India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsRe: Chanakya's Claim - Ii
By Indian_turf_record | 12-Aug-2021@ Chanakya
The old thread is going into back pages and so I am opening a new one so that it remians on front page.
It was you who first introduced the concept of money and especially of Rs. 100 k and it was you who first suggested the name GP, Iimblue and Godzilla as neutral judges.
It was in godzilla's thread on Hyderabad Selections Sunday 1st August 2021 that I posted on 05-08-2021 at 01.13 pm that ,,, "But I am ready to bet ....." The operative word is "bet" and for it to be a bet you have also to put up your stake of Rs. 100 k with the neutral judge. I am not offering a prize of Rs. 100 k. I am betting and you are conversant with rules of a bet.
I also accepted GP the first name selected as neutral judge. GP has declined. I would have thought that you would have checked their availability before naming them. It is for you find a judge. My money is ready.
I will have my say on rules and conditions till they are finalised. Therefater I will accept the judge's verdict. I have recently discovered that on 5/12/2020 Cal, 20/12/2020 Hyd and 25/12/2020 Pun/Mum, no odds are available on respective club websites, indiarace or BOL. Can you tell me what is to be done in such cases ?
Let me assure you that I have no palpitations. I have done preliminary calculations of your performance in 2020-21 and you are in MASSIVE loss. That is why I want to know where to get the odds on the days mentioned so that I can pusblish full stats.
@ IIMBLUE
Your posting of 07-08-2021 08.37 pm.
You are right. People follow one tipsters tips of their own free will. But tipsters also give tips of their own free will. The forum has not invited them to do so. If they give tips and someone benefits and says well done, that's good. If someone follows tips and loses and vents his feelings that is also his right because this is free forum. The only restriction is the language used.
But I think it is wrong for any tipster claim something which is not factually true. If a tipster, on his own, claims, "I gave 5 winners yesterday" when in fact he has given only two, the claim of tipster is open to challenge. He has to either prove his prove or accept his mistake. False claims are an indirect self advertisement. That is my view.
I also like to mention that I have already said that if I win, the money will be donated to Injured Jockeys Fund. From some browsing I see that a bet is not illegal. This site can have its own views. I am also a bit surprised when almost everyone is betting at half tax and admitting it on this site, a lot of people are now worried about legality. You may have a different view and you are entitled to it. If that so we can agree to disagree.
30 Replies
Chanakya said ...
23-Aug-2021ITR.,
I know kautilya has a very low IQ, as is evident from his postings and wrong calculations but you also seem to be reaching his level. Read yor head post and my posts elsewhere and in this thread. I've NOT CHALLENGED anyone of you 3 . I've made a statement to convrt 50k to 500k. ALL YOU 3 - Kautilya, you and D Dynamite are CLAIMING TO BET 100K EACH and CHALLENGING ME TO PROVE THAT I can convert 50 to 500k in one year. I am READY TO PROVE my claim PROVIDED YOU 3 DEPOSIT YOUR BETTING AMOUNT with a acceptable to all judge...
The 'non-existence' soul 'always' butting in every thread has no reason to be here ...
It is correct that selections posted 'here only' will be considered. Agreed.
ONCE AGAIN - read my post correctly , interpret and THEN respond...
Dancing Dynamite said ...
21-Aug-2021Chanakya is an afraid main now. His posting clearly shows that. First he starts with his 100k, then he agrees for 200K. and logically, when he accepts my bet (with reduced target of 450k), he should deposit 300 k in total. But now he wants to deposit 100k. and that too "may". He has made a mockery of himself.
My challenge was totally different from other two. my challenge is with reduced target and settlement through a bookie. I think, Chanakya should stick to his words and not run away. My Challenge stills stands. He deposits 100K with a bookie of his own choice (against my challenge) and I will also deposit the same with his bookie. Regarding challenge with kautilya and ITR, he should find a judge amicabley and start the contest by depositing 200K. Either of us should win or lose 100K each (gross of judge fee). Actually, he does not have even 2 Rs. to play, let alone betting 100K. I further give him a gift of Rs. 5000, when he accepts all 3 challenges and deposit 300K. This 5000 will be a gift and not connected with the end result. Is the game ON??
Chanakya said ...
20-Aug-2021@ IIMBlue,
OK , I understand....
Kautilya said ...
20-Aug-2021Chanakya said he "MAY" deposit 100k later on if he defeat becomes certain. Such a gasbag. IIMblue his true blue chamcha so i dont trust either of them to honour the terms of the challenge. IF he is challenging three of us he needs to deposit 300k. How can one trust who lies through his teeth all the time. He very well know that the contest will never go through, I give to him for his high IQ for that bluff. Let him post his selections anywhere. We will have them exposed. No use thowing stones in mud. Umpire need to be neutral like Glasgow Prince.
