India's first & foremost horse racing portal
Topic Details
Back to listsTfr Testing Continued
By S.k.sagar | 10-Dec-2022TFR TEST NO 20: MUMBAI RACES 8TH RACE DANGEROUS WIN
17 Replies
Glasgow Prince said ...
15-Dec-2022Sagarji,
You are right. Dangerous had finished ahead of KR on two occasions. I stand corrected on that count. The record books will show that. However, what they may or may not show is the following. All the same these are important pieces and need to be remembered.
- The Forbes Breeders' Fillies Championship which KR lost by a short head, was contested by only 4 runners and was run at a slow pace. After jump out, KR veered out and lost 3 to 4 lenghts and was further reported to be lugging out in the straight. She lost by just a short head despite these disadvantages.
- In the Fillies Championship at Bangalore, KR finished one and a quarter length behind Dangerous but her saddle had shifted back in the straight.
- Dangerous was in the pink of condition at the time of the Pune Derby as was born out by the fact that she was adjudged the best turned out horse by a panel of experts. KR who prefers to finish on was at a disadvantage in the turning track and the short straight as she needs time to gather momentum before finishing on despite which she won.
The answer to your first question is already covered in point 2 of my previous post.
Coming to the second question, it would be superfluous on my part to say what I would have done after the even is over and the result is known. The idea behind my post was to present a different perspective from the same data that was presented.
What would have been my comment if Dangerous had won? Well, I would have been keen to find out where I had gone wrong.
Pepps said ...
14-Dec-2022I think as punters we are always short of relevent informations details. There were three points of information in public which most of us missed about 1000 Gns:-
1. King's Ransom was entered at second supplementary stage for 2000 Gns on 16 November.
2. Poonawalla Farms and Usha Stud were tied at top of table with 371 Classic wins each.
3. Adhiraj Singh Jodha is yet to train Classic winner in in twelve years since he started training.
these three points do not have any direct effect on any horse's potential and fitness condition. But I am thinking that they have some effect on winning probability.
S.k.sagar said ...
14-Dec-2022@ Glasgow Prince .... Prior to the race on Sunday, King`s Ransom and Dangerous raced with each other on three occasions, twice over 1600m when Dangerous finished ahead of King`s Ransom including once at the same Mumbai track, and once over 2000m when King`s Ransom won by less than ½ length, where Dangerous was leading till 50m from the winning post.
With the above record … would you have considered backing King`s Ransom at 10 to 6 on a better proposition than backing Dangerous at 11 to 2, particularly when the distance is 1600m and not 2000m and the track is the same Mumbai track where Dangerous earlier defeated KR by a shd.
My second question : What would you have done if odds on King`s Ransom increased to Even money and that of Dangerous shortened to 5:2 ?
S.k.sagar said ...
14-Dec-2022@ Glasgow Prince ... You have given your comment after the race is over and King`s Ransom has won. I would like to know what would have been your comment after the race had Dangerous won the race?
Glasgow Prince said ...
14-Dec-2022Well,
Many questions arise from this exercise and the data presented and it is upto us to either address them or ignore them. In the process, if I make a post race analysis, it is only because it is necessary :-)
1. When I say high probability, it is in absolute terms as given by the system and not the probability as indicated by the odds. If the probability given by the system is 25 %, is it high on a scale of 0 to 100 ? In my book, a high probability would mean 75 % and above. In any case, I do not think anything below 50 % can be called high. By the same reasoning, would a horse with a winning probability of 5 % qualify as a value bet just because the odds were 20 to 1 or above? Should we back it as a value bet? This is the reason why the term 'value bet' is deceptive. The BCG terms this as the 'Problem Child'. In racing it becomes RFD ( recepie for disaster). The absolute probability has to be high for it to become a value bet.
2. As per the data presented, the probability of Kings Ransom winning was 50 % which was 100 % more than that of Dangerous. In that case how can one back Dangerous just because the odds were higher than expected? Does it stand to reason? If the odds on KR were too low, the right decision would be to pass the race. Isn't it?
3. If the TF ratings were so close, 92 and 90, what considerations contributed to KR's winning probability becoming 100 % more than that of Dangerous? The results don't bear them out. So, what can be learnt from this?
4. Pesi Shroff had four runners and CS Jodha was going to ride Dangerous. All this data was available before the race. So how did Dangerous become the choice to bet? Only because of the odds? This is the trap of a conventional value bet!
5. The data that was available but was perhaps not considered was that in the Pune Derby, Dangerous was adjudged the best turned out horse ( I am relying on my memory but I am reasonably sure of this). In the 1000, KR looked much sharper than at the time of the Pune Derby. The flat track and long Mumbai straight would suit KR much more than the turningh track at and the short straight in Pune. If the effect of the track topography is effectively factored into the ratings, they would not be so close. The only time Dangerous had beaten KR was when KR played truant at the start and lost some ground. That was the period when the youngsters were finding their feet.
