Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Luck Or Skill?

By Raghavan | 06-Dec-2022

The Supreme Court has decided that betting on races is a game of skill.  We (punters) do not knoww whether this judgement is correct or not.  But, in India, what the SC has said is Law.  There is no appeal.  The only authority that has the powers to modify or reverse the SC decision is SC itself.  I have wondered too many times what would be the judgement if somebody brings a review petition on the ruling of SC in this matter.

Perhaps, the SC may find some force in the review petition and may declare betting on races is pure gambling.  But, may also allow the punters to indulge in betting.  Casinos are running the show at Goa, Sikkim etc.

******

In the last 10 days of horse betting, there are several  hundreds of punters who have lost 2 to 3 lakhs.  This is from many punters whose average bet per horse varies between 5500 to 11000. Many punters bet 1100/2200. And these punters may have lost between 10k to 25k  and must be in several thousands. There are good numbeer of punters at BNG, DEL, PUN, HYD & MUM who bet 50k to 2 peti (or still more)  per horse. I do not know how much these high end punters have lost.

And, it may be interesting to learn how much money every punter has lost during the last two decades.  

*****

I have talked about last 10 days and has given just two examples.  There may be hundreds of races every season where the punters feel that the trainer, owner or jockey has taken them for royal ride.  

****

So, the argument that betting on horses is a game of skill may be theoretically correct but in reality it may be just gambling.  If it is a game of skill, then at least 1% of punters must be winners. 

I think the real winners in races can be counted on fingers.  And the entire lot of punters are losers only.   My trade mark generalisation: THE ONLY WINNERS ARE BOOKIES, CLUB & ROGUE STAKE HOLDERS.

*****

My argument is  "No skill is involved in betting on horses".  At least 99% of punters bet on horses based on the odds, previous records.  For favorites they may overbet,  For horses quoted 8/1, 10/1 or above their bets might be modest.  I fail to understand what skill is involved in betting on a horse at even money or 4/1.  Only thing is you should be able to ignore the warning note of your conscience.

*****

There are several tipsters in this site who give free tips.  Punters are highly appreciative of their aptitude to locate winners and their thankless service.  Let us say some give tips on horses quoted at 10/1 or more in the ring.  How many bets will be on that horse/s?  Whether the tipster himself bet on that horse.  I do not give credence to their post race boklahat of betting big on that horse after the races.  At best there may be a bet of 1100 or 2200 from those tipsters for win or place.  

******

Some tipsters habitually claim that they had bets on the winners.  Not only win &/or place bets with the bookies.  They will also claim to have won all the exotic & multileg pools allowed by the club.  And also, their bets in several web sites.  The funniest (or most outrageous) claim by such punters was their claim of 100 tickets box forecast & box quinella that too when the site was non operational & also the tipster himself has dismissed the chances of winner in plain terms.

*****

I have taken several tipsters to task whenever they boast of their astronomical wins. 

****** 

It is better if one realises the ground reality and bet within his means.  He should not bet the money he requires to pay his house rent or housing loan emi,  or school fees of children etc even on a 35ps horse.

*****

ENJOY THE GAME.  BET WITHIN YOUR LIMITS.  You can not fund your children's education abroad or their marriage from race winnings.  You can not buy a house with the race winnings.  Consider yourself lucky if you are a winner in any day.  Spend that money on sumptuous dinner with your wife/children in a decent hotel.  Whenever you lost, treat the loss as entertainment expense. 

Post Your reply

27 Replies

Kulkarni Datturao said ...

08-Dec-2022

Raghvan sir I agree with your advice.

Sudheer said ...

08-Dec-2022

@Raghavan

I can't tell you my selection well in advance.. I might give you tentative selection but me backing a horse depends on no. Of race day parameters.. 

For example on bangalore first day I posted here that its a straight fight between triple wish and stormy ocean and stormy ocean has better chance but on race day I went and backed triple wish.. 

I have asked your email I'd because we can't post screen shots or can't upload any media over here.. Anyways, making money in racing is possible.. That's all I want to say.. 

