The Central Government has appealed against the orders passed by the single judge regarding Section 31(A)3 of the cgst act.
May be, the High Court will hear the matter in coming weeks. The Central Government will press for stay of that order until the writ appeal is decided by the Division bench of Karnataka High Court.
So, it is safe to presume that even if the Division bench upheld the order of single Judge, the Central Government will appeal in the Supreme Court.
***************
Let us not speculate as to what the final orders of Supreme Court will be.
Of course, till the case is heard at highest Court, the punters have to pay the GST as per the rules.
**************
Pune is hopeful of start of races from Aug 15th. There is no word in respect of racing at Mys, Kolkata or Delhi.
***********
Bangalore should have been started today. But, there is issue of rent. And the BTC is blinking.
***********
9 Replies
Raghavan said ...
21-Jul-2021
Amit Mukherjee,
The Government desires that its citizen do not lose money from betting on horses. It desires that the citizen should not consume alcohol.
According to the Government, gambling & consumption of alcohol are the two serious immoral habits of mankind. They are not crimes. They are sins. So, the government is levying sin tax on these two habits.
You are saying that Government has greedily fixed highest tax slab for horse betting. The Government is framing tax laws only after consulting with experts. And, every citizen must obey/follow that.
Amit Mukherji said ...
21-Jul-2021
Dear Raghavan
As per your survey, if less than 2 lakh patrons visit race course. Why is current govt so hungry for 28%GST then? They should do 3% GST? Makes Sense? High % itself depicts the interest of Govt in the Horse Racing Gold mine...
Raghavan said ...
20-Jul-2021
srinivas c
I do not think the club will conduct off course betting. It is too much to expect the club management to sort out the problems it is facing in less than a week. So, a stalemate. Of course, some illegal bookies may function.
Let us wait till 25th. Let us hope the management will be able to convince the Government. Several hundred tote clerks are in deep trouble. At least their pitiable condition may compel the Government to relax its rigid stand.
I do not know the situation at Mysore.
Raghavan said ...
20-Jul-2021
Sunny bajaj,
Only some newspapers publish race card and results & dividends in respect of all centers.
You are talking of tv coverage! Well. TV Channels believe that horse racing is not a sports but only a form of gambling. In thinking like this, the TV channels are in good company. The Government also believes & endorses that logic. And, we punters also should appreciate that the TV channels & Government are reasonably correct. The punter bets with bookie paying 10% premium in lieu of GST. And the turf clubs are in the stranglehold of bookies.
It is only the punters, trainers, owners, jockeys, turf club management & employees who are interested in horse racing. Less than 2 lakh people are interested in horse racing. (India's population is 130 cr).
What revenue a businessman can expect if he starts a channel dedicated to horse racing?
So, be happy with the two sites indiarace & racingpulse. These two sites are giving almost everything that a punter is interested in.
"Why every turf club is not updating their web site every week?"
Yes. A valid point. The turf clubs should ensure that their site gives all information that a punter is curious about. Hope, the authorities will look into this. They should update at least twice in a week.
Srinivas C said ...
19-Jul-2021
Hyderabad season starts on July 26 , Do any one think we can bet on July 26 on BTC . .
Sunny Bajaj said ...
19-Jul-2021
Why News Channels so not report on horse racing?
Why every race course does not update their websites every week as a responsibility to keep healthy relation with prospects & Visitors.
why there is no reporter who covers all racing centres updates at one portal accurate and fast ? Why ?
Raghavan said ...
19-Jul-2021
Ashok kumar,
Every punter desires that races should resume at BNG asap. A punter can understand if the start of races is halted because of corona.
But, as on date, the situation is near normal. Week-end curfew has gone. Public movement allowed from 5am to 9pm. Bars are open. So, there should be no reason for holding up the races.
But, there is question of rent that is in arrears.
Pitambar Rathore,
The club can give information and you can rely on only such information. HYD is starting on 26th. Even God may not be knowing the starting dates in respect of other turf clubs.
Pitamber Rathore said ...
18-Jul-2021
When will Bangalore or Hydrabad Races Start? Which is the Exact Date?
When will Mysore Races Start? Who can give correct information?
Ashok Kumar said ...
18-Jul-2021
Hope BTC members may be putting allout efforts to Retain Racecourse and to start early
Few months were not good due to pandemic situation
All things r controlled by government good
Hope even BTC may get permission to start Races at the earliest
Regards