Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Tfr Test Continued

By S.k.sagar | 06-Nov-2022

TFR TEST CONTINUED

TEST NUMBER 14 : PUNE 4TH RACE : RAFFAELLO  WIN

Post Your reply

32 Replies

Gopinath. Raman said ...

13-Nov-2022

I appreciate Sagarji's indepth knowledge in Racing. But what ever said and done, one rule applied to a race on one day is not applicable to another race on the same day. It is very tricky.  At the end of the day,  for what so ever ages you have been in racing, winning percentage is roughly around 22%.This is the final outcome and is a universal fact. ACCEPT IT with Graciousness. 

 

Jp said ...

10-Nov-2022

I am rather sad that RUCHI has expressed his desire to leave this forum due to some few thinking one is above the other. There's no one as NUMBER ONE in racing. I am also of the opinion that any arithmetical calculations will not work in Indian present day racing. Each trainer has their own agenda and it goes accordingly.

Take the case of the first race on the last day of the concluded Poone season. One trainer had left 4 horses. The favourite was ridden by a jockey who had just 2 winners for the season. The next best Mozelle was ridden by a 5kg claimer and the trainer himself was not confident in his talk about his horse running without a whip. 

Let someone answer how many horses are on job in a particular race. Million dollar question? Only after the race you will get an answer. In the race quoted above Mozelle and Cipher were on a hatrick both were not on job. Mozelle trainer's reservation about running without a whip and Cipher's running. Cipher's much projected jockey kept it at the back of the field and came to the frame when the race was almost over. Now the trainer who had left 4. He indicated by declaring a 5kg claimer on Majestic Warrior and the rest by declaring regular jockeys. The running also confirmed that except MW rest were switched off. The much speedier Desert Fire and another front runner Northern Singer never went in front. 

In most of the races only few horses will be on job. Any kind of calculations will not succeed if the horse selected is not job. This cannot be found out by paddock looks. My take on present day racing is select your horse , back that and keep your fingers crossed and if it wins or places ( as per your bet), it is a blessing.

 

Tammy said ...

09-Nov-2022

Sagar sir

The knowledge you impart is a boon for punters. With the disruptor declaring he is going away until the Indian derbym the field is clear for you to progree on. Please try to give your selectiions on race days. Thank you sir

Rajaraman said ...

09-Nov-2022

Hi Sagar ji  and all Htans I'll  never  follow anyone iam a very small  person to this  field I am neither expert or to know the informational I have been  given some kills to do my best  I'll never post my postings that's my strength  Racing is more than  the pregnancy it's very  tough we're ever it's run entire World thanks if it posted Admin 

Pepps said ...

09-Nov-2022

Mr. Sun

Congratulations. You gave your ratings and choice before race. Some people are experts to give perfect ratings and super analysis after the race result is known. Good they are going on holiday.

Philip Dcruze said ...

09-Nov-2022

@ Mr Blinkers

Can you please explain your modification with Sagar Saab TFR so that we can also get the help to come into conclusion as i am also great admire of Sagar saab TFR system..

Thanks and awaiting for your favorable response.

Sun said ...

09-Nov-2022

@Ruchi,

Thanks for obliging me and posting the Dy Ratings of top 4 horses for Rno 3 and single selection for Rno 5

Of late I have switched over to Timing Analysis from Ratings Analysis I consider up to 5 previous races and select the race for Analysis for all Placed horses up to 5th Position.

My Calculations give as under 

Rno 3    Wonderful Lady 8639 which is 1Min 26.39 sec (expected Time at PNR 2.3 highest of previous races considered)  Morieseiki 8670 Bumblebee 8742 Responsibleforlove  8772

Rno 5     Jeweller 7269 The Cheetah 7296 Too Good 7318  Adorable 7328

I respect your reading of the race and Distance Suitability of horses.My attempt has been to find a Winner between 2 horses.One and Two in both races tally with mine.

For both i go with first one.

After first race result I will know today's PNR then I will indicate Expected Times and hope the Rankings will remain

Thanks.

 

Ruchi said ...

