An insight on Dynamic handicaping theory.
Some of the people have requested for an insight in the handicapping/Dynamic Handicapping theory.I put forth my little and humble undertsnding of the same.
Pl find an insight on the dynamic Handicapping theory: Taught in a session taken by renowned Handicapper and person who is in field of racing since long.
Its common knowledge that if we make a purchase of something weighing about 4 kgs and carry it our pace of walking is slower than usual.if it takes 3 minutes to walk one furlong bare handed,thenit will take 3.5 minutes to cover same distance with the weight.This basically is the underlying principle of any handicap theory.
Horses are alloted different weights based on their performance, by the official handicapper so that all are on paper supposed to run with same chance and if its true then there will be multiple dead heats in all events.in reality it does not happen as we all know that apart from handicap several factors like fitness,stable intention,luck of the race etc come to play.
But in reality the handicap theory helps to narrow down the choice to three /fourin a race haveing best chance.
In the old convential Handicapping system,which also i used to practice based on a book called"master Key of races " by T Bhutaney.Here the comparision is made between the official handicapper and my system based on revised weights.The calculation is done based on the number of lengths the horse has won by,winner beating the second,second to third and third to fourth.
Generally in covential handicapping much stress was placed only on the first four on board and for the rest a thumb rule is used to reduce the weight(ratingwas not in vouge then)in when they next run.1 length was considered as 1.5 kgs and an adjustment was made accordingly when the horse ran next.
Here the simili ends and Dynamic handicapping is more in detail.In DH the revised rating calculation is done upto the horse finishing last and all four parameters that is distance won/lost,weight carried,timing,and the track correction are applied and no thumb rule deductions./drop in ratings for no show animals.
Here is where the Dynamic Theory has an edge.It considers The distance by which won/Lost,the distance ran, the timing clocked and most important the MOTHER CHART, the judious understanding of the same helps to get a near perfect rating for comparision when the horse races next.The mother chart is so unique for each Category and can be explained only in detailed interaction.further when the horse races next there is an adjustment that has to be done for each and every parameter that is weight carried,distance run,category ,timing clocked,vis a vis last run and present run.
Finally when all runners have their DH avaialble look for the First three/Four highest in rating in the race and in all probabilities the likely contenders are narrowed down.
The updation of the DH by using the scientific calculaor and formulas given in the detailed notes has to be done relegiously.Nothing comes without sweat and effort, the same principle holds good here also.One has to work to keep the Revised ratings updated and need to spend time.
No system can in racing give cent percent results because other than the DH other factors are also there as discussed earlier, which i suppose all knowledgeable agree.
I have been trying my hand on several handicapping theories But my experience with this system over the past 15 years is its results are quite satisfactory and can be felt only if one experiences over a continous span.
All the best.
20 Replies
Achem Kumar said ...
29-Aug-2021
@ Indian _Turf_Record ji
Many thanks for extending me correct piece of information.
Achem Kumar said ...
28-Aug-2021
@ Indian_Turf_Record ji
Nice to note, Sir. You are correct. Many thanks for the same.
Indian_turf_record said ...
27-Aug-2021
@ Achem Kumar
The dam of sporting alliance was 'Ghazal'; not Gazelle. Gazelle, as already pointed out by Glasgow Prince, was an older mare, a daughter of Indian 1000 Guineas, Gr.1 winner Fitna. She was owned by the Goculdases and was subsequently at Sewania Stud.
Glasgow Prince said ...
26-Aug-2021
Achem Kumar,
Do feel free to ask your queries.
The race referred to by Butaney and won by Gazelle was run on 13.8.1960. Evidently, it is not the same mare.
Achem Kumar said ...
26-Aug-2021
@ Glasgow Prince ji
Sir, In your last para, mentioned about T.G.Butaney, quoted an example of tipping by naming a horse "Gazelle". Reading this name Gazelle, my memory if correct, remembered one Filly name, of around 1988-89 years.
The Filly, Sporting Alliance (Everyday-II --Gazelle), won races of almost all distances right from 1000M to 3200 M, trained by Shri M.K.Jadhav?? Please, correct me, is it the same Gazelle, delivered Spotting Alliance? Subsequently, this Sporting Alliance also delivered Class-1 foals.
