India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsA Poser On Rating System
By Critic | 13-Jan-2022Hello Sun,
I am amazed at the rating system followed in our country. Going back to the Violin case. She was penalised harshly for having run second in a non-graded event ( rating jumped from 86 to 121).
I am taking Miracle as case in point. She is an unbeaten winner of 7 races which includes 4 classics as well as the PBBM (Grade.1).
Dear Sun, do you know her present rating?
Just 80. Yes sir, you read that right!
Look at the way she was penalised.
She was officially rated at 60 after the PBMM win (the thrird victory).
MIRACLE given a rating of 70 after the victory in The Deccan Fillies Championship Stakes (Gr.3).
Upped to 76 from 70, yes, 76, after winning The Golden Jubilee Deccan Derby (Gr.1).
Reatained at 76, can you believe it, after winning The Golconda 1000 Guineas (Gr.2).
The handicapper may have blinded after her dazzling victory in The Villoo C. Poonawalla Indian 1000 Guineas (Gr.1).
Do you know what rating she earned after the effortless victory?
She was penalised 2 kg and her rating jumped to 80.
Just imagine, if Viloin (121) were to run with unbeaten Miracle (80) in a handicap event. She would have to concede 20.5 kg to her.
Doesn't that sound ridiculous?
So, dear sir, do tell me if I am wrong in assuming that there is a serious flaw in the allotment of ratings by the handicappers across the country.
55 Replies
Sun said ...
07-Feb-2022@Veteran Punter
Zuccarelli gone up to 104 from its earlier Rating.Miracle at same 80
Is 104 an arbitrry number
Sun said ...
06-Feb-2022My selection for RNO 5
Juliette Alluring Silver Truly Epic
Thanks
Sun said ...
05-Feb-2022@ Veteran Punter
Thanks for your post.
As usual I rank horses based on Rating Advantage/Disadvantage
As per Ratings Zuccarelli and Miracle (Almost same) Faith of Success Chopin and A Star is Born
As per Timings after Adjusting for Rating Advantage and Disadvantage Values
A Star is Born Faith of Success Zuccarelli Chopin and Miracle
Timings of Faith of Success and Zuccarelli are from Hyderabad abd Bangalore I feel Bangalore Timings are on Slower side compared to Hyderabad. So i put Zuccarelli ahead of Faith of Success
Zuccarelli's Rating is over stated because Win by 15Ls means other horses did not fully exter themselves So my positions are
Miracle A star is Born Zuccarelli and Faith of Success
Incidentally I analysed other Terms Races. Based on Ratings with Timings after adjusting for Adv/Disadv my first 3 choices are
RNO 2 Dear Lady Super Natural
RNO 4 Sultan SUleiman Cosmic Ray Petronia
RNO 5 I will post here tomorrow
Veteran Punter said ...
04-Feb-2022Hello Sun,
Since you have asked, my selections based on the parameters mentioned are as follow:
1- Miracle
2- Zuccarelli
3- A Star is Born
4- Sun Gold
Veteran Punter said ...
04-Feb-2022Hello Sun,
Requested Sagarji to analyse the Indian derby field based on certain calculations by factoring in timings.
To see how effective it is I requested Sagarji, No other interest.
Sun said ...
03-Feb-2022@Veteran punter
Thanks for educating on what all aspects one has to look into while picking a Winner
I would appreciate if you can indicate the Winner in Derby on Sunday after considering all those factors
Incidentally you have shown interest in TFR and Indian Rating in the post by Sagar Saab but it is also totally calculations based What you want to convey by that post?
Veteran Punter said ...
02-Feb-2022Hello Sun,
No mathematical projection will give that. The ability to last out longer distances can only be sourced from the bloodlines of the horse. Using timing to gauge and predict in long distances races will fail if you fail to incorporate the ability of a runner to last out long distance races.
Another important aspect would be the pace of the race. If there is a speedy runner or pacemaker, then timings automatically are good/ And obviously, contrary, if the opposite.
The third would be the weight carried by the runner. That also needs to be factored in.
Another crucial element that plays a vital role is the 'Going'. You need to take the 'PNR" for the day.
Try to improvise by getting the above into consideration.
Also, try not to depend too much on mathematics as there no 'winning formula' in racing.
Try to be less technical and more practical. That would help.
My thoughts spoken aloud.
Sun said ...
02-Feb-2022@Veteran Punter
You are very correct.Now the issue is 1000G 2000G are 1600 mtr races
If a horse has not run beyond 1600 Mtrs how can we compare its Timing with a horse which participated in Oaks.This is the crux of the problem.My syatem is under correcting the Times from 1600 Mtrs to 2400 Mtrs
Faith of Success Oaks run must have been run at very slow pace because the Time is too inferior to Guineas Winner OR a 2000 Mtr winner like Count of Savoy.
One thing I am happy is Karanveer's Time for 1800 Mtrs normalised to 2400 Mtrs came better than Trirestia oasks Winner timing plotted to 2400 Ptrs.
I will strive to improve.
Thanks for your suggestion
Veteran Punter said ...
01-Feb-2022Hello Sun,
I feel you should give the distance the importance it deserves. If you had to do that then Faith of Success would have been there in your calculation.
