

195 double bets by you.  How many bets were passed & you received dividend?

 

Ksmrow said ...

30-Jun-2021

Correcition please read as 1000 rupees not k.

after 195 doubles of 1000k each my total returns were 230k,

Ksmrow said ...

30-Jun-2021

Chankya ji, from early days of my racing always tried to find Winners on my own way and searched for Better results  From  different ways and that is still  going on, multiple or hedge betting not a New thing to me i did it in the past even now do in one or two races in a day, Decades back once in a stretch my betting was only doubles every  race day 4 to 6double bets a day finally after 195 doubles of 1000k each my total returns were 230k, maintained a record also my starting bet 0.5win×3.5place Was success never worried or need to add money to intial bank never arised,twice i failed to win single double in 10 consecutive bets,  all my bets were written on a paper and with cash given to bookie before 11am Who is my neighbour he was honest in giving right odds He is still in the business. in 2017Ht  contest win/shp conducted by me for four months the idiea multiple bets on single horse it is one plays 2units win&1unit shp or 2 unit shp&1unit win, recently in charchand 3 introduced  a satellite bet to main choice bet.

Roi is final result  of your betting ofcourse strikerate needed for positive Roi is different  one to another it is depend on the avg odds one gets from his winners, what ever the system it must have to be sound enough and by good strategy betting further enhances system efficiency. 

Racing  quite fits in to a Telugu Saying "shatha koti daridraniki annatha koti upayalu"

 

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

30-Jun-2021

Errata:

The first sentence in the caps portion in the second last para in my previous post should read as follows.

IT IS ONLY WHEN THE STRIKE RATE OF THE SELECTION METHOD DESIGNED BY A PUNTER IS NOT SUFFICIENT TO GENERATE REGULAR PROFITS DOES HE FEEL THE NEED TO OVERCOME THE LIMITATIONS OF THE SELECTION METHOD BY ADOPTING AN APPROPRIATE STRATEGY.

Error is regretted.

Sun said ...

29-Jun-2021

Dear All

Very interesting discussion is going on Strike Rate.Odds and ROI.

Suppose a punter is not in a position to analyse more than 2-3 races on a day and if Strike Rate is 30% or slightly more,how to select which Races to analyse.

Suppose he selects Races where Favourites Win then his ROI is low.In other words before detailed Analysis is it possible to select Races for Analysis with better returns..

@ksmrow,

You are running a very good contest to assess ROI of tipsters but I could not participate because of the above issue that analysis of 2-3 races per day only.

Your insistence for 5 races on a day is it because you feel the real strike rate comes out if one Tips(Bet) in reasonably good number of races in a day.

This can also assessed over a season/month if someone gives selections for 2-3 races in a day.

Your views please.

Glasgow Prince said ...

29-Jun-2021

 

IIMBLUE,

You are not at all interrupting. You are most welcome to share views on the topic anytime.

For the sake of clarity, let me say that a punter's system has two components: the selection method and the betting strategy. Taken together they form his system.

You must have seen from my lead post that it is particularly aimed at systems which select a single bet for win or place per race and employ the strategy of eliminating on money bets in an effort to increase profitability.

As I see it, you could not have given more telling examples in support of the point I am making. At the outset, I must clarify that I don't recollect the exact nature or results of the exercises undertaken by Vamanan and PG and I am going totally by your account.

Why did Vamanan, a respected and knowledgeable race goer choose to back only one horse in a day and that too for place? Why did he not choose to back one horse in a day or for that matter several horses per day for win at high odds? The answer is obvious isn't it? It was simply because his selection method did not allow him to do so. Evidently, if his selection method had thrown up sufficient number of high priced winners regularly, he wouldn't have chosen to back horses in place and that too one per day. In other words, the selection method did not give a sufficient strike rate of winners at such high odds as to ensure a regular and significant profit. What his selection method could not achieve was sought to be overcome by his betting strategy. 

In the exercise conducted by PG, a list of follow horses was compiled based on certain parameters at the beginning of with the expectation that they will strike during the season at whatever odds. Evidently, the odds were not known when the list was made. Here again, the system would have succeeded had it thrown up sufficient number of high priced winners regularly (sufficiently high strike rate at high odds). It failed only because it could not do so.

It is pertinent to note that in both the examples, the selections were made on the basis of the horses' credentials and not the odds. They made the selections, placed their bets and hoped for the best. 

It is creditable that both Vamanan and PG were willing to experiment publicly with the objective of improving them further if need be, put up their own results and accepted the outcome with grace. They definitely deserve kudos for their effort.