I'm not posting in HorseTalk recently.. The only reason being I might not back the horse at the last moment.. So I don't want to tip horses which I might or might not back depending on the race day conditions.. 

Raghavan said ...

08-Dec-2022

Sudheer,

"Every punter is a loser!" .  It is my fixation.  Of course, there will be minuscule exceptions.  Let there be.

One may be winning continuously 5 to 6 days.  His winning may cross 30k if his bets are 1100 per race.  And his winnings may cross 1.5 lakhs if his bets are 5500 or above.  But, racing does not stop in one week or month.  The gambling thumb rule catches up soon and he surrenders his winnings and his own cash.  May be there are 100 to 200 winners among one lakh plus horse bettors who might have earned big amount, and another 200 members who might have earned very very small amount.  The balance punters are the one who are supporting the industry with their generous donations. 

You are telling that I should give you my email-id.  This is rather unnecessary.  We are talking in Indiarace.  I am telling that all punters are losers.  You are disputing that.  Very good.  But, why do you need my email id to prove your point?  You can as well speak through indiarace horsetalk itself.  Tell me your selection, your proposed bets etc till the end of March 2023. (the current winter season).  If you are winner, there may be other horsetalk members who browse this site & follow you and they will also benefit.

I am not at all pessimistic.  I have big admiration to several tipsters in this site who are helping the pinters with their valuable tips.  But, it is my firm understanding that every punter is a loser.  That is ground reality. O K,  Your understanding is different.  My best wishes.  ANY BODY & EVERY BODY WHO FLEECES THE BOOKIES ARE MY BEST FRIEND/S.

Sri said ...

08-Dec-2022

@Turftie , what a confident selection Kudos.

Eagerly waiting for your next selections.

B V S Prasad said ...

07-Dec-2022

When money involved in any sports it's purely Gambling only in my opinion.

Whereas winning in horse racing requires lot of qualities like first patience, observation, analization, predicting according to the circumstances, skipping of few races also more important finally its not easy task to make money in racing as per my experience only 1% or 2% people will gain in racing wd the lot of talent in hand of course luck also should be there to win the money in races, aftet covid total racing scenario has been changed, trainers, owners changed their tactics first they bet on their horses after huge betting by public they are eating their own backed horses punters are becoming scapegoats in racing this kind of things happening in all race centre's people can watch & observe keenly  for this cause majority of heavy backing horses are not winning if anybody accept or not accept this is true 

Sinndaar said ...

07-Dec-2022

Ragavanji whatever you have said is absolutely corret . Skill is required to train horses ,  ride horses  and to select winners but ultimately the outcome depends on the LUCK of the race.

At the birth of a child its fate is written and luck plays its part in education , career , life partner  ,children , propertuy, business , gambling and death . Very few haveing  strong luck  who defy death also in major accidents  , go from rags to riches  ,earn  in whatever business they do or win in any gambling game they play . Majority dosent have the luck and so all cannot become Bill gates , sachin Tendulkar , R  Jhunjhunwala . If a jockey's luck is powerful and is on a winning streek , then all trainers / owners prefer to engage that jockey to winthe race. All trainers prepare their horses with confidence yet they belive in the luck of the jockey to win the race and we try our skills .

Luck plays a major part in your winning or loosing ,  observe it minutely and you will see how luck favours you or decieves you

Skill may ride the horse perfectly , push it vigorously , whip it hard yet loose the race by a nose to LUCK beacuse the horse lost one shoe in the race.

Ramsubbu (blr) said ...

07-Dec-2022

Hi Mr. RAGHAVAN 

Nice and valuable write up. I like your follow up responses to HT members. You are absolutely bang on with facts.

@Ramsubbu (Chennai)  - I believe that in Chennai, book makers accept bets from Rs100 - 200 also plus taxes. That's a good option provided by book makers in Chennai which is not the case in Blore which is atleast Rs 500 to 1000 as minimum bets.