Just a suggestion, nothing else.
Sun said ...
31-Jan-2022@Veteran Punter
Yes in the final selection Faith of Success is not there.In my post of 28th Jan 8.25PM it was in 3rd postion on Ratings and 4th Position on Timings.
In the final selections I attempted a method to combine which backfired.Your poser to me helped to identify 2 logical issues which I have sorted out.
I will try with improved method for Indian Derby where i think I should not touch Timing bevause horses of different centres may participate.
Thanks.
Veteran Punter said ...
31-Jan-2022Hello Sun,
Surprised to see the eventual winner Faith of Success find no mention in your rating of Golconda derby contestants.
Was it not in reckoning as per your system?
Sun said ...
29-Jan-2022@Veteran Punter
Just I want to explain in brief the basis of my system
Refer Golconda Derby Card Its a terms Race but horsess come from different types of races Handicap of Different Classes and Classics from 1000G to Oaks
Highest Rated horses are at 65 namely Count of Savoy Faith of Success and Terestia
Now to get Ratings of all horses to common Datum we need to undersatand one concept
Suppose you take a horse at a Rating og 34 it will be set to carry 57 Kg and say it turns out some time for 1600 Mtrs
Suppose this horse carrying 54 Kg can turn out typical time in 40-65 Class then we say its rating is 48 So what I say is if a horse's rating is 34 then I map it to 48 by equation 34+0.7*20 48 Here 20 is the difference in Bottom Ratings Like this all have to brought to common level
Now in the card terestia's Rating 65 is at a Bottom Rating of 51 How I arrive at 51 requires further discussion
Now Ashwa Raudee won in Race no 99 which is 40-65 Class My Revised Rating is 61.7 So at Bottom Rating 51 of Terestia this 61.7 maps to 61.7 plus 0.7*(51-40)which 69.4 Now 65 being the highest Official Rating whwn we compare iit is 4.4 Rating points better
Like this we plot for all horses There are 20G and Oaks races in addition to Handicap Races
Now mere Rating Advantage may not be sufficient We have to superimpose Timings on this.Times Clocked by various horses are different distances.We have to estimate the time to 2400 Mtrs from Distance and Time of differentn horses which is another subject.After doing this I arrange Times on Ascending order and the won which turns out best time is Winner.
There are some empirical values assumed for which there is no quantitative base.
Count of Savoy 15054 which 2 min 35.04 sec
Ashwa Raudee 15024
Icicle 15242
Painted Apache 15268
Karanverr 15469 Ba
Teresita 15631 Ba
Let us see what happens tomorrow It is Racing
Sun said ...
29-Jan-2022@ Vetran Punter
I want to slighly chane my selections of 4 Plus Ba Contender
Count of Savoy Ashwa Raudee Icicle and Painted Apache Some how I feel Monsoon and Winter Timings are not One to One
Out of Bangalore Contenders Karanveer instead of Trestia
My system may fall flat but i am not worried
About my system a littler later
@ITR,
Yesterday I was mentioning about Bangalore Handicapper discarding Rating of Southern Dynasty rated 60 by HRC and put at 47 by BTC and Evaldo was put at 50 and at Madras as both Madras and Hyderabad are in Sync the Rating of Evaldo can be taken as 63 While writing my post I did not know that Evaldo won SI Derby
Again some people may say is Post Race prediction It is not by way of prediction but to highlight the need to look at Ratings critically
Sun said ...
28-Jan-2022@ITR,
I cannot directly answer your question.In a round about way there is a general principle that in a Handicap Races the Winner can always prevail over PPlaced horses in that race though Penalised more than the Margin of Win.I don't rember off hand any such race but you can satisfy yourself by looking at Racords.
Handicapper is a dogmatic person.Once he assigns a Rating he will not reduce just like that and uses that as his reference to eavaluate other horses.So in Bangalore 2000G Kensington and Evaldo were in photo finish
Before Race they were rated 52 and 42 Revised Ratings 58 and 51 Why? He does not want to penalise Evaldo with a bad rating nearer to 58 but at Level Weight if they meet it does not matter him.In my view he takes average of 58 and 42 to put it 50/51.He is satisfied that it s not a bad deal for Evaldo in Handicap Races.In this race Handicapper simply ignored Southern Dyanasty's Revised Rating of 60 assigned by Hyderabad Handicapper Why ???? No idea.
We shall continue to analyse the factors
Thanks.
Veteran Punter said ...
28-Jan-2022Hello Sun,
Kindly give the ratings based on the system followed by you. We are dealing specifically with ratings and you have just given 4 selections like a common tipster.
State the ratings of each individial horses mentioned by you. That will give an idea about its effectiveness.
I was not asking for tips but an analysis based on your system.
You have claimed Secret Life winning South India Oaks proves my point. Do so with the Golconda derby analysis.
I am not throwing a challenge but trying to understand the system followed by you.
Sun said ...
28-Jan-2022@Veteran Punter
Re your post asking me Analyse Golcond Derby as per my system
For Terms Races I do Analysis from 2 Angles
Normalised Rating Syatem Count of Savoy Painted Apache Faith of Success Ashwa Raudee Terestia
Normalised Timing Sytem Painted Apache Ashwa Raudee Count of Savoy Faith of Success On this basis I cannot put Terestia on Common Platform as its Timing is on Bangalore Track All others are Hyderabad Track.Again Painted Apache Rating wise is from Monsoon Timing wise Winter.