Now let us look at this whole exercise from the beginning. Ideally, a punter wants maximum profit in minimum time. For that he has to select a horse to bet on for win or place. His profit depends on how often he win (strike rate) and what returns he gets (odds). So, how should he go about selecting the horses to bet on? The strike rate in turn depends on the winning probability of his selections. Higher the winning probability, higher will be the strike rate. To maximize the winning probability of his selections, he looks at the comparative credentials of the runners. To maximize his returns, he would love to get winners at high odds. While studying the comparative credentials is in his hands, he has no control over the odds that his selection will be quoted at. So, in order to maximize his returns, can he start making his selections on the basis of desired odds instead of starting with credentials? Let us say, he decides to select only such horses that are quoted above a certain minimum odds, say 5 to 1 and then evaluate their comparative credentials?. Is it possible for him to design such a method? Can he get winners sufficiently regularly to make a decent profit? If it is possible, then obviously he has cracked the puzzle. But if it is not, then he has to focus on his strike rate. IT IS ONLY WHEN THE STRIKE RATE OF A SYSTEM DESIGNED BY A PUNTER IS NOT SUFFICIENT TO GENERATE REGULAR PROFITS DOES HE FEEL THE NEED TO OVERCOME THE LIMITATIONS OF THE SELECTION METHOD BY ADOPTING AN APPROPRIATE BETTING STRATEGY. HIGH STRIKE RATE DOES NOT NECESSARILY MEAN PLAYING FAVOURITES. IF HE CAN IMPROVE HIS SELECTION METHOD TO ACHIEVE A HIGH STRIKE RATE ACROSS ODDS, HE WILL AUTOMATICALLY LAND WINNERS AT HIGHER ODDS. HE WILL NOT NEED A BETTING STRATEGY TO OVERCOME THE LIMITATIONS OF HIS SELECTION METHOD.

Generally, very high priced winners emerge when there is some reason for the horse to be neglected in the betting. The reasons could be an unheralded jockey, an unsound horse, hidden preparation, change of equipment, suitability of heavy going, better fitness especially at the commencement of a season, first timers with no performance, luck of the race, in and out running or simply a doosra or teesra. How does a punter build in these factors into his selection method which is based on credentials, so that it throws up high priced winners regularly? HIGH PRICED WINNERS MAY BE LURKING OUT THERE ON A REGULAR BASIS BUT THE MOOT POINT IS HOW FREQUENTLY A PUNTER'S SELECTON METHOD CAN CATCH THEM.

       

 

Chanakya said ...

29-Jun-2021

GLASGOW  PRINCE,

ROI and  strike  rate though  interlinked do  not  give  the true  picture  unless qualified  by some  conditions. Strike  rate  of  30% or even 40% may  give  only  smallROI, even  negative ROI if  punter  goes  for favorites  or low  odds winners. A fair  sprinkling  of  winners with  odds > 4/1 is  a  must to  get a  fair to  good ROI.

It  is  true  that if  a  punter adhers  to  the use  of  standard  parameters  he will home  on  to  probable  winners  having odds  of  4/1  or  lower resulting  in  a low ROI with  30 (3/10)  or  40% (4/10) strike  rate. It  is also improbable that  these 3  or  4  winners  will  have even one 4/1 odds  winner. Yes, out  of  7  winners  from  say  15  or  16  races( on  2 days) one  odd winner  may offer  4/1.

one  thing  i  can  say - a  punter  can  NEVER remain  a  SUBSTANTIAL   winner if  he  'rigidly' follows his  system  without incorporating  'flexibility' in  his  final  analysis   Many  times I  find  2  or  3 runners  having  very  close 'value'  as  per  my  system. I classify them in 'open' race group and  bet equal  amount  on  both or  all 3  of  them. This  'strategy' has  enabled  me  to  improve  my ROI drastically or should  I say fantastically.

Example: Mumbai(2/1/20): 5th race: choice- (365) open race, favorite will  lose.......................

Result : 6  won at  20/1 and  my ROI increased  by 20-2+1 = 19  points. Favorite  will  lose  was  through  ASTROLOGY...

 

Ksmrow has recently accepted  that it is not  wrong  to  bet  on  more  than  1  probable  in  a race if  this  method  gives  better  roi.  Timeform  which  gives 2% ROI and  DRF (daily  racing  form of  usa) which  uses  Beyer's  numbers as  their  reference  point do  not  give  any  help  to  a  punter - he  can  keep  his  money  in  any  bank  and  earn 4% NO  RISK    interest in  a year.

