Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

The Conundrum Of Odds

By Sudheer | 03-Oct-2021

“PUNTERS WILL LOSE EVENTUALLY” this is the most common line I’ve heard in the racing circuit from the past 5 years. I asked myself why? Is this because the punter has no idea about racing or the system is biased towards bookmakers in general? The knowledge of the punter is the paramount to success or I thought so. Can a punter who has sufficient knowledge can win in horse racing and defy bookmakers? Or this sport is so unregulated and biased towards the bookmakers that punters had no chance?

Lets discuss this in detail and I have chosen the mathematical approach to try and solve this conundrum. I have presumed that there is no tax in the bets placed by us while writing this.

Everyone knows horse racing s game of chances and odds represent the percentage of chance that each horse has in a field. The horse goes odds on if it has a winning chance more than 50% in a field.

Now how to know the chances of a horse according to the odds? Its by a simple formula

                           Chance of winning = [1/(1+odds)]*100

Then you will arrive at the chance of your horse.. An even money horse has a chance of 50% to win the race and 2/1 chance has 33% chance of winning the race and half money horse has 66% chance to win the race.

Mathematically speaking an even money horse will lose once in 2 races and a half money horse will lose once in every three races.

The sum of total chances of a horse winning can not exceed 100% and the sum of total chances to run a place can not exceed 300% if 3 places are paid.

If it exceeds 100% it is biased to bookmakers and if it is below 100% it is biased towards the punter.

Lets consider a 2 horse race for understanding this theory before going to the real scenario.

Odds on horse 1

Odds on horse 2

Chance of winning of horse 1

Chance of winning of horse 2

Even

Even

50

50

80p

125/100

55.55

44.44

50p

2/1

66.66

33.33

40p

7/2

71.42

28.57

This shows a fair book maker and at all times combined chance of winning of both the horse is 100%

Now coming to a real race scenario and to see how unregulated and biased is the odds system I will take one of yesterdays races in Hyderabad which has 10 runners and no withdrawals and analyse the chance of winning as per the closing odds on india race. Take race 4 for instance.

Horse No

Win odds

Place odds

Chance of winning

Chance of running a place

1

20

4

4.76

20

2

18/10

40p

35.71

71.42

3

20

4

4.76

20

4

12

2.5

7.69

28.57

5

12

2.75

7.69

26.66

6

20

4

4.76

20

7

20

4

4.76

20

8

4

60p

20

62.5

9

20

4

4.76

20

10

2.25

40p

30.76

71.42

 

 

 

125.65

360.57

As per the above the odds were quoted for the race total winning chance is 125.65% where it should be 100 at the most and place chance quoted at 360.57% where it should be 300 at the most. On top of that they charge you 10% on your investment then God save the punter.

Mathematically, its an impossible situation for the punter as the odds are biased heavily towards bookmakers. As the no. of horses is increased the bias is getting worse. In a 16 horse field I have seen 160% as winning chance and 490% as the place chance. So if you are playing those races surely you will lose.

So the saying is right indeed. Punters will lose eventually. They stand no chance mathematically to survive in the field of racing. So if you are looking for money this is not a place to look for even if you have sufficient knowledge about racing, People who follow tipsters, your luck will run out sooner than later.

So in this impossible situation, what are the options ahead of us the punters. Not much really but if you want to continue in racing industry, the best way to go forward is devise your own odds according to the chance of the horse. So as per your reasoning if the horse should be 2/1 and its 3/1 back it if its even money don’t touch it or lay it depending on your confidence levels.

Stop backing horses and start eating on them. The place market will aid you greatly if you start eating horses for place. You don’t have to know anything. Just eat the 3 paisa favourites for place and in the long run you will surely be in front because of the bias and you need not pay the tax to eat..

So to survive in this field of racing, you have to be smart enough to know when to lay and when to back a horse.

We all are eternal optimists riding our luck in a no chance situation So good luck to all..

 This will be my last post in knowledge sharing.. Thanks for reading my never ending post.

Post Your reply

11 Replies

Chanakya said ...

08-Oct-2021

@ Sudheer,

I have been  reading your postings which  are very logical and corect. Here  is  my  perception and  opinion  on  various  issues and  observations  you  have  made and  various  positive  and  negative  responses others  have  made.

All over  ther  world majority  of  punters will 'always'  lose is  a  universal  truth and  need  not  be emphsised. Reason  for  losing  are  many but  inadequate knowledge  or  understanding is one  of  the  major reason. 

Bookis  are  businessmen  and have  every right to run  a  profitable  business which  is  clear  from  the  table of  odds you  have  presented  for  race  no  4  of  2/10/21 giving  a  book 'value'  for  race  for win  as  126 showing  whoever  wins  a  bookie  will  have  his  share  of  profit; this  does  not  'include'  10% extra which  punter  pays  for  win and which  goes  to  the  kittie  of  bookmaker...

