Indiarace.com - india's first & foremost horse racing portal

Topic Details

Back to lists

Prince Of Lir In India

By Ravi Gowande | 27-Aug-2023

Last week has been truly remarkable for India. First and foremost, I am thrilled to share that I, along with my fellow countrymen, celebrated a monumental achievement as Chandrayaan 3 successfully made its historic landing on the south pole of the Moon on August 23rd. India has now become the First nation to accomplish this remarkable feat, and my heartfelt congratulations go out to the entire ISRO team for their incredible efforts and dedication.  Touch point Named Shiv Shakti by Honorable  PM Narendra Modiji

Adding to the sense of pride, I also noted the outstanding performance of Praggnanandhaa, who exhibited his exceptional skills at the Chess World Cup 2023. It was indeed a moment of triumph on August 25th when he showcased his prowess on the international chess stage.

Simultaneously, on that very day in England, there was another reason to celebrate as Live in the Dream (IRE)," a  4-year-old horse, clinched victory in the prestigious Nunthorpe Stakes, a Grade 1 horse racing event held at the York Racecourse. This splendid achievement highlighted the prowess of the sire, "Prince of Lir," proudly standing at Bishan Stud Farm in India. Furthermore, it's important to note that the Nunthorpe Stakes is a key component of the Breeder’s Cup Turf Sprint challenge series, securing an automatic free entry in the turf sprint category.  .

This race was also in the world pool I could get only Rs 320 against the investment of Rs 10 as India. Is not in the world pool.

My investment of Rs 10 yielded only Rs 320. Unfortunately, India is not part of the world pool, which significantly limits the scope of online betting in the country. The local online betting pool is quite restricted, leading to me receiving a win amount of less than 100 rupees. Moreover, combination tickets for betting are scarce in India. The substantial 28% GST imposed on the invested amount acts as a substantial deterrent for bettors.

I have attached the dividend or payout chart from the Hong Kong Race Club, which oversees the world pool. If I were granted access to the HKJC Racing world pool, I believe I could utilize my expertise in pedigree analysis to a greater extent.

Regarding Prince Lir, he is currently stationed in India,. I am hopeful that his progeny will achieve Grade One victories in the future.

 It's worth noting that for ordinary bettors, placing bets using combination tickets can be quite profitable, as is evident from the significant returns seen in the Tanala Forecast pool for the second and third place horses, as well as the winner.

In contrast, due to the absence of these opportunities in the local betting scenario, I am unable to take advantage of these potential gains. Although the Indian racing industry is well-developed, it remains disconnected from the international betting market. The imposition of the 28% GST on horse racing betting is a contentious issue. Especially considering the courts have already declared horse racing as a skill-based game.

However, based on my understanding, any foreign betting company or entity registered with the GST department could potentially operate in India officially. Yet, the combination of the 28% GST and a 10% commission to the operator renders this proposition economically unviable. As a consequence, illegal betting activities are likely to persist. 

Ravi Gowande

Pedigreestar

Post Your reply

7 Replies

Anil Xk said ...

31-Aug-2023

Friends

A successful racehorse not always a successful stallion, same mare too. The breeding standards are varying from stud farms as they follow some system of practice. None of us are so qualified to teach them but with gained experience can comment. 

The facilitation and maintenance of imported stallions and mares are not up to the mark as per their racing period. I found a very costly imported mare treated very badly and none of her progenies are sound in first three seasons. The big breeder sold her two years of service to a small stud and both yearlings in consecutive years won good races in India, after 5 years that mare returns to Europe. Their also she gave birth to a champion horse. As far as facilities in stud farms and turf clubs not improved exporting blood stock is a distant dream. 

Some of the markets where Indian horses can perform better are ignored due to lack of collective mind set of Indian breeders. But Japanese breeders are working as a single entity, which paid rich results. Horses from Japan outclassed Arab horses in sand tracks. 

Indian breeders got golden opportunity to gather Max markets in Vietnam

China

Thailand

Sri Lanka

But done nothing.

Dr Harun said ...

