India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsIn Continuation : Tfr Testing
By S.k.sagar | 05-Oct-2022In continuation .. Testing my Time Form Rating System.
The next bet ( BET NO: 2) will be in tomorrow`s Mysore Races, 6TH race:
STAR GLORY WIN in the Mysore Dussehra Sprint Championship.
CHEERS
22 Replies
Sun said ...
06-Oct-2022@ Sagar Saab,
My view point is if your exercise to test TFRs for Indian Races you should go by what the system throws out ie Endeavour
If u select another horse u r actually making a selection with TFRs to guide you.
Thanks
Onederboy said ...
06-Oct-2022@ S.K.SAGAR
your Rating was Perfect
S.k.sagar said ...
06-Oct-2022Played @ 9 : 2 and lost.
Cumulative score after two bets: + 1550 ( RET 3750 - INV 2200)
All six horses including the winner performed well below their potential. The TFRs of the first three finishers as per specific performance of today were as follows ( I assumme it was good going) :
Endeavour : 94 ( 23 points below its best)
Ascoval: 84 ( 20 ponts below its best)
Star Glory: 62 (46 points below its best) .. Curious .
I have no explanation of why it ran so poorly.
But that does not mean the revised ratings will be as above, for the simple reason that the potential of the horses has not reduced in the same proportion. My revised TFRs of the 6 runners will be as follows:
Endeavour: 110 as against 108 previous rating
Ascoval : 98 as against 94
Star Glory : 90 as against 100
Golden Guest: 79 as against 81
Sovereign Orb : 88 as against 94
Dandy Satyagraha: 78 as against 92
Philip Dcruze said ...
06-Oct-2022Well Explained Sagar Sir,
Pedigree Pundit said ...
06-Oct-2022Respected Sagarji,
As per the Timeform ratings given subsequently by you I would say you were spot-on on the ratings of the runners.
ENDEAVOUR got the highest rating and it would have done good had you gone by that.
Nevertheless, I would say your system works fine.
Good luck in your future assignments!
Sunil R said ...
06-Oct-2022Firoz Bhai,
Delhi me hero ban gaye aap. God bless you. Thanks
Ruchi said ...
06-Oct-2022As expected ENDEAVOUR MADE MINCE MEAT OF THE OPPOSITION.
STAR GLORY WAS SIMPLY OUTCLASSED FROM THE WORD GO.
S.k.sagar said ...
06-Oct-2022
@ Ruchi … Thanks for your valuable comments.
My area of specialization lies in evaluating the Time Form Rating of a horse entirely based on a specific performance, and in this respect I can match strides - never mind bragging - with the best in the business such as the various experts in UK and many other countries who do it regularly. In my book I have discussed at great length several case studies wherein I have explained why I am in disagreement with the so called experts on the accurate evaluation of some great horses such as of `FRANKEL` and of `DEEP IMPACT` etc.
So, notwithstanding the fact that Star Glory may lose or even be unplaced, my system of evaluation of TFRs cannot be questioned considering the fact that the system just determines the potential of a horse based on a specific performance. Now, there is always a possibility that the horse may not achieve the same rating ever in its future, and in its very next outing may run with a sharply reduced TFR. But the same criteria applies to all participating horses.
Ascoval`s best performance was on 26th June 2022 worth a TFR of 104. Even If It performs to that level again, it will still require Star Glory and Endeavour to perform well below their potential TFR, in order to win the race. Currently I rate him at 94.
Endeavour`s best TFR of 117 was achieved on 27th August 2022 at Pune, which if it can repeat he will be very difficult to beat. But based on his recent lacklustre performance, I rate him at 108, which can still be good enough to win, if Star Glory runs below its true potential.
Star Glory`s best potential rating was 108 in its very last outing on 19/8 August 2022. But I usually need two similar great performences before I rate the horse at that level, so I rate the horse at 100 as its expectation value in the next outing. Besides .. looking at the current odds ie 5 to 1, it is a good value bet .. I think.
More later.
Good luck and best wishes
Munesh said ...
06-Oct-2022Knowledgeble ones
Are the races, nowadays, run according to the merit?
S.k.sagar said ...
06-Oct-2022@ Pedigree Pundit ... Yes Star Glory is rated higher plus carrying less weight plus younger horse,
These are the Time Form Ratings of the main contestents:
Endeavour : 108
Star Glory : 100
Ascoval : 94
Between Endeavour and Star Glory I prefer the latter as it has potential to improve further being younger, besides Endeavour had a poor last run. Even Ascoval had a poor last run though he was badly interfered with.
Golden Viper said ...
06-Oct-2022It is mission impossible for a 3 yr old to win in this class unless an extra ordinary horse which it is not.
Last spurt of Ascoval makes it a clear winner So the race comes to Ascoval and S. orb
Firoz Khan said ...
06-Oct-2022Hi guys, MY "TEN BET TEN VICTORY".
Delhi. 1st race. 5. CRESSIDA. 2nd by shd.
Mysore. 2nd race. King of the jungle.
Best of luck.
From MEYDAN.
Jp said ...
06-Oct-2022I have very little understanding about the system. Few points I just like to put it here out of my experience and from memory:
a) very few horses as 3 year olds have run in terms race against older horses and have tasted defeat and no winner as per my memory.
b) very few horses have run as 3 year old in the highest class(class 80 and above)
c) I remember only Confident Victory won as a 3 year old in Class 80 and above. It was ridden Gaurav Sapna claiming 3.5 kgs allowance. The horse had a handicapped weight of 49 kgs. I am not sure of the jockey's weight and the actual weight carried. The difference was more than 10 kgs to the record time breaker Rhapsidian Snow, which finished 2nd. The other 3 year old was ,still racing My Opinion which won in Hyderabad against Class 74 and above.