At the end of the day it's the mindset of punters to wager and make quick money, to their capacity of investment though.

Kudos once again to Mr Raghavan to give food for punters thoughts.

Cheers

Kurban said ...

07-Dec-2022

Dear Raghavan sir,

I am totally agree with SC dicision.

Yes.... it's purely game of jockeys skill.

I am pleased to inform you that I am not loose in horse racing in last 4 year's.

I got 18 to 20 jackpots in racing / Y

For my view please study basic rules in horse racing you never lose.

Iam seen in this forum about 90 % people directly jump to English grammar.

You must start with A to Z first.

Hope all understand.

Thanks

 

Sudheer said ...

07-Dec-2022

@Chase

Well written sir.. 

@Raghavan

Everyone has their opinions about racing being a game of skill or luck.. I don't want to go into the details of it.. For me it's a game of skill.. 

Coming to your statement about people losing money in the last 10 days, in everything there are winners and losers.. Stock market or business you name it.. 

I don't understand why it is hard to believe if someone actually wins..  For that I have a proposition to prove to you that not all punters are losers.. 

You said 10 days, so provide your email Id here and I will forward all my bets which were settled through app.. I play on a app so everything is documented.. So you can see for yourself the performance for a period of 2 weeks.. 

For anyone who doubt whether you can win in racing, ofcourse you can but be careful in betting as factors affecting the result of a horse race are endless.. You can't cover everything.. So diversify your investment and don't go big on one horse.. Even if you think its a certainty, never go more than 2 times of your usual bet.. 

There's absolutely no need to doubt anyones claims of winning or losing because we won't gain anything by saying that we won or lost on an ananymous platform... 

Every person on this forum is already into racing by choice.. So instead of telling them you can't win, tell them ways to do better and sustain in this field for longterm..

Turfite said ...

07-Dec-2022

Well mr RAGHVAN what do you say.

10 k at 24/10 - minus 3 k shp..total profit.

21 k .........

Await my third bet tommorrow in main thread

Kumar said ...

07-Dec-2022

MURARI...your last paragraph is well drafted and put aptly to CRUCIFY,the crusader.

Yes if one says he has won all sort of proofs are asked.This crusader is well i don't have words to describe....any way age I think has caught up plus unable to predict even a single positive..so it happens.

Raghavan said ...

07-Dec-2022

Ramasubbu,

It seems a high profile jockey has caused grand injury to your finance.  When the going is rough & tough, it is better to pause a little.  You need not stop the betting altogether.  But, you can definitely downsize the quantum of bets.  

I do not know volume of your bets.  I presume it is 1100 per horse.  You can certainly reduce your bet size to 500 or 400 (that too at tote).  Of course, a punter who has lost the money will double or treble his normal bet in order to get back his lost amount in one lump.   But, 80% of such misadventure will always prove disaster.  You need not stick to the reduced betting forever.   After winning two or three bets in tote, you can resume your normal betting.

Rudolph furtado:

Of course you were having a good job and you could always charge your betting loss to entertainment expense.  But, many punters are not that much blessed.  They are desperate lot.  They have to win their bets compulsorily so that they can pay some pressing liabilitues.  But will they win?  That is million dollar question.

Dancing dynamite,

So SC has not said that betting is a game of skill.  You are right.

Govindarajan,

There are some disciplined bettors.  They do not need any sort of advice.  But, for every such disciplined bettor, there are several hundred bettors hopelessly addicted to betting.

Turfite,

Best of luck on your proposed bet on Vijay Falcon.  But, remember just one thing.  You can bet on form, past performance, track record or jockey's reputation in centers like BNG or MUM.  At Mysore & Kolkota, it is always better to be ten times cautious.

Chase,

So "luck" has no meaning or relevance.  It is only skill that matters.  You may be right.  Skill helps you to locate the winner.  But, will that skill helps your betting?  I have my own doubs.  Let me explain:

Granted that you will confidently bet 11k on your selection if it was quoted at 2.00 or below.  But, will you bet with equal confidence if the same horse is quoted at 10/1 or 12/1?   Bets at such loose odds will be fruitful only if the luck is smiling at you.  At least that is my understanding.  Opinions vary.

