Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

An Addendum To Major's Article On New Sires

By B. Vijay | 14-Aug-2021

As always Maj. Nargolkar 's article on new stallions was packed with facts and figures and his expert analysis and opinion. However while

discussing Basem and his sire Pivotal , Siyouni ( 2007 ) has escaped attention. Another Gr. 1 winner by Pivotal , Siyouni has , more importantly, emerged as a world leading sire very much in the news today. To mention a couple of his progeny , Sottsass ( 2016 ) won the French Derby and the Arc. Then St. Mark's Basilica ( 2018 ) completed the French 2000 Guineas and Derby double and added the Eclipse Stakes. It must be emphasized that Siyouni as a sire is way ahead of other sire sons like Farhh , Kyllachy and others whom I rate as strictly average or at best a shade above average. Thus I

cannot rate Pivotal as a successful sire of sires.

B. Vijay

Post Your reply

3 Replies

Murari said ...

15-Aug-2021

I very rarely frequent this site, but was indeed interested to read my dear friend B. Vijay's input on the subject of Racehorse Pedigrees.

Forget about "Sire of Sires", I have always rated Mr. Vijay as a "Guru of Gurus" when it comes to matters of Racehorse Pedigree and Horseracing. I still remember his very kind gift to me - over 10 years ago - of his Pedigree Reference tomes, which regrettably I was not able to carry to England with me upon my return.

But, he did manage to plant a seed in me, through our extended discussions at the BTC, for an interest in Pedigree matters.

While I could not in my wildest dreams claim to have a smidgen of the knowledge of the two Gentlemen in this discussion, I have been very privileged to see up close the likes of the legendary late Galileo (and that vision in gold, the beautiful Derby winner 'Australia', and the - just missed Triple Crown Champion - 'Camelot').

And also 'Dubawi (Sheikh Mohammed) and 'Frankel' (late Prince Khaled Abdullah). Both Gentlemen great patrons of the sport. 

'Kingman' is another one I would rate highly in the Galileo/Dubawi/Frankel league, and I understand Coolmore have high hopes for Wootton Bassett as a successor to Galileo. Only time will tell. 

Mr. Vijay, wish you all the best with your top class American Stallion and promising Stud Farm. Bangalore sorely needs a quality operation!

Hals said ...

14-Aug-2021

Always the articles of Major are more interesting n informative. Additional input from B.Vijay furthermore informative. Being a racing enthusiast, leave alone the part of punter, would like to thank and wish to have more n more information please.

Major S. Nargolkar (retd.) said ...

14-Aug-2021

Dear Vijay, 

      Yes, Siyouni did pass under an old radar. Thank you for mentioning him and his most recent achievements.

      I was not thunderstruck with Pivotal at first. Then a very dear friend, Zeyn Mirza, passed on an article appearing on the website genesisthoroughbred.com. I then saw him in a new light. Of course, that article highlights Pivotal's prowess as a damsire. You may find the article interesting but I dare say you have already read it. A voracious reader like you is unlikely to have missed it.

       Farhh, I think is a bit under-rated. He has produced some very good horses. Excellent Art would have, perhaps, done better had got a consistent number of mares in India rather than moving from feast to famine. And Siyouni, as you have brought out, is the toast of the moment.

       Just as two stud farms dominate in India, Coolmore and Darley operations make it difficult for a stallion standing at Cheveley Park Stud to grab the limelight. Would Pivotal have been recognised as a sire of successful sires by now had he been standing at Coolmore ? Difficult to say but it is a thought.

        All the same, thanks for your inputs.