09-Nov-2022

SUN....as requested here is the dynamic ratings for the two races you had asked .

3= BUMBLEBEE (603)-RESPONSIBLE FOR LOVE(603)-MORESAKI(600)

Analysis= just three points separate the top three.A bit difficult to seperate them out but RESPONSIBLE FOR LOVE has seen class and has been in class one for a while.The day number (5) supports MORESAKI.My short list will be between these two.

5=THE CHEETAH (625)-ASHWA KAHIRA(625)-TOO GOOD(620)-JEWELLER(620)

Analysis= straight away i will leave out ASHWA KAHIRA,it is a class (3) type and the owner mate THE CHEETAH IS FAR FAR BETTER..

JEWELLER over 1200 mts is suspect.

As i already mentioned all boxes are ticked for THE CHEETAH.NEXT BEST TOO GOOD.

1) STRONG DAY NUMBER (5)

2) THE CHEETAH has beaten a genuine class one horse VICTORIA PARADE a outstation horse.

3) THE CHEETAH a season back has won a classic,i think Colts trial.

4) THE CHEETAH is actually a Mumbai import 

My final take THE CHEETAH IS UNBEATABLE,NY BET will be THE CHETAH for win and cover shp as this is racing and the way races are conducted Nowdays one has to give in to the 10 percent of uncertainty.

LASTLY this is my last post here,one thing my posts,comments have a lot of problems.Many post,comment others post but there is no problem.Irs only when i post that a few guys erupt.So why have the tension..I quit,i will now post only when SUCRE runs to follow it's progress.

Good luck..all the best to Sagar ji too.

Blinkers said ...

08-Nov-2022

Dear Sagar Ji

I am using your TFR method for very long time. I created your calacutions in EXCEL sheet and using this method. 

The ratings calcuated by this system is very much sucessful for me, and i am very happy with the rating to shortlist the selections. 

In the last day of Pune, Rafello comes first in the rating for 1400 mtrs. If you consider the distance and the class (i.e 1600Mtrs) Count of Savoy and Multistarer will come frist in the TFR rating as per their run in Race no : 66.

I played Conunt of Savoy eachway with edge bet on Multistarer. Unfortunalty Jockey fell down on Multistarer.

My humble request to you is don't bother about the negative feedback. To me, TFR is one of best Rating system for Indian Horse racing. 

(Admin : Please post this...)

Ruchi said ...

08-Nov-2022

SUN....

Tomorrow in race (5) card no (5) THE CHEETAH is one horse race.

It is top in rating.also tommorrow SUN - MERCURY (5) is in conjunction.It will pay to follow card and draw (5) tommorrow.It will come in 80 percent races in paying place and will win atleast two races.

So considering that THE CHEETAH is top in rating+ the added analysis of.

1) Strong day number combo of (5) with (1) draw 

2) C S Jodha a very positive jockey shift from last two times 

3) THEE CHEETAH. Being a Delhi horse has beaten in the last season VICTORY PARADE,a genuine class one horse.

4) DELHI CLASS one is like class 2 or 3 of other centres,but this one has beaten a outside genuine class horse.

5) THE CHEETAH a season back is the Guineas winner.

6) Earlier days THE CHEETAH started its carrier from MUMBAI.

SO all boxes are ticked in favour of THE CHEETAH.

We do have to consider the small negative factor,the way races are run,i MEAN BUT FOR SOME HANKY PANKY THE CHEETAH CANNOT LOSE.

MY BET WILL BE WIN AND CONTINGENCY (SHP) to protect the risk

I could understand what you are hinting for the third race.well as of now, the hot fav WONDERFUL LADY WILL NOT WIN,I hv to still finalise ratings of the 3 rd

 

Sun said ...

08-Nov-2022

@Ruchi 

Just to see how good is the Dy Rating system can u provide Ratings of top 3 horses in tomorrow Delhi Races Race 3 and 5 

U can post here OR Delehi Selections thtread.

Please treat this as an attempt to see how my system compares with yours.Nothing else

Thanks.

Ruchi said ...