Only Late MAM who used to throw such challenges. Trainer of Star Glory was MAMs stable jockey and I think all wins were in his colours. Maybe inspiration from his ex-boss.
Mahesh Gowda said ...
06-Oct-2022Maybe star has a age in his side..star glory is not a condemned horse..have a very good chance n should maintain a good pace
Ruchi said ...
06-Oct-2022SAGAR JI... You are knowledge personified in this forum for over years and a big bow to you sir.
its always good to interact and "QUESTION" your suggeations as in the bargain,a racing enthusiast will definetly LEARN and gain some more knowledge.
Racing has been and is a very passionate sport for me.
Coming staright to the point. I find that RATING and HANDICAPPING systems practiced by various people adopting Various methods at many time sthrow out Different conclusions.
i being an ELECTRICAL ENGINEER would like to pose this riddle to you?
We know that in ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING V=I X R.... that is VOLTAGE is equal to CURRENT multiplied by RESISTANCE, this is the universal KIRCHOFFS law, its universal and every body on earth will get the same results if this law id adoopted for any electrical network world over.
But the same is not truw in case of different methods of Handicapping.
For example , the Ratings system which i adopt ha sthe Following RATINGS.
ENDEVOUR (632)
THE SOVERIGN ORB(624)
GOLDEN GUEST (616)
ASCOVAL (616)
DANDI SATYAGRAHA (616)
STAR GLORY (609)
Ironically STAR GLORY is last in my method of rating, suggesting that its chances are definetly too low., Can you throw some light on this different method of ratings and your experience.
My method of study and evaluation also brings me to the conclusion, that STAR GLORY lacs class. It is at best a class III type whilst the others are GENUINELY CLASS ONE STUFF.
ASCOVAL in Pune was a bit unlucky that in race (28?) it was badly knoecked out of the race by jostling at the start.Though ASCOVAL also lacks class , its still better than STAR GLORY. DANDI SATYA being a KOLKOTTA based we can take the risk of ignoring it.
That according to me brings us to three prime contenders ENDEVOUR-GOLDEN GUEST-THE SOVERIGN ORB.
ENDEVOUR and GOLDEN GUEST are genuine class one stuff and have matched strides with the best sprinters .Off the two GOLDEN GUEST being afront running type may cut the wind with STAR GLORY and both will come back to the field,
So its between ENDEVOUR and THE SOVERIGN ORB.Lat run of THE SOVERIGn ORB was shady, it has in teh previous run finished second to TRAFALGAR who has won again. that was over 7F , so the hot pace set up by GO:LDEN GUEST and STAR GLORY will suit it to the "T"
ENDEVOUR is class apart its run in race (50) and in race (4) especially where it came 4th is to be seen, it was alst and then when PSC alerted it , it covered horse after horse to finisha close 4th.
Also as i mentioned STAR GLORY knows only one method of running, HIT THE FRONT, this horse has no finishing burst, so i feel it will find the down hill track of mysore, the last 200 mts difficult as, at the 300 to 200 MYSORE tarck is a UPJHILL where most of the front running type are FINISHED.
My take ENDEVOUR versus THE SOVERIGN ORB.
ALL THE BEST. Above is strictly my view and my method.
Good luck again and hope you will clarify my doubt on various Handicapping methods a sto why they throw differnt conclusions unlike V=IXRj
Ruchi said ...
06-Oct-2022By the by win or lose ,i am a ardent student of handicapping and various system I keep exploring in various methods.Please do inform in this forum when your book will be on sale.
It will be interesting to read it.
Good luck again for your ENDEAVOURS....who knows ENDEAVOUR may beat STAR GLORY .......today
Ruchi said ...
06-Oct-2022Sagarji ....all the best.First of all ,good luck.
STAR GLORY has got beaten by at best Class III runner like YUKAN..and the one who finished behind was MYSTIC EYE who is at best CLASS III./ IV.
Here we have genuine class one stuff though all at 60 kgs giving weight to STAR GLORY But nevertheless in sprint handicap does not matter much
All others have run with genuine CLASS HORSES.
THE SOVEREIGN ORB ran shd to TRAFALGAR.Who after words reeled off two races
ENDEAVOUR and GOLDEN GUEST have run with giants and pure class one runners at MUMBAI AAC OVAL is also no mean customer.To beat all these and win ,i feel STAR GLORY may even struggle to come third
Another point against STAR GLORY is it's a one paced front runner with no finishing dpeeef whatsoever.Here GOLDEN GUEST will cut a solid clip and STAR GLORY would be defeated at the gates itself.If at all STAR Managed to pace with GOLDEN GUEST,she will have nothing left in tank to fight the finish.
I expect the Mysore 1200 METERS record will be shattered today and a new record under 1 minute 9 will be established.
Good luck
Pedigree Pundit said ...
05-Oct-2022Dear Sagarji,
Does your TimeForm rating systen throws STAR GLORY as higher than ASCOVAL?
Please explain the criteria for having reached the conclusion.
I would be much obliged for the courtesy extended.
Hoping it comes forth.
Thank you
Prasannaa said ...
05-Oct-2022This technique may be useful in handicap races.. I doubt if it is as effective in terms races..
Gamble @ $ said ...
05-Oct-2022Great selection... Odds more den 4/1 very good handicap.... Me too trying.. Finger crossed
Philip Dcruze said ...
05-Oct-2022Sagar Saab,
Also post your current TFR for Star Glory.
Thanks.
Sunil R said ...
05-Oct-2022Dear Sagar ji,
Thanks & hope for the best. I have a doubt in this race. My sincere apologies. Thanks????????
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now