My final positions are Painted Apache Count of Savoy Terestia(having run in better company) and Ashwa Raudee.
Best of luck.
Indian_turf_record said ...
28-Jan-2022@ Sun
Many thanks for a prompt reply.
My interest is only academic and you can drop off at point of time. I am intrigued because it is rare for two horses carrying the same weight and s being involved in a close finish to again run their next race at same weights facing each other. I know the Oaks is always at level weights irrespective of ratings. (This will happen often in Classics/Terms races. Two horses who fought the finish of a 2000 Guineas may face each other in Derby).
My point is this. If two horses have finished close at level weights, their 'rating' (by official Handicapper or individual handicappers) should be approximately the same. If they next run in the same race at same weights, logically, they should again run close to each other. If they don't, does it suggest that some parameter is missing ?
By the way, I have watched replay. Secret of Life was in the lead and was whipped mercilessly (jockey fined) to keep up. Princess Gloria came from far back and won under a hands and heels ride.
Sun said ...
28-Jan-2022@ ITR,
Not as an explanation bot an addittional point .Both Princess Gloria and Secret Life were in a photo finish.I have not seen Race video but if Secret Life came from behind it might have some energy left while Princess Gloria did not any reserve.
Now look at Handicapper's Rating it Princess Gloria 31 and Secret Life 25 so much for significance of Handicapping.By definition he has to put Winner at a higher Rating.My Revised Ratings exactly with these
Thanks.
Sun said ...
28-Jan-2022@ Veteran Punter
I have very clearly stated I could not have tipped Secret of Life but while plotting values in my Analysis Sheet I did come across the horse's timing
My post was only to highlight the point that Ratings do represent the caliber but any horse can come up trumps if it can turn out a good time
SI derby it is too late Golconda Derby let me try not as a challenge but to test my system
@ITR
If I have a clue on that I could have minted money Handicapping is my hobby and I am working on A Datum Timing for a Horse at a centre by looking at which one can predict a Winner
Sun said ...
28-Jan-2022@Sagar Saab
In my earlier post Time 99.01 is adjusted for PNR 3
Just for your information
Indian_turf_record said ...
28-Jan-2022@ Sun
I do not understand the complex calculations involved but from your posting it appears that Secret of Life's run over 1800 held a clue to her performance at Chennai.
I can accept that. But I have question. Secret of Life was beaten by head by Princess Gloria over 1800 and both carried same weight. Both next ran at Chennai in same race carrying same weight and Princess Gloria should again have won by head. Princess Gloria did not win but finished three lengths behind. As common race goer I can accept this reversal but what scientific or "system" variation explains it ?
Veteran Punter said ...
27-Jan-2022Hello Sun,
After the race proclamations sound hollow. Had you done so much before the race was run then I would have appreciated but not now.
You ave still 2 chances. The South India derby tomorrow and The Golconda derby on coming sunday.
Have the courage to state BEFORE the race as that would vindicate your claims.
Sun said ...
27-Jan-2022@ Sagar Saab
PNR on that day is 3.5 For checking my system can you give Time Form and of course Indian Rating if I say on Normalised Basis for 1600 Mtr the Timing is
I min and 39.01 Secs
An academic exercise please
Sun said ...
27-Jan-2022@Sagar Saab
Your Rating absolute power rating
My prediction is 80 at Bottom Rating of 48
Derby being Grade 1 Handicapper may upgrade to 80 Bootim Rating which will be 80+32*0.7 equal to 102.4
Of late they are not doing this because due to COVID they don't mind Ratings being on the Lower Side This is the main reason that Miracle is only at 80
Let wait for Handicapper's Rating
Thanks for initiating interesting discussion
Sun said ...
27-Jan-2022@ All
Secret Life winning South India Oaks proves my point
In the Lowest Class it carried 61 Kg was Head second and Timing of 1800 to Common Datum is 9982 at Ba 121b Alicia 124b 10154
Not that I could have tipped Thepoint is Time Clocked carrying 61 Kg for 1800 and Time Clocked for 2400 Mts carrying 57Kg if brought to Common Datum of 1600 Mtrs gives an idea of absolute power of Horse which we should attempt.
Forget which class or at which Rating it is running It is the Weight on its back and Time Clocked matters.It may also happen that all horses are not fully exerted and this provides challenge to punter.
One can say it is a Fixed Race but I believe if we can bring Timings to common Datum we can take a chance at such long shots
Thanks.
S.k.sagar said ...
27-Jan-2022Zuccarelli`s rating as per his Bangalore Derby run:
Timing: 151.24 secs Long term Track Index for 2400m for the Bangalore Track = 0.98349. I do not know the Penetrometer Reading yesterday. Assumming it was good going, I take it that the Short Term Track Index was 1. Accordingly the adjusted timing = 151.24*0.98349 = 148.75 secs. Timing corresponding to a 150 TFR for 2400m = 142 secs
Weight Carried was 57 kgs
Hence Time Form Rating of Zuccarelli = 2.22*57+ 30 – 22222*(148.75 – 142)/2400 = 94
Rating as per Indian Rating System = 94*1.2 = 113
Sun said ...
