Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Nizam''s Gold Cup : Hue & Cry: Fine Revised Ratings:15th Aug'21

By Achem Kumar | 17-Aug-2021

   It's a usual fashion to go for post race analysis & find out some inferences & conclusions. Just putting one step forward, let's visualise a table given below.

##Comparative /Imposed Ratings Table Race-37 Hyd 15th Aug'21##

Current Rtg  Present Rtg  Change In Rtg   Name Of Horse  Placing''s In Set 

(87)             (68)              (+19)             Alluring Silver            First

(50)             (42)             (+8)                Bisate                   Second

(113)           (113)            (00)                Salazaar                   Third 

(66)            (66)              (00)                North  Star                Fourth

(99)            (99)              (00)                Point  To Prove          Fifth 

(65)            (65)              (00)                Roaring Tiger             Sixth

(84)            (62)              (+22 Max)       Taimur                       Seventh 

**Stood last horse penalised/ratings increased  +22 & winner's  ratings increased +19, keep in  mind the beauty of the system & imagine  handicapper's compulsons.

??Now see last track work dates & venues of the above horses,please. 

1)Alluring Silver 6th August, Pune.

2)Bisate --> 13th July  Hyd, ran in a race on 8th August, Hyderabad.

3)Salazaar  7th August, Bangalore 

4)North Star 11th August, Pune 

5)Point To Prove 10th August, Bangalore 

6)Roaring Tiger 10th August, Pune 

7)Taimur  4th August, Pune 

   Heard/read/visualised at this platform noise/ arguments regarding 2nd placed Bisate --> bay filly by  Western Aristocrat(USA)-Verbier, a daughter of  Kingda Ka  (AUS) & her fit  distance seems to me 1400-1600M. She was winner of Race-22,distance 1400M in Hyderabad on 8th Aug'21 & next run with a gap of mere 7 days  (advantage of a run & rest of the field with a lay off). Moreover style of her running after gate exit settled down, caught front & this was done nicely by herself/her jockey, made Bisate compulsorily going & going on & rest of the followers following her  marrily.

     There is  nothing big to boast about Bisate, perhaps in next outing in a good  standard  set of horses may not perform as she performed in Nizam's Cup. Bisate out  of total 5 outings  (before  Nizam's Cup) 4 times in money & started her career from Hyderabad.

    Alluring Silver grey filly, out of Leitir Mor (Ire)-Personal Allure  (USA), first time  touched soil of Malakpet (also ran first time out of Western Ghats) in her life that too with a gap of almost 4&1/2 months. British produced stayers genetically best for 2400M & Americans produced stayers of 2000M. Let's wait & see next Group Race I.e. The President Of India GoldCup, a distance of 2400M. My assumption that Sire Leitir Mor passes genetical characters of brooding mare as it is, like Sire China Visit in their next generation foals, may be same "Phenotype".

    Salazaar's performance was below par (Spent Force??)& before commenting anything wait for his next  outing.

  This is the  "Mercy" done by connections to field which horse, actual distance, selection of jockey, track work when & where leads to "Ghal Mel" in ultimate results, my small personal thinking.

     Present Rating System is an artificial/fake/false system just to keep manage/ run things in order. (System of rating, have it 's own limitations & boundaries). Different co-ordinates of racing follow it with their whims & vested interest, knowingly or vice-versa but the "Individual Strong Co-ordinate  (horse) who has to perform in actual race/track, not know anything about their or competitors rating etc. & result of an event solely depend on everyday current mood & temperament of horse, basically.

Post Your reply

19 Replies

Ksmrow said ...

23-Aug-2021

@Sun, @Sun,Try to elaborate 1,2,3,4 

1) first adopted  my speed rating  system to know potential  ratings  of 2/3 yr olds after 2 or 3 runs even after 1 run if placed,or after theirs first season,earlier in maiden 3yr old races colt or gelding  and fillies  allotted 54&52.5kg weight now increased to 56&54.5  this & increase of bottam weights we can take 56 or 55 weight no problem.

2)this is potential rating we arrive  by its best good run for (3,4 yrs) their last3or4  runs give their strength generally they improve then add points if not stick to original for atleast 5 more runs or upto end of current running season.for older horses best run in last two seasons can be taken.

Rating of horse don't  change

By distance as i earler said for each distances a certain time assumed as 100 rating

On that base we allotted  rating what iam trying to say is 100 is 1mn11.5sec time for 6fl,100 is 1.24.5 for 1400

and for mile 1-37 is 100.hope

You got the point.

3&4) answered partly in above write up.

5)false rails, pentrometer  differences last year in a thread many experts  given

Their opinion in i think in Glasgow Prince thread, and i think i have given my view  while discussed on jetfire runs. 

My work out;

For pentro fix a reading as base for center

Bng 3.8

Mum 4.0

Hyd 4.5

Mys 3.0

Add or subtract points according to less or more than above.

False rails presently clubs using  rodo meter distance don't  change still i take  adding to tme as 1/10sec to 1mtr width rails.

 

Sun said ...