You advise  to  'lay'  a  weak favorite, but  the  catch  is  how  to  find that;  for  that  a  punter has  to  be  a  good  handicapper. In  that  case  he  can  also  find  nd  home  on  to  the  'real' winner and get  better  odds than  even  or  less  for  'laying'  the  favorite... what  do  you  say?

This  is  an  open  forum  and  every TD&H are allowed to  post and  ask funny questions and make  funny  remarks. Ignoring  them I also  believe  that  'who  can  afford only  should  stay othewise  get out of  racing' . But I  don't accept  or  agree  that  betting on  races  is  a  pastime or   should enable  a  punter  to  break-even after enjoying  an  evening. In  my opinion  it  is  as  good  a  business  for  a  punter  as it  is  for  a  bookmaker o  make  money to  earn  a  livelihood. Sometime  back  I had  a  discussion  with 3 great people who  wanted  me  to  put 300k while  each  of  them  will  put only  100k without  understanding  the  basics  of bettingwhere  every  body puts  his  money on  his  choice. I can  still up  my contribution  to  200k if  each  of  them  put  similar  amount with  the  condition  winner/(s) takes all...

JP says - bookies  pays  fees to  club, pays  employees etc. ignoring  that  book  is  made  for  126 and  not  for  100 and  every bet 10% has  to  be  paid  by punter. Even  if  in  a  race  a  bookie  gets  50,000 he  will  have  enough  from  'book' (126 -100) and Rs. 5000 from10% extra. In  a  8  races/ day he  will  have  enough to  continue  and  remain  in  the  business...   

Pg said ...

04-Oct-2021

" PUNTER's  WILL  LOOSE  EVENTUALLY ".

This goes for 98% of punters, who mostly do not have any knowledge nor any calculations about racing, but depend on others, and any information comming from various quarters or those who just pick up racing book / paper just 1/2 an hour before start of races.

The balance 2% can win repeatedly, those with very sound knowledge of all the dynamic's concerning horse racing., and taking all calculations into account . Hard work does pay in horse racing,  provided the race is run on purely merit. But, the  problem here is of, what is called race fixing / made-up-races/ pulling etc etc in about 3 races mostly frequently on all race days.

If races are atleast 80% run on merit / fair racing, then these 2% of punters can win in horse racing. Yes, many will not agree, but this my experience. Only made-up-racing spoils this sport.

Also it is always wise to bet much more on the preferred horse in place money, and much less on win.

There were / are few top horses like SEARGENT AT ARMS, DESERT GOD, JULLIET and now MIRACLE, and few more, where one after good study and having confidence, can back the horse to win heavily. These races are called BONUS money making in horse racing, where the prospect of top horses win are virtually assured. These races will have large money in stakes, where the connections /owners will try to win the huge amount. Here one will see some punters playing in PETIS, even at low odds, knowing that these races will run on merit only and they could be assured to win.

Once again saying that made-up-racing or match-fixing in racing is the main cause for knowledgeable punters to loose, otherwise these knowledgeable 2% punters can win in horse racing.

 

Jp said ...

04-Oct-2021

It is a nice article based on calculations. But, the bookies are not there to payoff without any benefits to them. It is a buisiness venture and it has to earn profit. The following points have not been taken into account:

       a) Bookies paying fees to the club

        b) salary for employees

        c) Income tax

So if you add up all these and his net profit into your betting calculation then the chances of winning and placing will be more than the norms you have quoted @ 100 and 300.

I totally agree with the other member's advising to play place only. Your chance is 300 whereas it is 100 for win. As he said,patience is the key and playing the horse selected by you without listening to the rumours,talks or tips from your friends since opinions,method of selecting differs from one and another. Further limiting your bet to 2 to 3 bets a day is good and if you play all the races in a day your chances of losing is more.

Parashar said ...

03-Oct-2021

@Sudheer

@Jr NTR Veerabhimani 

Well said u both..all the best for your Future events..Play Safe..Think twice 

Thanks

Madhu said ...

03-Oct-2021

Well written Sudheer and Veeraabhimani....

Ashok Kumar said ...

03-Oct-2021

@ sudheer 

Excellent analysis No one can make money in Raceing irrespective of any position 

It's just a hobby to watch and spend some time

U can see how favorite will lose drastically even with good jockey 

Better to watch racing  and enjoy the sport 

Regards 

Sudheer said ...

03-Oct-2021

@ jr NTR Veerabhimani

It's good to have confidence in your picks.. but it is all about keeping your longevity in the sport.. I couldn't prove your point 1 because it's a subjective argument.. you may think 90p is calue on a horse and I may think even 50p is value on the same horse. So it is subjective and I respect your confidence level of backing at any price..

When it comes to point 2 statistics are available. I'm suggesting to lay on the paise place favs because I feel that they are under the odds.. 

With 7 favs winning in 9 races eating 3 paise favs should be miserable on day like yesterday.. so let's see how the strategy fared yesterday..

Let's say I was laying each horse to win 1000rs

Race 1: 3 paise favs for place 1,2 and 5

1 is money-back so 10p 2 is 70p and 5 is 80p result was 1-2-8 so you will be infront by 200rs because you lose 100rs on 1 and 700 on 2

Race 2: didn't qualify as only 2 horses are paise favsfor place.

