Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Revision Of Ratings Of A Placed Horse

By Sun | 08-Jan-2022

@Critic

Re your earlier post Chennai 6th Jan 22 Race No 8

Priceless Gold goes up from 84 to 100

My Opinion 4th Placed horse retained at 110

2nd Placed horse 92 to 91

3rd Placed horse from 38 to 84

If you can decipher this then you will get answer to your earlier query

 

Post Your reply

5 Replies

Critic said ...

15-Jan-2022

IIMBLUE ji,

The handicapper has realised you say. That's an open admission of some faulty system followed by the handicapper.
Regarding breeder's perspective, it his wish and will but as a punter it is my duty to point out any flaw in the handicapping system.

Iimblue said ...

11-Jan-2022

@Critic ji, 

I think the Handicapper too realised that he has treated Violine harshly and after Race 47 her rating has been reduced to 116 ( from 121). Since Shivaansh now has a rating of 120,  your other wish too seems to have been fulfilled. 

      Graded Race is also a Terms Race. All Terms Races are treated equally by the Handicapper. The questions before him are 1)whether the Horse has placed 2)Rating of the horse in front of her and behind her. 

       Regarding your opinion about the Career of Violin,  I beg to differ. The Filly is owned by Shapoorji  who is also a Breeder. No doubt Violin is on the way to her Studfarm duties in another few weeks. Winning a Terms Race would have looked  good in her CV and increased the value of her progeny.The calculations slightly went wrong. Afterall she almost won Race no 18.

A Breeder will have his own view point and nothing wrong with that. 

Critic said ...

09-Jan-2022

Hello Sun,

I do understand and did understand what was explained before but my grouse is against the stiff penalty given to Violin in a non-graded event. Sorry, not the penalty but for getting a higher rating than the winner.

Shivansh to 118 up from 106
Violin to 121 up from 86

In the very next run of both, they met each other with the runner-up at a higher rating than the winner.


To get penalized harshly in a graded event is acceptable but not in a non-graded event.

I only wanted to know if there were any anamolies in the rating system followed by the handicapper. The career of Violin looks as good as over. There should be some clause inserted to avoid such occurences in future.

Thanks for the trouble taken to explain the nuances of handicapping system..

Sun said ...

09-Jan-2022

@Harish Kumar

U are correct.I went byn the Revised Ratings page of Chennai Race Club

Updating of Data in MRC site seems to be not happening.Though In the Results of Ooty races on 29th September iitself it shows 84 but they carried 38 because there is some problem with updation in the Site 

Thanks I have correct my File 

 

Harish Kumar said ...

09-Jan-2022

3rd plced is anegelino it's rating 79 NW 84