27-Jan-2022@Veteran Punter
For finality I am not saying Star Superior is not the Bet Horse.My only submission is there can be a horse with much Lower Rating but can come close or beat and higher rated horse.
If you take into account the Prize money Won by placing close to highly rated horse and the Winnngs it may forego for going up in Rating may influence the decisions.Hidden Power as can be infered from the Timings a horse clocks has to be assessed properly
Sun said ...
27-Jan-2022@Veteran Punter
I did guess u changed your name from Critic by the substance of your post
We are like 2 parallel lines and our views differ.
For an unified view first do not assign any significance to Ratings It is only a method of assigning a Number which obviates to remember which horse beat which horse by what margin and if a third horse comes to compete then how to assess.So for simlifying matters they assign a number and have devised Handicap Scale System to reduce the burden on the back of the horse.So we have 0-25 to 95+ Handicap Classes and in Terms Race of a very high caliber horses at 100 Bottom Rating. Star Superior is of that Class what it means taking 100 as Bottom Rating and Carrying 61 Kg it can beat a horse carrying 50 Kg if its Rating is Hundred
Now Timing going into Rating you got me wrong.In fact it is defect of Rating System.If a race of 60-85 Class runs in Slow Pace based on Weights and Distances separating the Handicapper revises Rating.Now if on the same day in a lower class 40-65 horse clocks too superior Time than the 60-85 Class the Revised Ratings will be within 40-65 Class only.Now 65 Rated horse while running in 60-85 Class can Win .In Handicap Races this point is not noted because of Weight Differential common in a Hcp race.
Come to Terms Race in Derby all carry 57Kg and if a horse which ran in 20-45 Class can turn out a better time it can win beating a 80 Rated horse.
While Rating Handicapper does not integrate the Timing Factor and as a Punter we have to factor in.To do that we have few variables
Class 0-25 20-45 etc Distance 1000 1100 1200 Etc. The higher class Timings are better but is it good for that class is the question It is a matter of fact that the competetion in the bunch dtermines the final time but best Times cannot be hidden
Now if you can plot Timing Clocked to a commom datum then you can compare which horse or race is above normal on a day.
I take 1600 Mtrs as base and 0-25 Class as Base.
For your information i give the Races where a Timing is note worthy
Yester Day Bangalore Shining Rock 9881
Bangalore Classics 1000G 9879 that is 1 Min 38.79 Secs for 1600 4th horse
2000G 9854 3rd horse Oaks 10154 3rd horse Derby 10042 Winner
Kindly review it critically and offer your comments.
Veteran Punter said ...
26-Jan-2022Hello all,
Assumed the pen name 'Critic' as I thought that to be appropriate for the subject. However, to avoid confusion to self and others, I am keeping this pen name common in future - Vetran Punter.
@Sagarji
Many thanks. Your inputs and claculations were a revelation.
However, I would like to know if you are satified with the rating system followed in our country by our handicappers, especially in classic races. Also, in non-graded races, like in Violin's case, in which she was given a penalty she will find to overcome.
@Sun
What do you have to say in general to what I have said citing Star Superior as the base. Does that not justify my grouse against the systen currently being followed for giving ratings to NON-WINNERS?
I was not aware that handicappers take timing into consideration while -re-rating a runner. That is news to me.
Sun, again you getting confused.
I am trying to tell that a runner in a non-graded event should not be penalized severly for placing behind a much higher runner.
Bisate ran in a graded event ( Nizam's gold cup - Gr.2).
I know of many horses who were penalized heavily for placing in graded events. I have no issues there. Please understand that.
Sun said ...
26-Jan-2022Zuccarelli will now be at 80 on par with Miracle
S.k.sagar said ...
25-Jan-2022
@ Critic .... Miracle`s best performance was in a race over 1400m in Mumbai where she clocked 83.15 secs carrying 54.5 kg. Long term track index for Mumbai for 1400m is 0.995, It was good going so the Short Term Track Index was 1. Accordingly, the adjusted timing is = 83.15*0.995 = 82.74 secs. Timing for a TFR of 150 for 1400 m = 78.4
Hence Time form Rating = 2.22*54.5 + 30 – 22222*(82.74 – 78.4)/1400 = 82
Rating as per Indian Rating System = 82*1.2 = 99
Incidentally Violin`s best performance was in her very first race over 1100m in Bangalore where she clocked 66.46 secs carrying 53.5 kg
Long term track Index for Bangalore over 1100m = 0.9596, adjusted timing = 66.46*0.9596 = 63.78secs
Timing for TFR of 150 for 1100m = 60.55secs
Hence TFR = 2.22*53.5 + 30 - 22222*( 63.78 – 60.55)/1100 = 84
Rating as per Indian Rating System = 84*1.2 = 101
Sun said ...
25-Jan-2022@Veteran Punter
You have cited example way back in 2019.So I cannot explain with correct calculations because my Latest File address 2 seasons one current and one previous to that.
First let us understand that Rating Numbers and Speed of a hose are not related.
