India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsRctc Handicapper Defies All Logic
By Critic | 23-Dec-2021Date: November 2021
Event: The Mayfowl Cup
Shivansh rated at 106 wins the race by 2 lengths from Violin rated at 86.
The rating change after the race:
Shivansh to 118 up from 106
Violin to 121 up from 86
They both clash on coming sunday and the runner-up is rated higher than the winner.
Can someone please explain the bizarre happening?
The best person would be the RCTC Handicapper.
28 Replies
Sun said ...
30-Dec-2021@Critic,
What you are saying that Winner's Rating should be more than Placed horses depends on many matters most important being Weights.
In a Handicap Race the Ratings and Weights are aligned while in Terms Race Weights are as per Terms of Race In Race number 18 Violini carried more Weight.First Rating of Winner is fixed then for Placed horses.When we come across any such Race in future I will bring to your notice.
Sun said ...
28-Dec-2021My Ratings after runnuing of 2000Gs
A star is Born and Zuccarelli same Rating 67 OR winner may be gven 70
Presidential 61 and Alastair 56
Thanks.
Critic said ...
28-Dec-2021@Sun
You all seem to be missing the point I am trtrying to convey. Shouldn't a winner be rated higher than the runner-up?
It was not so in the case of Violin. Obviously there is a flaw in rating system. The anamoly in awarding the rating change needs to be corrected.
If on technical grounds then that shows there is some correction that needs to be made in awarding the ratings post a race.
The winner at a lesser rating than the runner-up sounds hilarious.
Sun said ...
28-Dec-2021@ITR.
I workoutrevise Rtgs immeditely after races on the same day and my Rtgs are very close Handicapper's Ratings
Thanks
Sun said ...
28-Dec-2021@ Chase
For Rating difference among race clubs just look at Ratings of
A Star is Born after its Win at Bangalore on 1 st November it was rated 44 but in 1000Gs race its Rating is shown as 48
Indian_turf_record said ...
28-Dec-2021@ Critic
My posting addressed to @ Sun was merely to point out a fact which he may or may not have noticed. He had mentioned Taimur's rise of 20 points whereas Theon had gone up by 42 points.
It was in no meant to be comment on Shivansh-Violin issue. Maybe I should have clarified that
Sun said ...
28-Dec-2021@Critic
Kindly note in Stayer's Cup both horses carried same weight of 57Kg while in the earlier race Violini carried 2.5Kg more than Winner
I gave the working kindly go through.
ITR's point,if I am not mistaken.it is about Rating going up from 52 to 96
Chase said ...
28-Dec-2021Nice to read the response of SUN sir after a long break.
Thanks Sir for your clarifications
Critic said ...
27-Dec-2021@Sun and ITR
The rating of Theon remains below that of the winner.
On the day Stayers cup was run, My Opinion was rated at 110 and Theon at 54.
After the race Theon goes up to 96 which is less than that of My Opinion at 110.
In Violins case it is not the same.
Violin is rated higher than the eventual winner, which is bizzare to say the least.
At least in Theon's case the jump of 16 kg is justified because Stayers cup is Grade.1 event whereas in Violin's race The Mayfowl cup was a non-graded event.
Looks highly illogical the handicapping parameters of the official handicapper.
TAI should set right the anomaly at the earliest so as to not harm the career of a race horse.
There should be clear segregation for penalties to be imposed in a graded race to a non-graded one.
That could avoid the bizzare situation like Violin landed herself in Rctc. She loses to Shivansh and in the very next clash as well as their run, Violin is rated higher than Shivansh. I find that most perplexing.
Sun said ...
27-Dec-2021@Chase,
Your query is best answered by looking at Miracle's Rating in the 1000Gs Race card which was given as 60 while after its Win in Hyderabad it was rated 76.
As per my study there are few parameters which come into play
1.The Handicapper's practice of awarding Penalties to the horses finishing on board
2.The difference in Timings clocked by horses at different centres even after adjusting for Track Variance because the competetion (read as pace) varies from centre to centre.
When a horse runs at different centre after its run in another centre observing the Rating difference gives some clue.
Today at Bangalore when they have again fallen in line with other centres for Handicap Classes you can see that they have adjusted Ratings by 6 points So min bottome weight and range of class like 40-65 versus 40-66 OR 41-66 as at Kolkota also bring in small adjustments..
Sun said ...
27-Dec-2021@ITR.