Late  Vamanan was  a  decent  man but  he did  not use 'flexibility' in  his  final approach and  failled. PG is a well  established race analyst and  I have  attended  his   tutorials conducted  at  RWITC many  years  back and  got  lot  of  gems but  FAILED  TO  USE  THEM. Follow  horse will  fail  in  India because  of  various compulsions of  owners, trainers  and  finally jockeys who  many  times  lose - ON  INSTRUCTIONS ( owner? trainer  or  outsider?)

Finally,  strike  rate  does  not  give  the  true  picture. I may  win 2out  of 10 races but  with  odds  of 6/1& 7/1   giving  me  20% strike  rate but  it  will  be  better  if  I win  5 out  of 10 races when betting  on  favorites  of  odds on  and  5/4 or  6/4 or  even 2/1...

(to  be  continued) 

 

Againstodds said ...

29-Jun-2021

Sir, 

Very healthy & logical discussions. As Glasgow Prince sir said, one should strive to achieve a 30% strike rate. Different people follow different methods from Astrology, numerology to inside information and backing. But eventually, the method should help achieve the goal with even betting.  With new seasons to begin shortly, if some sort of contest is conducted in HT, which will make us respect other people's selections and improve our choice as well.

 

With warm respect & regards to all and wish you all good luck.

 

Chanakya said ...

29-Jun-2021

@ K,

 With  your  pedestrian IQ  and  very  poor knowledge  of  racing, I feel  you  don't deserve  a  reply for  your  now well  established  selective  pickings.

This  is  a  serious discussion and  people  like  you  have  no  place in  this  discussion... 

The Doc said ...

29-Jun-2021

 

Another brain teaser from Glosgow Prince. Always a pleasure to see your posts sir. 

Good strike rate may not translate into good ROI and vice versa. What matters is at what odd you are striking winners. Favourite backers need very good strike rate say 30 to 40% to make significant ROI but the fluke hunters can achieve similar ROI of favourite backers at just 15% strike rate. Does it mean we should chase the odds/?? I guess not. The winner selection should not just be guided by the odds but the selections which can give better value for the money must be concentrated on. The odds offered are not in our hand and should not be a criteria while selecting your bets. But whether to bet on the odds offered at race time is in our hands. Odds are deciders whether to bet or not and not the selection criteria. 

I agree with IIMBLUE that odds are always stacked against punters. But I do not agree with that Middling of odds is a good strategy to counter bookies. It will give you good returns sometimes but in long run it will only hurt. For middling to be successful the winner must have odd more than 3 every time which is not possible. If the winner is below 1.5 even the middling will give negative returns. If u lose all bets in middling losses can mount. Whatever strategy you adopt, it will have its pitfalls. 

I feel betting is not just about finding winners. Sometimes place getters also give good returns. I have seen many punters who feel it beneath themselves to play place. I never understood the logic. Agreed that they give low returns but are relatively safe bets, relatively is key word. 

Here I will take some liberty to divert from the main topic. The biggest enemy of punter is not bookies, trainers or jockeys, it’s their ego. IIMBLUE has rightly pointed out it. No one wants to be a loser, not even for a day or for that matter a race. Almost everyone want to recover the loss in next race only. That’s the biggest undoing for any punter. There are rare punters who take losses in their strides but most bet like there is no tomorrow. 

If there is anything to work upon, it is your EGO and emotional intelligence not the betting strategy, handicapping or selection methods. ROI, SR are all secondary things. 

 

Raghavan said ...

28-Jun-2021

IIMBLUE,

This is a serious discussion.  Unfortunately, your post is a fine example of sychophancy.  

Whether Ruchi is a good tipster or not is not at all relevant here.  Ruchi charges for his tips.  Certainly, punters are not fools to pay him monthly fees if he is tipping paisa favorites or his tips are as mentioned in BOL, VEL etc.  He is tipping, demands fees for that & that is his bread & butter.  

You are saying that by targeting the bookies, I am playing spoilsport.  Absolute lie.  It is posts that are sychopathic in nature OR singing one's own praises that spoil the discussion.

Ruchi, as I have said earlier, is a paid tipster.  He is  giving tips in this site occasionally that too for 1 or 2 races in a day.  There were well over 750 races between Nov 2020 to 4 April 2021.  (Excluding the races at Mumbai/Pune from Dec to Feb 2021.  Ruchi might have tipped in less than 10% of 750, and certainly has not set Arabian sea on fire.  

Another fellow about whom you mentioned is Chanakya.  The man who tips 15 to 20 horses in a day and  as if that is not enough, he also says too many times  "favorites will lose" (without mentioning horse name or number). .