If a horse can turn out better time than other horses then it can Place in a Terms Race and attract high Penalty.Why go back so many seasons Look at Nizam's Gold Cup run on 15th August 21
There is this horse Bisate a 20-45 Hcp Class runs second to Alluring Silver and goes up from 50 to 96
Even before the Race I commented why Bisate in entered here.Now reconciliation of Ratings and Timings
Prior to Nizam's Gold Cup
Alluring Silver Indian Derby Placed Third My Rating 85.4 BR 75
Bisate 20-45 Class Winner My Rating 49.8 BR 20
Now difference in BRs is 55 Multiply by 0.7 which is 38.5 Add to 49.8 which is 88.3
So the fallacy of a 50 Rating horse running Neck behind is solved.Do take into consideration Rating at What Bottom Rating
Now coming to Timing
Alluring Silver on a Norma;ised basis for 1600 mtrs is 10033
Bisate 9671
I am still working on Common Timing across Race Courses whichn is very remote possibility
Any doubts you can post your queries
Sun said ...
25-Jan-2022@All
Vis this post I want to post some aspects on which I wamt your comments
1.What is the significance of Weights Raised by 5.5Kg for the race won by Imperial Power
2. What will be the Rating of Electra after Race No 148 As per my system it will be around 93
Kindly offer you comments
Sun said ...
25-Jan-2022@Sagar Saab,
Thanks for responding to my post and giving Miracle's Time Form Rating and Rating mapping to our system.Your figure is very close to my figure of 94.
@IIMBlue
Are u by any chanse an Alumni of IIM I agree with your views but i want to add few points
1.For outstation horses the Club Handicapper assigns his own Rating Why such Ratng is different?I take Mumbai"s Ratings are the reference with which other Ratings have to be mapped.For this few parameters come into lay
A) Each club puts PNR reading so firmness of track is on some standard scale though Kolkata it is typically 1.8 or so we can double that to bring it to 3.6 a typical figure at Mumbai.If we ignore the effect of Race Track topography aside we find Timings at Mumbai and Kolkata are wide apart.So while mapping Rating from Kolkata to Mumbai this has to be factored in
B) The competetion at Kolkata is not as fierce as at Mumbai and hence a Kolkata Based horse may keep adding Rating points without absolute improvement as Rating is only a relative figure
Considering these 2 points I estimate Kolkata Rating is 6 Points more than Mumbai
Bangalore and Mumbai are close.Hyderabad till recently was not up to the mark but now its Ratings are about 3 Points inferior
Micarcle may struggle to Win in highest class The factor of how pull in Weight comes into Play is any body's guess At 94 it will carry 57Kg and if a good Class 2 horse rons at 50Kg it can upset.
In terms race it has no serious threat.
Veteran Punter said ...
25-Jan-2022To all,
The reason why I am emphasising on some changes for the present handicapping system.
As you all know every kilo counts in a race. If proper rating is given then the results pan out accordingly.
Let me illustrate by taking an Indian derby winner to serve as the best example - Star Superior.
In his final career start, Star Superior won in a thrilling 3-horse photo-finish at Kolkata, yes, Kolkata. It was a TERMS race and all 3 top finishers carried 62 kg.
The result
1 - Star Superior - 62 kg - rated 121
2 - Trafalgar - 62 kg - rated 120
3 - Psychic Force - 62 kg - rated 122
Verdict: Head, Long neck
Handicapper at his best.
Another example: Nizam's Gold cup:
1 - Star Superior - 62 kg - rated 122
2 - Mr Hndsome - 53.5 kg - rated 65
Verdict: Neck
Mr Handsome was immediately given a rating of 95 and never won again. In fact, he retired after a couple of months.
----------------------------------------------
In short, what I am trying to get at is that a horse's creer should not be harmed by giving such massive hikes. When winners of classic races escape with ligth penalty, then why should horses who run close to champion horse be penalized harshly?
High time TAI gave it a thought in the interest of those wannabe champions or challengers to proven horses. A classc winning horse faces no such problems but those who place behind them get penalized.severely.
I hope I have my point sufficiently clear for all to understand.
Any error in the above may kindly be pointed out.
Critic said ...
24-Jan-2022Sagarji,
How have you arrived at that?
Kindly elaborate.
Critic said ...
24-Jan-2022Hello IIMBLUE ji,
I am not talking from a punter's perspective, but rather for the horses (runners).
If, as you say, handicapping is an imperfect system, then, shouldn't some changes be wrought in wherever necessary so as to remove injustice done to some due to the flawed, in my view, system.
Mull on that.
S.k.sagar said ...
24-Jan-2022MIRACLE`S Time Form rating as per her best performance todate is 82 which is equivalent to 99 on the Indian rating system
Iimblue said ...
23-Jan-2022I have been reading the exchange between Critic ji and Sun ji with lot of interest. It has been of great educative value.
To my mind, Miracle may never run in a Handicap Race. I cannot agree with the opinion that, she will struggle in Class 1.A genuine classic horse, should find all Handicap Races, easy fodder.
I don't think , the ratings matter too much, in an Auction ring. In a hypothetical case of both Miracle and Violin retiring today, other things being equal, surely Miracle progeny will carry higher value.