Yes of couse.As per my method it comes to 100 However,if I adjust with Race Day's Timing Average it is 97
Indian_turf_record said ...
27-Dec-2021@ Sun
I am sure that even bigger jump in THEON's rating after the Stayers Cup has been noticed by you.
Critic said ...
27-Dec-2021IIMBLUEji,
The race for which Violin was penalised hheavily was not a graded event. To penalise harshly in such races is harming the career of a talented filly. The norms ought to be changed in such cases. Hope TAI has a look.
Many thanks to you and the rest who responded to my query.
Iimblue said ...
27-Dec-2021@Critic ji,
In the Army Cup the same set of Horses clashed again. This time Violin was running on better terms. To my surprise, Shivansh slaughtered the field . He certainly has hit top form.
Violin ran below par.No hard luck story here. May be, you are right. The handicapper has penalised the filly too harshly .
Iimblue said ...
26-Dec-2021Never thought the Handicapper will get a chance to vindicate himself so early after The Mayfoal Cup.
I am referring to today's 6 Th Race THE ARMY CUP
Almost the same set of the horses are participating and distance is 1400 ,with REVISED RATINGS.
Adjusted Ratings in descending order are as under.
1.Awesome One (131)
2.Violin (130)
3.Shivansh (129)
4.Rainbow Trot (124)
5.Consigliori(119)
6.Royal Satsuma (119)
7.Silver Bracelet (113)
The Handicapper is VINDICATED if Violin finishes ahead of Shivansh.
The Trainer is VINDICATED if Violin wins today as she proves herself worthy of terms races.
To my mind Violine has to beat only Rainbow Trot, which she is capable of.
Let's see.
Chase said ...
25-Dec-2021A good discussion .
It brought the much respected Sarat Sarma Sir on board.
IIMBlue and JP sir are back.
Many other Handicap experts and stalwarts were absent and that is very sad.
I wonder if Shivansh and Violins were to run in Mumbai or Bangalore what would be their comparative rating!
All said and done , despite the terms, Principles, Rules and norms handicapping is still subjective. Different people, different yardsticks!
Sun said ...
25-Dec-2021Dear All
Further to my earlier post I analysed tomoroow's Terms Race.These are my Placings
It appears Shivansh has made good improvement from Race no 18 to 32.At its age 8 RPs improvement is a question mark.Perhaps the Ratings of horses higher than 118 ie Psuchic Force at 120 is to be diubted..If it is felt that it cannot have made that much improvement my placings are
Awesome One Silver Bracelet and Prince Sastuma/Shivansh
Sun said ...
25-Dec-2021@ Critic,
Your query is answered many times in the past but for your benefit I will repeat.
RNO 18 is a Terms Race.We limit our analysis to the 4 horses that fininshed on board.Highest Rated horse is Awesome One Rated 123 Carried 56KG.At any Club in India Rating once given to a horse is taken as sacroscant and it will not reduced just like that and on other hand Rating of other horses will be increased.So if we take Awesome One as reference the Winner's Rating without considering the separating distance is 123 minus 6(for 3 Kg less Weight) which is 117..Time difference is 1mi 27.29 versus 1 min 26.8 OR 8729 minus 8680 which is 0.49 secs for 1400 mtrs it translates to 6 RPs
Now Revised Rating for Winner 117 plus 6 123.but Handicapper has put it at 118.Now Vilonin carried 2.5 Kg more so its is 118 plus 5 minus Rating Eqivalent of Time difference of 0.29 secs which is 3 RPs so 118 plus 5 minus 3 which is 118
Handicapping is not complicated as broutht out by so many here but it is simple arithmatics.It is different matter whether these horses live up to their Ratings.
Thanks for your interest For further study look at Rating of Taimur after 19 th Dec races at Mumbai.
Sps said ...
25-Dec-2021First responce in this thread is by "SARAT SHARMA"
It is very hard to believe that "It is SARAT SHARMA of "Turf Eagle" but if he is the same person then it gives me ammens pleasure.
I REQUEST FROM THE AUTHOR to confirm that this SARAT SHRAMA is same SARAT SHARMA of Turf Eagle or a different person.
With Regards
Iimblue said ...
25-Dec-2021@Critic ji,
May be I was not very clear. Let me give another try.
Consigliori (top weight) with a rating of 119 is carrying 60 kg, while the next horse Awesome One with a rating of 123 is carrying ONLY 56 KFC.