You do not worry what Chanakya & Ruchi tips here.  You are shouting from roof tops that you command high degree of racing knowledge.  Well.  Glasgow Prince desires that horsetalk members should speak on the topic ROI in respect of horses that command higher odds.  If you have any meaningful ideas on that subject, share that with horsetalk members.  OR if you do not have any new ideas or you do not want to speak out your ideas absolutely no problem.  Oceans will not dry up.  You stay silent.  Avoid posting rotten useless stuff or about the tips from some third persons.

Punters are losers.   You say that is because of their ego.  You are also a punter.  And unless you give some acceptable proof, you are also a loser.

What I mean by "acceptable proof" is, you should give tips & also the quantum of amount you desire to bet on that horse.  Your claims that you are a winner may be up voted by your friends here without subjecting you to cross exam.   But, by their up voting, you will not gain phootee kowdee or by questioning your profit claims, I do not gain a phootee kowdee.

Glasgow Prince,

By betting horses that are offered at mouth watering odds, will a man's ROI will be improved?  Surely.  But the horses that he bets should win.  But, Brahma, Vishnu & Shankara will not be able to achieve 30% strike rate.  If winning is so easy in horse race, then there would not be a single bookie anywhere in the world.  Bookies are not incarnations of Bali Chakravarthy, Dana soora Karna etc to enter the race course with gunnybags of cash and distributing the same to punters.  

If one bets on horses that are offered at 4.5 to 5.0, at best you can win 12 bets out of 100.  Punters with supreme racing knowledge may achieve 15% strike rate.  I have said this much to Ksmrow also; but it seems he is fully satisfied that a sharp punter can achieve success by betting on horses with higher odds.   Certainly, in such matters there will be difference of opinion.  Best of Luck to Ksmrow.

Ksmrow said ...

27-Jun-2021

Glasgow prince,

Iam searching ways to improve Strikerate and upper limit scope of avg odds one can expect on his winner with different betting strategies,my analysis is for above average ability punters  and those who are moving in that direction.

A disciplined  meticulous punter when with his system try to zeroing on to find Best horse capable of winning he use mathematical data find  one but two or more very close here problem arises he use logic,intution,prejudice & some other waylike distance, pedigree,age and finally find his choice to bet insted  of wasting  time i think here we can go for multiple bets, Timeform a top system in recent analysis Gave only +2%roi if one bet religiously on Timeform top rated horse in every race.

In missing odds on winner by Passing that race actually improve avg odds on winner strikerate doesn't drop as non  backed horses Will not effect on Targeted strikerate.

 

Iimblue said ...

27-Jun-2021

GP Sir  ,

Sorry , if I am interrupting.Let me add two more points before you conclude.

  As you may recall , many years back ,Late Vamanan devised a method for the benefit of Race goers.He started with the BangalorevSummer Season (28days) , an imaginary kitty ,and one bet per day.He would select one horse per day for place (likely place dividend at least rs16) ,  and betting amount was flexible (from the kitty).Paper calculations showed that one would end up with a substantial sum ,even if the dividend was rs 16 or more ,if one kept reinvesting.

       Late Vamanan ,ran the kitty very well , but it ran out  ,I think by 21 st day.

Later Mr.P.G , another very respected name ,chose a different strategy.He made a list of 30 follow horses ,at the start of Bangalore Summer Season.He had an imaginary kitty ,and would make his move only when the horses in his follow set ran.He would study the race in which horse in entered ,and take a decision to bet (win/place) or not to bet.Here too the kitty ran out by the later half of the season.

There is no fool proof method.Having noted that , my point is both these very well devised attempts failed because both of them depended heavily on strike rate.

Chanakya said ...

27-Jun-2021

Roi is  considered  as  a  percentage though  I would  pefer it  to  be  a  number because my  'system'  may  give  an average  small % in a long  run. However, the  issue  is  raising  ROI with higher  odds.

I doubt anybody  can  have an ROI of  4.6 or  3.8 as given  by Ksmrow about  Bangalore  races because  no  body  can  catch  the  winners  of  72  and  185  races- only a  %  of  these  can  be  caught by  an  astute  punter. In  my  opinion, even  an  ROI of  2 is  difficult  to  achieve, if  we move  between  even  to  4/1 odds  frame...

Another  point. We  are  all trying rather  obsessed  in  'catching  a  winner' that  is  why  we  go  to  races to  win  or  to  make  money  and  not  for  entertainment. A punter who  fails  to  catch  is  a  loser , one  who  succeeds  is  a  winner!