If you have fleeced the bookies to the maximum by betting on your "skill", then you are my dearest friend.

Ashokmysore said ...

07-Dec-2022

Turfite better to skip Mysore 8-2 is shp for me or place or will not come to board according to my calculations let's see its racing good luck

Rawther said ...

06-Dec-2022

Kudos, 

If one is teaching in wrong way that represents a point, in view of chase if one is playing an selected one horse race in a day what you mean to represent other races becomes question mark, consider one can select an super duper horse in an entire day with all his experience he might successfully go with pack full of cash or may get upset thinking about other day, 

To the understanding of your point brings you one thing that a punter can take one horse per day in 7 race card pack, what is highlighting is should not play other races because you will find no mans land ,To the conclusion out of 7 on 6 races were not game of skills , 

Here one should not teach how to play racing because you don't actually knows how well they experienced may be it's your day but damn sure people's who teach other or influnces other will bend down to in race course, 

Earning money is different please read it carefully is it game of skill, if you represent skill then each day you will find multi millioners in race course and book makers will force to stop quit, 

If one has to live one has to give this is simple concept running here, I believe it's game of gambling nothing else,. No matters what it takes for whomsoever, Don't just assume and argue with you everyone saying that you are in right in racing, there is no one in racing who is 100 percent even if it is you or I, if you still wants to teach someone to play one race at a time then you are not a lover of racing ask those experienced person where they able to recover the total loss amount either in that way, 

For an experience person Racing is still uncertainity and for babies it looks like easier but it may not will learn about it later , 

Have you ever seen people around race course where they have single sheet of paper gone old, do you thing they don't know anything and they just came up for one or two months to play jackpot, if say it's a game of skill then there will be no word called carried over, 

Murari said ...

06-Dec-2022

Raghavan,

If you want to buy a house, educate your children, Retire comfortably etc, the best way is to Invest in a diversified stockmarket index fund from as early as possible. Let the growing Economy do your job for you. Time is your best friend. The longer you Invest, the better the chance you will come out more than happy. And wealthy.

With Horserace gambling (there is no other word for it, even if some knowledge and thought goes into it), Time is your worst enemy. The longer you gamble, the greater the likelihood you will come out unhappy. And poor.

People who believe otherwise are only fooling themselves. And others. All this talk of "Be patient", Numerology, Astrology, is all clutching at straws. Fake Gurus, Tipsters and such like play on these superstitions.

 

Jp said ...

06-Dec-2022

@Chase: you have hit nail on its head.
How many punters he has spoken to and how many would have given the right picture. Staying in Bangalore he speaks about punters in other cities.

When a rank outsider like Leto's win in Mumbai you may not see any punters in the bookies for payment. But in most of the races there will be some collecting payments. 
Skill in racing is different from other skills. You can train others in different skills but horse racing skill is unique and the main virtue is patience. In 70-80s racing was merit based and most of the owners were rich and racing was their passion to adorn their house with silverwares. No Benami owners.

In present day racing there are lot of benami owners and owners who have invested black money. Bookies have invested through benami owners.There is no control by the officials in the clubs in racing as well as in ownership. How do you expect FAIR RACING?
I do not say all the races are predetermined. Some rides by few selected jockeys remains questionable. So in present day racing SKILL is required more.

I do not know how many will agree that the present Hyderabad races(after pandemic) is more on merit with several close finishes and the trainers championship decided on the last day and the top 4-5 trainers tally are very close last season. Yes sometimes few rides by one or two jockeys are questionable more so the imports.

I have mentioned several times that we should back 2-3 races per day and should not attempt all the races which is impossible and the main culprit for everyones downfall.

