How much does trackwork mean or is reliable is subject of debate. Especially when we see a horse like Spectacular winning In such a way today.
In India the concept of working a horse on sand track varies from center to center. In Mumbai or Pune the horses are worked on Sand on inner track, in Bangalore mostly they work on Outer sand. In Kolkata they work on outersand and Hyderabad they work on Sand track. If you compare all these timings of workout at all center they vary from center to center. The only logical calculation that can be used is fastest timing. Also there is something called "Andhere main kaam dena" Which newcomers won't be aware of. It means work the horse before track reporters report and note the timing. This doesn't come in any record only trainers know for their own horses.
The only reason to put this on post is I have seen racegoers relying a lot on it. Fact is this is all manipulation and racing is not clean as we think.
This is best described by Mr. Zavaray Poonawala in his one of the interview about S. M Shah and we all have a lot to learn in just one statement he did. " S. M Shah was different, as it is very unique to find a genuine human being as horse trainer" Understand what did one of the most prolific personality in racing meant to say.
17 Replies
Saurabh said ...
29-Jul-2022
Thank you all for a Healthy discussion. I would like to share something I have learnt over the years.
When a horse races if it is streched for a good gallop irrespective of winning, placing or off board it looses around 10 to 15 kgs which is it's excess water content. Everyday feed does put around 1 to 1.5 kgs on it. When worked out over 1000 mtrs to mile it looses around 6/9 kilos.
This is only catch in track work. If you see horse is in form, has been worked every 5/7 days and maintains the similar weight after it is still fit, eating well and can be trusted on fitness and form. On the other hand horse working regularly still gaining weight is positive sign. It means it putting on good condition and developing muscles. Horse loosing significant weight without much workout is loosing mass and is not a good sign. Watch this for a time and you all will agree.
Also will tell you something interesting about weight of horse and workout, light weight horses are immediately discarded by big trainers if they don't have the power. If you don't believe see how many horses does Pesi, Padmanabhan Or Attaollahi have which weigh less then 400 kgs. Also tell me how many horses have won in Mumbai season with weight lesser than it. It is not like horses with light weight are not good. Intact if they are they are Multi Classic winners. Will give example of Jacqueline and Juliette. Both were light mares. In short this is all far complex then what has been mentioned by some experts.
Glasgow Prince said ...
29-Jul-2022
Malicious,
Are you referring to track work when you refer to sand track and race track? Horses are worked on the grass track only by exception. To the best of my knowledge, horses are normally worked on the sand tracks.
Malicious Grudge said ...
27-Jul-2022
@Glasgow Prince Sir,
Please, permit me to express my valueless opinion in this aspect/ respect of track work -->
1) Sand Track & Race Track are two entirely different dimensions.
2) Sand track reveal fitness & temperament of animal that particular day.
3) Race track reveal, Spurt, Gallop, Final Assault, Rate Of Dash in last part/ initial speed etc.
In addition to this some other concepts are also. Please, correct me, if possible.
Regards & tks,
Malicious Grudge said ...
27-Jul-2022
@IndianRaceCritics Sir,
Right Idea. Importance of such punters forum is a timely demand/ requirement & badly needed since inception of horse races in India. (British Period)
Initiative should be on card, very much indeed.
Iimblue said ...
27-Jul-2022
@PEPPS,
I am sorry. I could not recall the name of the horses. Now that you have pointed out, I think it was some other lesser known jockey.
I remember the incident vividly because, after the first horse won, I scratched my brain and played the second horse.
Horses can maintain condition and fitness for a month or two, particularly when the trainer is targeting them for one particular race.
That Ooty is a high altitude center may also be a helpful fact, when you are. bringing the horse to a low altitude center.
Nothing wrong in horses having a vacation or trip, as long as the tracks are transperant. One has to remember that in the olden days, track given at one center, was lost on the radar of punters when it ran at some other center .
Pepps said ...
26-Jul-2022
@ IIMBLUE
T Mahesh has won only five races at Pune. He never won two races in one day or for Katrak/KND. So Iam confused. If you can kindly give names of horses or year it happened, I will check again.
Ooty track closes in middle of June. Pune has first race usually after Bangalore Derby.Is it possible that preparation in Ooty helps horse to win after a month after travelling long distance.
We go on holiday to refresh ourselves. Anything wrong in horses having holdiay ?
Iimblue said ...
25-Jul-2022
@Glasgow Prince ,
Sir, many such incidents happen with Mr. K N Dhunjeebhoy horses. Some older horses stabled at Pune would reach Nanoli Stud for rehabilitation, would come back and win with lesser known jockeys.
I also casually came across two KND older horses (under trainer Katrak ) tracking in Ooty.They did not run there. In Pune both horses were entered on the same day and won their respective races at odds of 15/1.Lesser known T. Mahesh rode the horses.
I also came across instances wherein R. Foley was preparing MAM horses at Mysore and they were running in Bangalore summer races under J H Foley.