30-Aug-2023

well said Murari,ordinary Sire he is.

Making much about him.

On national pride as well ,it was the untiring effort of those scientists who are paid pittance who got it done.

The daily struggle of the aam aadmi remains unchanged.

They are killing racing using gst ,how long will they be able to run the show

Ravi Gowande said ...

30-Aug-2023

Dear Murari,

I fully agree Maruti and Ferrari can not be compared. But in sports certain basic things have a common factor which many people are not considering. 

in 1983 Cricket world cup kapil dev team won, when India was all out for 186 that time also no one thought Indian will but history changed after that and cricket flourshed.

Regarding Indian Bred Gene pool is same as England, or France or USA. since 2001 hundreds of quality broodmares and stallions have been imported in India which has improved stock considerably, If you see the track records in India at various turf club records are broken regularly. Unfortunately stud farm owners, breeders themselves do not have faith in their own abilities, in 2008 Indian bred horse has won in Dubai multiple times. Time will only prove my faith in Indian bred horses. 

Ravi gowande

Pedigreestar     

Murari said ...

29-Aug-2023

Ravi, in my observation most Sires in India are (to put it kindly) no more than Internationally average.

And their Mares definitely not up to International standards. The pool is tiny in comparison to the British or International thoroughbred Industry.

So I am not sure where you get your idea that India bred horses will win International Graded races consistently.

Compare and contrast with the Japanese, who have very carefully invested over a long period, and are now reaping the benefits in full.

Yes of course your points about Worldpool and GST are well made. But you can't expect bullock carts or Maruti to compete in Formula One. The Infrastructure has to be there.

As for your points about Moonshot and Chess being some great National achievements, I beg to differ. They are to the PERSONAL credit of the Scientists and others involved, and Pragg, Anand etc. Where does Nationalism or national pride come into this? How does any of this impact the daily struggles of the common citizenry? These achievements are purely to the personal credit of the individuals themselves.

The common Brit can similarly take no credit for England's Cricketers winning the World Cup, or Jenner, Newton, Stephenson, Brunel, Shakespeare et al.

Nationalism and national pride are fleeting and ephemeral. I have never understood it.

Ravi Gowande said ...

29-Aug-2023

Thanks Murari,

Its the same sire, I only wanted to point out Grade 1 winner in york is standing in India. I happened to see the Payouts at Hong Kong races where it is well regulated and very competative market. This race being in the world pool I was feeling sorry for myself being in India we can not be part of Global world pool betting. It will be good if government close down all turf clubs as the way racing is happening in turf clubs. Most of GST violations happening in Turf clubs only.  I personally feel Indian thoroughbreds if exported can compete in middle east at fairly good level. Winning Grade 1 is a distant dream but G2 or G3 events can be won duing carnival stages for sure.

Ravi Gowande

Pedigreestar  

Murari said ...

28-Aug-2023

Prince of Lir's (2014) Sire is Kodiac. Damsire very succesful in France and Europe.

He won 2/5 races as a 2 year old, including the Grade 2 Norfolk Stakes at Royal Ascot. Earnings c. £75,000 (although that is a meaningless figure in the UK as most races here earn peanuts and the bigger Festivals attract a bigger purse).

Stood at Ballyhane Stud in Ireland for a mere £3,000 fee. Very low. A decent average of 39% winners/runners in 2020 and 2021. Only a handful of black type (Grade2 and Listed, plus one Grade 1 placer), before the Nunthorpe (according to Ravi).

Median sales price of progeny not high - around £7,500. Best year 2021 with £19,000 median sales.

Not a top drawer Stallion, but good enough for India, I guess.

I hope the information above is correct, and we're talking about the same horse! Anyone, please feel free to correct me.

Sinndaar said ...

27-Aug-2023

What about Prince of Lir , nothing in the article . Prince of Lir's  racing performance , its english stud career , progency , its pedigree , family and its  preasent  status in India , quality of mares covered and foal prospects in India .. The subject title is Prince of Lir  and article is different about betting , GST etc. More informayion about Prince of Lir was given , it would have been informative and interesting.