A Division Bench of the High Court said that the BTC cannot conduct such activities even during the pendency of the petition challenging the State's refusal to allow horse racing and betting this year.
Bangalore Turf Club
Meera Emmanuel
Published on:
22 Jun 2024, 12:52 pm
The Karnataka High Court on Saturday stayed a June 18 single-judge order that had temporarily permitted the Bangalore Turf Club (BTC) to conduct on-course and off-course horse racing and betting [State of Karnataka and ors. v. Bangalore Turf Club and ors]
A Division Bench of Chief Justice NV Anjaria and Justice KV Aravind pronounced the order today on a writ appeal filed by the State government against the single-judge order.
The Court concluded that the State had presented a strong prima facie case and that it appeared to have refused to grant a license to conduct horse racing and betting for germane reasons.
"The order of single-judge is hereby suspended and stayed. The respondent-original petitioner club is prohibited from conducting on-course and off-course horse racing and betting even during the pendency of the petition (challenging refusal to grant licence), subject to the outcome of the petition," the Court said today while dictating the operative portion of the order.
The dispute before the High Court concerns the State Home Department's order refusing a racing license and the Finance Department's order refusing a betting license to BTC. Both orders were passed on June 6.
This refusal was challenged by way of a batch of writ petitions not only by the BTC but also by the Karnataka Race Horse Owner’s Association, the Karnataka Trainers Association, punters (those who engage in betting) and the Jockeys’ Association of India.
The petitioners highlighted that racing and betting activities had been carried out for over a century without hindrance. It was argued that more than 20,000 people directly and indirectly depend on horse racing and that it produces more than ?1 crore tax daily.
On the other hand, the State argued that BTC was wholly responsible for the illegal betting being carried out, which led to the refusal to grant a license. BTC does not have a vested right to be granted a license, the State said. The State further contended it had faced a loss of ?296 crore on account of tax evasion.
In a June 18 interim order, the single-judge Bench of Justice SR Krishna Kumar observed that the State government's orders refusing racing and betting licenses to the BTC were violative of the principles of natural justice.
Justice Kumar found that BTC was not granted a reasonable opportunity to make their case for a grant of licence and that the show cause notice issued to them lacked material particulars.
Therefore, the single-judge granted the petitioners interim relief and said that the BTC could resume on-course and off-course horse racing and betting activities during the pendency of their petition.
The State government challenged this interim order before a Division Bench, which has now suspended the order.
The Division Bench added that the question of whether petitioners apart from the BTC have locus standi (legal standing) to pursue their writ petitions is kept open.
22 Replies
G C Raj said ...
27-Jun-2024
I THINK ONLY RACE CLUMB HAS ITS OWN LAND AND NO LEGAL ISSUES IS ...HYDEERABAD...All other clubs may get closed any time.. BTC WILL BE THE FIRST TO GET CLOSED..
Godzilla said ...
27-Jun-2024
I have already made my comments to Ayyernet not to express his happiness, as Bangalore Races are not going to be reality in the near future.
Veteran Punter said ...
25-Jun-2024
Pg said ...
24-Jun-2024
Mysuru turf club notice say's races postponed till further notice. So, do not expect any Mysuru races at present, until further developments.
Ahmed Khan said ...
24-Jun-2024
Approach the Supreme court and in the mean time use the services of Mysore race club and start the races to safeguard the intrest of all individuals involved
Deepak said ...
24-Jun-2024
When Mysore reces start any info ??
Romeo said ...
23-Jun-2024
Tommorow morning meeting there with cm Friday onwords Mysore start 28th
Harish said ...
23-Jun-2024
The races on course or off course may/will start from mid of August
Ramesh Doraiswami said ...
23-Jun-2024
The BTC should conduct the summer season races in Mysore in cooperation with the Mysore Race Club. This will provide livelihood to the hundreds of stable hands who are now left without an option. This is a test of how much race clubs work together to support one another for a cause !
Deep said ...
23-Jun-2024
It seems future racing is long long away in BTC...
Let's hope some solution comes out but for time being it's long wait for banglore racecourse
Avk@1985 said ...
23-Jun-2024
Looks like the ending of horse racing in india started
Rrajesh said ...
23-Jun-2024
if BTC loses then its end of the road for racing in india
Darshan P said ...
23-Jun-2024
Hello, Friends. Does anyone know when will Mysore race commens?
Does MYRC have the permission to conduct on course races?
Thanks
Thought Provoking said ...
23-Jun-2024
K. Vijayakumar said ...
23-Jun-2024
This is a lesson not only for BTC , but also fo all other racing centres in Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkatta, Hydrabad etc who follow the footpath of BTC.
Misinterpretting the supreme courts verdict terming the equine sport as game of skill, the BTC has taken things for granted and violate the norms of the licence granted by karnataka government.
If racing has started owners, trainers, jockeys and the management alone will all prosper except the hapeless punters who are always at the receiving end. The courts intervention has made the punters to heave a sigh of relief and pave way for spending their hard earned money in a more constructive way.
God is great
Sunny said ...
23-Jun-2024
Munesh said ...
23-Jun-2024
Chalo Dilli
Explore Supreme Court Option
Cheer Up
Ashokkumar said ...
23-Jun-2024
BTC can challenge the high court judgment in supreme court
It's very bad all of a sudden stopping all the activities
So may Employees and horse owners .jockeys. trainers their condition in cross roads
The land is given by Maharaja to conduct the sports activity
Since from 152 years old
With some vested reasons stopping horse racing is not good to present government
They should hv given condional permission
In my opinion BtC members can challenge in supreme court without any further delay else forget the land
There are so many outskirts places for them to do skyteam park
Y they r eying on the prime land
Bangalore is famous all our India because of added beauty of BTC
No hope on government permission
Immediately BTC chairman and all members and bookmakers join together can fight
If some bookmakers are not upto the mark that will b taken care from legal department
If they delay hope u will loose land
Regards
Ayyarnet said ...
22-Jun-2024
Now what next for BTC sir vocal?
Will the Club approach Supreme Court
for relief for the Zane of livelihood of Contract Labourers /Trainers/jovkeys
and also for the maintenance of Race Horses.
Regards
Ayyarnet
Mannu said ...
22-Jun-2024
What about mysore can any one answer
Ess Ess said ...
22-Jun-2024
Ravi_hud said ...
22-Jun-2024
Looks like end of the road to BTC