Coming  back  to  strike  rate. I tried  to  calculate  my  strike  rate on  the  selections   posted  in  this  forum  from  29/12/19  to 12/3/20  and  found  it  varied  widely  from  a  low  of  22% to  a high  of  56% with  a  complete  wash-off on  one  day 5/3/20  giving  an  average  of  35%. To  refresh  my  betting  method I must  say  that I  bet  only on  my  first  choice( without  any  suffix) on  both of  a  jodi  and all 3  if  I  say  it  is  an  'open  race' or  put  3  numbers  in  a  bracket(...).

For  example  on  29/12/19  my  choice was: race 1) 21jodi; 2) 351; 3) 156 open; 4) 325; 5) 351 open; 6) 712.

Result : 5/11 - 5 wins  from  11 bets = 45%

On  2/1/20  the result  was  6/12 = 50%; finally  giving  an  overall average  of 35% over  the  period of  2 1/2 months.

I have  not  kept  any  record  of  my  strike  rate of  past and  therefore, can not  say  with  certainty about  it ; because  there  is no  racing  since  long  I  did these  cals  for  the  period 2019/20...

I also  don't  agree that  a punter  is  always  a  loser and  boasts about  his  wins which  you  and  IIMblue think. A punter  gets  an  opportunity 'at  the  cost'  of  the  owner/ trainer/jockey combo  to  make  money without  any  'obligation'  to  them! where else  a  person  can  make  money without  any risk and  selective investment?

I am  really  surprised  to  read the  'fate'  of  a person  who  had  85% strike  rate  and  the  tipster  who  is  now  under  debt. I don't mind helping  them by  my free selections because  monetary help  of 10 or 20k  will  serve no  purpose....     

 

 

Ksmrow said ...

27-Jun-2021

Hi all , 

continuation of earlier post
one more sample of 2018-19winter Hyderabad gave 4.8average odds for  67 races ran in first ten race days with 327 total winning odds. These average odds showing us how races are running, as win odds with strike rate decides our over all
Performance in betting one has to keep trying for enhancement in these aspects for positive ROI
But how?  (1)can we go for multiple bets each race what will happen if your total bets(14)& (16) for 7or8 race card, my opinion given earlier also you have to win 5out7(14)and 6outof8(16) it is not possible for punter To win so many races on average.
(2) single bet type betting if you backs oddson need 2.25 avg odds(which is difficult) with 35%strikerate for+roi.
(3)For The middle path 10 ;12 bets  7races 10 bets& 8 Races 12 bets one need to win on average 3.5 & 4 races from 7&8races day card meetings that means one has to win 50% of races one wager at 3.25 to 3.5 average odds, I just wants to give clarity on 50%winners it is from number of races but not to be confused as 50%strikerate which is calculated on Number of bets. 
Please come to  your own conclusions on types of betting 1), 2), 3).

Kautilya said ...

27-Jun-2021

@ C

 

I knew you will try to divert the authenticity of data.. everything is here.. Give ur calculation. Catching 1 mistake and ignoring rerst of the correct data is only thing u can do. You bracket horses n say you play multiple horses when u bracket them. Mow you say you play all horses when you mention open race. So mych vagueness..  

Since you hoghlighted my one mistake let me highlight your gem of selections on

Feb 7, 2020 Bangalore. Out of 15 selections only 1 passed, AMAZING. 

March 1, 2020 Mysore, you gave 19 selection and NOT a SINGLE WINNER... SUPER AMAZING. 

MARCH 5, 2020 Mumbai: 17 selection and NOT a SINGLE WINNER.... ROFL... Stupendofantbulously FANTASTIC. 

Care to comment on those???????? or will you againt hide behind your temper tantrum when got got with hand in cookie jar.. LOL

Chanakya said ...

27-Jun-2021

GLASGOW PRINCE,

I reiterate - raising  ROI by achieving  a  win  at  higher  odds  is  a truth and  not  a  myth.

Ksmrow has  also, perhaps inadvertently,  proved  a  fact - average  odds of  the  few days at  begining  of  a  season  will  ALWAYS be more  than the  average  of  the  season! 4.6 to 3.8 proves  it...but  that  is  not  the  issue...

 The  issue  is  increasing ROI by  betting at  a 'winner' who is at higher  odds.  How many punters  have caught the winner at  Bangalore at 4.6  or  3.8 average? I think  not  more  than 2  to  5% - maybe even  less...

We  should  find  out  why ? why  a  punter abhors a   high  priced runners  who  WINS  60 TO  70% OF  THE  RACES, ANYWHERE  IN  THE  WORLD...

(to  be  continued)

 

 

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

27-Jun-2021

IIMBLUE,

 

In some ways you seem to be a man after my own heart. I couldn’t agree with you more when you say that once we get obsessed with catching winners, we are not playing our game, we are playing the bookies game and therein lies the trap. It follows that things get even worse when a punter becomes obsessed with catching high priced winners.