Do the connections (trainers/jockeys) play all the races and play win only ? They always play each way depending upon the odds. Our friend calculates win percentage on WIN only. Place bets is also win only if it clicks. We should always play place(depending upon the odds) since there will be 3 chances( more than 7 runners) whereas win means only it has to win. Your chances of getting back your money with profits is more in place bets whereas your risk is higher in win bets. This choice many fail to take. 
First of all it should be noted that all the horses in a race are not tried. All the trainers do not win every day but when they win they always try for a double. Last Sunday, Kamaria won and the trainer did a double with Sentinel. When Lord Vader placed second, it was on cards that the trainer is going to try his horses that day. These are the few indicators some trainers give. But you will have to be careful in selecting and playing.

Last Sunday, in Mumbai Nord was the favourite but it was not tried and finished 4th. It is going to win definitely when the odds are favourable. Many of us back a horse and our concentration is only on that horse running and we fail to see other horse's running. We have to select a race and check the running of the horses in that race by seeing the videos of previous races. You will get some reasonable opinion about the horse/s running etc.

I completely agree that why one should tell about his winnings here in this forum. Is it to satisfy someone who keeps challenging to prove to him ? Even if someone tells he had made money then he will ask for IT return for authentic proof.

PLAY FEW RACES IN A DAY-PLAY PLACE BETS MORE AND WIN BETS LESS.

Ramsubbu Chennai said ...

06-Dec-2022

It's been noted people here not understands once claim, rather starting to teach how to be in racing just understand one thing we punters not taken money as so easy one to bet blindly on a horse, we too know and we too have some statergy selections, 

Just think one thing if one has to bet on one horse on racing there is no value of betting jackpot, even if they had more options after using so much of selective methods reading tracks using options why jp is getting carried over, 

I am not here for argument I raised a question that is it possible for a punter to claim if jockey keeps doing mosreble things of keeping down good horses, 

I am not asking tips to earn that has been giving daily with different horse name everydaty by different tipsters , it's easy for giving a tip in racing but after reading all theories practice and still it let you down one should have the rights to claim, will here be any claim fir a punters . I am betting my money I should have the rights to ask what happens, now I am asking authorities or editor whomsoever why jockey akshaykumar keeps robbing punters money don't mind even my post unpublished, I am deciding it to seen it through court by all last 30 rides that will show what he is upto, 

Iz said ...

06-Dec-2022

Chase,  Aptly written...kudos to you.

Turfite said ...

06-Dec-2022

If you see the DELHI Thread..i had given only one bet DIVIT.I backed my standard bet 10 at 70 paisa,but as per my strategy bet 2.5 k SHP.so a modest 3 k profit...but profit is profit.

So technically my this week has stated with 3 k profit.

Will come back again after VIJAY FALCON .,remember it's 10 k win and probably 3 k shp

Turfite said ...

06-Dec-2022

Patience is the key... tommorrow at Mysore...there is a good one VIJAY FALCON.

it's the last race of the day.I fully agree with GOVINDRAJ,be patient and one can return plus.

But how many will wait till the last race to take a chance.

Also it's best to cover with a bet in book and second horse in tote .if the horse is Fav and each way if fluke

TOMMORROW VIJAY FALCON a worth wait and back WIN.A calculative bet WIN and cover in second pool in tote such that net is plus.I feel it will be fancied that's why WIN AND SHP

Tommorrow is 7/12 and let me prove the point by one bet next 5 days 8/12( KOLKOTTA),9/12( Chennai),10/12( Bangalore) ,11/12( Bangalore) and 12/12( MUM AND HYDERABAD).

I will give my bets for next six race days and prove my point.

Tommorrow it will be VIJAY FALCON WIN and hedge calculative SHP.

IF it's 2.5/1 win bet will by 10 k.So being in top fancy SHP will be 40 rupees on tote.Bet in shp 3 k shp will ensure a modest return back if it loses and if win then huge profit.

Let's see,i will come back on this column or main thread tommoro evening 

Hussain said ...

06-Dec-2022

@ Chase,

What a fantastic piece of writing!!!

Govindarajan S(chennai) said ...

