Respected Sun Sir & All Learned Senior HTians
Please try and explain how "Hunting Goddess" rated 41 was placed in Div.-II of The Berlioz Trophy on 06.01.2023 though Mr. Shroff (Trainer) had another runner "Golden Rule" rated 27 in Div.-I and also Mr. Shirke (Owner) had another runner "Nobility" rated 27 in Div.-I. Thus if division is made by either Trainer's or Owner's accepted horses Hunting Goddess should have been in Div.-I.
Even if Rule 7 of "Division of Handicap Races" given in RWITC Prospectus is followed which requires "Grouping of Horses of same owner trained by different trainers" then also Hunting Goddess should have been placed in Div.-I.
Regards to all HTians.
Bhan
11 Replies
Sun said ...
13-Jan-2023
Just continuing the thread for the sake of completeness
What I discussed is Data and not technicalities.There is general impression that Division 2 horses are inferior horses Perhaps this is because the Timings are poor in Div2 which is because Weight Raise factor
The method adopted at Bangalore for division of races gives opportunity to assign a heavy weight jockey on a horse whose rating is at the bottom of the scale
Sun said ...
13-Jan-2023
Just continuing the thread for the sake of completeness
What I discussed is Data and not technicalities.There is general impression that Division 2 horses are inferior horses Perhaps this is because the Timings are poor in Div2 which is because Weight Raise factor
The method adopted at Bangalore for division of races gives opportunity to assign a heavy weight jockey on a horse whose rating is at the bottom of the scale
Veteran Punter said ...
13-Jan-2023
@Sun
Many thanks for the clarifications. To be frank, I do not feel compelled by technicalities, but rather by the merits of the runners based on their past performance and their aptitude for the trips.
Well, as they say, to each his own. Let it be so since none have mastered racing yet.
Sun said ...
12-Jan-2023
@ Veteran punter
Look at Race Nos 63 and 70 of Bangalore Jan 7th and observe how starting from top horses are put in Division 1 and others in Division 2 There may be one or two exceptions
As posted earlier Division 2 is a Weights Raised race while Division 1 normal scale race
Veteran Punter said ...
12-Jan-2023
@Bhan
I am just taking a wild guess. I believe the splintering in the divisions of a particular are not based on relative ratings, but rather on the large number of acceptances.
I disagree that the top half of the field (based on ratings) goes to Division 1 and the bottom half goes to Division 2.
My take is that the grouping is made by having an equal, or almost equal, number of rated runners.
For example:
A - 25
B - 24
C - 23
D -22
E - 21
F - 20
When divided into two divisions, it may be in accordance with the following:
Div. 1
A - 25
C - 23
E - 21
Div. 2
B - 24
D - 22
F - 20
The above is just guesswork, but it seems the most plausible conclusion.
Sun said ...
11-Jan-2023
@Bhan,
I view it this way. Though Timing Clocked in a race is dependent on many factors,on Ratings scale that a horse rated 30 in 20-45 class will be assigned 55Kg if it is not a Weight Raised or Lowered case.
Suppose such a horse becomes first acceptor in a Division 2 race it will be set to carry 60Kg.Now horse being same it is carrying 5Kg more the time clocked will be inferior to Standard Class time for the race.Hence Division 2 times appear to be slower
My post may not be directly related to your post but this what I wanted to convey
Thanks
Bhan said ...
11-Jan-2023
Respected Sun Sir,
The relevance of placement in Div. I or Div. II is visible in the final timings of the result of the race mentioned in my query. Hunting Goddess clocked a timing of 0:59:104 in Div. II whereas Divine Thoughts winner of Div. I clocked a timing of 1:00:24. It is evident that Hunting Goddess been placed in Div. I would have won the race but in such a case Div. II would have gone to Mojo (Rated 37) who also clocked a smart timing of 0:59:975 and in such a case Divine Thought would have lost a race and Inishmore who finished third in a timing of 1:00:67 would have been place out.
Please note that Faisal also had another runner Tanhaiyaan (Rated 43) in Div. I, as such it appears to be a clear disadvantage to Faisal and owners of Mojo.
Sun Sir, I have always kept in you in high regard as far as Ratings knowledge (earlier) and Timings (Presently) are concerned and that is why I addressed this topic to your goodself. But even if you also feel that Divison of Handicap Races has no relevance then all my hopes are shattered and now I feel there would be no logical / rationale reply of my query.
With Regards
Bhan
Sun said ...
11-Jan-2023
Dear All
Can someone clarify the significance of Division of Handicap Race and the importance of a horse getting placed in a particular division ?
As per me it does not matter at all and there is no uniform procedure in dividing a race across Clibs In some case Top few horses are placed in Division 1 and in others horses are alternatively placed in 1 and 2. In the second case a horse in Division 2 will be set to carry more compared to when it were to run in Division 1 If the horse is not a weight carrier then the problem However the disadvantage is same all horses
Bhan said ...
10-Jan-2023
Respected Ksmrao Sir,
Though there is no mention of such an option in the RWITC Prospectus, still if such an option is made available to either the Trainer or the Owner it will make a mockery of the entire Rating & Divison of Race system.
Respected Chanakya Sir
You know so many bigwigs and learned fellows of this industry can't you find the reasoning behind this allocation for me. Please. I think a clarity on this would help many.
Regards to both of you.
Bhan
Ksmrow said ...
09-Jan-2023
Not sure but i think have read it some were many years long back that a trainer can request for inter change of his horses from one division to other division at accepting stage.
Chanakya said ...
08-Jan-2023