India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsRwitc To Probe Sandesh’s Ride On Juliette
By Turf News | 21-Dec-2021“Yes we have open an inquiry on the handling of favorite Juliette” Chief Stipendiary Stewards Shujjat Hussain told TOI on Monday.
In the 2400 meter race Sandesh kept Juliette far back in a seven horse field for most of the journey and pushed her only nearing the home stretch. Juliette accelerated brilliantly and overtook all the rivals but failed to catch the front running eventual winner Alluring Silver and finished second.
When asked by the stewards, sources say even Juliette’s trainer Karthik Ganapathy expressed disappointment over the handling of his mare by Sandesh.
24 Replies
Glasgow Prince said ...
26-Dec-2021Shishira Vaibhav,
You are right. However, there is a method to realize that Juliette was not goint to win.
Shishira Vaibhav said ...
24-Dec-2021At the end of the day
All said and done only punters are at receiving end,,,
Glasgow Prince said ...
24-Dec-2021After running third in the President of India Gold Cup behind Juliette and Parisian, Alluring Silver ran a listless seventh 9 lengths behind the stablemate winner Rambunctious (quite a coincidence) in the Villoo Poonawalla Pune City Gold Cup. She was beaten by many older horses much to the chagrin of the racing fraternity. There was no enquiry into her running. Even a mundane charade of questioning the trainer and jockey was not enacted.
Subsequent to finishing second in the President of India Gold Cup behind Juliette, Parisian from the same stable as Alluring Silver ( note the coincidence once again), went on to win a couple of graded races creating an impression that she was on the upgrade although in reality she had beaten nothing of note. As a result, she became the perfect decoy - intentionally or unintentionally - for the Invitation. The market duly ignored Alluring Silver who was allowed to run loose at 20 to 1 while Parisian was installed the second favourite. It is obvious that Sandesh was eyeing Parisian as the possible threat while her stable mate Alluring Silver wrapped up the race running with the pace.
Such things have happend in the past and I am sure they will happen in the future. The races that immediately come to my mind are the Indian Oaks won by Victorious (Jagdish) and the Indian Derby won by Mohawk (Wally Swinburn). Jagdish was alert to the threat in the front and managed to win the race while Shinde (Everynsky) and Jagdish (Aristocrat) were both unable to sense the danger posed by the up-in-front Mohawk.
While it may be appropriate to open an enquiry into the riding of Sandesh on Juliette, it defies logic that no enquiry was opened into the running of Alluring Silver when it finished a miserable seventh in Pune. An enquiry into that run would have maintained the market focus on Alluring Silver in the Invitation.
Minchu said ...
23-Dec-2021It's a clear tactical error by the rider... That's all...! May be Sandesh would have thought, Parisian is the main threat and he rode the horse in check with Parisian and forgot about other horses. However being a professional jockey, he should know the pace of the race and shouldn't have kept it too far. Nobody would like to gift such a big event, it's all about riding skills. Sandesh missed the trick and had to heavily, so did punters!
Ankush said ...
23-Dec-2021Bottom line .....AS will beat Juliette again..whereever and whenever and the stewards should call Frankie Detori to ride Juliette.
Ramesh Akhade said ...
23-Dec-2021Mr.A Sandesh not any wrong with ride that day his not day...Big event no one cheat so plz understand punter.....
Raghavan said ...
23-Dec-2021Vikas,
Agreed. Alluring Silver is not such an outsider that it is believed as a no hoper and bookies quoted 20/1. It had credentials, had finished 3rd against 2 big horses, its trainer has done exceedingly well, and ridden by top jockey etc..etc.
But the debate here is not about competence of Alluring Silver. The debate is regarding the incompetent handling of Sandesh on Juliette. No one would have faulted if Sandesh had given the charge a little early and yet lost to Alluring Silver or any other horse.
I remember several instances where the jockeys did rank misjudgement in important races and inflicted a big hole in the pocket/s of punters.
(1) Be Safe (50/100) lost to Quasar (30/1) in invitation cup because Jockey Suraj Narredu unleashed the charge a fraction of second late.
(2) Native Chieftan (400/1; 60/1 for place in a 5 horse field) won by 400 lengths in Bangalore derby race because the other four riders kept their horse a street behind and the gap went on increasing every second!)
(3) Pesi Shroff eased Crown Treasury (13/10) just a fraction of second early. Pesi Shroff & the crowd believed that Crown treasury has won the Invitation Cup. But in the final moment, Ministerial (40/1) came like an express train and pipped Crown Treasury by a whisker!
There may be many many races where the favorite would have won easily but lost to rank outsiders due to overconfidence (or stupidity) of jockeys or their bad judgement. In all instances it was the punter/s who paid a heavy price. And, in horse races, A RUPEE LOST IS LOST FOR EVER!
Just one thing. When will our punters learn to skip races where the favorite is quoted at cramped odds? Really heavens would not have fallen if the punters had skipped betting in the invitation races 2021. I am repeatedly asking punters not to bet heavily in any race and particularly in races where the favorite is odds-on. But practically no takers. I have seen punters betting five lakhs, three lakhs etc on Be Safe (plus 10% tax) in Invitation cup.
Godzilla said ...
22-Dec-2021Your justification for Alluring Silver winning over Julliete in Invitation Cup should be a point to ponder for Stewards to instittute an unwanted Enquiry on the running and riding by Sandesh over Julliete. This disposes off the impending Stewards Enquiry.
Jockey A Sandesh will be jubiliant over your write up.
Ruchi said ...
22-Dec-2021I got the name of the derby winner ridden by R Hughes.....it was the ever conquering SMART CHIEFTAIN.....wonder why the inquisitive mr know all did not pop up.
Any way ......
Prinit said ...