I also agree to a large extent with you when you say ‘Sadly, I have to say the punter is a loser because of his own ego. He wants to catch a winner and boast around. A punter should only bother about increasing his own kitty’.

But then, there is a contradiction when you further say ‘he should play a statistical game not bothering about the strike rate’ because strike rate is nothing but one of the statistical measures of the efficacy of a system.

My experience about the utility of strike rate and its usage by punters is substantially different. I have seen that hardly any punters excepting a very very few keep a record of their bets and consciously monitor their strike rate. Only and only when a punter does so does he get an authentic record of his strike rate and profit or loss. Most punters don’t keep a record of their strike rate but are strangely satisfied with it. They realize that they are making a loss only when they find themselves short of money. The only reason for this is that they don’t monitor their strike rates and profit / loss but are under the erroneous impression that they are ‘doing alright’. I have seen a very experienced punter who ‘feels’ that he has a strike rate of 85% but is surprisingly broke and does not have funds to sustain his betting. Another respected erstwhile tipster on HT had run up debts due to his betting. There are similar other cases.

I will further share my views about strike rate and its importance when I respond to Chanakya’s / Ksmrow’s viewpoint so as to avoid repetition.

 

Glasgow Prince said ...

27-Jun-2021

Ksmrow and Chanakya,

Thanks for sharing your views. I am awaiting the conclusion of your posts so that I can respond comprehensively.

 

Chanakya said ...

27-Jun-2021

@ K,

I'll only show  your 'incompetence' for  29/12/19 and  leave  rest  to  the  reader's  imagination because any  further response  increases the  question  mark on his IQ...

race1)  2,1 jodi : 1 won(85paise) net  must  be(-350) ; he says (-1350) !!! which  logic?

race 3)  1,5,6 open race. since  ages  I've  been  betting  equal  amount  on  ALL 3 choices  of  an  'open'  race. This  is  well  known  to  this 'tote calculator' also. 5 won  and  paid  more  than  60  on  tote giving  a  plus  of  4  units... By  the  way  I  never  bet  on  tote, I bet  only  with a  bookmaker...

That's  enough  to  show the  knowledge, competence, understanding  etc.  of  a 'tote' player or  calculator...

I've  no  more  time  to  waste...  

 

Iimblue said ...

26-Jun-2021

GP Sir ,

Once we get obsessed with catching wimners , we are not playing our game :,we are playing the bookies game. and therein lies the trap.! 

Say ,there are nine runners in a race.IEven if you choose a horse carefully and play ,the remaining 8 horses belong to the bookie ,which means the odds are always stacked against you .In the long run, th is is one game ,which you will never win ,whatever may be your strike rate.

       I donot follow any particular tipster in HT ,but the methods followed by them is of interest to me.

Ruchi ,a respected tipster here , goes by dynamic rating method selects 4 top horses in the field ,eliminates three by logic and zeroes on one.He method has thrown many outsiders and in my opinion he has easily surpassed his "Guru".Ruchi does not need a good strike rate as he not only gets long priced horses for win but also for place.

Chanakya --his selections I will leave out of this discussion and concentrate on his method.To  my mind Chanakya is following the classic "middling"strategy.He may be playing many horses , but why one should bother if his "middling " is perfect---whichever horse wins , he makes profit.If more punters go for "middling" , bookies will be horrified, because this is not the game they wanted !Here too strike rate may go for a toss , but one should not be complaining.

Sadly ,I have to say the punter is a loser ,because of his own ego.He wants to catch a winner and boast around!  Winner is for the owner.A punter should only bother about increasing his kitty ,by playing a statistical game, not bothering about the strike rate.He cant urn the tables against , this cozy set up --the club ,bookies and trainers ---by doing opposite of what they want him to do.Avoid Classics and main event of the day.Avoid odds on favourites.Avoid races where the odds are staked against you.Stop chasing winners and the winner may be staring at you.

Kautilya said ...

26-Jun-2021

I had decided not to publish Mr C's return. But seeing this post I coudnlt stop myself. 

So Mr C claimed some postive returns and based on hsi unit bets and betting strategy, here is compilation of the bets and results.

Chanakya will surely find some clarical mistake rather than aknowledge the truth. Figures may be off slightly here and there but the gust remains the same. Qualitiative analysis is Truer than quantitative analysis. 