For that matter, many progenies of unraced Mares have been sold at a premium!. There is also a feeling that overraced mares cannot produce quality stock.
Violin's fate was decided the day, she was accepted to run in a terms race. It was the Owner's call.
I feel it is perfectly in order for the KOLKATA Handicapper to limit his view for the horses stationed at Kolkata , while giving ratings. It is not his brief to take an all India View. If the Horse goes to any other center, the handicapper of that Club is free to give his own rating, based on his assessment. There is nothing like all India Rating. Many unbeaten horses from Delhi, failed to win in Bangalore Summer Meeting, despite drastically reduced ratings.
Handicapping is a imperfect system. The imperfections in the system, give an opportunity for a serious punter to zero on an outsider. To my mind upsets are not due to pulling a favourite or due to collusion among the professionals. It is mostly because of cleaver placing of the horse in a suitable set .Not that I am always able to identify it ! Many times I get wiser after the event !!
Critic said ...
23-Jan-2022Hello Sun,
Feel free to indulge in your passion.
With regards to Corfe Castle, if the handicapper has kept it at the same level (ratings), there in nothing wrong in that. In fact, I would compliment him. Corfe Catle won by a mere beck and justifies the handicapper's assessment.
The hanciapper showed utmost wisdom as Corfe Castle is rated above 100 ( 108 to be precise). Penalising heavily would have harmed the future winning prospects. Wisdom at its best.
But same cannot be said about Violin's case. Her career got ruined in one stroke.
Whereas Miracle continues to make merry at current rating of 80, despite having 4 Grade.1 wins to her credit. That gets my goat.
There should be some consistency in handicapping.
The shortcomings ought to be taken note by TAI and necessary inputs be given to save future 'Violins' from harm.
IIMBLUE ji has gone cold. No response from him!!!!
Sun said ...
21-Jan-2022@ Critic,
Hope U will not mind my continuous posts on the subject because it is a subject close to my heart.
Coming to your query for Breeding/Foal value Classic Winners are put in one Category and other higher Rated horses in another .Reason being a Classic is run on Level Playing ground that is all horses carry prescriped Weights except for Geneder Aloowances.Other Terms Races assign Weights based on their earnings and Graded Races Won or Placed. A terms race for 4 year&Up may see good OR marginal Weight Differences and hence Winner picking is either too easy or too tough.
Look at Revised Ratings in Corfe Castle race Winner retained at same Rating and second horses dropped by 2 Points effectively Corfe Castle is Penalised by 2 Points while on the face of it is Zero. Why so low Penalty
Here Bottom Rating like in a Hcp race comes into play.Corfe Catle Rated 108 carried 54 Kg so Bottom Rating is 108-(54-50)*2 =100 So it is the Highest BR because we know that Highest Rating of a horse in India is 125/126 If Computed Revised Rating crosses this Value then other horses Ratings are reduced and Winner put at a Max of 125/126 Of Course in Corfe Castle Race the Computed Rating is 109 Only.(as per my method)
Now how Ratings can be deceptive can be seen in 1000G race where Miracle was Rated 80 while Teresita was at 41 mind you at level Weight.Inspite of this some tipsters did put it in first 3 places in Invitation Day Contest How was that possible.
One thing is by qualitative statements like its earlier run was eye catching OR can we by calculation show that it has a chance
Just think over these points.
Critic said ...
20-Jan-2022Hello Sun,
Got your point.
Now check out mine.
Let's suppose that Miracle and Violin are retired to the stud tomorrow.
Miracle, a multi-classic winner with 4 Gr.1 wins, would retire with a rating of 80, whereas Violin would with a rating of 116.
How would that reflect on the chances of their foals ( pricewise as well as peformancewise)?
Would the foal of Violin command a better price becauseof her much higher rating or would the foal of Miracle do, being out of a multi-classic winner.
Likewise on the the performance of their foals.
Ponder over that.
Sun said ...
20-Jan-2022@Critic
Slight digression from the topic
Look at the rating change of Chopin Why 57 is it an arbitrary number
What is the significance of Grade 1 2 and 3 for Graded races
Is there a difference to those grade for Classics and a simple Terms Race for 4y and upwards
Chpin race is 4y only race Ruia Gold Cup is important race
If we can find answers to these we have some clue to Miracle's Rating My rating is 94 at which if run on 80+ class will have to sweat out to Win
Just think it over
Sun said ...
18-Jan-2022@Critic
All points raised by you are relevant
The only 2 people can answer your doubts are
SK Sagar Saab who can give the Time Form Ratings of Miracle in its various based on Times clocked in those races and u can take highest of all as its True Potential or Power
Another person Ksmrow who predicts potential of a horse based on its runs in few races in its first season which actually a sort of prediction at what Handicap the horse reaches it full potential
Thanks
Critic said ...
15-Jan-2022IIMBLUE ji,
Is the handicapper's ability so poor that he lacks the knowledge to penalise a classic winning horse.
Just see the penalty (change in rating) given to Miracle. Simply astounding to say the least.
Hello Sun,
We are definitely blind as far nuances of handicapping is concerned but we expect the handicapper to go about his job with eyes WIDE OPEN.
Look at the rating jump in Mirace's case to illustrate the same.