22-Dec-2021Ruchi maybe you are referring to Smart chieftain who was pocketed and got an opening in the last 100 mts to come flying home to beat Ray of light into second...
Vikas said ...
22-Dec-2021I think ALLURING SILVER,was better horse on that day.Pre Race some people were asking whereabouts of IMMORTALITY,who won both Indian Oaks and Indian Derby of 2021.In both the events first three placings were IMMORTALITY,FOREST FLAME and ALLURING SILVER.And on both the occassion ALLURING SILVER was within 3 lenghs from the winner.So on last Sunday in the absence of IMMORTALITY and FOREST FLAME,ALLURING SILVER was the best 4 year old in the field .Secondly in Race no.82 of Hyderabad Mansoon season 2021 ALLURING SILVER finished 3rd behind JULIETTE So she had definately credentials to turn the table.I think after this performance THE TRAINER trained her Excellently, which reflected in her last spurt given on 16.12.2021on Outer Sand Track which reads 800m in 52sec. and 600m in38sec. on official website of the club.i.e.www.rwitc.com.compared to Juliette's track on the same day on Inner Sand for 800min55sec.and 600m in 41 sec.I think ALLURING SILVER was worthy winner of Invitation Cup 2021.
B V S Prasad said ...
21-Dec-2021Diabolical won Hyderabad winter Derby & went to Mumbai Derby in that race Southern Empire is 40ps odds like Hyderabad style Diabolical gone Start to finish & won Southern Empire didn't tried, coming to the Calcutta Invitational Cup same duo participated & Southern Empire easily won the race from Diabolical this is MAM strategy on those days now a days every one following his foot steps like last Sunday Invitation Pesi shown Parisian & gone wd the Alluring Silver last but the least punters are loosers
Ruchi said ...
21-Dec-2021Oh oh ...I got it wrong ..The horse ridden by R Hughes was SOUTHERN .......I don't remember may be Mr know all can throw some light...he is quite agressive in such debates ...nothing else
Autonomy said ...
21-Dec-2021@ruchi
cryptic blue is correct. diabolical beat southern empire in 2007 indian derby
mystical lost derby to velvete rope
regards
Iimblue said ...
21-Dec-2021I am sure CryptiBlue is right. Southern Empire and Diabolical were involved in the Indian Derby 2007 (held in the first week of February). Only a month later, Southern Empire donkey licked the opposition at the Indian Invitation held in KOLKATA.
Mystical belonged to the senior batch. In fact, around the same time (Februry second week 2007) ,Mystical won a Race in Dubai.
Indian_turf_record said ...
21-Dec-2021@ Ruchi
Kindly don't twist historical facts.
MYSTICAL and DIABOLICAL never ran in the same race in their entire careers. So no sacrifice or donkey licking.
Southern Empire DID NOT WIN the Indian Derby in which he was ridden by the late B. Prakash.
Crypticblue said ...
21-Dec-2021@Ruchi
You need to get better at your homework
Mystical (Alnashar Alwasheek x Mystic Memory) came 3rd in 2006 Indian Derby won by Velvet Rope (Turtle Island x Truffa), ridden by P Kamlesh, Holding Court (Royal Kingdom x Confiture) was 2nd
Diabolical (Major Impact x Double Quick), won the 2007 Indian Derby beating Southern Empire (Placerville x Stunning). Diabolical had won the Hyderabad Winter Derby just a week ago & had traveled to Mumbai immediately after.
CB
Name Withheld said ...
21-Dec-2021Ruchi, when he stated the correct facts why do you need to change it with totally incorrect facts. Mystical lost to Velvet Rope in the Indian Derby.
Southern Empire won by street at Calcutta beating Diabolical Prakash was on the second horse in both races.
Chase said ...
21-Dec-2021Whether it is Juliette or Corfe Castle , they always come from the back with sustained acceleration. A split second soon , if made the final move , the verdict may be different. It happens in racing . Just Sour Grapes. Just an eye wash enquiry.
Ruchi said ...
21-Dec-2021Cryptic blue
It was MYSTICAL who was sacrificed for DIABOLICAL and not SOUTHERN EMPIRE.Then MYSTICAL donkey licked DIABOLICAL in the INVITATION.
SOUTHERN EMPIRE WON the INDIAN DERBY after being badly pocketed,covered ,5 lengths and thrashed the field under Sir Richard Hughes
Mohan said ...
21-Dec-2021It's just the replay of besafe losing to quasar.....
Sushil said ...
21-Dec-2021No i don't agree with that.
If Hindu sing dependent over confidential then sandesh also over confidence that day on julliate. She came from last regularly this time also same.but alluring silver given his best performance. Thats All.
Crypticblue said ...
21-Dec-2021Reminded me of similar tactics employed in the 2007 edition of the Indian Derby, won by Diabolical over 30p stablemate, the towering Southern Empire, then ridden by Late-B Prakash
The irony of the horses of racing legend Late- Dr MAM's horses in the last decade & a half is that they have always faltered when it most mattered the most. Be it the mighty Mystical, Southern Empire, Be Safe or Juliette. For whatever reasons
Coming back to last Sunday, the beauty of Alluring Silver's success was in how effortlessly she earned the race, thanks to some very calcuated riding by jockey Sandesh
Indian Racing is on a steadfast downhill.
Rudolph Furtado said ...
21-Dec-2021Finally confirmed that a STEWARDS INQUIRY is being launched into the manner of running of the favourite " JULIETTE " .Rarely in my over 25 years of on/off racecourse attendances have I ever seen a jockey so badly misjudge the pace of the race.Tons of " PUNTER MONEY" gone down the drain due to injudiscious riding.Can the "MONEY" be refunded ? What's the use of a probe when this race was a open daylight robbery or for benifit of doubt one of the worst misjudged rides by a professional jockey.
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now