Theoretically, Consigliori is running the worse as per the Terms and will not be able to beat Awesome One. The difference =4 kgs or 8 points(60-56).Adjusted rating
Consigliori (top weight and hence the Reference Point) 119+0=119
Awesome One 123+8 =131.
You can calculate for others.
The trainer expected Violin to win. It did finish ahead of others but met a tarter in Shivansh.
Each one will have an opinion. But to my mind, a Horse is born to run in a terms race. Handicappers are mediocre horses.
Handicapping comes with plenty of limitations but there is no alternative.
Critic said ...
24-Dec-2021Hello IIMBLUEji,
All that you have said goes sailing over my head. Please be more elaborate.
The ratings are as per which date?
What are the + numerals after the rating?
How have you arrived at those figures?
On what basis have you made the final standing?
You say the trainer was brave and ought to be congratulated. For what?
For knowingly making Violin participate in a terms race, the results of which would be detrimental to her career.
I would say exactly the opposite for letting Violin earn a rating which classic winners display. The career is as good as over. She can never run in handicaps without having to concede huge chunks of weight to the competition. The terms races are her only solace and refuge as well.
May be my ignorance is glaringly obvious and I would appreciate and be thankful for answering my queries,
Apologies if I am asking wrong questions.
I'M RED at the Rctc handicapper until you convince me otherwise.
Agastya said ...
24-Dec-2021Hi All,
The Word Terms Makes that much difference means, I will bring Class V horse to terms. Than my donkey will have higher rating than other Horses.
Iimblue said ...
24-Dec-2021Continuing from my 6.40 pm post, I would like to add the following.
Violin with an adjusted rating of 95 has finished just 2 lengths behind Shivansh with adjusted rating of 120.In the bargain it has finished ahead of 3 other horses with higher adjusted rating.
Handicapper had no other option than to substantially increase the rating of Violin.
The net result will be that the horse will run only in Terms races in future.
This is one reason why some trainers avoid running their horses in Terms races. Even when they win handicap races, the Jockey is under clear instruction to win with as small a margin as possible.
Jp said ...
24-Dec-2021@ Calcutta Punter is correct. Terms race is different from handicap races. We will have to know the terms of the race to arrive at the weights.
Iimblue said ...
24-Dec-2021@Critic ji,
At the outset you query is right. But I believe that the Handicapper seldom goes wrong. Let me try to clarify as best as I can.
This is a terms race. The weights are allowed as per TERMS of the race.
Let me readjust ratings with reference to weights carried.
Consigliori 60(119) readjusted rating 119.+0=119
Awesome One 56(123)(readjusted 123+8=131)
Violin 55.5(86)(86+9=95)
Rainbow Trout 53.5(110)(110+13=123)
Shivansh 53(106)(106+14=120)
Now writing in order of merit, the positions should be as under.
1.Awesome One (131)
2.Rainbow Trout (123)
3.Shivansh (120)
4.Consigliori (119)
5.Violine (105)
As we can see Violine is worst placed as per terms. It is to the credit of the Trainer that he accepted to run in this race at all. (incidentally it was favourite ,which means hidden potential not reflected in ratings) True, Violine has not one but it's performance is beyond it's rating and this fact has been duly recognized by the handicapper.
The Trainer need to be congratulated because he did not take the easy handicap route.
Critic said ...
24-Dec-2021How can the runner-up be rated higher than the winner in their next clash?
If one goes by your logic, if the handicapper feels Violin needs to be rated at 121, then, how come, he gives the impression that Shivansh is inferior to her by rating it at 118, even though she has beaten Violin?
Defies all logic.
A winner running at a lesser rating than the runner-up in their next clash!
I find it amusing.
Calcutta Punter said ...
24-Dec-2021@Critic
If I may say so, you must be new to the sport.
These are "terms' races Totally different fron Handicap races.
Please study the 'terms' in the prospectus to comprehend the weights assigned
Best Wishes
Sarat Sharma said ...
24-Dec-2021The possible explanation could be as such.
SHIVANSH 6year old has been given a mandatory 6Kg penalty for the win by 2 lengths which most handicappers do and his rating goes up to 118..
VIOLIN is a 4 year old who was carrying 2.5 Kg weight more than SHIVANSH yet finished 2 lengths behind, considering 1/2 Kg equals one length VIOLIN is to handicapped 1.5 Kg better than SHIVANSH. Now his rating is 121.
Dont look at the previous handicap but at the present performance.
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now