Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Taxes On Winning Amount Hrc Online

By Ajp007 | 16-Aug-2021

Hello All

Recently I investes 3000 and in one of the race via HRC online betting and won 15900/-, 

I had played 500 tkts 2 times on a horse which won at 159

But ht e HRC dedutcted 30% nd just gave me 11400 how is it possible,

Is the tax liable on the ammount beyond 10000 i.e. 5900 in my case.

my investment is 3000 how can any one charge the taxt on complete 15900 isint this bulshit .

can somebody throw some light on the same.

 

Post Your reply

10 Replies

Anonymous said ...

24-Aug-2021

Regarding hrc and bet India online betting one of my friend had asked for the TDs vouchers which they have paid to govt on behalf of him but until now they have not replied to his mails from past one month .that is they have taken the tax AMT for themselves and simply showing the details in apps it is our right to collect the TDs certificates but till now they have not send any mails regarding this so pls make sure to collect the same because it is your right if you ask turf winner they put blame on hrc and heailed the same to hrc but still there is no response from both sides pls understand all the punters that they are doing some other calculations which is y they are hesitant to provide vouchers 

Jp said ...

18-Aug-2021

@ Raghavan you are correct. Winning from lotteries,horse racing and prize money or winning in kind like car/bike etc TDS should be deducted @ flat 30% plus cess etc. Value of the prize article is determined and TDS should be paid to receive them. No slab rate or basic exemption limit are applicable. The race club gives car/bike/scooter during derby day to attract crowd. The winner should pay TDS and then collect the gift.

Raghavan said ...

17-Aug-2021

AJP007,

It is immaterial whether your bets are 500/- each, two times or 10/- each 100 times.  You are betting through computer and computer considers your entire bet as one transaction.  If you had punched tickets at HRC counter,  (50 tickets twice or 25 tickets 4 times) there was a good chance to escape from  the TDS.

I think you have received 11,430/- & not 11,400.  Now you have to disclose it in your tax returns of 2021-22.  Do not expect any refund/s.  (Even if your income from all sources does not exceed 2,50,000/-, I do not think you will get any refund from the taxes paid from horse race winnings).

Of course I am not authority in tax matters.  But, I am of the opinion that you will not get any refund.  Perhaps, you consult your friends who have some exposure in tax matters or tax lawyer/ Chartered accountant.

Srinivas Varadarajan,

What is this "you can claim through RETURNS as per rules"? 

Of course, I once again submit that I am not authority.  My understanding of tax laws is zero.  But, I think that you are somewhat confused on this issue.

I will just speak what I believe the correct position: 

The winnings from  betting on horses should be taxed at 30%   TDS is different.  It is the responsibility of website owner or turf club to recover TDS at 30% if the winnings exceed 10k.

Now the question comes as to how will they calculate income tax? 

Presume that your income from all sources is Rs. X, and your winnings from betting on horses is 14,900/-. 

Then your income will be Rs. X + 14,900.

Now tax on the amount X will be worked out separately.  That may either be zero or 5,000/- .  Then the tax on 14,900 will be worked out.  And the assessee is liable to pay the sum of tax from profession & the tax on winnings from betting.

So, even if the income of the assessee from all other sources is zero, he has to pay taxes on horse race winnings.

This is purely my understanding.  I AM NOT TAX EXPERT.  Do not get carried away by what I have stated.  The right person to give a correct answer is tax lawyer.  

*******

Dancing dynamite, Spade or IIM Blue,

I am sure you three are knowing about taxation matters much much better than tax lawyers, Chairman of CBDT, Finance Minister and highly reputed Chartered Accountants.  Convey the correct position to AJP 007.   Please do something helpful to fellow horsetalk member.  Let that be free for first case.  Thereafter you can fix some tariff.

You were lecturing to me from roof tops about the tax matters.  Now. answer the punter who has made enquiries.

Ajp007 said ...

16-Aug-2021

Thank you all for your reply ,

So if I bet 1000 tickets on a 11 rupee place bet and I win 11000 .

And the site deducts 11000 ka 30 percentage.so I actually did not win I loose right ????

 

 

Bigboss said ...

16-Aug-2021

Above 10k  winning amount 30% tax cutting 

Srinivasan Varadarajan said ...

16-Aug-2021

Even if you ?500 per ticket or ?200 per ticket, the output is total money you won in that race (Win+place+forecast+quinella etc..).

If that exceed ?10000/- is taxable. How they tax 

1. On total amount

2. On the amount exceeding ?10000/-

3. Total amount - Principle

This tax you can claim through RETURNS, (as per the rules).

If you are already in the 30% slab youcannot claim.

Santosh Kumar V K said ...

16-Aug-2021

APJ 007,

Try splitting your bets on Betindiaraces Site also.Though they may not accept all bets becing accepted by HRC site.

TDS at source is applicable even if your Dividend is Rs-10001/-.

They go strictly by the rule book.Regards

Sixth_sense said ...

16-Aug-2021

Turf support has a good support system. Their email id is mentioned on play.hydraces.com

 

Please raise ticket there

M.sainath said ...

16-Aug-2021

4470/.   30%.    Deduction.   For.    14900/.  In that race only

Kurban said ...

16-Aug-2021

Dear,

TDS summary shown in (today's play) section in Betindia app.

For HRC app please check on play details.

Thanks