Sir, Myself feeling little bit shy by troubling/ gettingy corrected by your age group, so senior person, such a small query.
Please, make me fine with this piece of information, information.
My sincere thanks.
Cheverletrope said ...
25-Aug-2021
Ruchi Sir,
Better give an example by taking a race as desired by sam.,just like HARSH who has given step by step method in earlier postings.
SUN also raised suitable points to be discussed /answered concerning with DH. to appreciate the system.
Why past four runs are considered , why not good run in previous performance ,as done by other handicappers.
Does DH System takes daily track variant into consideration ?
Does pace/sectionals have bearing on DH System.
What is strike rate of the system. Will it throw open flukes ?
Regards,
V S R Krishna
Glasgow Prince said ...
25-Aug-2021
Ruchi,
You have not addressed most of my queries. Therefore I take it that DH does not cover those aspects and parameters. As you have clarified, analyzing all the runners after having short listed the top four is superfluous. In fact, an analysis of all the runners based on conventional reasoning may actually contradict the DRs.
You do not consider jockey skill but it stands to reason that if jockey skill did not matter there would not be good jockeys, not so good jockeys and bad jockeys. I think you are referring to Harsh in this context without naming him. I don't know if he has a tipping service but he seems to focus on winning rather than fluke hunting and that may be his USP.
Most punters bet for the thrill of ti and the higher is the price the higher is the thrill. Fluke winners capture a punter's imagination. Your product positioning is such that it caters to this class of customers. Harsh caters to a different class of customers who are more focused on winning in the long run. Nothing wrong in that. So why not live and let live? If at all one has to find fault with his score, it is that he does not take into account the tax element because of which his scores are losing their credibility.
Even T. G. Butaney was in the tipping business. His book is strewn with catchy lines. At one point he writes 'Gazelle was the only horse which enjoyed good advantage of 21 lbs (10 kgs) in all horses and was selected by me as a winner and given to all clients by me. It won at 4 to 1 against.' When I read the book for the first time in the seventies I was completely enamoured with it.
Sun,
The answers to all your queries can be found through Google.
Ruchi said ...
24-Aug-2021
CHANAKYA JI
Yes PG did this course
GLASGOW PRINCE
very rightly said.once the TOP FOUR IN DR is got there is no necessity to analyse the balance runners.
Normally to arrive at the DR I take padt (4) runs to arrive at the comparative parameters like WEIGHT,DISTANCE,Placings.,iI NEVER GIVE ANY WEIGHTAGE TO JOCKIES.Giving WEIGHTAGE points to jockey is tottally biased way at arriving the final rating as always AK,PT,PSC,A SANDESH,NEERAJ,JOHN will be indictes as top four.
Then what is the use of doing Handicapping.THIS IS WHAT WE CAN SEE WITH INE GUY WHO is dishing out Fav after fav.Hid choices as he takes weightage of jockey ,it hovers around only AK,PSC and Sandesh.He has tipped 20 bets in his bet plan.12 Akshay,4 psc, 2 sandesh??? Is it required to do any work just follow riders???
LASTLY yes we learn a lot after the races.i had taken only three runs of MAXWELL as I discounted it considering that 6 f will be sharp.If I had taken (4) previous runs,then MAXWELL coming second to DOWNTOWN GAL ,tilted the favour and it's DR WAS 590 20 pts superior to rest of field.
That's racing
Chanakya said ...
23-Aug-2021
Ruchi,
Yes, Dynamic handicapping has its merit and I'm sure must be giving positive results over a period. I have attended few lectures several (perhaps 10 or 12 years ago) at RWITC given by PG. This system scores over conventional system in that it analyses and 'revalues' all the runners depending on their performance. I also use similar - not same procedure and have been getting good results.
I remember having seen a chart where this system has earned 1000K over a period less than a year and hope that chart is still there on his blog...
Sun said ...