Race 3: didn't qualify as only 2 horses are paise favs

Race 4: 2,10,8 are paise favs for place 40p,40p and 60p 

Result 2-8-3 so you neither win nor lose

Race 5:  1 and 7 are paise favs1 at 90p and 7 say 20p

Result 7-6 so you are in front by 800

Race 6: didn't qualify

Race 7: didn't qualify

Race 8: didn't qualify

Race 9: didn't qualify

3 races satisfied the condition and any one took the lay option would have won 1000rs

3 is far too less to make a good sample size.. take 30 to 40 races to analyze yourself and then you can say it's bullshit...

Happy punting

Jr Ntr Viraaabhimani said ...

03-Oct-2021

Thanks for your time in writing this mate. Below are my points from your post.


Based on my study and confidence with some good knowledge on racing and particular runners , if I predict odds for my horse should be even money but actually at race time 3 times so I will be very happy and I can play it very happily with confidence because I am getting good odds for my horse. In other case if my horse should be even and at race time if it is 90 paise even though I am very happy and play it because my confidence and knowledge feels me happy to play it because i feel those 90 paise odds are sufficient for my creditable runner.

As per your point from the post, why I need not to touch my creditable horse or lay it? So you are ignoring the main point itself which is sound knowledge on particular race and confidence levels. To eat my horse which I feel it will win easily by seeing book makers drama even or 90 or 2/1.

2nd point ,
Eating 3 paisa favs for place, we cant expect everyday 3 paise horses in any centre it's a rare cases. For example a runner won comfortably last time with 3 lengths and now running with penalty If I feel some other horse should beat it at post due to this penalty or due to other good horse in that particular field. In this case as per your point eating this horse for place again. But I agree your point of eating paise horse for place based on sound knowledge only ,we can say some horses become hot paise favs which don't have credentials at all to come to board itself in this scenario your point workout(so we need to have sound knowledge before we eat place for a paisa fav becoz it may finish in 1 2 3 in a 8 horse filed based on its previous win performance and based on other runners running in that race, as I said it's a rare scenario only)

So finally what I can say is,

As a punter if you have sound knowledge in particular race that my horse should be in 1 2 3, then instead of going it for win for 2/1 go for just place for 60 paise and satisfy your self and continue this you will definitely will see returns on daily basis in longterm, amount may get low and dnt feel bad like your horse won after you play place. Just satisfy yourself for place money and continue this every race day with sound knowledge on racing handicapping system and previous and latest performance of horses ,latest tracks,and bunches and identifying merit of the horse with which company it ran and no mathematics required here.

My best note to all my fellow punters is dnt stand in ring and see the odds changing game of bookmakers just concentrate on your horse where you get good place bang it and happily have a coffee. And dnt listen to jockey information trainer information owner information and inside stable information. If you like your horse based on good study and confidence back for place(if place is not there happily play small win or leave that race and wait for other your study race these days any way all centers giving 50 to 60 paise for 2/1 or 3/1 favs. that's all I can say guys. Happy punting. Contorl yourself and be calm and patience past is past and loss is loss and dnt chase the races Just try to have regular income with hard working 8 to 5 job or any other job based on our capacity. But utilise your racing amount skills and sound knowledge in identifying your horses with complete study of card carefully with patience and with spending some good amount of time not in hurry looking for 20 mins if you dnt see particular race day card carefully if you feel I am not prepared well for that particular day races and dnt have much confidence just leave it and spend quality time with family. Do all these my taking care of your family well and keep some amount for racing aside and dnt keep money tensions payments to be made to some others or loans..etc..be calm control yourself be patient good days come to you slowly but for sure if you stick to your plan carefully. Be good to everyone dnt spoil others life or relationships for money after taking loans from them dnt lie face them directly like you came out from your mother's womb after crossing 2 crores sperms  tell them yes I will return give sometime if you can return something something they will be very happy. Dnt do bad things to arrange money for your racing habit. Dnt listen or dnt concentrate on others or to society who criticises you just ignore them world is very big .Pray god all the time he will show his blessings to you.

I dnt post any more knowledge sharing posts again, as a responsible citizen I shared my thoughts to my fellow punters from by 5 years racing experience. Take care guys.

All the best guys
Jr NTR Viraaabhimani

T.r. Ramadass said ...

03-Oct-2021

WELL said boss.continue further inthis forum to enlighten new comers. Tks

Bounty Hunter said ...

03-Oct-2021

Leave about the punters many owners are getting bankrupt, their trainers itself cheating them.

its simple, if you can't take the heat get out of the kitchen. Only who can afford the uncertainties in racing stay in racing and enjoy the racing lifestyle, Otherwise better stay away.

BTW well written mr sudheer sir

Bharat said ...

03-Oct-2021

If it is not an issue can you inform your profit / loss since you started betting on horse races. 2016 onwards. Yearly surplus. Past few weeks you are active in HT. What's the surplus from August to October period