08-Nov-2022

THE dynamic ratings just does not consider time.

The final figure of the DR.is a comparision with previous three runs and is arrived at after comparing, with the current race,factors as described below

1) DISTANCE OF PREVIOUS RACE VIS A VIS CURRENT.

2) HANDICAP DIFFERENCE,PLUS OR MINUS.

3) TIMING

4) POST POSITION, even if it has won or finished dead last there is a comparision.

5) Distance by which won or lost right upto last horse.

It's really hard work but the results are amazing

 

Raghavan said ...

08-Nov-2022

Sagar ji,

You have given some horses based on their performance and your assessment thereon.

Do not worry about the negative comments of any tipster.  In fact, the most dangerous comments come from those who seemingly sympathise with your failings but are  rather interested in highlighting that their system & method is more trustworthy than yours. 

It is clear that your losing tips are higher in number than your winning tips.  This is the universal truth.  Every tipster is good to the extent of 33% only.  

So, do not be defensive about your lower strike rate.  You are as good or as bad as any other tipster.  I do not say that I profited from your method or tips.  All that I am telling is your strike rate is to be really appreciated and punters have not lost much from following your tips.  Continue with the same confidence and conviction.  Punters have more than average intelligence and can certainly dismiss some of your tips that are not to their liking.  

Those who are faulting your system should give their  own tips and speak about their strike rate first and then only they can compare that with your strike rate.  

Ruchi said ...

08-Nov-2022

SAGARJI....while evaluation of winning,the practical situation has to be taken into consideration.

Now the GST is 28 percent,you cannot compare saying that IF the GST was at the earlier level of 12 percent,I would have won + X amount.

That way if the GST was 1 or 2 percent. Then your winning would have been X+ Y Amount.

And if the turf club allowed you to back for FREE then your profit would have been ,well i xant imagine.

So ,sir the real situation is out of 14 bets only 5 have won ,and you are at a big MINUS ,by following your TFR.

THAT IS THE STARK REALITY 

Ruchi said ...

08-Nov-2022

Sagarji .

Figures can be manipulated to arrive at a positive ROI.....

It's simple sir..5 winners in 14 attempts means that system does not worked

Good luck

Sun said ...

07-Nov-2022

@ Ruchi 

Your Dynamic Ratings give a number which may include for Track variant but if the Ratings are crowded then u have to separate them out

Is it not better to have values like 1 min 38.4 secs etc for horses running in a 1600 mtr race instead of a number 510 etc  Incidentally 1 min 38.4 Secs I denote as 9840 in 1/100 of sec 

If u post DR for runners in a race I will give corresponding times as per my method 

U can post here OR in selections page 

Thanks 

S.k.sagar said ...

07-Nov-2022

@ SUN and Glasgow Prince  ...

I do not have much understanding of Ring Dynamics. All I can say is that if a punter is SMART and can select a winning horse by observing the trends in the odds ... then it goes without saying that the concerned bookie has to be equally UNSMART in having allowed the punter to make the correct judgement. I doubt very much if this is  repeatedly the case.

@ Glasgow Prince ... You must have read the manuscript of my book which includes the chapter on Rating and Handicapping, and so should be knowing that I have taken each and every aspect into consideration including Long Term Track Indices to take care of track layout, curves and gradients  etc etc quite comprehensively as well as Short Term Track Indices to take care of the Going .. fast, or soft, or heavy or yielding based on the Penetrometer reading .. as well as distance suitability etc etc , so your comment is not understood.

Veekay said ...

07-Nov-2022

Any body can explain, how to calculate rating.  Please....

 

S.k.sagar said ...

07-Nov-2022

 

TO WHOME SOEVER IT MAY CONCERN

I will shortly be posting extracts from the chapter on `Rating and Handicapping` from my book ``AND THEY ARE OFF``. This will be in several parts and pretty comprehensive. Once the first part is posted on HT, the remaining parts will be posted in comments section. Request read the whole of it and understand the system before commenting on it.