A winner of 3 Grade.1 events rated at 80, made more glaring because Miracle earned her first Grade.1 status the earliest possible for her crop.
That's what I am trying to point out.
@Sudheer
I forgot to add. Most of the well-performed classic winning horses choose to participate in Terms or black-type ( graded events ) events. Very rarely do they venture out into handicap races. If they do, it is generally for two reasons. First if the horse has lost form (faced a setback). The second to serve as a lead-up race for a forthcoming black-type race ( when the connections feel the horse needs a run).
So in reality. there nothing much common between a multi-classic winner and a winner in a row of handicap races ( the horse earns a minimum of 5 to 6 kg after every successive win )..
So whu should the handicapping system be different for both as far ratings are concerned. A classic winning horse should not escape with a light penalty just because it calculated relative to the next best in the field.
There should and must be a winning penalty, like in the cases of horses winning in handicaps, a minimum of 5 to 6 kg. A minimum of 8 kg ought to be made compulsory for Grade.1 winners.
Without a revamp, the above is nigh impossible especially in light of what Sun has stated for penalty incurred in winning a classic.
Horses badly penalised like Violin for having run 2nd then stands a good chance of making an impact.
Otherwise, like IIMBLUE said, the owner who also happens to a breeder, will be forced to retire her to stud prematurely.
Why should a talent filly suffer because of inconsistency in our present handicapping system.
Critic said ...
15-Jan-2022@Sudheer
You say the handicapper does not know how good the horse is till it runs in a open i.e. handicap event.
A horse goes on to win classics and you mean to say that the handicapper is unaware as to how good the horse is.
All the more reason for the revamp of the present handicapping system which binds the handicapper in classics. Imagine, the handicapper, none else, does not know the true value of a classic winning horse.
Iimblue said ...
14-Jan-2022@Critic ji,
Handicapping System is unscientific by definition and hence the Handicapper's job is uneviable. It is futile to make sense out of the system. Hypothetically, a horse with rating of 0 (carrying 50 kg, say) and a horse with rating 120 (carrying 110 kg) should finish together!
The Handicapper tries his best under the circumstances. The reputation of a Club depends on the Handicapper's ability and integrity.
Ratings across the Clubs are strictly not Comparable. Multiple Grade Race winner Multifaceted, as yet carries 120 rating at RWITC/BTC. I have no doubt in my mind that Violin,(116, at Kolkata) if she travels back to BTC , will have her rating drastically reduced.
In the past, RWITC held match races during Carnival Week Ends between two horses with same ratings, but never did the Horses finish together.!
It is possible that sometimes Handicappers go overboard. They tend to forget that their job is not to stop a Horse from winning! Trainer R R Byramji had a grouse that his horses are heavily penalised by the handicapper. Trainer V. Khanna, on shifting his base to Kolkata found the Handicapper penalising his horses severely. To err is human....! The Handicapper is bound to err more and every time!! If he were perfect, all races would have needed photo finish cameras to separate out Horses!!!
Nagabhushan M Reddy said ...
14-Jan-2022I too think what Mr Sudheer has made the statements are true.
Sun said ...
14-Jan-2022Dear All,
Pardon me if I say that the sum and substance of posts here is like blind people describing the Elephant
To understand how Ratings are alloted we have to go back to Fundamentals
To start with Maidens are not Rated but to put them in Handicap Races Race clubs assume some arbitary numbers.However a Maidens Race is slightly below 20-45 Race and that is why we find Winner of Maidens Race failing in 20-45 class when alloted 45 Rating.
Now we have some races in the first year of Maidens where there are Penalties for Winners but other Placed Maidens are given a Weight Advantage.If we observe carefully winner is penalised by 4 or 5 Kg.Look at Rno 181 of 12th March 20 Leopard Rock at 57Kg and Dharsana 54Kg
Dharsana or Leopard Rock as Maidens run at 57Kg and in the Terms Race LR is retained at 57 while Dharsana ran at 54KG Effectively LR is penalised 3 KG which you can take it as Standard OR Min Penalty It goes on like this.If a horse is Penalised by say 6 Kg in Handicap Race it does not mean that it is 6 Kg supperior to the bunch On the otherhand the Placed horses were not up to the Ratings assigned.
As I explained earlier Rating is to relative to assess the strength of horse Finally carrying a cetain Weight it must turn out a Time better than other horses in that Handicap Class.This is why even 1000G winner can fail in Highest Class.The Timing of higher class Races is better because as they go to higher class the Weight is reduced from say 62Kg to 55Kg.So a Handicap Race reflects Relative Power while Terms race is absolute Power So LR is 3 Kg superior than Dharsana and it is more than that because it finished above it,
For 3 Year Olds PBRM is like calss 1 for horses in their first season and hence thay go from slightly inferior race of 20-45 of Maidens to 40-65 Class
Now with this background if we analyse the Ratings of a horse in Classics if the horses have not run in Handicap Race their Rating in Classics will remain under mentioned.In revising Rating in a race like Derby HC goes by highest rated horse among Placed horses and if that happens to be low the Revised Rating is also low.,
In Pune Derby observe Ratings they are very low if you compare with previous Derbies.So taking the highest among the Placed hirse Zuccarelli is Rated 67 and next race 2000g it was highest rated Placed horse and with reference to that A Star is Born rated and put at 70 because HC cannot but give some advantage to Zuccarelli so even 1.5Kg is considered as sufficient penalty.Note that as 2000g race is a Equal Weight race A Satr is born is in real terms superior to Zuccarelli.