Raghavan said ...
20-Aug-2021So, three people, Kautilya, ITR & Dancing dynamite gets 16,600+, whereas the umpire gets 50k. The three people to claim that 16,600+ have to deposit one lakh with the umpire. Chanakya will deposit one lakh only if it becomes evident that he will lose in the contest.
Chanakya
I was sure about you losing the contest; but you have hit upon an ingenious way to back out. I do not think any of the three will be interested in the contest anymore.
Iimblue said ...
20-Aug-2021@Chanakya ,
I thank you for your belief imposed on me , but politely , I have to decline the offer to be judge of this contest.My simple reasoning is that this contest should never take place.
A tipster is giving his selections many hours before the race , and leave alone others following the selection , he himself is not obliged to play his selection.
For example , will anyone play an alarmingly drifting horse in the betting ring, just because he has tipped it ?
Once a tipster declares his selection , it is no longer his baby.If some other members want to adopt the tip , it is their baby , their lookout ,purely their risk.
An attempt is going on by some, to bind a tipster to his selectiion , just to bring him down !
ITR and Dancing Dynamite are well meaning individuals and I request them to continue debate and not get into contest.
Kautilya ,I think exists with the sole purpose to bring down Chanakya.Even he had to keep that name to oppose Chanakya !
An attempt has been going on by some members to hound out popular tipsters.See how they are after Ruchi and of late ,on Harsh.In the past , a well meaning gentleman like late Vamanan was hounded out !
Frustrated punters are a bane not only in the race course but in this forum too! They are best left alone !
Chanakya said ...
19-Aug-2021@ all,
THis phoney man is trying to improve the rating or 'hits' helped by a perennial loser whose post is 'visible' within 45 minutes while my post takes 6 hours to 2 days to appear! 'Game/(s) people play' is a book written 50 to 70 years ago - forums still try it. This is/was a thread opened by a 'bookish' man with 50 or more years of Fonn's record books.............. I also have last 30 or 31 years records - these books of 1970 t0 1990 have to be sold as 'raddi' when I retired...
I want to know how many punters have won races with the help of these record books?
I hope at least 1 will come out - but with a proof....
All these challengers are crowing - 'my money is ready' ,.... Arre bhai select a judge of your choice and START........................
WHY WRIGGLING AND ASKING A JUDGE OF MY CHOICE...
Select a judge who is acceptable to many...
why should I do it you also can do it - that will show your true character...
GO ahead and select a judge - acceptable to many - not ALL...
Chanakya said ...
19-Aug-2021OK. The 'game' is on. You three, i.e., ITR, Kautilys and Dancing Dynamite should deposit 100k each with the judge and I 'may' also deposit 100k later on if my defeat becomes certain so that minus (50k) compensation rest of the money (i.e., 350k) is returned to all 3 in equal proportion.
I'll not use rolling but use only ONCE in day a double and if I reach a corps of 200k I'll have option to increase my bet from 2000 to 5000 for which prior intimation will be given...
Champ said ...
19-Aug-2021Don't worry. He'll soon be back with old sour wine in a new bottle. He can't stay for long without peddling his unfulfilled dreams as reality, here.
Chanakya said ...
18-Aug-2021@ IIMBlue,
Please confirm whether you are accepting to be judge at a compensation of 50k. It is a time consuming job and depends on the free time avaible. You can accept or reject it without any problem...
Raghavan said ...
18-Aug-2021ITR
If Chanakya does not post in this site hereafter, it is a good riddance.
Do not give him an excuse to restart posting his sound selections. I mean 99% sound and 1% selections.
It was right on your part to insist that if and when contest starts, only the postings in horsetalk should be considered.
Chanakya should first nominate the umpire and the umpire should agree to that. Even with 50k remuneration, Glasgow Prince refused to be an umpire. I think other horsetalk members also refuse to be umpire/s.
Come out with profit or loss statement in respect of Chanakya's bets from Nov. 2020 to Mar. 2021. He is harping non stop about his so called profits during December 2019 to March 2020. Let us see what explanations he chooses to give for his losses from Nov 2020 onwards.
Raghavan said ...
18-Aug-2021Dancing dynamite,
It is between you and Chanakya; I do not have any problem with that contest. All I desired is you should win from bookies. And not from Chanakya.
Anyway, there is not much progress regarding selection of umpire so far.