Regarding my performance so far, I have a strike rate of 36% ( 5 out of 14) with average odds exceeding 2 : 1.These odds were available to me after Bookmakers took their 15 % margin of profit, otherwise they would have been much higher. After 14 tests my net score was minus Rs 150, after contributing Rs 1400 to the Government in the form of betting tax.  In no case can this be considered unsatisfactory performance. If it was an investment made on the totalizer with a reasonable 12 % deduction .. which used to be the case before GST crushed it .. it can be easily worked out that my return on 15400 invested would have been  = Rs 15250*(100-12)/(100-25)  =  Rs 17893 which means + 2493.

Further please note there is nothing wrong with the system which in principal, determines the potential of a horse based on specific performances, but there is no guarantee that horses will run true to their maximum potential. Further, it may be noted that my postings regarding tests were done much in advance, so I did not have the benefit of `Paddock looks` or knowledge of `Trainer`s Plans`, or `Ring Dynamics` etc There are about a hundred things to be taken into account, some people even say we should look at the owners wife, if she is well dressed to lead in the winner, the horse has a good chance.

Further it is a tough job to update the Rating chart in respect of hundreds of horses who participate during the week.

Having said that, if people still think my selections are not ok, the answer is simple .. don`t follow me. If you think you are such an expert that you can keep winning even after taking into calculations 15

% Bookies profit + 10 % Betting tax, then you need not waste your precious time on me.

Ruchi said ...

07-Nov-2022

SUN....Not necessarily....that is why in my system there is a factor called TRACK CORRECTION.....however FAST or SLOW the track be, the TRACK CORRECTION NEUTRALISISES this and arrives at a near realistic and logical DYNAMIC RATING,for comparison next when the runner runs.If contrary to yesterday when the track is SLOW due to rain or other factors then the TRACK VARIANT is plus ,so that is why my DR is almost 85 percent correct and amongst the TOP THREE IN A RACE ,it works with 90 percent accuracy ,but we need to analyse and arrive at a final choice to cater for the 10 percent of unknown facts 

Sun said ...

07-Nov-2022

Timings and Analysis of Races.For Dynaminc Rating OR TFR system the base is Time Clocked by a horse.

Now suppose on a day like 6th November at Pune all races turnout fast  Times that are too good to be believed.So next time when we are analysing a race if there is a horse which has run on this day its Time always comes better than other horses and by corollary all such horses should Win but in practice we do not find this happenning.For this purpose I use a Par Time for each Distance and take Average which adjusts for such abberartions.

Looking at Timing and drawing conclusions is prone to errors if not adjusted for Weight Raise OR Lower value in a Handicap  Race.

Last 2 races of 6th November Pune are 20-45 Class and Times Clocked by winners are 57.89 and 57.46 Secs respectively.By looking at these times we may conclude that Timkng of Arcana is better than Phanta.Hoever Phants's race is Weight Raised by 4.5Kg and to compare Apples to Apples we have to adjust time of Phanta race by 4.5Kg

I have no idea how TFR takes into account the changing distances in which a horse runs.Perhaps if an adjustment is built into the system it may give better Results.

My recent experience is that Timing Analysis can be relied upon for most of the Handicap Races

 

Veteran Punter said ...

07-Nov-2022

Respected Sagaji,

Please continue on with your excercise undetered. Ignore the ones trying to bait you. Focus on your task and remain steadfast.

Ramsubbu said ...

07-Nov-2022

Pls come out with test # 15.

Ruchi said ...

07-Nov-2022

Leave difficult and easy argument,SAGARJI....Give your TFR for all the races in a day and let's see where you stand,that way you will not be left with any excuse,easy,hard,tough,trainer hospitalised,horse did not eat hay etc etc

Glasgow Prince said ...

07-Nov-2022

@S K Sagar

I don't know whether there was any further adjustment in placing the stalls or there was any error in the recording equipment. I don't have a ready explanation for yesterday's exceptional timings.

The great Rashid Byramji in one of his candid interviews had said that in his days, one couldn't see his ankles when he walked on the race track but these days one can see his shoes. That is why the track records are tumbling one by one. That shows how tracks have changed over the years at least in India. 

