Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

On Gst

By S.k.sagar | 09-Nov-2021

ON 2ND JUNE 2021 The Hon’ble Karnataka High Court (HC) in Bangalore Turf Club Limited and ors. v. Union of India [WP No. 11168/2018 and WP No. 11167/2018 decided on June 02, 2021] held that Goods and Service Tax (GST) cannot be levied on the entire bet amount received in the totalisator as it would take away the principle that tax can only be levied on consideration received under the Central Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017 (“CGST Act”). The Court also declared Rule 31A(3) of the Central Goods and Service Tax Rules, 2017 (“CGST Rules”) and Karnataka Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017  (KGST rules) as ultra virus of the CGST Act.

Then, On 12TH August 2021 : HC stays order Levying GST on commission & not on bet amount In Horse Races

Whats the latest on the subject?

Post Your reply

5 Replies

Transparency said ...

12-Nov-2021

Hon'ble HC Karnataka had rightly said that GST is on Commission earned by clubs on totalisor as that's their income and not the total bet collected as after deducting commission it is disbursed to one who had taken correct Win shp place jp etal  ......Same should be implemented by all clubs rather than collecting extra money from punters ........

Glasgow Prince said ...

11-Nov-2021

Dear Mr Sagar,

The Union of India has filed an appeal and the appellants have been able to make a prima facie case for grant of interim relief. Hence the operation of the impugned order has been stayed for the present.

Raghavan said ...

11-Nov-2021

Sagar,

I do not think there is any further development on that issue.  The Karnataka High Court declared the application oif GST on entire bet amount as ultra vires and thereafter the order was stayed. 

In court matters, the final decision on such complicated issue takes long long time.  The expected scenario is Karnataka HC vacates the stay on a future date, but the GST authorities will appeal in the Supreme Court.  And as far as the punters are concerned that is the stalemate.  It may take two years or five years at the Supreme Court.  

And, our beloved friends, I mean the bookies, also desire that the matter is not decided one way or other for the next 10-15 years!  

S.k.sagar said ...

10-Nov-2021

SOME EXTRACTS FROM THE JUDGEMENT OF KARNATAKA HC:

The Hon’ble Karnataka HC in WP No. 11168/2018 and WP No. 11167/2018 decided on June 02, 2021 held as under:

Opined that betting is neither in the course of business nor in furtherance of business of the Petitioner for the purposes of the CGST Act as the Petitioner hold the amount received in the totalisator for a brief period in its fiduciary capacity for which it receives consideration in form of commission and once the race is over the money is distributed to the winners of the stake. Thus, the entire money held by totalisator cannot be construed as consideration in terms of Section 2(31) of the CGST Act.

Observed that Rule 31A(3) of the CGST Rules/ KGST Rules completely wipes out the distinction between the bookmakers and a totalisator by making the Petitioner liable to pay tax on 100% of the bet value. It is the bookmakers who indulge in betting and receive consideration irrespective of the result. In contrast, the Petitioner provides totalisator service and receives commission for providing such service. Therefore, there is no supply of goods/bets by the Petitioner under the CGST Act.

Noted that, Rule 31A(3) of the CGST Rules/ KGST Rules make the Petitioner a ‘supplier’ of bets but the Petitioner is not the supplier of bets and therefore, cannot be held liable to pay tax under the CGST Act. The service or supply that the Petitioner do is only of totalisator component. The Petitioner dose not supply bets to the punters.

Held that GST cannot be levied on the entire bet amount received in the as it would take away the principle that tax can only be levied on consideration received under the CGST Act. The Court compared it to stock broker or a travel agent; both of whom are liable to pay GST only on the income i.e., the commission that they earn and not on all the monies that pass through them.

Stated that, Rule 31A(3) of the CGST Rules/ KGST Rules does not conform to the provisions of the CGST Act and thus are ultra virusthe enabling CGST Act and liable to be stuck down.
Held that, the Petitioner is liable for payment of GST on the commission received for the services rendered through the totalisator and not on the total amount collected in the totalisator.

As seen in the above extract .. There appears to be no ambiguity in the case .. The case looks crystal clear that the CGST is applicable only on the commission and not on the total amount collected in the totalisator. Then why the delay in its implementation ? Somehow I am unable to understand this.

Ramachandra Rao Nanduri said ...

10-Nov-2021

This matter should be brought to the notice of as many punters as possible, and a collective action by those investing their hard earned monies only will stop this unjustified taxation policy of the Government(s).