Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Kind Attn: Major Srinivas Nargolkar

By Veteran Punter | 12-Nov-2022

Respected Sir,

While tabulating about Fiero in your BREEDING STATISTICS 2021-22 - PART 3 article, you missed mentioning QUEEN SPIRIT (Fiero x Windsor Forest). She won the Nigiris Derby (Gr.1). She is the best performed progeny of Fiero thus far. She qualified to be termed the "best-performing progeny of Fiero" that have raced.

This is to bring to your kind notice.

Post Your reply

4 Replies

Gsl said ...

13-Nov-2022

@ Sir Major Nargolkar...Firstly Thank you very much for the latest four edition of articles, It makes a huge difference in the decision making..All or articles r worth every penny Sir..we all certainly n surely missed ur articles during ur absence...I can go n on for ur appraisal ...Thank u once again..GOD BLESS YOU ALWAYS ????

Rishab said ...

13-Nov-2022

Dear Major N,

We missed your articles on the recent derbies that were run.

Kindly keep posting them as they give a good insight of the competitors and their pedigrees and thus their chances in the race.

That are very informative and helpful.

Regards

Rishab

Veteran Punter said ...

12-Nov-2022

@Major Srinivas Nargolkar

If you believe that ratings carry more importance, then it your perspective, and you have every right to assess them as you deem fit.

As for me, I would definitely give more importance to a Grade. 1 winner than a winner of a Grade 3 event, even though it was rated slightly higher.

Major S Nargolkar (retd.) said ...

12-Nov-2022

@ Veteran Punter

      Many thanks for your posting. I accept that I should have also mentioned QUEEN SPIRIT. Memory is fading somewhat. However, I would like to mention that Wordsmith is rated 60 whereas Queen Spirit is rated 58.