When we come to recording times to the last digit as in the case of TFR, there are other factors that come into play. The track close to the rails gets pounded continuously in every race which renders it faster than the outer portion of the track. So the timings will go on improving ever so slighly as the day's program progresses especially in summer and winter. The intensity of sunshine will also have a bearing on the condition of the track and the time clocked.Whether a horse raced in the first race or the last race will matter. Whether a horse has raced along the rails or on the outer portion will also affect the time clocked.  In the monsoon it will be a different story. The penetrometer reading declared by the club which is used for TFR will not reveal these variations. 

When we try to compare timing across different race tracks, the contours of the tracks, the undulations and where they occur, the difference in curvatures in terms of their occurrence and severity, the length of the straight will all affect the final timing significantly when considered together. I don't know how these variations can be built into a rating.

In my opinion, TFR can be defined as the 'time clocked by a horse in optimum conditions'. Optimum conditions would be in terms of health and fitness, preparation, ideal distance, handicap advantage,  weight carrying capacity, draw number, nature of competition, jockey calibre, nature of going, luck of the race, etc. I feel this is the reason why it can't reproduce the same performance every time.

In the same interview, RR Byramji observed that the performance of horses has suffered over the years in terms of consistency. He also felt that the owners' expectations from their trainers have also changed.

Taking an overview, TFR may be calculated as the mean of the best and the worst performance of a given horse. This will help to integrate consistency of performance into the TFR. This will have two effects. Firstly, it will even out flash in the pan performances and once in a lifetime performances. Secondly, may be and just may be, it will induce trainers and owners to ensure more consistent performances from their wards.

 

Jp said ...

07-Nov-2022

Small correction. Majestic Warrior ran in Class III. Galloping Glory ran in Class B. A 3 year old horse trained by Mallesh Narredu running for the first time(maiden run) broke the course record for 1200 in Bangalore. The horse never won again. It was rated so high in terms of points it has to run in Class II after first win.

Averoff said ...

07-Nov-2022

By now you must have realized this theory of yours is not working. Improvise and come out with somethong better or just call it a day. 

Balaji said ...

07-Nov-2022

Trainer hospitalised is no excuse for RAFELLO losing, admit that the TFR is just not working.......

3 wins in 16 attempts...is a useless system 

S.k.sagar said ...

06-Nov-2022

 

I understand  Raffaello`s trainer  Dallas Toddywalla is hospitalised . I hope he will recover soon. 

As it might have been observed I have been selecting difficult races for the TFR Tests. The average odds of the 14 TFR Tests done so far  was greater than 2.5 : 1.

     In today`s card at Pune I  could have easily selected Mojito @ 8/10 and improved my score + strike rate. He was miles ahead of others in TFR.

     I am completely confused after seeing today`s timings. Majestic Warrior breaking Course record held by Ruffina is very difficult to believe. Even Campaign clocking 1m 9.05 secs carrying 61 kg in a class 5 race is unbelievable and so is Galloping Glory`s timing of 124.7secs  in a class 5 2000m  race, just about a second worse than Quasar`s course record time.

     I simply don`t know what to make of it.

     Somebody needs to clarify all this before I update my TFR CHART

 

S.k.sagar said ...

06-Nov-2022

I understand the trainer is hospitalised . Hope he recovers soon

Anyway, Cumulative score after 14 TESTS is : - 150 ( 15250 - 15400)

 

Ruchi said ...

06-Nov-2022

RAFELLO ,BOARD OUT

4=PURE (599)-RAFELLO (599)-COUNT OF SAVOY (599)-TERISITA (599)

Analysis= 

 At this time there is a strong MOON (2) aspect so i expect COUNT OF SAVOY to run a good race. Also PURE runs its best race over a mile, today both these horses have a good chance to hit the board.. 

 

Ruchi said ...

06-Nov-2022

RAFELLO is a fit horse for 7F, over a mile NO CHANCE to even come second, that too in this set. WONT WIN, may not come second also, SAGARJI, just my views.