Indian Race Critics said ...
25-Jul-2022
Bang on track work should be considered when it has ran with the company so that we can have an idea of the horse class moreover it's just waste always they try to hide the reality to fetch more odds earlier big owners horse were genuine and true trackworks in real race nowadays no owner has balls to win on cramped odds so they hide manipulate by giving runs one only solution for all this is stewards will record trainers instruction in paddock which are not disclosed to punters this should be changed and it should be announced openly so that we can understand the intent. These stewards and chairman's what they are doing using the recordings I don't know so many horse were hooked this season no one to question .
respected big betting punters I request to all anyone can take initiative and form an punters association so that we can question these races or else no one save punters . My sincere concern is what will happen to the new young punters life no study no info nothing will be helpful in making us profitable punter we will win for time being in the end we all losers . At least some one take initiative to form a punters association
Harish said ...
25-Jul-2022
Yes I agree ..best example day before yestady Theon track work was not much impressive bt in race he had proven.. same way some horse work very well in mrning track bt nt in race track...Matera horse who works like bullet in track bt in race he disapointed us...same way some horse doesn't get wip in mrning trails easy going thy give just because of ...not to lose its energy in race time...
Sps said ...
25-Jul-2022
"godzilla" sir
Thankyou Very much for the very good tutorial on TRACK WORK.
I request you to give further such tutorial time to time on regular basis on different aspects of HANDICAPING, for persons like me who want to understand from you.
With Regards
Chase said ...
25-Jul-2022
Glasgow Prince said ...
25-Jul-2022
Track work is not as useful as it may seem at first glance. It can be deceptive. Some horses don't need blazing track work to win because they thrive on light work. The timing will also depend on to what extent the horse was allowed free rein. We also don't know the weights carried by the horses. As IIMBlue has pointed out, sometimes heavy jockeys are used. Apart from this, there is no rule that prevents trainers from using lead weights in the saddle. To the best of my knowledge, there is no training track at any of the stud farms. Hence horses can't be given track work at the stud farms. IIMBlue, please correct me if I am wrong. Some horses can win with only swimming exercise. There are many examples. A recent case is Acaster. We don't know whether they were exercised in the dark. Hence we can't risk ignoring such horses. We can see which trainers' horses ususally win without published track work. Unsound horses will not be given hard work. Similarly, horses coming out of setbacks will be handled with kid gloves. All in all, track work needs to be taken with a bagful of salt.
Hals said ...
25-Jul-2022
Good narrative. Of course track work is only indicative of the horse condition, nothing else. One has to watch the padak condition, current weight, jocky, vet report etc. Finally the connections intentions matters.
Godzilla said ...
25-Jul-2022
What is a good track work:
At Bangalore .. In Outer Sand,in case of a mile track,if a horse finishes its work out in 40 or 41 seconds in last 600 mtrs, its considered to be the best track.
Sprinter Outer Sand
800 54 last 600 40 secs.
At Hyderabad
Same formula, here its Sand Track,, but last 600 should be anywhere between 42 and 43 secs.
For Sprinter Sand Track 800 54 sec last 600 42 secs.
At Bombay/Pune
Inner Sand
Last 600 in 37 or 38 seconds is too good a work out for a mile. .
Best Sprinter track at Bombay/Pune in Inner Sand for last 800 mtrs 49/35.
At Kolkata/Chennai/Mysore/Delhi
No track work is reliable in these Centres.
Iimblue said ...
25-Jul-2022
@ Sourabh,
What you have written is true. As far as trainers S M Shah and his brother S S Shah were concerned , one never had to ask the question, if the horses were on job. They were always triers. One could back them confidently for place.
I for one, take the track timings with a pinch of salt. They are indicative of the fitness of the horse and nothing else. At times, the owner gets ready the horse at a stud farm and obviously there will be no track in public domain. There were trainers who used heavy saddle for track work. That practice has been found out but nothing prevents the trainer from using a top weight work jockey. Then there are horses which donot like to run in company, so they leave the track work behind at the track itself (morning glories). Then there are horses which lack fighting spirit. Too many imponderables and too many possibilities. !
Long back , a Veteran warned me against studying too much. "study too much and you will arrive at the door steps of the favourite! " , he said. Very true !!
Ashok Kumar said ...
24-Jul-2022
Dear sir
All the Race course center should appoint Track Reporters and Reporters should give correct track timings and it should be cross verified by the club members
Horse owners and trainers influence should not be affected
As I hv noticed in track horses r good but when it runs in actual race lot of differences
Club should take upmost care and make horse track timings transparent
Regards
Kurban said ...
24-Jul-2022
Hi Saurabh sir,
Thanks for light on very important topic in horse racing.
Question in my mind is really horse run as per track work out ?
Some cases found horse run without trackwork but opening odd shows 50 paisa.
( Recent example Nugget win in Hyderabad race without trackwork.)
I think we go as per odds for winner chance forget track work out.
Thanks for nice write up.
Good day