5. While the close ratings of KR and Dangerous can be relatively easily accepted based on past performance, it would be extremely difficult even for a lay man to digest the choice of Flying Visit ahead of Zuccarreli. If FV got a better rating than Zuc, then the ratings certainly need a relook.
6. Most racegoers allege foul play when their choices do not click. What they actually mean is that their choices did not run to their potential because of foul play.
I have only tried to look at the exercise objectively with a view to highlighting certain areas that can be revisited.
Sun said ...
13-Dec-2022@ SK Sagar,
Changing from Kings Ransom to Dangerous look for a Value Bet in the race means you are not testing TFR system but testing your skill in selecting a horse from top contenders
In my opinion to test a System one shouls select the First choice given out by the system
Thanks.
Sksagar said ...
13-Dec-2022@ Glasgow Prince .. Yes of course, a value bet requires the probability to be higher than that reflected by the odds, which was precisely the case in respect of Dangerous. In my view Dangerous had a better than 25 % chance which corresponds to odds of 3:1, whereas the actual odds were higher than 5:1, so it was definitely a good value bet. On the other hand KR had a 50 % chance which correspond to Even money odds, whereas the actual odds were 10 to 6 on. So it was not an attractive betting proposition, which is why I did not play it.
Glasgow Prince said ...
12-Dec-2022My own perception.
- A horse always runs in a specified competitive environment in each race with some unpredictables thrown in. Additionally, it is not that a horse is performing alone but it's a package with various attributes that competes with other packages.
- A value bet is a deceptive term. A bet can be a value bet only if it has a high probability. A high odds low probability bet can't be a value bet. The BCG matrix will throw more light on this aspect.
- There are no ifs and buts in racing. We need to accept the results and move on and use a servo system for improvement.
S.k.sagar said ...
12-Dec-2022Prior to the race, My Time Form Rating for King`s Ransom was 92 and that of Dangerous was 90. King`s Ransom definitely had a better chance, but in my view only a slightly better chance. At 10 to 6 on KR was not at all a good value bet, whereas At 5: 1 Dangerous was a better value bet. With 4 horses in the Field, the trainer Shroff was able to control the pace of the race to suit KR. CS jodha was just not smart enough. Post race I am not making any change in their ratings.
My cumulative score at the End of 20 TFR tests : - 1850 ( 20150 - 22000). It could have been + 4150 ( 26150 - 22000) had Dangerous won.
Chase said ...
11-Dec-2022@ Guptaji: TFR is one Dimensional. It can never point out a winner much less a 5/ 1 winner . Because winning has many dimensions.
Sagarji is not only testing his pet theory- he is testing himself.
Chase said ...
11-Dec-2022@ Gupta ji: Time Firm Rating is one dientional. While winning Inna race has many dimensions. TFR by its construction can never point to a 5 /1 winner.
Safari is not only testing his TFR
Sandeep S said ...
11-Dec-2022Only win King r.....
Ashokmysore said ...
11-Dec-2022Dangerous will place if u r lucky
Gupta said ...
11-Dec-2022KINGS RANSOM IS ONE HORSE RACE.In racing there is a belief " beaten is beaten" very very rarely it's reversed.
KINGS RANSOM has beaten DANGEROUS in Pune Derby last run, over the short Pune straight,it will be a cake walk over the long Mumbai track.
By the by your system always throws out first or second fav max.
So many races are won by good odds give atleast one 5/1 shot if your system has any stuff
Transparency said ...
10-Dec-2022Meh Aaya Tere liye
Sagar Saab Mentors Doosra Theory is profitable one .... But as you had read four months before Don't play Akshay and C.S as they r booked .....Anyway why All 4G r distance ahead of you fooling the Gullible .....Cuz they give specific 4G lay bets unlike your Ashok or pseudonym advising lay at 5and above as well specific Win or Place ... Tommorow there r three
So What 4G lay bets specified by one
Northern Light (Hadn't heard this joc name )
Eat on Square (Malesh )
Kings Ransom (Many Doosra in the field and a profitable theory )
Dilbar (Antia who went nearly blank in Pune winning as fav with Not his stable joc )
Stop once profited and Don't be Greedy like those Real Punters nowadays partying regularly at Ashish in suburb opened all Night after Royal Challenge
Now There r 4G specific Win place
Lazarus Win
Mozelle Win
Place not giving but a hint that Neeraj is the joc in those two place at longer odds offcourse Doosra of Trainers
That's call Class as None of your Htian have any while tipping and Your Admn scared to publish ....ha ha ha
Bishal Shaw said ...
10-Dec-2022King Randsom and lagaruss win ????
Bishal said ...
10-Dec-2022Lagaruss win
Disclaimer
The views expressed in Reviews and Analyses depict the personal perspective of the authors only. Indiarace does not subscribe to or endorse any of the same and is not responsible for adverse consequences (if any). Every effort is made to provide accurate information, we are not responsible for any discrepancies that are beyond our control.
News Letter
Register Now