Like this if we go to other Terms Races where there is Difference in Weights you get Revised Rating to Winner by taking the Highest Rated Placed horse and separating distenace with due consideration of Weights
Now coming to Bellator race Sheismyscript is highest rated Placed horse and Bellator carried 1.5 Kg more so 94+3 It also finished 3/4L ahead.So 98 is resonable but it is a different matter if it runs in 80+ Hcp calss whether it can beat other horses carrying 59Kg.
To sum up Classic Race winners Rating may be subdued depending on to which extent they ae Rated in Handicap Race.The Penalty in Races like Derby reflects absolute superiority as thay carry equal weights except for gender allowance
Thanks.
Sudheer said ...
14-Jan-2022@Critic
Theres nothing wrong with the handicapping system here..
1st and foremost try to understand that ratings of a horse are relative in nature..
Derby and guineas looks like big events because of the stakes.. Purely in rating purposes, they are restricted races.. For 3 or 4 year olds..
Even if miracle wins the oaks and then the Derby handicapper can't penalise the horse because it would beat lesser rated horses than it..
If miracle comes to open company then beat a 120 rated horse then the handicapper can penalise it..
Forget about miracle, many classic winners couldn't beat a class 3 fields in open company.. The recent example is akido..
Handicapper just don't know how good the horse is until it runs in the open company..
It's not wise to change the system because you will have one or two horses like miracle in a decade..
The 2017 Derby winner Hall of famer has just struggled in open class.. It won 2 derbies and 1guineas but as soon as it came to open class it struggled..
To be honest we don't know how good miracle is till it runs in open class..
No need to revamp the handicapping system just because one horse is toying with the opposition.. Take it as an exception and move on..
I hope you understand what my point here is..
Critic said ...
14-Jan-2022@Sudheer
I do understand all that. Sun was gracious emough to explain
Please try to understand that I am saying the handicapping systen needs a revamp.
A derby winner getting 3 kg penalty and the Indian 1000gn winner just 2 kg.
Can it get any more ridiculous than that?
Kamlesh said ...
14-Jan-2022remember 1 thing nothing is wrong in handicapping, winners, 1st ,2nd,3rd ,4th or 5th all rating given are basis of field (short/long field,nos of runners in that races)and ratings of 1st to 5t placed horses go thru full result of races of all centres, it will take time to understand, needs a thorough practice.
generally in big field handicapping is based on 3rd or 4th placed
based on 4th
Ksmrow said ...
14-Jan-2022Hi all,
After seeing the post checked the fate of Bellator a jump of +26rating
BELLATOR 99(73)
Shesmyscript 94(94)
I never give any importance to clubs official ratings go with my speed ratings except in terms races because trainers aware the risk of heavy penalty often denying best horse to win , generally we have to go with top rated horses which fall in top10 rating points they win 99% times if the field is not too small or long shot Doosra's design by trainer or big owners.
I think it is necessary all race clubs re looking in to penalty pattern in terms and graded races fixing a maximum cut out point, say for terms races 15 points to winner 10 to second and 5 for 3rd place for classic 25;15;10 may be fair insted of solely depending on ratings of beaten horses.
Sudheer said ...
14-Jan-2022One more example I forgot to quote was Enigma who was penalised 25 points for running 3rd in the sprinters Cup.. Where the winner was retained at the same rating..
So the penalty of rating points depends on the rating of the field..
Sudheer said ...
14-Jan-2022@Critic
Im not an expert in the handicap systems but from the limited knowledge I have, I think you are doing one basic mistake of comparing the runs of within the age group with the runs in open company..
Winning the black type races or classics doesn't have a great impact on the rating of a horse unless otherwise its open to all ages..
Handicapping and rating system doesn't work on the stakes or glamour of the race.. It works on pure class and class alone..
I will explain you with an example.. War hammer won 8 races in a row.. And it was rated 90 by the time of Indian Derby.. The only time it was penalised heavily was when it won an open class 1.. It was penalised 15 points for that.. And within the age group it was just like miracle only..
No matter how good the horse is the handicapper won't penalise it based on the performance in a same old age group race..
Coming to the violin case, it ran 2nd in a terms race open to all and beaten horses rated above 100.. The handicapper has no choice but to penalise it for that.. It was penalised 35 points and its fair as per me..
Same goes for theon it was penalised 42 points for running 2nd in stayers Cup.. Where as the winner wasn't penalised for even 1 point because it was already rated 110 and was the highest rated horse for the particular race..
The penalty of the rating points only depends on the class of the race.. And handicapper can only penalise the horse heavily if the race is open to all age groups...
It will be penalised very heavily if the horse beats any horse whose rating is more than it while running in the top 3.. Coming back to miracle again, it won't be penalised because it will be the top rated horse in the field and is expected to win carrying the same weight as the lower rated horses..
All the above is my understanding of the rating system.. Experts, correct me if I'm wrong..
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now