 

CHANAKYA SPECIAL JAN 2020 SERIES

 

UNIT BET 1100 ( inclusing tax)

 

29/12/2019: MUMBAI

1)  21 jodi   ( 1 won at 85p) {-1350}

2)   351            (3 won at 92p)  {+820}

3)   156  open race (1 lost) -1100}

4)  325   (3 won @ 80p)  {+700}

5)   351  open race  (3 lost) {-1100}

6)  712 ( 7 lost)  {-1100}

 

NET: {-3130}

 

 

MUMBAI SELECTIONS JAN 02, 2020

 

1)  Nicollini   (won at even   +900)

2)    54  jodi  (4 won @ 4   +2800)

3)    1 5 10???   (1 lost  -1100)

4)      87 place 2   (8 won ar 76p , 2 place out  -740)

50 365 open  favorite  will  lose  (3 lost   -1100)

6)   546    (5 lost   -1100)

7)  582 open race   (5 lost     -1100)

 

 

NET:  {-1440}

 

BANGALORE JAN 03, 2020

Tote dividend considered as bookie odds were not available

1)xxx

2)  10 place      (10 plc out    -1100)

3)   (325) open race  favorite  will  lse   (5 won @ 5.5   +3200)

4)  xxxx

5)    1           (1 won @ 50p   +400)

6)   (25) Jodi    ( 5 won @ 1   -100)

7)???????????   favorite may lose   ( fev lost   +1000)

 

NET: { +3400}

 

BANGALORE JAN 04, 2020

 

1)   (2 11 1) open race   (2won @ 2.25    -50)

2)(2 11 4)   again open race (2won @ 1.25    -1050)

3)   8 1  14P  (8 lost 14 plc out    -2200)

4)  8 EW    ( 8 plc @ 70p   -500)

5)     8?       (8 won @ 4  +3900)

6)    (195)    (1 won @ 2  -300)

7)   xxxxx

8)   xxxxxx

 

NET : { +-300 }

 

MUMBAI JAN 05, 2020

 

1)Xccc

2)     5    (5 won at 80p     +700)

3)    2     (2 won at 1.5      +1400)

4)    xxxx

5)    4     (4 won @ 95p   +850)

6)    (516) open race  (6 won @ 6.25  +3950))

7)    2   (2 lost    -1100)

8)    xxxx

 

NET: {+5800}

 

MYSURU JAN 8, 2020

 

1) favorite  of  race  no. 1  CAN NOT  WIN...

2) favorites  of  races  no  2  and 5  may  also  lose...

punters  can  avoid  betting  and  'layers'  can 'eat'...

 

( All fev lost )

 

NET: { +3000 }

 

 

MUMBAI JAN 09, 2020

 

1)   (49) Jodi   ( 9 won @ 2.25   +1050)

2)  4                 (4 lost     -1100)

3)   (45)            (5 won @ 5     +3800)

4)  11 ?             (11 lost    -1100)

5)   3                 (5 lost     -1100)

6)   4                 (4 lost   -1100)

7)  (12  10)       (both lost   -2200)

 

NET: { -1750 }

 

BANGALORE JAN 11, 2020

 

1)  4      ( 4 won at 50p     +400)

2)   29   ( 2 won @ 30p    -900)

3)    3 10 6  OPEN RACE  ( 3 lost    -1100)

4)  (25) JODI   ( 2 won @ 60p  -600 )

5)   12 7 2   OPEN RACE  ( 12 won @ 4.5   +4400)

6)    145    ( 1 WON @ 3    +2900)

7)     (245) OPEN RACE ( 2 won @ 1.25   -1450)

 

NET: { +3650 }

 

MUMBAI JAN 16, 2020

 

1) xxxx

2)    51               (5 lost   -1100)

3)    (23) Jodi     (3 won @ 75p   -450)

4)    10 6            ( 10 lost   -1100)

5)    3                 (3 lost     -1100)

6)    (35) Jodi    (3 won at 5.5     +4300)

7)xxxx

8)    2             (2 lost lost  -1100)       

 

NET: { -550 }

 

 

MUMBAI JAN 18, 2020

 

race 1)   7      (7 lost    -1100)

race2)     6     (6 lost    -1100)

race3)     8     (8 lost    -1100)

R4)   542       (5 lost     -1100)

R5)   (476)  open race (trio lost  -3300)

R6)     4                (4 won @ even   +900)

R7)     (827)          (8 won @ 1.3    -1000)

R8)    (3 11 5)          (5won @ 4   +1700)

R9)     126 open race   ( 1 won at 2.25    +2150)

 

NET: { -3950 }

 

MUMBAI JAN 24, 2020

 

1)   (54) Jodi   (4won @ 1.9   -300)

2)     2             (2 lost    -1100)

3)     (34)         (3 won @ 1   -100)

4)    64             (6 won @ 1.75    +1650)

5)    6?             (6 lost    -1100)

6)    (3 10 5) open race  ( 3 won @ 2.25    -050)

7)    (182)     open race   1 won @ 5      +2700)

8)    4??           (4 won @ 3.8   +3700)

 

NET: { +5400 }

 

 

BANGALORE JAN 26, 2020

 

Bangalore  Derby  is  anybody's race...