22-Aug-2021

@ksmrow,

Sorry as I was travelling I could not see your post earlier.

Yes I reember this method.My few comments are

1.Today since Min Bottom is 49/50Kg is there a need to take it as 55Kg

2.If I consider A Horse which keeps running at Difference Distances does it Speed Rating Change say being 90 for 1200 and 80 for 1600 and by this can we guess whether the horse is On Try on a day.

3.Does your system plot Speed Rating for all horses which have run on a day OR only for Placed Horses.

4,If a Soeed Rating is computed for a Horse do you keep it at that Level for all future Races till it is surpassed OR is it computed for every new race

5.Lastly How you adjust for False Railings?

Eagerly waiting for your reply.

Thanks

Ksmrow said ...

20-Aug-2021

@sun, I have gone through your posts about salazaar&Bisate in this thread and also other thread I appreciate your effort nobody through more light on this I am sure  every body more or less agreed what you said, The  point in my post is Bisate reached its class where it belongs by penalty and salazaar because of age may win a race at the most,Nri sun at the official rating of 40 very good chance of winning two  races in this monsoon  season. Now about 54 is near to mean weight Between(Top wt60 and bottom wt47). 

For the second query I give my procedure step by step, 

1) time clocked (official published time or raw time) 

2) Stranded time(consider pentro meter reading &false rails or track variation) 

3)Synchronized time [at wt 54(add or subtract by reading the race or by viewing)] 

Now we get time clocked from it you get speed rating, compare( for every center and every distance Time is fixed ie assumed as rating 100).

 

 

Sun said ...

20-Aug-2021

@ksmrow;

Any logic to take 54Kg as Reference Weight for Speed Rating Comparisions?

What is the Unit of Speed Rating Is it Km per hour ?

Achem Kumar said ...

19-Aug-2021

  @Ksmrow ji 

      Sir, Self admire/appreciate your good logic & behind this hidden is your tremendous hard work.

     R-22, 8th August'21 NRI Sun, very late tried to challenge Bisate & stood 2nd, besides these two horses,no other horses tried  (Not On Job,rest of the field & finished the formality of completing race), that set was having some good name but their vested target, was other race in future.

     My opinion is different about NRI Sun, difficult to win races in this current season of Hyderabad. Moreover, Sir you might be knowing better Trn. S. Sreekant & his powerful tactics/compilation of work.

   Time/ Clock theories deliver successful results generally around 30%,as per my belief. Let's hope best.

My sincere thanks.

Achem Kumar said ...

19-Aug-2021

 @  Sumant Dalmiya  ji 

   Sir self appreciate your "Good Memory" & **Maharaja Scindia's Family** / your affection to racing field.

a) Right Sir, North Star reached in vicinity of Class-1 horses as maiden & his as well as his **Sire Name** , now will  be in the list of record  book. (A Big  Deal)

b) Small set  (7 runners & out of that 3 charges of  Trn.P.Shroff) created/ caused anamalous results talk line for the 4th placing. Roaring Thunder was slowly out, so it seems, clear instructions to Joc. P.S.Chauhan to be 4th placed with his mount in this tiny/ non competitive set, or was it  circumstancial compulsion?? Point To Prove (Charge of Trn. A.Mangalorkar) stood 5th, verdict head behind North Star. 

c) Admirality  (Sire) performing  his stud duties under custody of Trn. P.Shroff, an old piece of information. North Star is Admirality's "First Foal To Reach Elite Class-1", plus as maiden also.

     4 year old maiden won Indian Derby (Mumbai) in Indian  Racing, long back,taken place.

My sincere thanks. 

Achem Kumar said ...

19-Aug-2021

@ Sun ji

 Delighted with your feelings, Sir.

a) Your estimated ratings are in close proximity with official ratings.

b) Very much true about Bisate's "Fate & Future", revealed by you.

c) Self doubt about **Weight Carrying Capacity** of Bisate.

Thanks.

Ksmrow said ...

19-Aug-2021

The horse which impressed me most  is Nri sun  when it narrowly lost to Bisate iam sure atleast 2wins are in store dont miss to back.

Long back Nelston won in 2mins 7sec on monsoon track Went on to win indian derby Now hyderabad monsoon track giving much faster timings even we add 2 sec to bisate clocked time in Nizam gold cup (pentro5.2 ), i think it is not flash in the pan the horse has potential my speed ratings at level weights(54) According to nizam goldcup Run:-

Alluring silver(90)

Salazaar(88)

Bisate(85)

Sumant Dalmiya said ...

19-Aug-2021

After many years a Maiden reaches Class I as rating of North Star goes up to 84 after running 4th in Nizam's Cup - There have been others before, but Name of the last case eludes me - Memories however, take me back to the 1970's when this had happened with MANDSAUR owned by the Scindias of Gwalior

Sun said ...

19-Aug-2021

@Achem kumar.

Let me close the topic with the following 

1.I estimated Rating of Alluring Silver at 105 as against 107 of Official Rating.Similarly Bisate at  101 as against 96

2.Bisate future is in Terms Races only that too where spread of Weights is substantial

3.In Handicap races if it is a Weight Carrier

Thanks.

