Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Tds Deduction On All Payments

By Kukku Tilak | 02-Apr-2023

Totalisator collections are the main revenue earners for all Turf Clubs. These earnings have taken a beating the past few years with a high GST imposed on all collections. The clubs plea to impose GST only on the Clubs' earnings has not been accepted by the powers that be. 

Wef April 1, the new TDS regulation to deduct TDS @30% on all winnings, instead of winnings of Rs.10000 or more, has the potential of providing a death blow to horse racing in India. 

Typically, about 50% of tote collections is distributed after deduction of GST and Clubs' share. With this rule, 30% of the balance will collected as TDS. That leaves 35% for tote dividends. That is insane! If this aims to collect more revenue for the government, this will have the reverse impact, and that is not tough to anticipate.

Unless this regulation is scrapped, horse racing will be history and the people whose livelihoods depend on horse racing will be jobless very soon.

Post Your reply

13 Replies

Sathish said ...

06-Apr-2023

What you said is rite damodharan sir, it looks like race in upcoming days will head to make attraction to tote players after your statement I just checked kolkata race results I found arman khan finished 2 spots hasib alam finished 2 spots rs bhati finished 2 spots all them will benefit only tote players when they play different types like tanala forecast quinila etc, when coming to bookies all these mentioned jockies were hidden with odds more than 5/10 for win and they made punters betting horses finished at  3 rd places where no one can benefited if they bet even for place example jamaica dr doom, let us watch the upcoming races in ooty so that we can get the conclusion to play withbookies or tote or quit, I feel which ever we move we can't be benefited much as even in tote tds will make set back, only thing which is certain we can loss 100 percent and if we gain it will be 35 percent, 

If the turn club declares to protest against tds race lovers we all will definitely support them it's all depends them , seems like it will not happen 

 

Damodharan Chennai said ...

05-Apr-2023

Guys now at present situation we could stop nothing rather stop playing at tote but if you do that you will end up in more loss when u play at bookies, 

For instance I am sure racing trend now changed, to keep alive and stay tote players the clubs have decided to change racing results , 

To understand this just follow up the results after April 1 racing, the declared favourites will finish the spot on second or third , even if you go with jockey merits or horse merits you will end up the horse in second and third horse pool, this will tempt more number of tote players to play sho thp forecast tanala or whatever may be, the upcoming dividends will make the tote players will keep them alive at counters, for instance just check the results of calcutta race after April 1 , 

   It may sounds like good to tote players about dividened but the real thing behind this which is not letting people know is punters who plays with bookies, it's like just eye wash to people who play with bookies that there is no tds deducted, but real thing is to make tote players alive people who bet with bookies will affect indirectly when their horses finishes at sho or thp when they bet for win with clear merits, 

Admin if I am wrong please let them correct me and we need a clear picture what is racing upto be in future more and more adjustment will make only people suffer but also the racing industry, the authorities has to face the government directly instead of back stabbing their own people in name of tax because one day or other this all would be heared as history as there was game called horse racing, tote players and punters have to be balanced if one suffers the other one will also gets suffered, this will lead to less number of people at racing clubs day by day

Surjit Singh said ...

05-Apr-2023

On 1st april ooty races I played horseno.7 santamarina star for win at mrc portal which payed 70 rs for win but the amt credited to wallet was 50 .same thing happened in second race played royal ikon not sure if the name is correct but p sai kumar was on board paid 25 for win but the amount credited was 21 . They applied tds of 30%on the above two bet can i get back that tds amount back if tds is not applicable on the above two bets

 

Dr Harun said ...

04-Apr-2023

crazy the proposed tax on racing.

only those who are addicts will land up at the race courses to waste their hard earned money.

as for the bookies they will take up cricket to make better money

Ramdas said ...

04-Apr-2023

i think it is going to be curtains down for indian racing  hoping for the best in 2024

Againstodds said ...

04-Apr-2023

@Ramiyer sir, good to see, your concern for our fellow HT participant Sri Raghavan sir

N. Jayram said ...

04-Apr-2023

Dear Friends,

At BTC there is no practical Implication. 

No Registration with KYC is taken by any one. To getther informatio, I asked at counter for the form of KYC. They say at present not required.

TOTE is not deducting any TDS if profit per ticket is below 10,000/-

Bookies are paying as usual without any TDS.

If any body has paid any TDS please come forward.

On 1st.and 2nd. April, I have received payments of SHP,THP etc without any TDS. (all payments below 10K)

From Bookie I have received payment much above10 k. No TDS.

Please share real experience.

 

Ramiyer said ...

04-Apr-2023

Dear Raghavan sir

Hope you are keeping fine. It has been so long that you are absent from ht. Whenever a topic comes like this you would be the first person to write something about it. 

Punter Since 1999 said ...

03-Apr-2023

God save our racing and so so humbled punters who continuesly getting suffered by turf authority and the worst government.

Ramiyer said ...

03-Apr-2023

One of the worst finance minister India ever had after independence. They have removed senior citizen quota in train ,stopping all forms of pension to the lower as well to the middle class. Authoritarian decision.They should have given an opportunity to the concerned sports before announcing this tax.How many crores are flowing in ipl and other sports bets without a penny in tax.All illegal. 

The only way out is all the turf clubs immediately stop all activities regarding horse racing and they should stage a dharna at Delhi.

Punter Since 1999 said ...

03-Apr-2023

Guys I ve stopped going to tote from last 5 years ànd it's getting worse and worse, just we punters have greed and this is the greatest weeknes they all know undoubtedly, no matter how the worsen it gets the race and race goers will continue. Guys just wait for Kalki Avatar to come añd that day all out hard earned money will be returned including interest amount so just wait. All are greedy for money just way's to attempts are different. I remember my one of school lesson GOD SEES THE TRUTH BUT WAITS. Guys let them now after life only we and our lovely horses will be with us in paradise, give your money like King, God bless All punters. Dear admin please be with us and post it it's not wrongly said. Thanks again.

Golden Viper said ...

03-Apr-2023

your calculations are right it is.How did rwitc circumpt the rale every race thouands of rs collected in tote in this prize taxabefeed of prize money per race betwwen rs 30to 50,000

Vishal Agarwal said ...

03-Apr-2023

Clubs revenue is not dependent on betting.

Please speak to people who are involved in running clubs operation 

You will understand the truth behind india horse racing