ITR has pointed out that Chanakya has lost 4 lakh during the just concluded winter season. Even if ITR is correct to the extent of 50%, then Chanakya is loser of 2 lakhs.
Chaltha hai. He had already admitted earlier that he lost 10 lakhs in 30 years. Another 2 or 3 lakhs loss should not make much difference.
Indian_turf_record said ...
17-Aug-2021@ Chanakya
In my posting of 06-08-2021 09:42 am, I had proposed draft rules of the bet. You had accepted proposed rules 1,2 and 3 according to your posting of 06-08-2021 08.14 pm. Rule 1 read:-
"1. Only selections posted posted on HT to be considered."
Now vide your17-08-2021 12.29 pm you are saying that your will not be posting selections on HT but only on your blog. Are you unilaterally backing out of an agreed rule ?
I have said umpteen times that my money is ready. You have to name the judge and how and where the money is to be delivered to him. So don't attribute any wriggling to me.
Chanakya said ...
17-Aug-2021@ all,
I am in the habit of reposting again my postings which has been 'accepted' by the 'acknowledgement'. athe partisan attitude is nt acceptable and therefore, I will not be posting my selections on this forum but will post only on my blog.Furthermore , I will reduce my interaction here to the barest minimum, closure to nil in future...
Goodluck to all...
Chanakya said ...
16-Aug-2021ITR.;
Don't try to WRIGGLE OUT. On my thread 'Goldmine' I said I may be able to or I can convert 50k to 500k. It was a STATEMENT or a opinion or a confidence to succeed but it never had a betting angle. The words were ' let the NORMAL' racing start I may ( or perhaps can) convert 50k to 500k.
kautilya jumped in and started his normal duplicity and later on, on 5/8/21 at 1.13 pm you jumped and WROTE - 'I am ready to bet that you can not make 50k to 500k...'
I've not asked or CHALLENGED kautilya or you to COUNTER my statement by an EQUAL BET but you both were insistent on betting .
So here we go. Both of you put 100k each with a person of MY/your choice, acceptable, to me and let the contest begin...
I know why both of you are jumping in your 'frocks' because in a year therev used to be 260 to 300 race days at 5 centers- Mumbai/Pune, Bangalore, Hyderabad, Mysore , Kolkata ( I leave Dehi & Chennai) where I can bet and roughly 2000 race were run during this period. Now only Hyderabad is operating , Pune Bangalore , Mysore kolkata are 'silent'. Even the winter season racing at these centers is not certain. INSPITE OF THAT I ACCEPT THE CHALLENGE FROM BOTH OF YOU EVEN IF RACE DAYS ARE LESS THAN 250 AND RACES ARE ALSO LESS THAN 2000.
Accept and confirm....
Dancing Dynamite said ...
16-Aug-2021@Raghavan,
In gambling, winning and loss is as important as making a good bet. For me, chanakya challenge is a good bet for me, so I am inclined enough to offer him a discount too. If the odds would be 2 to 1 in his favour, then also, I consider that as a good bet. And getting that bet at even money is mouth watering.
I am not here to fleece chanakya or anyone else. I am here to make a good bet (which we seldom get at race course).
Raghavan said ...
15-Aug-2021IIM Blue,
ITR is sufficiently senior. It is better if you resist the temptation to advise him. In case you have any kind of problem because of the heated debate between two seniors, you should not be advising him (ITR) in isolation. Such advise should be to Chanakya also. That is the simpolest thing that you can do in terms of fairness and reasonableness.
Normally ITR gives inputs only in response to some queries about old incidents in racing. If he disagrees with the claims of Chanakya, and start calling his (Chanakya's) bluffs and lies, the least we can do is to maintain silence.
Chanakya has claimed that he can convert 50k to 500k. Kautilya & ITR have expressed doubts. (I believe, Kautilya also is sufficiently senior). Forget about Chanakya. Even his creator Brahma can not convert 50k to 500k. If Chanakya has some extra cash and ready to squander, that is his lookout. The money will end up in bookies cash box.
I do not think the proposed contest will really start and run smoothly. They are yet to identify the referee. And, of course, there is admin who may not encourage this contest.
So, stop advising one of the parties. Your admiration & loyalty towards Chanakya is well known. And it is totally unnecessary to display such devotion & admiration as if it is badge of honour.
I would like to see in this site the old IIM Blue who was quite vocal against half tax bets.
Indian_turf_record said ...
15-Aug-2021@ Chanakya
I made offer to bet Rs. 100 k and will always stand by my offer. But it is a bet and has to be matched with similar amount from your side. I am agreeable that Rs. 50 k goes to judge (my suggeestion in first place) and winner takes Rs. 150 k. What winner does with his share of money is his lookout.