06-Dec-2022

Respected sir,

As for as my 25 year experience

Horse racing is game of skill. Race

between you and bookmaker . If you

Predict with confidence go to bookie

and play, other wise simply skip to another race ..... You should know how to avoid certain race. Nobody follow

this . Now a days punters betting each and every races, finally they go home with empty pocket.

Their are two types of racing .....one is predictable favourite race, another is all out effort race. We can judge these two types and should avoid all out race.

Finally i tell you , wait for your turn to bet, don't go first race itself to bet.

Prediction is easy for senior race goers, but punting is difficult . Your mind will be diverted by many things.

Racing is full of skill, calculative...

Betting is gambling.

I am ready to help how to pick try horses. Their is no magic, only calculations.

Rudolph.a.furtado said ...

06-Dec-2022

The Mahalaxmi racecourse was my playground for over 25 years having finally quit betting on horses in 2017 ..I must have invested over Rs 20 lakhs on betting on horses  and although i enjoyed myself due to the suspense the Rs 20lakhs +  money spent on horse race punting was akin to membership of a plush club. Thankfully i had a well paying job and later after quitting employment became a successful investor on "Stocks/ Mutual Funds" thanks to learning speculation skills in the World of Horse racing which is akin to " Day Trading" in stocks. Take my advice as a seasoned " SPECULATOR" that a common punter can never ever earn a living from dividends betting on horses. It is a expensive hobby that keeps your mind active and has no retirement age except a " BANKRUPTCY RETIREMENT AGE" if you are a reckless gambler on horses.

Chase said ...

06-Dec-2022

LUCK: is an external event , many times a random event that is not in your control.

SKILL: Is more personal. Internal , requires discipline, self control, practice , sharpening the mind , and learning from mistakes and failures. It is hardwork.

You don't find many Tendulkar's, Dhoni, or Kholi. A lot of duds for every Kholi. 

Is Cricket a game of skill or Luck?

If You Gamble it is Your Fault. Your Money. Your Decision.

There are many who do play horse races intelligently and you don't find them flaunting their winnings. They are silent mostly.

They don't play every race. They don't play every day. They are never in a hurry. They know they can not win them all. They wait and watch. They don't rush. They take calculated risk. You demand evidence? Sorry their game is different. 

Horse racing is not a random event. Meticulous planning goes into a win. 

If you have watched last Hyderabad races there were many close finishes. In some races there were many clear winners. 

Some capable horses are not tied. It is part of the connections strategy. Sometimes their strategy  and planning may not workout. It is part of the game. 

Don't depend on luck. Don't Gamble. Learn from mistakes . Upgrade your knowledge. Observe. Keep your eyes , ears and.mind open. Learn to analyse . Hone up your decision skills. 

Don't Bet. Play. Play with Skill.

Understand that you can not win them all. Oppurtunities are always there. You spot some. Many you don't . It depends on your knowledge and skill.

Your Money. Your Decision Your Decision is Under Your Control. If Not Blame Yourself.

Don't Blame The Game.

Dancing Dynamite said ...

06-Dec-2022

I think SC judgement says that horse racing is a game of skill.  It does not say that betting is a game of skill.

Ramsubbu Chennai said ...

06-Dec-2022

Raghavan ji, 

If it's a game of skill how an jockey keeps robbing a punter, what you said is rite last 10 days plenty of money for me gone , there is no question a punter can raise if it was taken a Royal ride, nowadays it's becoming worse and even worse is one particular jockey keeps taking granted the Hyderabad rockstar keeps looting and it seems like in a mission, of it's a game of skill just take last 30 rides will get clear idea of what he is doing with punters without any difficulty, all merited horse stayed back with the hands of him, I don't know what meaning of authorities or stewards while they watching. 

When things clearly visible to punters that we are taken for a Royal ride as a punter there is no way to scream out even in ht discussion form, 

In those days there will be hope for tomorrow if we lost today but what happening nowadays says clearly no day if you are not quitting.

Zeke said ...

06-Dec-2022

Well said Sir. So true