Achem Kumar said ...

18-Aug-2021

@ Ruchi ji again 

  By mistake my response lines not completed & reached to  HT.

    Owners/ breeder's may switch over from Western Aristocrat  (USA) to a suitable Sire. Recently arrived Sire in India, Cougar Mountain  (U.K.) in Capricorn Stud, for  better foals to be delivered to stay 2000-2400M. Someway, Fiero (Japan) another Sire newly arrived in India, can be another alternate & fitting into the spectrum.

   We are not supposed to specify terms but "Enquizitiveness Prevails".

My  sincere thanks. 

Achem Kumar said ...

18-Aug-2021

@ Ruching ji 

   Sir, Fully agreed with your ideology & analysis that Bisate  has reached to her almost peak level. True, her owner's Mr.K.N.Dhunjibhoy & Mr.Z.K.Dhunjibhoy are good breeder's also & may send her today/ tomorrow for stud/ maternity life.

   In all probabilities, likely mating of Bisate, may switch ov with newly arrived Sire, Cougar Mountain  (U.K.) , now in Capricorn Stud for expecting better foals to stay a distance of 2000-2400M 

Achem Kumar said ...

18-Aug-2021

@ Sun ji 

    Myself highly realised the importance/ scope of your posting. Self likely  basic idea furnished below for your perusal.

a) Just to guess next participation in terms/ handicap race is a million dollar question. So,under "Heavy Confused State" (At least for me at this juncture) self'm trying to mention/ predict it. However, hypothetically based on my small instinct, if self'm thinking firstly as trainer & secondly as owner of Bisate filly, gravity of my parafernelia is in favor of  **Terms Race** (if self both trainer as well as owner??), just to achieve "Partial Success", in next few further outings.

  Great  efforts by  yourself to sum up "Grey Areas" with nice postulates in a decent & natural way. Wish you well to find out good success in your "Research/Design & Development Endeavours".

b) Appreciate, likely ratings of Bisate from your end. Bisate current official ratings 96.

c) Relation of time/weights & proper distances etc. dimensions,  i.e. a **Mathematical Equation** & derive "Optimum Results" with that is a  mind boggling exercise. Yes Sir, you are right, may not exert fully or nearby to it, in forward direction. Ready to put my hand forward.

My sincere thanks.

Ruchi said ...

18-Aug-2021

BISATE has reached her limit.it will not perform again ,against a similar field that's for sure.It has been gifted a slot ,( 2 nd spot) in TERMS RACE.

ITS OWNERS ARE BREEDERS ,this will be used as a good advertisement..

I too feel BISATES run was a flash in pan or fixed.Now that it has placed in NIZAMS it's progeny will hv good value..

My take is BISATE won't be sighted anywhere in top three in her future endeavours in similar company

Achem Kumar said ...

18-Aug-2021

  @ godspeed  ji 

Sir,  Many thanks for forwarding/correcting. Extremely Sorry/Regret for the trouble caused. Here are "Revised Ratings" of  the whole set after  Nizam's Gold Cup, 15th August'21, from Hyderabad website.

Table:Revised Ratings Of Complete Set Participated 

1) Alluring Silver   Prev 87 -->107   #Change +20 Ratings 

2) Bisate                 Prev 50 -->  96   #Change  +46 Ratings (Max**)

3) Salazaar             Prev113 -->110 #Change   -3 Ratings 

4) North Star          Prev  66 -->  84  #Change   +18 Ratings 

5) Point To Prove  Prev  99 -->  95  #Change   -4 Ratings 

6) Roaring  Tiger   Prev  66 -->  66   #No Change In Ratings 

7) Taimur                Prev  84 -->  81  #Change  -3 Ratings 

    Now, one can compare/analyse these ratings.

My  sincere thanks. 

Godspeed said ...

18-Aug-2021

New ratings published on the HYD website

ALLURING SILVER 107     (87    +20)

BISATE                     96      (50    +46)

SALAZAAR              110     (113    -3)

TAIMUR                    81      (84      -3)

Sun said ...

18-Aug-2021

@Achemkumar.

Can you atleat guess in which race it is likely to run.Handiapa OR Terms Race

From my side i posted its likely Rating on the other post.

What matters is Time it can clock with certain Weight on its back matters though it may not be required to exert itself fully in all future races.

Achem Kumar said ...

18-Aug-2021

  @ againstodds ji.

Sir, Admire your bottleneck fully. (Also, brain/intelligence). Self'm too eagerly awaiting Bisate's next outing venue/ distance/ days gap etc. or simply she may be despatched to stud as "Broodmare" by **Decision Makers** turning down all #Extrapolations#.

   Sincere thanks.

Againstodds said ...

17-Aug-2021

Sir

With due respect to everyone's opinion and without contesting their views, Bisate's next run will prove whether it was one-off or like all other horses it too has improved.  Several such surprised horses later performed well in the higher classes as well. Just my opinion

 

With warm regards