Bet is between you and me. Do not bring others into it. If you want to have similar bets with others you can have them but those transactions have nothing to do with our bet.
I will not suggest a judge because I do not know any HT member personally or where he is located. I cannot name a judge without getting his prior approval and I cannot do that.
So please find a judge and tell me how he would like to receive the money.
I will always stand by my committment but prospect is no longer interesting. The entire objective in entering the bet was to prove that your system does not work. I have just completed my calculations of your system from Nov 2020 and March 2021 and find that at conservative estimate your system lost over Rs. 4 lakhs during that period. I know horse can finish last in one race and win classic in next outing but I do not think your system can do it. I have said your system beacuse you yourself may be in profit if you stopped following your system and just played a small double on Immortality in Oaks and Derby.
My aim was to bring shortcoming of your system before people with blind faith like Einstein (by the way, do you know where he has disappeared ?). I have achieved that.
Hals said ...
14-Aug-2021@ IIMBLUE. Well said. Most of the tipsters wants to participate inHT out of love to horse racing, exept for a few, may be to showcase their talent which is welcome. But one can disagree with the choice of other irrespective of the results, there is no compulsion. Applaud the positive result, forget the failure as no point in blaming as nobody compelling anybody to play their choice. Let us leave it at this. We can have healthy discussion and debate on various points. Thanks for your neutral stand and hope everyone will agree.
Chanakya said ...
14-Aug-2021ITR.,
I understand that it was also you in addition to kautilya who initially disagreed with my statement or claim to convert 50k to 500k in a yeat and offered a bet of 100k 'unilaterally' without asking me whether I'm ready or not ready to put 100k from my side. However, I am accepting to put 100k if you and Kautilya also put 100k each and if dancing dynamite and any other personalso wnts to put 100k to join he is also welcome. If isucced all the money minus 50k (compensation to the judge) comes to me If I lose it may go to the highest unit winner from the participants, if all of you agree.
Regarding judge you can also sugget some name/(s). IIMBlue and next Godzilla are my choice if they accept...
If there is no odds in the result books - Cole/BOL/Vel then following odds against the tote returns can be accepted:
tote win - Rs. 11 (odds 2/10), Rs 12 (odds 4/10), 13( 5/10),14&15(7/10), 16(8/10), 17& 18(even), 19& 20(5/4) , 21&22(3/2), 23-25(7/4), 26&27(2/1), 28&29(5/2), 30&31(3/1), 32,33&34(7/2), 33-35( 15/4), 36-38(4/1), 39-41(9/2), .......47&48(5/1).....55&56(6/1), 59&60(7/1), 65,66(8/1), 70&71( 9/1), 75& 76(10/1), more than 80 less than 90 (15/1).
This table has been created after lot of effort, if agreed will be a standard for non availability of bookmaker odds...
Iimblue said ...
14-Aug-2021@I T R
The only sentence I agree in your lead post is the last sentence ---"we agree to disagree ".
I will leave Chanakya out of it and only concentrate on your views on tipsters.
In my opinion , people post their selections in this site mainly because they genuinely want to help fellow punters.Some like Racebro ,Dharmesh and Ruchi do deep study and also give their reasoning why they made these selections.These insights may help some punters in crystallizing their selections.It is not necessary that a tipster's selection should pass.If he is adding to the knowledge of other punters , that is good enough , in my opinion.
A tipster by posting his selection , is sticking his neck out.In return he is not expecting anything.No one should follow any tipster blindly.If you are playing ,it is your own money ,it is your own selection.I cannot agree with your logic that a tipster should be blamed for a punter's loss.
A tipster is posting his selections at least two hours before the race.He is not having the benefit of watching movement of odds.I doubt if many tipsters will stick to their own selections when the time to bet comes.I fully understand their position --tipping is different , playing is different.If you come across a new factor , after posting surely you will change your opinion and why not ?
Myself --I do not tip.When I was very active (pre GST days ), I used to shortlist my horses and make my final selections only after watching odds movement.Then , I have pathological hatred for favourites .If a favourite is winning ,I skip that race.But then most of the races are won by favourites.I am not a big bettor and I play only at BTC tote.(lost its charm post GST).For all these reasons ,I have no capabilities to be a tipster.But I appreciate all the tipsters here ,whether their selections passed or not.
No purpose is going to be served by proving or disproving their claims.Our comman enemy is the System --govt (gst ) , club (no facilities , poor supervision and professionals (lack of professionalism ).Do not fight with fellow punters.