 The  winner  should be from:

897             ( 8 won @ even   +700)

 

NET : { +700 }

 

 

 

 

FEB 2020

 

Mumbai Feb2, 2020

 

r1)   (42)open            ( 2won @ 4.75        +3550 )

2)   6                          ( 6 lost    -1100 )

3)   (653)                   ( 5 won @ 3      +700 )

4)   75                        ( 7 won @ 5.5  +5400 )

5)(136)                      ( 6 won @ 1.9   -400)

6)(18 20 15)              ( 15 won @ 3    +700 )

7)  72                         ( 7 won @ 2.25  +2150 )

8)   134                      ( 1 lost               -1100 ) 

 

NET: { +7900 }

 

Mumbai Feb 9, 2020

 

R1)    3                  ( 3 won @ 1.2    +1100 )

R2)   4     67          ( 4 lost     -1100 )

R3)     (82)             ( 2 won @ 2.4    +2100 )

R4)     (3 8 10)       ( 8 won @ 4    +1700 )

R5)     3                  ( 3 won @ 56p   +460 )

R6)     (45)              ( 4 won @ even -200 )

R7)      XXXXX

R8)      9EACHWAY    ( 9 plc @ 50p    -700 )

 

NET: { +3360 }

 

Bangalore Feb 15, 2020

 

R1)   XXXX

R2)    248          ( 2 won @ 2   +1900)

R3)    6   34       ( 6 won @ 4    +3900)

R4)   (65 10)      ( 6 won @ 8  +2700)

R5)    (1 10 2)    ( 2 won @ 5 +2700)

R6)      719         ( 7 lost     -1100 )

R7)    (312)        ( 2 won @ 3 +700)

 

NET: { +10800 }

 

 

Mumbai Feb16, 2020

 

R1)   XXXX

R2)    (421)            ( 2 win @ 1.5    -1800 )

R3)     526)            ( Trio lost    -3300 )

R4)      4     &nb

Chanakya said ...

25-Jun-2021

GLASGOW  PRINCE,

Raising ROI by achieving  win  at  higher  odds  is a truch  and not  a  myth or  a  fiction. But  let  us  differentiate the  meaning  of ROI. Is  it  a  percentage - 30%,40% etc.  or  a  number ; say, invest 1,00,000 get  a return  of 1,50,000 getting  a  profit  of  50,000 ( which  is  also  50% of  investment!)...

This  brings  us to  the  main  issue.

I don't  agree that the  higher  odds  can  be  only  4/1 or 46/10. In  my  opinion it  can  be  10/1  or  even  20/1. Statistics tells  us  that  favorites  win  only  30  to  40%  of races; in  that  case MAJORITY  of  winners  70  to  60%  will  be  at  high  odds with  a  fair  sprinkling  of  10/1 and  20/1 winners. Can  we    deny  that?

Ksmrow has  commented  that  I bet on  10  to  12  runners  in  a  card  of  7  to  8  races. Yes,ofcourse  I do and  do  win  by  this  'weirdo'   method which  I  call  my  'betting  strategy'...

Just  to  prove  my  point  I'll give  a  summarised  detail of  my  winter of  2019/20 period( 29/12/19 to  12/3/20) when  racing  was  stopped...

Mumbai : 15 posts, ROI ~ 35%  Result : +58 units

Bangalore: 5 posts, ROI -???,  Result : +20 units

Mysore (-13) units  and  Kolkata (-2) loss  to  be deducted, lost during  this  period.

Net  result : Gain = 60 +  units

unit  may  be  a  tenner, 1,000 (1100) or  2,000 (2200) etc.

( to  be  continued)

 

Ksmrow said ...

25-Jun-2021

Glasgow prince, 

For years my Strikerate move around 30% from single bet in a race of my choices only, avg win odds range2.25 to 3, not a big gain or loss,on this i said" if one plays  single bet restraining from odds on favourite then 30% strikerate is good enough" that is 30% from  your practical Bets  i never play on less than  80p odds, pass other odds on races if horse falls  in my  priority of selections. 

Now about 4.6 average win Odds arrived from BNG 2018 winter 72races ran1st to10th day winners total odds 333 you can check that it is the figure you get as sample is small i took one More 2019 Bng summer 185 races total win Odds  are710 Avg is 3.8.

To be continued in a day or two