23-Aug-2021
In my opinion there is nothing like Dynamic Handicapping OR Static Handicapping.It is amusing to me to see such complication of a Sinple Handicapping Process
Anchor yourself to Ratings and Weights&Distance Handicapping using elementary mathematics of 6th Standard.I can confidently give Revised Rating of horses based on results but the core issues are
1.Do we ignore Time clocked by 2 horses on the same day of same Rating but margin of Win that is Distance From second horse is different
2.How Time Clocked by a horse changes if Distance Changes Is it linear relation or some thing to be added
3.How to compare Timings clocked at different courses say Mysore to Bangalore
4.Do Handicappers retain the Rating when a Mumbai vased horse runs at Hyderabad
5.Is Grade of a Race a factor to be considered especially for 3 Year Olds Observe the Rating of Miracle at 60 in FTS and other horses very less
6.Finally can we have a value for Standard Time that a Horse Rated 40 will clockk at 2 centres assuming all other factors are same Is it possible by looking at Time Clocked in a race whether we can predict a future Win OR Place prospect.
Without addressing these factors no one can say that a System is Perfect.
@GP I will try to post the comparison of Ratings of 4 horses though ORs are within a narrow range.
Sam said ...
23-Aug-2021
well said.need lot paticence and skill to compre the previous runs we appreciate if you can give one good example of any indian race.so that it will be help full for begieners like us.
regrds
Glasgow Prince said ...
22-Aug-2021
Ruchi,
At the outset let me clarify that this is not meant to criticize DH but to focus on what it covers and does not cover as well as its application. I believe it will provide basic clarity to all readers.
The case for reference is today's sixth race at Hyderebad which you have analyzed in the selections thread. The race had 11 runners out of which the top rated runner had a DR of 571 while the next three had DRs of 570. Out of the remaining 11 runners 9 were eliminated using different criteria such as weight handicapping, distance suitability, form and class. Eventually, none of the four top rated runners finished in the first two placings.
My queries are as under.
1. You have explained that DH takes many more factors into consideration as compared to conventional handicapping. However, in your analysis you have applied conventional weight handicapping after having worked out the DRs and ruled out some of the runners. Does this not amount to applying conventional handicapping after DH and undo what DH tries to do?
2. You have not limited your analysis to only the four top rated runners but have analyzed all the runners. Why is it necessary to analyze all the eleven runners after having short listed the four top rated runners?
3. The analysis to eliminate runners is base on weight handicapping, distance suitability, form and class. Aren't these criteria already factored in by DH?
4. Does DH factor in pace of the race, effect of the draw, fitness, jockey skill and stable intention? If so, to what extent does it do so?
5. Is DH only a reflection of past performance or does it also factor in how a race is likely to unfold and provide alternate scenarios?
6. The top rated runner in this case is separated from the next three by just a solitary point which works out to a miniscule margin of about 0.18 %. If we try to predict a winner in such circumstances, doesn't it amount to overreaching by a long distance?
7. In your opinion, what are the limitations of DH?
Thanks
Achem Kumar said ...
22-Aug-2021
@ Ruchi Ji
Trn. R.H.Sequeira, total 12 wins in this season so far, leading the table. How is his stars/ owners/stable jockeys & fleet of his stable horses? ?
Shall we request Sequeira to send his horoscope& find out probability of "Gaja Keshari Yoga" & it's impact over his most success during Covid-19 pandemonium?
Kindly, enlight us, if possible, Sir.
My sincere thanks. In
Achem Kumar said ...
22-Aug-2021
@ Richi ji
Sir, Like your stability of continuing with **Dynamic Rating** since last 15 years, such a long time, when World is fast moving.
Any timely change in your theory, carried out or would like to carry further??
All the best.
Cheverletrope said ...
22-Aug-2021
RUCHIJI,
Insight is not clear.
What is mother chart.
Is it from pedigree chart, dam side.
Be specific on your insight subject manner.
Regards,
vsr krishna.
Xiscafan said ...
21-Aug-2021
Thank you Ruchi ji for the insight and trying to help others unlike some free devil minded folks who have all the time to comment negativity and negatively. Your help is highly appreciated
Sadness In The Sack said ...
21-Aug-2021
Mr Ruchi... very well stated !!
Dancing Dynamite said ...
21-Aug-2021
Some people have all the time to write such lengthy post which actually serve no purpose.
Patlolla Ram said ...
21-Aug-2021
- totally agree with the views expressed reg DH
- One needs to work hard revising and updating the data constantly
- best wishes to all
- regards
Srinivas said ...
20-Aug-2021