Raghavan said ...
14-Aug-2021Dancing dynamite,
There may be some elite punters to whom one lakh rupees is peanuts.
But, even in the current days of money value, it is a decent sum. Especially to race punters it is like life-saver oxygen.
The contest has not started yet. They are still on the look out for umpire. You expressed the desire to join. But, I am doubtful whether Chanakya will welcome you.
ITR & Kautilya are banging Chanakya left & right. I know both Chanakya & ITR are above 80. I do not know about Kautilya; but I think he is also sufficiently senior. Let those elderly people hammer out a solution.
Do not try to fleece Chanakya.
Fleece the bookies.
Indian_turf_record said ...
13-Aug-2021@ Chanakya
You brought in the Judge so you name him.
You still have not answered my query about what is to be done if no site carries the odds.
I have never said I will frame the rules. If you read my head post(now on previous page) I have said "finalised through dialogue". Dialogue means that if you don't like a rule, you have state why and what is acceptable to you.
My money is ready but I have to the name of judge, where is he located. Then I can tell you time required to deposit it with him.
Indian_turf_record said ...
13-Aug-2021@ Phantom Raider
There is a typo in my posting 13-08-2021 12.48 pm. Rs. 1,000 should read as Rs. 10,000 (ten thousand). The typo is regretted.
Dancing Dynamite said ...
13-Aug-2021I am pretty sure, Chanakya will never deposit the amount. He is playing on the assumption that nobody will deposit 100k. For him, it seems to be a big amount, listening to which, everybody will run. But little does he know that for some punters, its a peanut.
I am also willing to participate in the bet. And since I am late to the invitation, I offer Chanakya, Juice of 10%. My bet will be that he cannot make 50k into 450k (not 500K). Other conditions remain the same. I would like that the amount be placed with a bookie (He can deposit it with Mumbai bookie, and I will also do the same). The bookie oral commitment that the money is with him for both the customers, will suffice for me.
Indian_turf_record said ...
13-Aug-2021@ Phantom Raider
I am still in the process of finalising my calculations but I can say with confidence that from November 2020 to January 2021 the loss is well over 100 unit bets. That is to say that anyone following the system with Rs. 100 as unit bet would have lost Rs. 1,000.
I need some time to complete the calculations so that they can stand Auditor's scrutiny.
Chanakya said ...
13-Aug-2021ITR.,
Yes, I'll put 100k with a neutral judge but don't try to be clever and behave like a crook that Kautilya is. You can not have unilateral 'say' when you 'demand' equal amount from your opponent.
And don't harp on my past performance - good,bd or indifferent. We are contesting the current performance which will start when you mke payment to the judge. you may also suggest sombody who is ready to accept. I think 25% of 200k should be OK with him for the trouble taken by him.
Kk Menon said ...
12-Aug-2021ITR has no right to prove any claim right or wrong..most cases claims are wrong but pretend like its true..
Let everyone claims.. cheaters cannot survival at the longer..end
ITR YOU SHOULD OPEN YOUR ALL DATA BANK TO PUBLIC..DONTS WASTE YOU TIME TO PROVE RIGHT WRONG...
Raghavan said ...
12-Aug-2021ITR,
Betting at half tax is outright illegal. It will not be granted "legal" status just because a large number of punters are betting with bookies.
At a conservative guess, I think I have posted 500+ letters in this & other site questioning the bookies who are openly cheating the Government & club.
At Bangalore, during 2019-20 winter, bookies stall was closed for most of the days because commercial tax department, gst council or police raided the bookie's stall too many times. People were travelling to Mysore on a daily basis because the bookies were present there.
By the by, IIM Blue was also strong critic of half tax bets. I only hope that he still continues to bet at tote.
But, he is also a strong defender of Chanakya. Perhaps, he wants to be in good books of Chanakya. May be he benefited from Chanakya's tips. Best of luck to him.
Phantom Raider said ...
12-Aug-2021Hello Indian_Turf_Record,
This is something I have also been very curious to find out if Chanakya's claim is valid and with proof.
Glad you have made an effort to bring this in the open with valid records and stats.
I think punters need to be shown the reality of betting on races....it is very important...some claim to be able to make money but I personally think otherwise. If we have a champion punter so let us see their consistancy and all of us benefit from it too.
My suggestion is if we find one such consistant tipster or bettor then we all follow him and get some profit out of it and share the same so that we all (those loosing regularly) do not loose more money (unless we can afford it)...(just a suggestion and if others agree)
Best wishes
PR
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now